Why can Catholics call Mary the 'Mother of God' but not say that 'God died on the cross'

  • Thread starter Thread starter McDonnell
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Two things here:. In regard to the “woman” of Rev 12. Any double meaning must be supported by biblical witnesses. "Upon the mouth of two or three witnesses let every word be ESTABLISHED Jesus said. Otherwise it becomes no more than someone’s subjective opinion. Anyone can make the Bible says anything, but unless there are checks and balances to filter out false doctrine, any pronouncement can be dangerous.
 
Two things here:. In regard to the “woman” of Rev 12. Any double meaning must be supported by biblical witnesses. "Upon the mouth of two or three witnesses let every word be ESTABLISHED Jesus said. Otherwise it becomes no more than someone’s subjective opinion. Anyone can make the Bible says anything, but unless there are checks and balances to filter out false doctrine, any pronouncement can be dangerous.
That was Paul 2 Corinthians 13, not Jesus. Jesus established his Church and appointed ministers to preserve and clarify the deposit of faith, including the scriptures. The Church is what establishes the difference between truth and subjective interpretation, the latter of which is what you’re doing.

You labeled yourself Catholic Christian, which framed how we initially responded to you. But you apparently come from some type of Protestant belief system and are not Catholic or Orthodox in your beliefs.
 
Wesrock … The quote came from neither Paul nor Jesus. Both quoted Moses if you want to split hairs. And Jesus Christ is the head of the Church and all doctrine. That is a fact.
I have deceived no one. I came from a Roman Catholic family and church. I was confirmed there and saved there. It is true when I say that I am Catholic using the truest sense of the word. I never once have I said I am Roman Catholic. You throw this word around as if you have copy rights to it and shocked if someone not in your circle uses it.
I use it here to help others understand there is a very large body in Christ who protest no one, but answer not to Rome but to their local Pastors and to God. The Roman Catholic church hasn’t quite figured that out yet. Do not hate the non-Roman Church or look down on us as if you are superior. Jesus said the greatest in the kingdom are the least.
 
Wesrock … The quote came from neither Paul nor Jesus. Both quoted Moses if you want to split hairs. And Jesus Christ is the head of the Church and all doctrine. That is a fact.
I have deceived no one. I came from a Roman Catholic family and church. I was confirmed there and saved there. It is true when I say that I am Catholic using the truest sense of the word. I never once have I said I am Roman Catholic. You throw this word around as if you have copy rights to it and shocked if someone not in your circle uses it.
I use it here to help others understand there is a very large body in Christ who protest no one, but answer not to Rome but to their local Pastors and to God. The Roman Catholic church hasn’t quite figured that out yet. Do not hate the non-Roman Church or look down on us as if you are superior. Jesus said the greatest in the kingdom are the least.
Any religious label has certain beliefs attached to it. You profess to be Catholic but you do not carry Catholic beliefs. And for the record, Catholicism spans both East and West.
 
James 248, Christ lives in my heart and there are millions upon millions just like me. We too are universal. If you want to build a wall between us, that is between you and our Lord. I do not want walls, I want reason and understanding.
 
James 248, Christ lives in my heart and there are millions upon millions just like me. We too are universal. If you want to build a wall between us, that is between you and our Lord. I do not want walls, I want reason and understanding.
It is not I who build a wall. It is you who simply does this by discounting facts when they don’t fit your theology.
 
Wesrock … The quote came from neither Paul nor Jesus. Both quoted Moses if you want to split hairs. And Jesus Christ is the head of the Church and all doctrine. That is a fact.
I have deceived no one. I came from a Roman Catholic family and church. I was confirmed there and saved there. It is true when I say that I am Catholic using the truest sense of the word.
 
tgGodsway:
Any double meaning must be supported by biblical witnesses.
tgGodsway. Where is this thesis of yours supported by Biblical witnesses?

What verse can I find, “Any double meaning must be supported by biblical witnesses” in?

(By the way. I think the Blessed Virgin Mary as the “Mother” of Jesus IS supported Scripturally. Mixing my metaphors for a moment, I think affirming this is a proverbial “lay up”.)

Jude talks about Jesus who has the power to keep people from falling and present them to God “WITHOUT BLEMISH”.

Do you affirm that at least in principle . . . this CAN happen (I know you had denied it with the Blessed Virgin Mary, but do you at least acknowledge that Jesus CAN present someone to God who is “WITHOUT BLEMISH”)?

JUDE 24 24 Now **to him who is able to keep you from falling and to present you without blemish before the presence of his glory **with rejoicing, 25 to the only God, our Savior through Jesus Christ our Lord, be glory, majesty, dominion, and authority, before all time and now and for ever. Amen.

(Tim Staples brings out this point in his book on the Blessed Virgin Mary if I recall correctly).

amazon.com/Behold-Your-Mother-Historical-Doctrines/dp/1938983807
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top