Why Catholics adore Mary

  • Thread starter Thread starter aball1035
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
We had the traditions of the Church and the Church itself long before the Bible was compiled by the Church.

(By the way, I love our Blessed Mother and thank you Jesus for giving her to us as our Mother too.❤️

She was with Jesus His entire life and she is still with HIM. Someday may we all be as blessed. She leads all right to Jesus and she was doing this long before we had a Bible
too. We all ought to be more like her and her precious Son.)
👍

And she was the very first Christian, since she believed from the moment of her fiat at the Annunciation.

N-Cs talk about having “a personal relationship with Christ” all the time. Who had a closer personal relationship with Him than the Blessed Virgin? Nobody…that’s who.
 
Now, I will say we adore Mary in the same way we adore our children, our parents and so on.

It isn’t worship, only admiration.
We pray that she intercede for us to her Son, for how can a Son deny his Mother, even more so with our Blessed Lord. This picking apart language differences isn’t right. I know I explained what I said earlier, not talking about worship and this time I know I don’t need to be slapped on the wrist with Vatican 2 documents.Noboby is “slapping you on the wrist with Vatican II documents.”
Adoration is necessarily worship even though Worship is partly adoration, if that makes sense. It’s like when we make a Holy hour with the Most Blessed Sacrament, the act there is Worship, but adoration is a huge part of it. We don’t give that worship to Mary, but because of her roll in Salvation history we do give her an ENORMOUS amount of respect and honor.
Please read again my post that says that Catholics do not worship Mary. When you make erroneous statements like that that, you merely play into the hands of ignorant protestants who really believe the Catholics DO worship Mary. They will quickly point out flaws like this.

(From the Catholic Encyclopedia)
(Greek doulia; Latin servitus), a theological term signifying the honour paid to the saints, while latria means worship given to God alone, and hyperdulia the veneration offered to the Blessed Virgin Mary. St. Augustine (City of God X.2) distinguishes two kinds of servitus: “one which is due to men . . . which in Greek is called dulia; the other, latria, which is the service pertaining to the worship of God”. St. Thomas (II-II:103:3) bases the distinction on the difference between God’s supreme dominion and that which one man may exercise over another. Catholic theologians insist that the difference is one of kind and not merely of degree; dulia and latria being as far apart as are the creature and the Creator. Leibniz, though a Protestant, recognizes the “discrimen infinitum atque immensum between the honour which is due to God and that which is shown to the saints, the one being called by theologians, after Augustine’s example, latria, the other dulia”; and he further declares that this difference should “not only be inculcated in the minds of hearers and learners, but should also be manifested as far as possible by outward signs” (Syst. theol., p. 184). A further distinction is made between dulia in the absolute sense, the honour paid to persons, and dulia in the relative sense, the honour paid to inanimate objects, such as images and relics. With regard to the saints, dulia includes veneration and invocation; the former being the honour paid directly to them, the latter having primarily in view the petitioner’s advantage.

More detailed explanation of dulia and the reasons for which it is shown to persons or things will be found in the articles IMAGES, RELICS, SAINTS. See also ADORATION and WORSHIP.
Catholics do not adore Mary. We highly venerate Mary. Adoration is rendered to God alone.
 
n4mgr;5422370:
Noboby is “slapping you on the wrist with Vatican II documents.”
Please read again my post that says that Catholics do not worship Mary. When you make erroneous statements like that that, you merely play into the hands of ignorant protestants who really believe the Catholics DO worship Mary. They will quickly point out flaws like this.

(From the Catholic Encyclopedia)
(Greek doulia; Latin servitus), a theological term signifying the honour paid to the saints, while latria means worship given to God alone, and hyperdulia the veneration offered to the Blessed Virgin Mary. St. Augustine (City of God X.2) distinguishes two kinds of servitus: “one which is due to men . . . which in Greek is called dulia; the other, latria, which is the service pertaining to the worship of God”. St. Thomas (II-II:103:3) bases the distinction on the difference between God’s supreme dominion and that which one man may exercise over another. Catholic theologians insist that the difference is one of kind and not merely of degree; dulia and latria being as far apart as are the creature and the Creator. Leibniz, though a Protestant, recognizes the “discrimen infinitum atque immensum between the honour which is due to God and that which is shown to the saints, the one being called by theologians, after Augustine’s example, latria, the other dulia”; and he further declares that this difference should “not only be inculcated in the minds of hearers and learners, but should also be manifested as far as possible by outward signs” (Syst. theol., p. 184). A further distinction is made between dulia in the absolute sense, the honour paid to persons, and dulia in the relative sense, the honour paid to inanimate objects, such as images and relics. With regard to the saints, dulia includes veneration and invocation; the former being the honour paid directly to them, the latter having primarily in view the petitioner’s advantage.

More detailed explanation of dulia and the reasons for which it is shown to persons or things will be found in the articles IMAGES, RELICS, SAINTS. See also ADORATION and WORSHIP.
I actually meant to say that Adoration is NOT necessarily Worship, but mistyped that and didn’t catch the mistake before it posted, you are right, but in my intent I was as well. I apologize for not proofreading better.
 
For our friend Martin,
PLEASE do us all a favor if you must keep bashing us with the book [BWE] gave you (It did not magically fall out of the sky with red letters and gold trim) would you please get a REAL Bible? I had a college prof for an Old Testament class that had someone sitting in the front row with one of those who slammed it accross the back wall and gave him the same advice. I see generations of monks weeping at you doing this!:crying::crying::crying:
Martin as many protestant do remind me of Thomas Jefferson who took a Bible and a razor blade and cut out the parts he liked and pasted them in a book and the stuff he didn’t was consigned to the ash bin. His buddy Ben Franklin called his new Bible the “Holy Pamphlet.”
I challenged you Martin to look at what the Bible, a catholic book which you say you follow, does say about her.
How do you sideswipe past the Magnificat a prayer that many Christians not just catholics but orthodox, anglicans, lutherans and even some presbyterians say everyday at vespers (evening prayer)? Verse 28 of Luke says flat out,“ALL GENERATIONS WILL CALL ME BLESSED that is they will honor me for the mighty God has done great things for me and Holy is His name>” Mary takes glory from God-ABSOLUTELY NOT!!!
Actually probably the best reason for honoring her is her very role in salvation history. As I’ve said before NO Mary, NO Jesus. Throught out many many generations God has set forth the incarnation of his Son Jesus. Isaiah 7:14 was written more than 600 years before Jesus. despite a current protestant theory , God had already chosen Mary to fullfill the prophecies regarding the messiah and her role in it. God did not have an understudy waiting in the wings or a first runner up or even a Miss Congeniality ; there would be no Virgin Ruth or Susan either, who’d step in if after God sparing no expense we might add sent the Archangel Saint Gabriel, his greatest messenger, to tell Mary that she was to be the Mother of the Messiah and allow God to come down and become one of us so as to see what being human was all about and to finally breach the gap caused by sin. She was given the ultimate hand of deal or no deal to put it in a modern parlance. What if she had said NO DEAL? I’ve got laundry to do. The New Testament would never have been written. Mary’s FIAT ANIMA MEA -let it be done to me- a very poetic YES. With apologies to Jim Carey she is the yes gal and because of it is the first fruits of them that sleep.
Mary’s intercession is right there in John 2 at the Wedding of Cana. (2nd Luminous Mystery) a couple has no wine she goes to Jesus who ends up performing a miracle for them even though He didn’t want to (if you need a favor from a jewish boy ask his mother! It works, I’ve tried it) The most important advice is given from her lips-Do what ever He tells you to do. Can it be any plainer than that?
 
PLEASE do us all a favor if you must keep bashing us with the book [BWE]
gave you (It did not magically fall out of the sky with red letters and gold trim) would you please get a REAL Bible?Yes I do intend to read it when I get time. Please pray for my sore eyes from all the reading I do. The Bible is the Word of God and Jesus was last seen going up into the sky to be with God so you could say the Bible *did *come from the sky.
How do you sideswipe past the Magnificat a prayer that many Christians not just catholics but orthodox, anglicans, lutherans and even some presbyterians say everyday at vespers (evening prayer)? Verse 28 of Luke says flat out,"ALL GENERATIONS WILL CALL ME BLESSED
Plenty of people have been blessed but does that mean we should have statues of them that we bow to? The Bible has plenty of verses that start, “Blessed is he who…”.
Come to think of it, Abraham was told “All nations will be blessed through you.”

Leviticus 26 says
1 Ye shall make you no idols nor graven image, neither rear you up a standing image, neither shall ye set up any image of stone in your land, to bow down unto it: for I am the LORD your God.

and you think it’s ok to bow to statues of Mary?
I’ve heard it said that Mary would be horrified if she knew what was being done in her name.
Originally Posted by Martin R:
Do you ever hail Jesus or hail God or don’t they matter much?
Well, I could give you an answer, but you appear to already know all the answers. So, why are you asking?:rolleyes:
Just trying to make the point that I’ve never heard a Catholic hail anybody other than Mary.

I try to always quote from God’s Word in this forum and God knows all the answers, so if it sounds like I know all the answers, then I suppose that’s what you’d expect isn’t it?

As your ideas for Mary being the queen of heaven,

Jeremiah 44 (NLT) says:
25 The LORD Almighty, the God of Israel, says: You and your wives have said that you will never give up your devotion and sacrifices to the Queen of Heaven, and you have proved it by your actions. Then go ahead and carry out your promises and vows to her!
26 "But listen to this message from the LORD, all you Judeans now living in Egypt: I have sworn by my great name, says the LORD, that my name will no longer be spoken by any of the Judeans in the land of Egypt. None of you may invoke my name or use this oath: `As surely as the Sovereign LORD lives!’
27 For I will watch over you to bring you disaster and not good. You will suffer war and famine until all of you are dead.

Doesn’t that worry you?

If Mary is a perpetual virgin, how do you explain Matthew 12 where Jesus compares his actual family (which includes brothers), with His spiritual family?
Code:
                                       The True Family of Jesus
46 As Jesus was speaking to the crowd, his mother and brothers were outside, wanting to talk with him. 47 Someone told Jesus, “Your mother and your brothers are outside, and they want to speak to you.”
48 Jesus asked, “Who is my mother? Who are my brothers?” 49 Then he pointed to his disciples and said, “These are my mother and brothers. 50 Anyone who does the will of my Father in heaven is my brother and sister and mother!” (NLT)

I’d never heard that idea of Mary being the living Ark of the Covenant before and I do like it but think back to the Old Testament where the people were placing too much importance on the other Ark of the Covenant. They thought it would win battles for them and they were punished for it.
What are you, a Jehovah’s Witness?
No.

I’ve started a new thread to discuss “Is Jesus God” and answer the quotes from this thread as they were off topic. forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?p=5524736#post5524736
 
Please show me any authentic authoritative Catholic document that teaches us to adore the Blessed Virgin. If you cannot provide one it is because no such teaching exists and never has and never will.

As I told the first anti-Catholic guy to allege this to me, “we worship God alone, end of story Dude.”

My Testimony
 
Please show me any authentic authoritative Catholic document that teaches us to adore the Blessed Virgin. If you cannot provide one it is because no such teaching exists and never has and never will.

As I told the first anti-Catholic guy to allege this to me, “we worship God alone, end of story Dude.”

My Testimony
I would gladly give you a piece of my mind for disrespecting my Mother here, but you still wouldn’t get it. I will include a few things, but you’re so entrenched in V2 or whatever that you actually think our Lady’s role has been reduced, just like the protestants. I can’t believe your actually Catholic and spewing this mess.

What your doing here is “hair-splitting” over the english language. It has been clarified what people meant by the words they used.

You ask for proof that we should worship our Lady, you make a mockery of my Mother and the Church and all of this for what? Worship and adoration(translated to mean Latria) is reserved to God alone, but we most certainly DO put our Lady on a pedestal higher than the Saints and we do pay Her a special devotion of Hyper-dulia. You can find this for yourself as you are trying to start or continue an argument with a seriously disrespective tone.

BTW, We also offer a type of devotion to the Saints known as dulia, but you probably wouldn’t know or understand that either.
 
40.png
Martin_R:
As your ideas for Mary being the queen of heaven,

Jeremiah 44 (NLT) says:
25 The LORD Almighty, the God of Israel, says: You and your wives have said that you will never give up your devotion and sacrifices to the Queen of Heaven, and you have proved it by your actions. Then go ahead and carry out your promises and vows to her!
26 "But listen to this message from the LORD, all you Judeans now living in Egypt: I have sworn by my great name, says the LORD, that my name will no longer be spoken by any of the Judeans in the land of Egypt. None of you may invoke my name or use this oath: `As surely as the Sovereign LORD lives!’
27 For I will watch over you to bring you disaster and not good. You will suffer war and famine until all of you are dead.

Doesn’t that worry you?
:rotfl::rotfl::rotfl:

The “Queen of Heaven” mentioned here was a pagan deity. It’s totally irrelevant.
 
40.png
Martin_R:
If Mary is a perpetual virgin, how do you explain Matthew 12 where Jesus compares his actual family (which includes brothers), with His spiritual family?
Code:
                                       The True Family of Jesus
46 As Jesus was speaking to the crowd, his mother and brothers were outside, wanting to talk with him. 47 Someone told Jesus, “Your mother and your brothers are outside, and they want to speak to you.”
48 Jesus asked, “Who is my mother? Who are my brothers?” 49 Then he pointed to his disciples and said, “These are my mother and brothers. 50 Anyone who does the will of my Father in heaven is my brother and sister and mother!” (NLT)
The word “brother” in this context is ambiguous- it could just as easily be interpreted to refer to relatives.

As for Jesus’ words, isn’t it quite evident that it reinforces Mary’s relationship to Jesus, since she gave herself over to God’s will?
 
40.png
Martin_R:
I’d never heard that idea of Mary being the living Ark of the Covenant before and I do like it but think back to the Old Testament where the people were placing too much importance on the other Ark of the Covenant. They thought it would win battles for them and they were punished for it.
This comparison would be valid if the Catholic Church encouraged its members to use Mary as a means of “winning battles” apart from God’s own power- which it does not.
 
I would gladly give you a piece of my mind for disrespecting my Mother here, but you still wouldn’t get it. I will include a few things, but you’re so entrenched in V2 or whatever that you actually think our Lady’s role has been reduced, just like the protestants. I can’t believe your actually Catholic and spewing this mess.

What your doing here is “hair-splitting” over the english language. It has been clarified what people meant by the words they used.

You ask for proof that we should worship our Lady, you make a mockery of my Mother and the Church and all of this for what? Worship and adoration(translated to mean Latria) is reserved to God alone, but we most certainly DO put our Lady on a pedestal higher than the Saints and we do pay Her a special devotion of Hyper-dulia. You can find this for yourself as you are trying to start or continue an argument with a seriously disrespective tone.

BTW, We also offer a type of devotion to the Saints known as dulia, but you probably wouldn’t know or understand that either.
You better check again my friend. I happen to be a knight of the Immaculata and I know very well what the church actually teaches and there is no teaching that calls us to adore the Blessed Virgin. Adoration is NOT one of the meanings of hyper dulia.

I have in no way disrespected my Queen and my Mother but if you want to discuss this I suggest you PM me about it.

For those who need to see the actual study of these Latin words I suggest Saint Worship?
 
I’m looking for a few brief reasons on why Mary is so adored in Catholicism.

One reason I have come up with is that we Catholics on earth aren’t holy enough to truly worship Christ as we should, so we need a “middle man”, which is Mary. However then that leaves the question of why Christ Himself came to earth…

Any help would be appreciated.

To both questions:​

    1. She is not - if she were, that would be to make a God of her
    1. We don’t - because devotion her & other Saints is not dependent on our moral characters. So no “middle man” is needed; other than Christ Who is God and man. As the NT shows clearly enough - just as it says that Christ “came to save sinners”. He came for many reasons, but that is supreme so far we are concerned; not to be an example, but to be the Saviour. So the question that’s left, is answered, in great detail, in the NT.
She is no more a “God” than anyone else.
 
To clear some things up, maybe ‘adore’ was the wrong word. I meant ‘honor’. And when I said we should have a ‘middle man’, it’s because we aren’t holy enough to realize just how holy God is, so that’s one of the reasons we need a mediator. He however, knowing everything about us doesn’t need to have a mediator to come to us.

LilyM you say “You’re not speaking for any other Catholic I know of - and what you say is nothing like Church teaching”. Well for one St. Louis de Montfort writes in* True Devotion to Mary* "It is more perfect, because it is more humble, not to approach God by ourselves, without taking a mediator…if we rely on our own works, skills and preparation to reach God and to please Him, it is certain that all of our rightous works will be sullied or of little weight before God, in urging Him to unite Himself to us and to hear us and answer us… we have need of a mediator before the mediator (Jesus) Himself, and that the divine Mary is the one who is the most capable of fulfilling this charitable office.
-4th Truth in Chapter 3

The OP is correct, & de Montfort is wrong. He’s wrong because his argument is based on ideas that are completely beside the point when compared with the doctrines of the NT; for the NT’s teaching on our approach to God is Christ-centred, not Mary-centred. And de Montfort completely ignores the extremely important fact of the Holy Spirit - it is no exaggeration to say that for him, Mary undertakes functions which an older & healthier tradition attributed not to any Saint or creature, however highly graced, but instead to the Holy Spirit.​

De Montfort’s stuff is nothing in comparison with the NT - it is the NT, not the ideas of much later authors, that is canonical, and inspired. His book is neither. :mad:
 
Hmmm… good point. But would Mary be the mediator for Christ though?

You do know that Christ is a Divine Person - & that Mary is not a Divine Person ?​

Why would He, “the Holy One of God”, need a mediator ? Are you suggesting that He needs to be saved by the mediation of Mary ? :eek::eek::eek::eek::eek::eek::eek::eek:
 

The OP is correct, & de Montfort is wrong. He’s wrong because his argument is based on ideas that are completely beside the point when compared with the doctrines of the NT; for the NT’s teaching on our approach to God is Christ-centred, not Mary-centred. And de Montfort completely ignores the extremely important fact of the Holy Spirit - it is no exaggeration to say that for him, Mary undertakes functions which an older & healthier tradition attributed not to any Saint or creature, however highly graced, but instead to the Holy Spirit.​

De Montfort’s stuff is nothing in comparison with the NT - it is the NT, not the ideas of much later authors, that is canonical, and inspired. His book is neither. :mad:
Maybe I get banned for this, maybe not, but you sir are a joke of a human being and I am positive your not Catholic. I don’t know where you get this drivel, but even Martin Luther recognized our Lady for who She truly is. I know there is a lot of misinformation out there, even in this thread and our limited understanding, but you are DEAD wrong in your assertions on St. Louis de Montfort and you are even more so on our Lady, my Mother. I have no charity for someone who so openly and blatantly attacks my Mother like that.
 
I’m looking for a few brief reasons on why Mary is so adored in Catholicism.
Actually, the Catholic Church forbids worship of Mary or anything or anyone other than God. I hope this clears up your misaprehension of th subject.

God Bless.
 
I’m looking for a few brief reasons on why Mary is so adored in Catholicism.
Actually, the Catholic Church forbids worship of Mary or anything or anyone other than God. I hope this clears up your misapprehension of the subject.

God Bless.
 
I’d point out Anglicans as the exception to that idea that Protestants don’t honor Mary. While Anglican attitudes towards Mary vary greatly (Evangelicals tend to be much like other “Protestants” in their attitudes), some of them aren’t so far from the Catholics. The Evensong or Evening Prayer services usually have the Magnificat. Some Anglicans alos pray the Rosary. Many Anglican and Episcopalian churches also have “Lady chapels”.

I also discern a subtle difference between the Orthodox and the Roman Catholic attitudes towards Mary… Interesting enough, the earliest Fathers don’t talk about Mary much, if at all. Perhaps Marian devotion survived as part of Tradition or a sense of the faithful, but it was hardly the core of the Christian faith.
 
She is the embodiment of sinless perfection.
No, Mary was a sinner, just like the rest of us.
Blessed because she gave birth to the Son of God, yes, but still in need of a saviour.

Luk 1:46 And Mary said: "My soul glorifies the Lord
Luk 1:47 and my spirit rejoices in God my Savior,

She wouldn’t need a saviour if she wasn’t a sinner.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top