If Mary herself did not consent, if her “yes” does not come from her own choice, if Mary did not utilize free will, then the Incarnation is just an elaborate farce, as is salvation and the entirety of human history.
I didn’t say she didn’t consent.
She did - but that consent does not come from anything in her; it comes solely from God’s grace working in her to move her to choose in accord with His Will. She did not choose to be created - that was God’s doing; she was not consulted, because she did not even exist. And the same God Who created her kept her in being, not to do her will but to obey His. There is nothing of good in her, or in any other created being, which is not always, totally, God’s doing; for there is no source of good except God Alone. So she did not suddenly begin at the moment of the Incarnation to be totally dependent on God - all creatures are dependent on God, because that is inseparable from being created by a single, unique, incomparable Creator-God. Whether all of us are subjectively aware of this dependence, is another matter - but our failure to do so, does not make it any less a reality.
Without God, she would not even exist, let alone be able to consent to anything. Without God, no created thing would exist, in any way whatever. Nothing can exist without God: not us, not her, not anyone else, not our faculties of willing or choosing, not the use or the movements of them, not anything human whatever; nor anything else, visible, invisible, potential, past, present, future,possible or impossible, in every respect. And that most definitely includes human choices, and the promptings that lead to them. That she was prompted by God’s grace to choose to consent to His Will, & then did so, is a grace of God to her, for which she can take no credit - just as nobody else can take credit for God’s grace to them.
Sorry if that is labouring the obvious - but the author of our salvation is not Mary: she is a handmaid of the Lord; not the Lord Himself. He, not she or any other creature, is the Author of salvation, in every way & at every step.
I hope that clears that up.