Why Catholics adore Mary

  • Thread starter Thread starter aball1035
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I’m looking for a few brief reasons on why Mary is so adored in Catholicism.

One reason I have come up with is that we Catholics on earth aren’t holy enough to truly worship Christ as we should, so we need a “middle man”, which is Mary. However then that leaves the question of why Christ Himself came to earth…

Any help would be appreciated.
We honor up to Mary as “Our” mother. She was given to all Christians at the foot of the Cross as their spiritual mother. Remember “Honor your Father and Mother”. We adore and worship only God. We follow Mary’s perfect example of being a follower of Christ.
 
No, Mary was a sinner, just like the rest of us.
Blessed because she gave birth to the Son of God, yes, but still in need of a saviour.

Luk 1:46 And Mary said: "My soul glorifies the Lord
Luk 1:47 and my spirit rejoices in God my Savior,

She wouldn’t need a saviour if she wasn’t a sinner.
A man falls into a pit. Another man comes along and pulls him out. The second man saved the first. A woman walks by, and would have fallen into the ditch, but the fsecond man stops her. He saved the woman from falling into the ditch. Both the man who fell in and the woman who did not fall in were both saved by the same man.

Mary, in Catholic thinking, was saved in the same way the woman was, and the rest of us are saved like the first man was.

In other words, Mary had a savior, but in a different sense that we do. 🙂

I could go into another discourse about the meaning of “savior” in that passage, but that’s a story for another day 😛
 
WWJD?

Obey 2* * "Honor your father and your mother?

Shouldn’t we do the same?
 
A man falls into a pit. Another man comes along and pulls him out. The second man saved the first. A woman walks by, and would have fallen into the ditch, but the fsecond man stops her. He saved the woman from falling into the ditch. Both the man who fell in and the woman who did not fall in were both saved by the same man.

Mary, in Catholic thinking, was saved in the same way the woman was, and the rest of us are saved like the first man was.

In other words, Mary had a savior, but in a different sense that we do. 🙂

I could go into another discourse about the meaning of “savior” in that passage, but that’s a story for another day 😛
also, it is the presence of God that heals and sanctifies. Imagine the intimate presence of God in her womb while she gives him his flesh he shall wield. there is no way there could be sin in that woman.
 
I have learnt that you think Mary is the new Ark of the Covenant. I can now understand that idea but it reminds me of when God’s people were placing too much importance on the Ark rather than the word inside it. They tried to use it to win battles for them and were punished for it. Whenever you meet a Catholic, they talk about Mary, have pictures and statues of Mary and as far as I know, Mary is mentioned in every church service.
It’s like receiving an important letter and then showing everybody what a wonderful envelope it came in. You seem to be missing the point of the Bible. i.e. Jesus.

Do you ever hail Jesus or hail God or don’t they matter much?
you seem to be missing the point that when we come to Mary, she leads us closer to Jesus…and that this is the reason we “focus on her”. We focus on her for His sake. And we love her because she gave us Jesus. If she didn’t say “yes” to the Incarnation, we wouldn’t have Him! yes we have statues and pictures of our Blessed Mother because she is Blessed, because all generations will call her Blessed.👍

To both questions:​

    1. She is not - if she were, that would be to make a God of her
    1. We don’t - because devotion her & other Saints is not dependent on our moral characters. So no “middle man” is needed; other than Christ Who is God and man. As the NT shows clearly enough - just as it says that Christ “came to save sinners”. He came for many reasons, but that is supreme so far we are concerned; not to be an example, but to be the Saviour. So the question that’s left, is answered, in great detail, in the NT.
She is no more a “God” than anyone else.
did anyone call Mary “God”? :confused:

The OP is correct, & de Montfort is wrong. He’s wrong because his argument is based on ideas that are completely beside the point when compared with the doctrines of the NT; for the NT’s teaching on our approach to God is Christ-centred, not Mary-centred. And de Montfort completely ignores the extremely important fact of the Holy Spirit - it is no exaggeration to say that for him, Mary undertakes functions which an older & healthier tradition attributed not to any Saint or creature, however highly graced, but instead to the Holy Spirit.​

De Montfort’s stuff is nothing in comparison with the NT - it is the NT, not the ideas of much later authors, that is canonical, and inspired. His book is neither. :mad:
I think De Montfort is right. He said in True Devotion, his theology IS Christ-centered. Through Mary to Jesus. You’re incorrect that there’s this competition between them…that Scripture is either Mary-centered OR Christ-centered. How can this be? Mary gave us Jesus. He consented to be in her womb.

Just as Jesus came to us through Mary, so we can go to Him…and that is not dishonouring Him…that is coming to God the way He came to us!

Our Lady is central to the Incarnation…and the Incarnation is why we have the Cross, why we have redemption.

As for the Holy Spirit… De Montfort was very much devoted to the Holy Spirit, you can see that in his writing. He called Mary the Spouse of the Holy Spirit. How can there be competition between them… the Holy Spirit acts through Mary… it’s not like its one or the other.
No, Mary was a sinner, just like the rest of us.
Blessed because she gave birth to the Son of God, yes, but still in need of a saviour.

Luk 1:46 And Mary said: "My soul glorifies the Lord
Luk 1:47 and my spirit rejoices in God my Savior,

She wouldn’t need a saviour if she wasn’t a sinner.
Mary was not a sinner…she was saved AT her conception.
 
you seem to be missing the point that when we come to Mary, she leads us closer to Jesus…and that this is the reason we “focus on her”. We focus on her for His sake. And we love her because she gave us Jesus. If she didn’t say “yes” to the Incarnation, we wouldn’t have Him! yes we have statues and pictures of our Blessed Mother because she is Blessed, because all generations will call her Blessed.👍

did anyone call Mary “God”? :confused:

The poster who opened the thread, asked “why Catholics adore Mary”. Since adoration is to rendered only to God, that poster was in effect doing so.​

I think De Montfort is right. He said in True Devotion, his theology IS Christ-centered. Through Mary to Jesus. You’re incorrect that there’s this competition between them…that Scripture is either Mary-centered OR Christ-centered. How can this be? Mary gave us Jesus. He consented to be in her womb.

Exactly - “through Mary”. That is where the problem lies; there, & in his re-inforcing this idea with the false notion that Mary is needed because we are - so he says - too impure to go to Christ otherwise. That is not what the NT says - it knows of no such idea. This is a false kind of humility. We do not need a mediator with the Mediator - not because we are anything (we are “useless servants” - Luke 17.10) - but because Christ is all-sufficient. By the logic of it, Mary would herself need a “mediator with the Mediator”, because she is as nothing, in comparison with God, as any other creature. But that would lead to an infinite chain of mediators, each requiring a mediator with the Mediator. It’s a completely false idea.​

As for Mary giving us Jesus, she did no such thing: God the Father gave His Son to be hers also, for our sakes. She is not a principal agent in this, but only the “handmaid of the Lord”, nothing more. And if she had not been granted the grace of faith by God, so as to believe when she heard, the mere material presence of that which was to be born of her in her womb would have done her no good at all. That is not my idea - Augustine said it over 1500 years ago. Jesus was physically near to a lot of people - but that was fruitless to save them if they lacked faith.
Just as Jesus came to us through Mary, so we can go to Him…and that is not dishonouring Him…that is coming to God the way He came to us!

I think I’ve answered that​

Our Lady is central to the Incarnation…and the Incarnation is why we have the Cross, why we have redemption.

Not really - she would be nothing, if God had not freely purposed to call her into being for His Glory. She is a beneficiary of his grace, not an earner or a cause of it. Once called into existence, she had a function - but only then. She is not remotely as important to our salvation as the Word Incarnate - He is involved in every step of all the counsel of God. What she is, she is through His grace & not otherwise. Just like everyone else.​

As for the Holy Spirit… De Montfort was very much devoted to the Holy Spirit, you can see that in his writing. He called Mary the Spouse of the Holy Spirit. How can there be competition between them… the Holy Spirit acts through Mary… it’s not like its one or the other.

Mary was not a sinner…she was saved AT her conception.

Christ is the Holy One of God - Mary is not. She is a Saint - nothiong more. There is no possible comparison of any kind between the Incarnate Word & His mother. There is more likeness between a speck of dust & and the BVM, than between the BVM & a Divine Person.​

 
GottleofGeer:
As for Mary giving us Jesus, she did no such thing: God the Father gave His Son to be hers also, for our sakes. She is not a principal agent in this, but only the “handmaid of the Lord”, nothing more. And if she had not been granted the grace of faith by God, so as to believe when she heard, the mere material presence of that which was to be born of her in her womb would have done her no good at all. That is not my idea - Augustine said it over 1500 years ago. Jesus was physically near to a lot of people - but that was fruitless to save them if they lacked faith.
You’ve been on this board several years now, yet you keep coming up with exactly the same arguments as if you’d never discussed the subject here once.

Your notion that Mary was some sort of robot who was “used” by God without her permission or consent is perverse. You accept that Eve and Adam had a FREE choice to make and were punished for making the wrong choice - condemning all humanity. Yet you refuse to accept that Mary too had an important choice, and she FREELY made the right choice -again with enormous effect on the history of salvation for all humanity. In your world, however, Mary alone had no choice. She was a robot, of no value other than an incubator. Even the vital gift of her human flesh and her human nature to Christ seems to be being denied here - which is a grave error.
Not really - she would be nothing, if God had not freely purposed to call her into being for His Glory. She is a beneficiary of his grace, not an earner or a cause of it. Once called into existence, she had a function - but only then. She is not remotely as important to our salvation as the Word Incarnate - He is involved in every step of all the counsel of God. What she is, she is through His grace & not otherwise. Just like everyone else.
This is the same stuff again, only expressed slightly differently. it seems to be based on a Calvinist idea that all humans are worthless robots, with no choices, no free will, just puppets whose decisions, good and ill are made for us without our (name removed by moderator)ut. Set in stone at the beginning of time.

The trouble with this sort of Calvinism is it makes the whole creation, the whole history of salvation pointless. It is a philosophy leading nowhere.
 
Actually, the Catholic Church explicitly forbids worship of Mary or anything or anyone other than God. See the Catechism of The Catholic Church for further information. I hope this clears up your misapprehension of the subject.

God Bless.
 
You’ve been on this board several years now, yet you keep coming up with exactly the same arguments as if you’d never discussed the subject here once.

A standard issue came up - & it deserved the same response. Four is the sum of two plus two, no matter how often the sum of two and two is asked for.​

Your notion that Mary was some sort of robot who was “used” by God without her permission or consent is perverse.

I’ve explicitly pointed out on a another thread she was no such thing. Am I to repeat everything in every post so as to forestall all possible objections ? That would be absurd; if it were even possible.​

You accept that Eve and Adam had a FREE choice to make and were punished for making the wrong choice - condemning all humanity. Yet you refuse to accept that Mary too had an important choice, and she FREELY made the right choice -again with enormous effect on the history of salvation for all humanity.

I do not refuse anything of the kind :mad: - all I did was point out that she is nothing without the God Who is Alone the author of our salvation. Not honouring her too much is not the same as saying she is a robot.​

In your world, however, Mary alone had no choice. She was a robot, of no value other than an incubator. Even the vital gift of her human flesh and her human nature to Christ seems to be being denied here - which is a grave error.

By all means believe I said or implied this - if it makes you any happier. It’s all in your mind.​

This is the same stuff again, only expressed slightly differently. it seems to be based on a Calvinist idea that all humans are worthless robots, with no choices, no free will, just puppets whose decisions, good and ill are made for us without our (name removed by moderator)ut. Set in stone at the beginning of time.

The trouble with this sort of Calvinism is it makes the whole creation, the whole history of salvation pointless. It is a philosophy leading nowhere.

It makes more sense than Catholicism does.​

 

The poster who opened the thread, asked “why Catholics adore Mary”. Since adoration is to rendered only to God, that poster was in effect doing so.​

Exactly - “through Mary”. That is where the problem lies; there, & in his re-inforcing this idea with the false notion that Mary is needed because we are - so he says - too impure to go to Christ otherwise. That is not what the NT says - it knows of no such idea. This is a false kind of humility. We do not need a mediator with the Mediator - not because we are anything (we are “useless servants” - Luke 17.10) - but because Christ is all-sufficient. By the logic of it, Mary would herself need a “mediator with the Mediator”, because she is as nothing, in comparison with God, as any other creature. But that would lead to an infinite chain of mediators, each requiring a mediator with the Mediator. It’s a completely false idea.​

Mary leads us to Jesus. She leads us closer to Him than we can come on His own… she said, “do whatever He tells you”. She still points us to Him today. So yes we do go to God through Mary…because this is the way He came down to us.

Mary is the Ark of the New Covenant…she’s not just a “vessel”. Please see Revelation 11-12…put the two chapters together.
As for Mary giving us Jesus, she did no such thing: God the Father gave His Son to be hers also, for our sakes. She is not a principal agent in this, but only the “handmaid of the Lord”, nothing more. And if she had not been granted the grace of faith by God, so as to believe when she heard, the mere material presence of that which was to be born of her in her womb would have done her no good at all. That is not my idea - Augustine said it over 1500 years ago. Jesus was physically near to a lot of people - but that was fruitless to save them if they lacked faith.

I think I’ve answered that​

Mary called herself “handmaid of the Lord” because she’s so humble. But yes she was the principle agent of the Incarnation, because without her, the Incarnation would not have been!! God didn’t NEED her, but He Chose to use Her. So we must honour His choice too.
The early Church called Mary “Mother of God”, because Christ’s humanity and divinity cant be separated…she carried the Word of God in her womb. Surely she is more special than any of us. it says in the Bible…all generations will call her blessed, and that she is blessed among women, and that she’s FULL OF GRACE.

Not really - she would be nothing, if God had not freely purposed to call her into being for His Glory. She is a beneficiary of his grace, not an earner or a cause of it. Once called into existence, she had a function - but only then. She is not remotely as important to our salvation as the Word Incarnate - He is involved in every step of all the counsel of God. What she is, she is through His grace & not otherwise. Just like everyone else.​

Christ is the Holy One of God - Mary is not. She is a Saint - nothiong more. There is no possible comparison of any kind between the Incarnate Word & His mother. There is more likeness between a speck of dust & and the BVM, than between the BVM & a Divine Person.​

as I said, God didn’t need to use her, but He did. And she freely consented to the Incarnation. That does make her special than any Saint. It makes her His MOTHER… Jesus honors the Commandment by honoring His Mother, Mary. Shouldn’t we, then, also? She’s our Mother too… (Jesus gave her to us as our Mother, in the Gospels…we’re the “beloved disciple”.)

God bless
 
Never think you are not worthy to worship Jesus directly.

What He did for you tells you your worth.

You are important.

You can be a co-heir to His kingdom.
 
Mary leads us to Jesus. She leads us closer to Him than we can come on His own… she said, “do whatever He tells you”. She still points us to Him today. So yes we do go to God through Mary…because this is the way He came down to us.

Not without Christ - He, not she, is the Mediator between God and men.​

Mary is the Ark of the New Covenant…she’s not just a “vessel”. Please see Revelation 11-12…put the two chapters together.

It’s uncertain at best whether she is intended - the usual interpretation is that the Woman is the Church.​

Mary called herself “handmaid of the Lord” because she’s so humble. But yes she was the principle agent of the Incarnation, because without her, the Incarnation would not have been!! God didn’t NEED her, but He Chose to use Her. So we must honour His choice too.

No - God is the Principal Agent. No mere creature could be. And she is a creature, nothing more; like every real being that is not God. She was not necessary at all - It is God’s grace, nothing in her, & no necessity binding Him, that caused her in particular to be chosen to be the mother of the Word Incarnate; for any woman might have been chosen. He chooses whom He wills - they are made attractive by being chosen; but until God freely chooses them be cause it is His Will so to do, they are nothing.​

The early Church called Mary “Mother of God”, because Christ’s humanity and divinity cant be separated…she carried the Word of God in her womb. Surely she is more special than any of us. it says in the Bible…all generations will call her blessed, and that she is blessed among women, and that she’s FULL OF GRACE.

Only because God is the Author of grace.​

as I said, God didn’t need to use her, but He did. And she freely consented to the Incarnation. That does make her special than any Saint. It makes her His MOTHER… Jesus honors the Commandment by honoring His Mother, Mary. Shouldn’t we, then, also? She’s our Mother too… (Jesus gave her to us as our Mother, in the Gospels…we’re the “beloved disciple”.)

God bless

And why did she consent ? Again, by God’s grace. Not because of anything in her. If anything in any creature is in any way good, it is by God’s grace.​

 

And why did she consent ? Again, by God’s grace. Not because of anything in her. If anything in any creature is in any way good, it is by God’s grace.​

If Mary herself did not consent, if her “yes” does not come from her own choice, if Mary did not utilize free will, then the Incarnation is just an elaborate farce, as is salvation and the entirety of human history.
 
Same thing. Mary is a type of the Church.

It isn’t the same thing. Mary can be related to the Church, without being intended in Rev.12. Adam is a type of Christ - it does not follow that wherever Christ is mentioned, Adam is mentioned. And even*** if*** Rev.12 has a Marian reference at some level (which is possible), that does not mean that the author of the book intended to write about an individual woman in that passage.​

 
If Mary herself did not consent, if her “yes” does not come from her own choice, if Mary did not utilize free will, then the Incarnation is just an elaborate farce, as is salvation and the entirety of human history.

I didn’t say she didn’t consent. 😦​

She did - but that consent does not come from anything in her; it comes solely from God’s grace working in her to move her to choose in accord with His Will. She did not choose to be created - that was God’s doing; she was not consulted, because she did not even exist. And the same God Who created her kept her in being, not to do her will but to obey His. There is nothing of good in her, or in any other created being, which is not always, totally, God’s doing; for there is no source of good except God Alone. So she did not suddenly begin at the moment of the Incarnation to be totally dependent on God - all creatures are dependent on God, because that is inseparable from being created by a single, unique, incomparable Creator-God. Whether all of us are subjectively aware of this dependence, is another matter - but our failure to do so, does not make it any less a reality.

Without God, she would not even exist, let alone be able to consent to anything. Without God, no created thing would exist, in any way whatever. Nothing can exist without God: not us, not her, not anyone else, not our faculties of willing or choosing, not the use or the movements of them, not anything human whatever; nor anything else, visible, invisible, potential, past, present, future,possible or impossible, in every respect. And that most definitely includes human choices, and the promptings that lead to them. That she was prompted by God’s grace to choose to consent to His Will, & then did so, is a grace of God to her, for which she can take no credit - just as nobody else can take credit for God’s grace to them.

Sorry if that is labouring the obvious - but the author of our salvation is not Mary: she is a handmaid of the Lord; not the Lord Himself. He, not she or any other creature, is the Author of salvation, in every way & at every step.

I hope that clears that up.
 

I didn’t say she didn’t consent. 😦​

She did - but that consent does not come from anything in her; it comes solely from God’s grace working in her to move her to choose in accord with His Will.

I hope that clears that up.
Consent is the free giving of use, it cannot be coerced even in the slightest. The grace worked in her but it cannot “make” her say yes. Either God gives free will or He does not, whatever free will Mary exercised is of the same ilk we have today.
Sorry if that is labouring the obvious - but the author of our salvation is not Mary: she is a handmaid of the Lord; not the Lord Himself. He, not she or any other creature, is the Author of salvation, in every way & at every step.
Mary admitted that in Luke so you do labour the obvious, but she still is and will be forever His mother. The angel said you will “conceive”, God condescened to be made up of human DNA, ordinary DNA from an extraordinary woman.

She is the mother of the Author of Life … Jesus’s genes are Mary’s genes. Is not this mother/son relationship continued?
 
Mark 15:18 Then they saluted, yelling, “Hail! King of the Jews!”
Not Hail Mary!
 
Mark 15:18 Then they saluted, yelling, “Hail! King of the Jews!”
Not Hail Mary!
Luke 1:28 And the angel being come in, said unto her: Hail, full of grace, the Lord is with thee: blessed art thou among women. 29 Who having heard, was troubled at his saying, and thought with herself what manner of salutation this should be.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top