I think that what was probably mistaken for a cross in all innocence is most likely a pagan or wiccan symbol (the actual cross itself.) It’s too “flowery” - almost druidic like. Druids, I believe, worship “nature.”
I know a “wiccan priestess” who has a statue of St. Francis of Assisi in her front yard because she likes him, what he represents, and she loves animals. She even “blessed” it.
Walk into her house and there are pentacles and other wiccan/pagan symbols. She has an “altar room” with the “Horned God” prominently displayed. (That’s the man-goat sitting cross legged symbol.)
So they’re known for combining Christian imagery and symbolism with their own symbols.
First of all, if you bought it in a gift shop, there’s a high probability that it was made in China or Taiwan. Cheap gift shop trinkets are usually made from there.
Secondly, I think this was really a pagan symbol especially with all the flowers, the fact that it doesn’t really look like a cross (the bars on the top or bottom, or the “square” that is behind the “cross” part), and the fact that there was some animal totem buried inside the cross. Whatever kind of animal it is, doesn’t matter. I wouldn’t even call it a cross at this point. Remember, various practitioners of the occult use christian symbols and even bible verses they like for their items.
I personally believe there are no accidents. It was no accident that piece of this item fell off, it’s RIGHT IN FRONT of the buried totem inside! How obvious could that be?
If you’re really curious about it, send the pictures to the resources listed here, but do get it out of your house. And quickly. This is definitely something of the occult, even though you did buy it in a “mere” gift shop. Sometimes gift shop owners don’t think, they just want inventory and merchandise for their shops. Many times they don’t even KNOW.
And as a Catholic, I think you should stick with crucifixes. I was given a celtic cross from my boyfriend’s dad during confirmation. That’s part of their Irish heritage. But I’m not Irish and I was disappointed it wasn’t a crucifix. As a Catholic it is important. As someone noted, the crucifix is the most “shunned” Christian symbol and yet, the crucifixion of Christ and his resurrection is the reason we’re here.