Why do Baptists hate Catholics?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Maxply
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
In response to the OP’s question… I believe that Baptists and others respond as they do…because they have been fed “disinformation” for all of their lives.

I have had them tell me the “silliest” things…some of them well, just downright wrong…but its their “preacher’s” telling them these things. SO they believe it. I’ve set a few people straight over time… 😃 Oh, and I did it nicely too!! 😃 😃 👍
 
In response to the OP’s question… I believe that Baptists and others respond as they do…because they have been fed “disinformation” for all of their lives.

I have had them tell me the “silliest” things…some of them well, just downright wrong…but its their “preacher’s” telling them these things. SO they believe it. I’ve set a few people straight over time… 😃 Oh, and I did it nicely too!! 😃 😃 👍
I used to work with a Baptist lay minister. He was ok but he used to argue in the works canteen by opposing everything the Catholic Church taught regardless.

He supported abortion only because the Catholic Church was against it! 😉
 
Are you will to stake everlasting life on more of what comes from men than from Scripture?
Boy- your just proving the OP point. .My salvation is my job - not yours- and are you so arrogant as to not question your motivation, anger and hatred? I’ve been around awhile but I never met a Protestant who didn’t challenge me with"are you saved?" or" why to you believe that" usually stated in a sarcastic tone.When I moved from NYC I was shocked that everybody wanted to know my religion.usually that’s something that’s among friends.somebody was always trying to convert me- 30 yrs later now this county is predominately Catholic!I don’t think you can get people into the kingdom of God by annoying them, tormenting them, belittling their believes, or generally being rude. So if you want to catch any catholic fish you better start using better bait!
 
Gotta be the oddest Anglican I ever met- and I’ve known a bunch- Never heard sole fide stressed so much- my Anglicans locally push lots of good works and we have donated to each other crosses for the church steeples.Anglicans as a whole usually have better manners(English you know! lol).
 
I
He supported abortion only because the Catholic Church was against it! 😉
Gee… what an inspiration… i am sure he made a lot of people want to join the Baptist “church”… and even more want to stay… :rolleyes:
 
Julia, the Anglican Church have serveral branches. I bet SIA belongs to the Calvinist low church one.
 
i think our reverence kinda gets in the way somehow…

(and no, i am not being sarcastic!! :hypno: ) 🙂
If you’re not being sarcastic I can only conclude you are being uncharitable and somewhat arrogant, despite the smiley face. I was raised Baptist and have an uncle and cousin who are Baptist ministers. I assure you they are very reverent. And having experience both Baptist and Catholic faith communities from the inside (which I’m betting you haven’t) I can honestly say that there are good and bad in both - IOW, neither has a corner on the reverence market. And, more to the point, I’ve seen good and bad singers in both. Some people (and I’m one of them) can’t carry a tune in a bucket. Some sing like angels. And they are divided widely amongst the faith spectrum.
 
Gee… what an inspiration… i am sure he made a lot of people want to join the Baptist “church”… and even more want to stay… :rolleyes:
Actually his own denom eventually took the same moral high ground as Catholics. It was a shock to him but of course it was an illustration of how moral his Church really was.

AT grassroots level, I think that actually Catholics and Baptist [at least in our area] enjoy good relations.

Blessings and peace
 
If you’re not being sarcastic I can only conclude you are being uncharitable and somewhat arrogant, despite the smiley face.
i can only conclude that you are being uncharitable by saying this. who are you to call me arrogant when you don’t even know me?

also… i have a friend who has been baptis all his life and he says the same thing, that there is a lack of reverence in the Baptist church…

so now you can call him arrogant… and whatever else you want to call him…
 
I think Baptists hate Catholics because they know we are truly of the Church started by Jesus Christ whereas the Baptist church was started by Roger Smith who BAPTIZED HIMSELFand after some years realized he didn’t have the authority to start a church and went to the Mennonites taking a good majority of his congregation with him. Even their founder knew their church wasn’t a church but an ecclesial movement. Of course they would be bitter.
 
I think Baptists hate Catholics because they know we are truly of the Church started by Jesus Christ whereas the Baptist church was started by Roger Smith who BAPTIZED HIMSELFand after some years realized he didn’t have the authority to start a church and went to the Mennonites taking a good majority of his congregation with him. Even their founder knew their church wasn’t a church but an ecclesial movement. Of course they would be bitter.
Uh no, I don’t think that’s it. While there is no sound reason to hate us, and not all Baptists do by any stretch, some dislike us because they sincerely feel we are heretics and idol worshipers and the CC spreads a false gospel.
 
I think Baptists hate Catholics because they know we are truly of the Church started by Jesus Christ whereas the Baptist church was started by Roger Smith who BAPTIZED HIMSELFand after some years realized he didn’t have the authority to start a church and went to the Mennonites taking a good majority of his congregation with him. Even their founder knew their church wasn’t a church but an ecclesial movement. Of course they would be bitter.
thanks… i didn’t know that… about the history of the baptist church… or ecclesial community…

probalby most baptists don’t either…
 
Uh no, I don’t think that’s it. While there is no sound reason to hate us, and not all Baptists do by any stretch, some dislike us because they sincerely feel we are heretics and idol worshipers and the CC spreads a false gospel.
and that is partly the Church’s fault…we are a bunch of weanies about spreading the True faith (not all of us, of course…)… some just give in to what society is doing… try to be “ecumenical”…

hmmm… not good…
 
I guess my question says it all. I always find Baptists to have a deep hatred toward the Catholic Church. Why so? I thought their big break was with the Church of England or the Methodists, a coupla centuries ago in England.
I am going to have to make a generalized statement of my experience:

I was raised Catholic and have been a practicing Catholic all of my life.

I have also made friends throughout my life of different denominations and been to their church service out of courtesy bc they have asked me too. I have been a few times to a few different ones.

Out of all the churches I found the Baptist to be the most critical and negative of other religions down to taking good time away from Sermon and Scripture and wasting time on being critical in the process…nothing Christian about that.

I believe that the presence of statues and the reading of the Gospel of the Lord being the majority of mention and not Biblical Scripture after Scripture in Mass are the put offs. However they do not know or understand that Adoration is the same thing and in my opinion just as devotional if not more than running around hysterically or semi-hysterically “on fire” for Christ. Also they do not understand Christening a baby bc they believe a baby has no conception of being Baptised by water and it should be a choice one openly makes with all of their heart before God.

What they do not understand is that we do that too, it’s called Confirmation. And I would say a 16 year old that chooses a mentor Saint has a better concept of that than a 7 year old being dunked in water. They do not understand that we pray through Saints for their intercession not to them as if they were God itself.

Baptists say Catholics can’t quote the Bible, that there’s not enough of it in our Church. A good Catholic and a good Christian are the same thing, because Christianity is the root of Catholicism. We can quote the Bible and we have prayers Baptists don’t even know about. Obviously they dont want to know about them because they believe they are right and we are wrong. Catholics are quieter and Baptists are louder, doesn’t mean Baptists love Jesus more, though most of them think the contrary.

So they think the Vatican is corrupt…it’s all about the money and the gold, and we practice idolatry…what’s the difference between the basket being passed through the pews, and a Baptist Pastor or Reverend running around whooping and hollering or giving a really nice motivational speech on putting the presence of God in your life and how God relates to every aspect of one’s being? Putting on a big show for “your” entertainment all in the name of GAWD, and then says, “Ok now we need YOUR money for this and that.” (Nevermind the Pastor is driving a luxury car and his wife looks life a trophy…dare I say statue!) I know Baptists that call their own church “Six Flags over Jesus”.

So what’s the difference between a “Cafeteria Catholic” that cant quote scripture and a “Back-Seat Baptist”…not much they leave Church and go right back out and do the same thing or worse…but there’s one small difference…atleast we Catholics’ are willing to admit it!:cool:
 
and that is partly the Church’s fault…we are a bunch of weanies about spreading the True faith (not all of us, of course…)… some just give in to what society is doing… try to be “ecumenical”…

hmmm… not good…
I’m not totally against being “ecumenical”. It would go a long way from ending all the bickering and false information going around.
 
thanks… i didn’t know that… about the history of the baptist church… or ecclesial community…

probalby most baptists don’t either…
My daughter-in-law (when she was still just my son’s girlfriend) didn’t know it either. She was very upset with me when I told her but I believe it helped her to start on the road to becoming Catholic. She hasn’t yet, but she and my son attend Mass 9 out of 10 Sundays.
 
I’m not totally against being “ecumenical”. It would go a long way from ending all the bickering and false information going around.
i am definitely not against ecuminsim… i am only against it when it is done at the expense of TRUTH…
 
My daughter-in-law (when she was still just my son’s girlfriend) didn’t know it either. She was very upset with me when I told her but I believe it helped her to start on the road to becoming Catholic. She hasn’t yet, but she and my son attend Mass 9 out of 10 Sundays.
Yeah, history usually works when nothing else will… Too bad some people aren’t interested in Church history…

I think all those who realy love Jesus will findthe Catholic Church… some day…

🙂
 
The Baptists hate everybody! They hate the human race!

zerinus
Boy, they must have slammed a lot of doors in your face! 😃

Just like in any situation, you will have people who hate the Catholic Church and those who do not. Making sweeping generalizations like that is factually wrong and you know it!

But zerinus, you are known for making these kinds of errors so we’ll forgive you … again.:yup: 😃
 
I am going to have to make a generalized statement of my experience:

I was raised Catholic and have been a practicing Catholic all of my life.

I have also made friends throughout my life of different denominations and been to their church service out of courtesy bc they have asked me too. I have been a few times to a few different ones.

Out of all the churches I found the Baptist to be the most critical and negative of other religions down to taking good time away from Sermon and Scripture and wasting time on being critical in the process…nothing Christian about that.

I believe that the presence of statues and the reading of the Gospel of the Lord being the majority of mention and not Biblical Scripture after Scripture in Mass are the put offs. However they do not know or understand that Adoration is the same thing and in my opinion just as devotional if not more than running around hysterically or semi-hysterically “on fire” for Christ. Also they do not understand Christening a baby bc they believe a baby has no conception of being Baptised by water and it should be a choice one openly makes with all of their heart before God.

What they do not understand is that we do that too, it’s called Confirmation. And I would say a 16 year old that chooses a mentor Saint has a better concept of that than a 7 year old being dunked in water. They do not understand that we pray through Saints for their intercession not to them as if they were God itself.

Baptists say Catholics can’t quote the Bible, that there’s not enough of it in our Church. A good Catholic and a good Christian are the same thing, because Christianity is the root of Catholicism. We can quote the Bible and we have prayers Baptists don’t even know about. Obviously they dont want to know about them because they believe they are right and we are wrong. Catholics are quieter and Baptists are louder, doesn’t mean Baptists love Jesus more, though most of them think the contrary.

So they think the Vatican is corrupt…it’s all about the money and the gold, and we practice idolatry…what’s the difference between the basket being passed through the pews, and a Baptist Pastor or Reverend running around whooping and hollering or giving a really nice motivational speech on putting the presence of God in your life and how God relates to every aspect of one’s being? Putting on a big show for “your” entertainment all in the name of GAWD, and then says, “Ok now we need YOUR money for this and that.” (Nevermind the Pastor is driving a luxury car and his wife looks life a trophy…dare I say statue!) I know Baptists that call their own church “Six Flags over Jesus”.

So what’s the difference between a “Cafeteria Catholic” that cant quote scripture and a “Back-Seat Baptist”…not much they leave Church and go right back out and do the same thing or worse…but there’s one small difference…atleast we Catholics’ are willing to admit it!:cool:
I don’t know about you but I seem to have a very short attention span, particularly when I am bored. I once attended an ecumenical meeting where the preacher was a Baptist. He apologised before hand that ‘Baptists have a reputation for long sermons and his would be no different’, I thought he was joking…he spoke for exactly an hour!!

The first 5-minutes were very good. Then it started to wain. After a further 10-minutes, he lost me. I remained lost until he had finished. I would have got up and left were it not for the fact everybody knew we were the Catholic contingent and one of our number was snoring very loudly from the front pew! This was the only break in his monologue.

He did not so much speak ‘to’ us as speak ‘at’ us. What is the sense of preaching for that length of time!!

Sorry to derail the thread.

Blessings and peace
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top