T
The_Truthinator
Guest
That’s news to me. Especially the allegation that the Tanach was more complete prior to Jesus than after. Which books in particluar do you claim were part of the Tanach that are no longer. And what verses make the claim that Jesus was God or the Messiah.
Hi. I’m not a Catholic, so I do not accept the Jewish/Catholic Apocrypha to be a part of the Word of God (although I do own a Catholic Bible in New Living Translation and enjoy the stories immensely, even if they ARE uninspired). Anyway, now that we see we are in agreement at least in part about the Jewish Canon, may I recommend you read Isaiah 53 again? Read with fresh eyes and an open heart. Once you have done that, pray. Pray without bias, presuppositions, or any such hindrances.You know of course that Isaiah is part of the Tanach as we know it today. As for “suffering servant”, there were a couple hundred thousand jews that were also crucified. We don’t call them all Messiah.
May I address a few issues the Jewish faith faces today that it did not in times past? I really only mean to help:
- The Temple was destroyed in 70 A.D. (Yeshua prophesied concerning this, also; Matt. 24:1-2) God requires blood for the appeasement of his wrath towards Sin. Why? “The penalty for sin is death.” Torah’s numerous purification rituals are enough to prove to anyone, observant or otherwise, that God takes very seriously these trangressions and will only be pleased by a perfect substitutionary sacrifice. Well, truthfully, all those sacrifices should have been our own blood … They were imperfect, yet God in his mercy “held back and did not punish those who sinned in times past, for he was looking ahead and including them in what he would do in this present time.” For modern Jews though, there can be no forgiveness without those sacrifices. Why? Because God is a God of not only mercy, but justice, as well. To pardon Sin without atoning sacrifices, without blood, would contradict his just nature. To abolish these sacrifices without providing a means of reconciliation would contradict his merciful, ever-gracious nature. Yeshua Messiah’s sacrifice was the fullness of both grace and justice, for only one who was without sin could truly be the appeasing sacrifice (only God could do it), and only God himself would have been able to bear the full wrath of God. His sacrifice means God did not forget to provide his people with a means of life, but also that his plan was carried out while keeping the fulness of Divine justice in tact. Hosea 6:6, which you quote, doesn’t deny the necessity of sacrifices. Not at all. If it did, they would have ceased, yet they continued anyway. That interpretation you have taken on the passage is not the way in which it was received until long past the Temple’s destruction. The passage speaks of the futility of offerings given in the wrong spirit … The people of Israel had betrayed their God, preferring idols to him. He was saying in Hosea to his precious Bride, “Your sacrifices mean nothing unless they are offered in steadfast love, with true and genuine repentance!”
- Isaiah 53 speaks of a Servant beaten, bruised, and killed for the people of Israel. It speaks of one who, even if death, would have many “descendants,” many children, because God would honor his selfless sacrifice. The modern Jewish community considers this a reference to Israel herself, yet this interpretation is opposed by many Talmudic writers and was not agreed upon until the Middle Ages. Beforehand, it was readily agreed on by the Jewish community that this passage was speaking about the Messiah (and indeed, it was, and to this very day still speaks whispers to those faithful few).
- If the Lord Yahweh could, would he not endure precisely what Christ endured for the sake of his people Israel (and even for her neighbors)? Was his unfailing love not enough? Now I ask one final thing: Would the God of unfailing, unending love allow ANYTHING–sin, included–anything at all to come between him and his people? Is anything (even taking the very form of a man, as he did with Jacob) too hard for him?
“Today I have given you a choice between life and death…
Oh, that you would choose life, so that you and your descendants
might live!” --Deuteronomy 30:19