Why do non-Catholic Christians gather on sunday?

  • Thread starter Thread starter TEPO
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Because the first Christians did.
And non-RCs do celebrate Holy Communion. At least most do.
Furthermore: Said celebration was not the only thing that occured at the gatherings of the First Church. Instruction (sermons), song, public prayers, etc, were also part of the service. It’s not like they all went in, then had Communion, and then went home again…
Exactly. All of these things are done for the mutual building up of the Christian community of faith. Christianity has never been about “me and Jesus” and no one else. Such and idea would be anathema to the early Christians.
 
I’m not sure what you are saying - the Protestants you are talking about are meeting with members of their own group, not with people who are not.

When Catholics live in a place where there is no priest or church, they often get together with other Catholics to pray, hear the Word, praise God, sing, study, and have fellowship with the larger Catholic community. Just what Protestants who are not sacramental do. In fact those things are part of the Catholic Eucharist service, or the group prayer services like Vespers.

As an Anglican, we have the Eucharist weekly, and many parishes have it more often if possible - my parish has the Eucharist three times a week plus on feast days. But we also have Morning Prayer and Evening Prayer daily, and sometimes Compline.

I am baffled that you are confused about why people would not see any reason to meet together for anything but the Eucharist. But this is the attitude that leads to that peculiar Catholic phenomena, the herd of people running for the door as soon as they come out of the Communion line.
Did our Jewish ancestors gather on Sunday? Is it some sort of tradition, or is it a natural spiritual reaction?
 
Because the first Christians did.
And non-RCs do celebrate Holy Communion. At least most do.
Furthermore: Said celebration was not the only thing that occured at the gatherings of the First Church. Instruction (sermons), song, public prayers, etc, were also part of the service. It’s not like they all went in, then had Communion, and then went home again…
Did’nt the first Christians gather around Jesus Himself though…? …And they still do today with the real presence of Jesus in the Tabernacle?

When did the early Christians gather without Jesus?
 
Because its a good way to get together, hear the word of God being preached and worship together.

And they have communion once a month.
 
Did our Jewish ancestors gather on Sunday? Is it some sort of tradition, or is it a natural spiritual reaction?
No Sabbath was Saturday for them. (actually it started Friday evening at sundown). It was changed to Sunday because that is the day Jesus rose.
 
People get out of a relationship what they put in…
Say instead of going to Church, I read my own bible and pray with my family every night, then go out into the world spreading mercy passion and love to every one I meet -am I not having a relationship with God through Jesus Christ?
 
No Sabbath was Saturday for them. (actually it started Friday evening at sundown). It was changed to Sunday because that is the day Jesus rose.
So did they all gather on the weekly sabbath to worship? What did they do? Seriously, I’m asking because I don’t know. :o
 
So did they all gather on the weekly sabbath to worship? What did they do? Seriously, I’m asking because I don’t know. :o
I think so but I am not an expert so I can’t say for sure, sorry.
 
And I think they went to the temple (or it’s equivalent) and prayed and worshipped.
 
Did our Jewish ancestors gather on Sunday? Is it some sort of tradition, or is it a natural spiritual reaction?
Jews mark the Sabbath on Saturday. These days many go to synagogue - I’m not sure what the custom was in Christ’s day - there was still a Temple then. But there was formal worship, reciting psalms.

The Christians chose Sunday as their meeting day, and most groups of Christians have continued that custom.

I think that meeting together with others is partly a natural spiritual reaction though - we are made to live in community and so we crave that kind of interaction.
 
Say instead of going to Church, I read my own bible and pray with my family every night, then go out into the world spreading mercy passion and love to every one I meet -am I not having a relationship with God through Jesus Christ?
We are not long rangers and growth is a process…Some villages may only have 2/3 believers you don’t think Christ is among them since there not Roman Catholic.
It starts with the person having a conversion experience…There are churches underground that aren’t Catholic, You don’t think Christ is among them…People chose to follow Christ every day…Our church has missionaries around the world sharing the message of Christ to villages around the world…It’s a relationship that grows…Gathering with fellow believers is part of that.We are called to spread the gospel message…You seem to think that your eucharist is the only place that Jesus is present…Jesus is present to more believers than you realize…Christ is present when my wife and I have devotions and prayer…You believe the way you do because of faith…What your church teaches…When we commune at church Jesus said this I my body…I believe that by faith…Our whole relationship is built on faith…Our communion is open to all who profess Christ…He sees the hearts and knows the faith, He knows who love Him with passion and those who will be spewed for being luke warm…I mean this with no offense but I live in a large Italian Catholic area…If it is a you say that you only have Jesus present you should have the most godly spiritually mature christians in the world…I have/had Catholic neighbors/co workers who were the most heavily drinking cussing partiers I ever knew…Comments like I"m born anew every week with my eucharist and I just confess and partake and their back to their wild lifestyles Monday…It’s a heart change not showing up in the correct “church building” every week…Christ KNOWS who are His every where His name is lifted up…You can show up in church every day and not have the sacred scriptures change you…God is way bigger that the box you seem to fit Him in…You have no idea where His presence is or isn’t…
 
I mean this with no offense but I live in a large Italian Catholic area…If it is a you say that you only have Jesus present you should have the most godly spiritually mature christians in the world…I have/had Catholic neighbors/co workers who were the most heavily
drinking cussing partiers I ever knew…Comments like I"m born anew every week with my eucharist and I just confess and partake and their back to their wild lifestyles Monday…It’s a
heart change not showing up in the correct “church building” every week…Christ KNOWS who are His every where His name is lifted up…You can show up in church every day and not have the sacred scriptures change you…God is way bigger that the box you seem to fit Him in…You have no idea where His presence is or isn’t…
The Catholic Church produces very good fruit… When looking for her fruits, try not to judge by the ones laying on the ground but the ones on the highest branches…

The Saints are our fruits. They’re the highest up, closest to the sun.
 
Why attend church on Sunday?

I can only speak from my own experience.

** 1. The Ten Commandments tell us to keep the Sabbath Day holy.** Because of the resurrection, Christians changed this from the 7th day to the 1st day. Frankly, I don’t think the day chosen makes all that much differences. To begin with, the calendar has changed over the centuries, so that we really don’t know when the original Saturday or Sunday occurred.

** 2. We assemble to hear the scriptures**, offer thanksgiving and praise, pray for forgiveness, listen to a homily usually related to the scriptures, give an offering for the work of Christ, encourage one another in the faith, enjoy singing songs expressing our faith, and share in the sacraments. The two usually conducted during worship are Holy Communion and Baptism.
Code:
**3. The scriptures tells us that where two or three ared gathered together.... **From the outset Christians of all kinds assembled together. As a child, in a rural setting, it was a time to dress up, greet friends and relatives at church, ask how someone's sick son was doing, inquire about Aunt Myrtle, congratulate old Isaiah MacAvoy upon his 90th birthday, learn lessons at Sunday School, anticipate parties, pageants and other special celebrations, etc. The social aspect of worship should never be denigrated. Christians need Christians as they bond together. 

** 4. Through the church parishioners support many worthy endeavors**, whether mission hospitals in Africa or the local soup kitchen. I believe it's still true that contributions to religious organizations far exceed those to any other charitable groups. In  many churches special attention are given parishiioners in need - maybe meals delivered when a member returns home from the hsopital.
** 5. Churches also are the early training ground for clergy,** and they inspire children to high ideals of other kinds, as well as instill a deep faith that can provide courage and other support during difficult times to come.

** 6. Churches often serve as community centers. **They may provide space for the local senior center, for blood drives, for thrift shops, for homeless shelters, community theaters, and for other worthy efforts to assist and serve the wider community, and especially its needy.

** 7. As for the sacraments, they receive more emphasis among Episcopalians and Lutherans **than, say, among Presbyterians and Congregationalists (United Church of Christ). Even in this, there is variation from parish to parish, often depending upon the tradition of the congregation or the focus of the minister.
**God bless Catholics, Protestants, Eastern Orthodox, Jews, Muslims and people of every creed, color and country.** Sometimes it seems as though a small group - even here on CAF - work hard to keep prejudice alive when Christians should view one another as fellow believers, members of the same family which (like most families) has a variety of opinions and personalities. That doesn't make anyone so tragically wrong, just loving the same Lord with different points of of view on a variety of matters.
 
The Catholic Church produces very good fruit… When looking for her fruits, try not to judge by the ones laying on the ground but the ones on the highest branches…

The Saints are our fruits. They’re the highest up, closest to the sun.
There is good/bad fruits EVERYWHERE Christ is lifted up…That’s what I am trying to say,
It’s the individuals not the name on the church building that says where God’s working …The Spirit blows like the wind…The whole OP just smacked of just we have God’s “real presence” why should any other believers gather…
It just reminded me of John telling Jesus " Hey there working in Your name but there not part of our Group…What did Jesus tell Him ?

You need to spend some time here and in third world countries working together in ministry with other christians that are not Catholic and see Christ’s presence reflected in their words,deeds, thoughts, attitudes and actions…
 
Why attend church on Sunday?

I can only speak from my own experience.

** 1. The Ten Commandments tell us to keep the Sabbath Day holy.** Because of the resurrection, Christians changed this from the 7th day to the 1st day.
The Sabbath was thought to have been changed by man.
Dan.7
25And he shall speak great words against the most High, and shall wear out the saints of the most High, and think to change times and laws:

It however has never been changed by God. The seventh day Sabbath of the old testament is still God’s holy day.
Ex.20
10But the seventh day is the sabbath of the LORD thy God:
Frankly, I don’t think the day chosen makes all that much differences.
So, you don’t think God’s blessing matters?

Gen2
3And God blessed the seventh day, and sanctified it: because that in it he had rested from all his work which God created and made.
To begin with, the calendar has changed over the centuries, so that we really don’t know when the original Saturday or Sunday occurred.
The weekly cycle has never been compromised. The CC says that it is a grave sin to miss mass on Sunday. The Sabbath is the day before Sunday.
 
Stay on the topic of the OP please.
If you want to open a new topic on the Sabbath day, that would be more appropriate.
 
I mean this with no offense but I live in a large Italian Catholic area…If it is a you say that you only have Jesus present you should have the most godly spiritually mature christians in the world…I have/had Catholic neighbors/co workers who were the most heavily drinking cussing partiers I ever knew…Comments like I"m born anew every week with my eucharist and I just confess and partake and their back to their wild lifestyles Monday…
Offense taken,
Nothing like a predjicial sterotype to ‘win’ the debate. In my lifetime I have never, NEVER, met a Catholic who thinks like this. Please produce one that does.
 
I am baffled that you are confused about why people would not see any reason to meet together for anything but the Eucharist. But this is the attitude that leads to that peculiar Catholic phenomena, the herd of people running for the door as soon as they come out of the Communion line.
Another stereotype, I have never seen that, ever.
You better than that BG.
 
Originally Posted by Hiskid1973
I mean this with no offense but I live in a large Italian Catholic area…If it is a you say that you only have Jesus present you should have the most godly spiritually mature christians in the world…I have/had Catholic neighbors/co workers who were the most heavily drinking cussing partiers I ever knew…Comments like I"m born anew every week with my eucharist and I just confess and partake and their back to their wild lifestyles Monday…

:rotfl:

Straight out of Chick, Hiskid?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top