Why do priests refuse 'laying on of hands' faith healing instead saying 'if God wills it'?

  • Thread starter Thread starter ethereality
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Why would the creator of the universe make someone ‘shake violently in his chair’ during confession to the point that he might fall out of it? It just seems silly and absurd: What does it signify?
 
Last edited:
Yes, and was denied: I was told it was only for people facing an illness that could result in death, i.e. it’s for the gravely ill or the dying. I have chronic but non-fatal health problems, e.g. severe short-sightedness, and apparently they don’t want to give the sacrament to heal someone’s poor vision, or else that’s apparently not the purpose of the sacrament.
 
Last edited:
Yes, it has happened to me too, during various Healing Masses.

One time I was so inert after I went up to see the priest for a laying on of the hands, that I could barely move. I felt like I was nothing but lead weight.

It was a really different experience.

I was like, “Uh oh, how am I even going to get up and out of the pew, to even drive home?!”

I don’t even know how I managed, but I did. I was so tired and relaxed that I went back to sleep and fell into one of the deepest sleeps that I’ve ever had, and went to sleep for several hours again.
 
Anointing of the sick is primarily for those who are seriously ill (note, not just at point of death, as made clear in CCC 1514). The Sacrament of Healing also includes Confession. CCC 1499-1532
I know that across Europe laying on of hands and anointing are routinely carried out for healing - of body, mind, and spirit.
I am sorry you have been met with such resistance.
 
Since our nature is driven by concupiscence, we must force ourselves to let go - a seeming contradiction in terms. It is a spiritual relaxation, a parallel to the physical relaxation we feel say, in a lounge chair at the beach or soaking in the tub. It is driven by the will - a letting go and a drawing nearer to God by agreeing to accept whatever He desires for you. A decision to abandon worry about appearing as a fool for God, and perhaps even desiring to appear as a fool.

What this amounts to is taking to heart the words of Saint John the Baptist: “He must increase. I must decrease.”
 
Last edited:
I think you are conflating the spiritual with the psychological and the
physiological. The spiritual is nonphysical and therefore cannot be felt.
 
Last edited:
We are not talking facts here, but impressions. I believe that the spiritual can be “felt” but not by the senses.
 
I don’t know what you mean unless you are trying to equivocate using
quotation marks. What does “felt” mean other than you are trying to say
again what I just contradicted?
 
Last edited:
Asking questions is a means of investigation: What does it mean for a
spirit to sense? Please define both ‘spirit’ and ‘sensation’, because I
have only heard of sensation referring to physical sense (taste, touch,
etc).
 
Last edited:
You can’t really explain something of the Spirit. It’s like explaining Transubstantiation. What is the parameter to gauge it on. Inevitably we will mrasure it against what we humans know and feel. It cannot be explained adequately.

There’s a saying - it is not taught but caught. When one has a spiritual experience, one cannot explain it in the way the listener will know like how the explainer knows and experiences it.

For the sake of simplicity, we can differentiate ‘sense’ and ‘prophecy’.

Sense is at the lower level of prophecy, like, your mind is drawn to something and you are thinking, like “Jesus says that we are his friends.” You don’t know why but your mind seems to think about it. Then you can say, “i sense that Jesus is telling us that he is our friend.”

That is a ‘sense’.

Prophecy on the other hand is more tangible, like, you hear a voice to the same effect telling you or you see a vision of Jesus saying it to you.

Those are the things which is hard to believe and accepted if you do not believe in it. But for those who experience it, how can they deny it?

Sure some expert would say, you are hallucinating or your mind is playing a trick on you. Others would simply say you are a fake. But scripture says we should not despise prophecy and things of the Holy Spirit. They all should be tested.

Even Jesus was accused of over the top by his relatives. It does not mean that he is crazy, only that people could not understand why and what he was doing.

Just a thought.
 
I think you are conflating the spiritual with the psychological and the
physiological. The spiritual is nonphysical and therefore cannot be felt.
If you want to categorize what human consists of, it probably has to include the emotion too. You you say we can be affected or respond emotionally (mind/thought), psychologically (physiologically/medically) and spiritually (soul/spirit).

In the deeper realm of the spiritual world, our spirit is able to communicate with the Holy Spirit since both are spirits. We know there are such thing as the Charismatic gifts (gifts of the Holy Spirit), only that we (some) cannot believe it happens to us.

Have you heard the saying ‘prompted by the Holy Spirit’? Why is such a saying if there is no such thing? Meaning we can tangibly feel the prompting of the Holy Spirit if we are docile enough to Him.

The connection between the spirit to our emotion and psychology is perhaps what we call the supernatural. We are not to seek them vigorously but if they are given to us, how can we refuse them? Actually we can. The Holy Spirit does not force (oppress) us, only the Evil One does. We refuse it by ignoring it. It is up to us.
 
Hi TheLittleLady,

No.

Like the others in this thread, I was referring to specific Healing Masses, where people go up to be anointed with chrism. 🙂

These are special Masses, and are not our usual Sunday Masses.
 
Yet, that is an innovation that is not covered in the official rubrics.
 
Isn’t that interesting?

These Masses are all over the country, in different parishes in the different Catholic diocese.

I think that it’s great that people have the opportunity to go to these Masses.

God bless you!
 
No, ‘prompted by the Holy Spirit’ means an idea comes to mind that we attribute to the Holy Spirit. It does not mean a ‘tangible feeling’.
 
Last edited:
No, ‘prompted by the Holy Spirit’ means an idea comes to mind that we attribute to the Holy Spirit. It does not mean a ‘tangible feeling’.
I would say it can be both. Sometimes idea can come with tangible feeling as well.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top