Why do Protestants pray to pieces of cloth?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Cluny
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I can,t think of any one in the USA that is worshiping the flag most people just horor the flag
I agree with Bill! I fly my American flag, but I dont worship it. I was raised in a Southern Baptist church. I am not Southern Baptist now though, but I did go to Vacation Bible school, gosh, every summer…lol…as a kid…and I know exactly what it being referred to in these salutes to the flags. There is one to both the Christian flag, and the American flag, but also the Bible. I never felt like I was bowing before the flags in a way of worship over God.
Have a great day, Bill!
 
So, Apryl, from your post, are you saying that there is no way to know you are saved?? Im honestly not trying to argue what you say, but I just dont understand quite what you are saying…do you believe that no one can know UNTIL they die…
I am a Baptist. Just happen to go to a Baptist church. I more consider myself a Bible believing Christian. I know that I am saved and am going to spend an eternity with Jesus Christ. In your church, is that a prideful assumption?? I just have not understood where the Catholic church basis their salvation. Thanks already for your answer! God bless!
Hi Blessed Hope. Your nickname actually is relevant to your question. We have hope, lively hope, blessed hope that we will find salvation.

What you say you have certainty of is not called prideful assumption, but presumption. Catholics believe three things are necessary for Salvation, faith, hope and love, or charity. We must worship God in faith, hope and love. Most Protestant groups follow Luther’s doctrine that all that is needed is faith. Think about it. If he is right, then a soul can go to heaven without loving God. Faith and love are different.

On the way of salvation the first thing that happens to a soul is receiving the gift of faith. Faith when exercised leads to hope. Charity or the love of God in the soul is the crowning gift. If one has not known charity it is impossible to understand. It is like a person born blind understanding green and red and blue. If their eyes are opened they immediately see it.

Faith, hope and love are called theological virtues, because they come from or relate directly to God. He gives them to us. Even though He might use some preacher’s words to your ears, the work in your soul to hear the truth of the gospel is God’s. He opens your ears so to speak and you receive faith. Paul says faith comes through hearing.

We can not be saved unless we put our hope in God. There are two sins against the theological vitrue of hope. They are kind of opposites from one another, or are on the extreme ends of hope. One is despair. The other is presumption. Despair is a sin against the Holy Spirit. If we die despairing, that is giving up on the power and love of God to save us we are lost. It is like refusing to accept the gift. The opposite of despair is presumption. Presumption is like placing ourselves above God. We don’t ask for mercy, but demand it or think we can command God to save us. We think He owes us salvation and have a right to it, rather than it be an unmerited gift of grace.

Jesus says He entrusts people with treasure. They must use it, work with it, invest it to increase it. If we bury it in the ground He says He will come back and take it from us and give it to someone else. It is kind of a use it or lose it deal. What that says is you have some responsibility to use your faith, or do some work with it and give some return. So the scripture says faith without works is dead. What you do with your faith is not only important, but critical to your salvation.

If that is true then what is it that you must do? You must love God and neighbor. By God’s grace we have the ability or power to do that. So we can say salvation is by grace alone. If we look within our souls and see that we do not love, then we can know we are not saved, yet. We are works in progress, being saved, we hope.

If I look in my soul and know I do love I know I am saved right now. I do not know what I might do tomorrow. I might be a seed that sprouted up in thorny or rocky ground that will wither or be choked out. I do not trust myself. I trust God, but not me, So I cling to God and continue to beg Him for His grace. Keep me from the snares of evil Lord.
 
Hi Blessed Hope. Your nickname actually is relevant to your question. We have hope, lively hope, blessed hope that we will find salvation.

What you say you have certainty of is not called prideful assumption, but presumption. Catholics believe three things are necessary for Salvation, faith, hope and love, or charity. We must worship God in faith, hope and love. Most Protestant groups follow Luther’s doctrine that all that is needed is faith. Think about it. If he is right, then a soul can go to heaven without loving God. Faith and love are different.



If that is true then what is it that you must do? You must love God and neighbor. By God’s grace we have the ability or power to do that. So we can say salvation is by grace alone. If we look within our souls and see that we do not love, then we can know we are not saved, yet. We are works in progress, being saved, we hope.



If I look in my soul and know I do love I know I am saved right now.
Gramps, I like your explanation much better than mine. 🙂

Blessed Hope, you might want to scroll up and check out the Bible cites in my post to see where all this comes from. It’s all there.
 
Ok, Cluny, now I get it.

Yes, that is a standard VBS ritual - the triple pledge of allegiance - to the American flag, the “Christian” flag and the Bible.

Even as a Baptist I was more than a little uncomfortable with it, since it seems to make the three equally worthy of our honor and allegiance.

And I presume your point is to show that when evangelicals accuse Catholics of “worshipping statues” because we sometimes pray in front of them, that this is an example of a “prayer” in front of “pieces of cloth” which is clearly not intended as worship, though to an outsider it might appear to be worship?

Possibly a useful argument, I’m not sure.
 
I think it may have been Morris Cerullo. In my early Christian days, 27 years before Catholicism, Mr. Cerullo wanted to send me such a cloth. I was praying for a Christian husband. I never got the cloth, but did get the husband! God is good. Yesterday was our 25th anniversary.
:hug1:🙂
 
Ok, Cluny, now I get it.

Yes, that is a standard VBS ritual - the triple pledge of allegiance - to the American flag, the “Christian” flag and the Bible.

Even as a Baptist I was more than a little uncomfortable with it, since it seems to make the three equally worthy of our honor and allegiance.

And I presume your point is to show that when evangelicals accuse Catholics of “worshipping statues” because we sometimes pray in front of them, that this is an example of a “prayer” in front of “pieces of cloth” which is clearly not intended as worship, though to an outsider it might appear to be worship?

Possibly a useful argument, I’m not sure.
It is an interesting analogy.Perhaps if the people saying the pledge actually expected the flag to hear it, then it might be considered worship, but no one expects the flag to hear or to respond in any way. People do expect Mary and the saints to hear them.
 
I am beginning to think that this all comes down to a misunderstanding of semantics.

The word “worship” developed from combining “worth” and “ship,” as a title. Here is the etymology. It was not understood to exclusively refer to the adoration due to God. That is why magistrates in the UK are styled “Your Worship” – yet no one accuses all Britons of idolatry.

Thoughts?
 
Also “pray” which used to have a broad meaning of “ask” (“I pray ye, good fellow, toss me that rope.”) but which has come to have a meaning mostly restricted to religious context and, among many if not all Protestants, to mean something akin to worship. So that, to many an evangelical, the expressions “pray to St. Stephen” and “worship St. Stephen” are equivalent, while to a Catholic (at least a properly catechized one) “pray to St. Stephen” means “ask him to work with you on this one” while “worship St. Stephen” would be, well, blasphemous.

I am more and more convinced that 90% of what divides Catholics and Evangelicals is semantic. Of course, the other 10% is really tough!
 
Gramps, I like your explanation much better than mine. 🙂

Blessed Hope, you might want to scroll up and check out the Bible cites in my post to see where all this comes from. It’s all there.
It might be further help to take one additional step. The question was an honest one about what Catholics believe is the basis for salvation.

For non-Catholics reading in here, assume for a bit that Catholics are right. Assume it is necessary to love God to be saved. The natural question then is, do I love God? How do I know if I love? Is it something I feel inside, or is there some scriptural definition we can use to determine whether we love God. Protestants reading in who want to know if they love God would be able to know as well as Catholics who believe they must love God to be saved. The Apostle John wrote in his epistle, “The love of God consists in this, that we keep His commandments”. Love and obedience are tied.

The next question we can all ask ourselves by looking into our consciences is do I obey God’s commandments. I confess that when I look into my soul I see things that should not be there. That tells me I am in trouble. I do have faith. I hope in God. I am not perfect when it comes to obedience, love.

My guess is that if those reading ask themselves the same question they will see some internal disorder.

When Jesus told the pharisees they would die in their sins He was telling them they would go to hell. He told His apostles to preach the gospel (good news) of repentance for forgiveness of sin. We must repent of our sins. Jesus did not tell them to tell us not to worry about our sins, that they do not matter as long as we believe He is the Savior. The demons believed. We have to repent.

We need grace to repent. Maybe all the Protestants and Catholics following this thread might agree to pray for one another for this grace. It is what we pray in the beginning of Mass in the Confeitor. I confess have sinned…I ask you my brothers and sisters to pray for me to the Lord our God.

It is God’s will that we help one another, love one another, on the way of salvation.

I was in a Nazarene Church where everyone stood and pledged allegiance to the American Flag, The Christian Flag (??) and the Bible. They stood before these emblems or images that represented something and swore allegiance. I though this was a little odd, especially in loght of what they think is wrong about Catholics, but so what? The more important question is do we love one another. Why don’t we start praying for one another and stop arguing even for just one day? “Love covers a multitude of sins”.
 
We have a Prayer Shawl ministry at our Parish. They meet twice a month to knit and crochet and these shawls are donated to hospice care patients.

Paul
We do that at our parish as well, except that we partner with the women’s section of the state’s prison, and donate them yarn and they add to our bounty!
 
:rotfl:

All jokes aside, Sola Scriptura and biblical inerrancy are one of the few things that all Protestants share. If a Protestant denies the Kleenex verse, then those are both out the window. 😃
Uhhh, wrong again. Not by a long shot. I am neither a believer in sola scriptura nor God forbid, biblical inerrancy. I do hope you are learning about the Roman catholic faith, for you seem to know nothing about any denomination of Protestantism.
 
We had sunday school, vacation bible school and we always had a Christian flag there … do you think it may have something to do with that?
Ok, Cluny, now I get it.

Yes, that is a standard VBS ritual - the triple pledge of allegiance - to the American flag, the “Christian” flag and the Bible.

Even as a Baptist I was more than a little uncomfortable with it, since it seems to make the three equally worthy of our honor and allegiance.

And I presume your point is to show that when evangelicals accuse Catholics of “worshipping statues” because we sometimes pray in front of them, that this is an example of a “prayer” in front of “pieces of cloth” which is clearly not intended as worship, though to an outsider it might appear to be worship?

Possibly a useful argument, I’m not sure.
NHInsider - I think we’ve got it tagged … Christian flag procession, in which prayers where said after the Attention, Salute, Pledge …

That was many moons ago for me … every summer during VBS …

I think that I can say, it is not worship … however I think Cluny and I must agree with him … does see it as a possible arguement, but really moreso a way of explaining Catholic’s prayers to Saints and Mary etc.

God bless!
 
Uhhh, wrong again. Not by a long shot. I am neither a believer in sola scriptura nor God forbid, biblical inerrancy. I do hope you are learning about the Roman catholic faith, for you seem to know nothing about any denomination of Protestantism.
Very well, I am withdrawing from this discussion (and all discussions on this forum).

I apologize for any offense.
 
Very well, I am withdrawing from this discussion (and all discussions on this forum).

I apologize for any offense.
Her comment was rude. If you were to read up on Episcopalians, you would find that they really just do their own thing as long as they all worship the same, I was one of them. Please don’t leave. Learning about Catholicism and converting takes a life time … Just join us all in the social groups, the Spirituality forum, etc … stay away from this one, you will be much happier! 👍
 
It might be further help to take one additional step. The question was an honest one about what Catholics believe is the basis for salvation.

For non-Catholics reading in here, assume for a bit that Catholics are right. Assume it is necessary to love God to be saved. The natural question then is, do I love God? How do I know if I love? Is it something I feel inside, or is there some scriptural definition we can use to determine whether we love God. Protestants reading in who want to know if they love God would be able to know as well as Catholics who believe they must love God to be saved. The Apostle John wrote in his epistle, “The love of God consists in this, that we keep His commandments”. Love and obedience are tied.

The next question we can all ask ourselves by looking into our consciences is do I obey God’s commandments. I confess that when I look into my soul I see things that should not be there. That tells me I am in trouble. I do have faith. I hope in God. I am not perfect when it comes to obedience, love.

My guess is that if those reading ask themselves the same question they will see some internal disorder.

When Jesus told the pharisees they would die in their sins He was telling them they would go to hell. He told His apostles to preach the gospel (good news) of repentance for forgiveness of sin. We must repent of our sins. Jesus did not tell them to tell us not to worry about our sins, that they do not matter as long as we believe He is the Savior. The demons believed. We have to repent.

We need grace to repent. Maybe all the Protestants and Catholics following this thread might agree to pray for one another for this grace. It is what we pray in the beginning of Mass in the Confeitor. I confess have sinned…I ask you my brothers and sisters to pray for me to the Lord our God.

It is God’s will that we help one another, love one another, on the way of salvation.

I was in a Nazarene Church where everyone stood and pledged allegiance to the American Flag, The Christian Flag (??) and the Bible. They stood before these emblems or images that represented something and swore allegiance. I though this was a little odd, especially in loght of what they think is wrong about Catholics, but so what? The more important question is do we love one another. Why don’t we start praying for one another and stop arguing even for just one day? “Love covers a multitude of sins”.
Bless you, grandfather, for this wonderful statement. The restoration of Christian unity will begin, not initially by reconciliation of doctrine, but by recognition of the Holy Spirit in each of us, by our love for one another.

Jon
 
Not been watching the thread,who is withdrawing from the forums .
Me.
40.png
DJgang:
Please don’t leave. Learning about Catholicism and converting takes a life time.
Don’t worry, I made up my mind that Catholicism was right for me a long time ago. 🙂 I will be receiving the Sacraments of Initiation on Easter Vigil and I would appreciate your prayers so that God will help me to be a better tool for His Kingdom. Thanks!
 
Me.

Don’t worry, I made up my mind that Catholicism was right for me a long time ago. 🙂 I will be receiving the Sacraments of Initiation on Easter Vigil and I would appreciate your prayers so that God will help me to be a better tool for His Kingdom. Thanks!
David you do have my prays but please do not leave here you are always welcome and you can learn a lot here I to get upset some times and in fact I was put off the board for two weeks because I told some one to get back on his meds ,I was not trying to be rude but some one did. Hane on for a few weeks believe you will have questions and this is a good place for answers… and it is the Church started by Our Lord Jesus Christ and has been aroung for almost 2999 years NO denomination can say that…David if you are in RCIA get the book Catholicism and fundamentalism by Karl Keating it is very good,have a great week end and I will keep you in my prays, may Our Lord bless you
 
Bless you, grandfather, for this wonderful statement. The restoration of Christian unity will begin, not initially by reconciliation of doctrine, but by recognition of the Holy Spirit in each of us, by our love for one another.

Jon
I have one more request or suggestion for the Catholics and Protestants who are reading this discussion and maybe to carry into all the other Catholic and Protestant discussions where vehemence often gets the better of charity.

First we should all ask ourselves a simple question. Do you want to please Jesus in what you say and do and think? It seems like a dumb question, but you never know what crazy theologies are out there. Maybe some people think it does not matter or that it is impossible to please God. For those, scripture says He will tell those who inherit eternal life, “Well done, good and faithful servant”. Do you want to hear God speak those words to you when you meet Him and stand before Him? I think most everyone reading this would say they do.

If that is the case then we should ask ourselves what it is that God wants us to be doing with one another. Would He rather have us argue with one another, or pray for one another? I suppose you could do both. But sometimes the arguments seem endless to me, and futile. I have won a lot of theological arguments or debates. That usually does not result in the opponent becoming Catholic. Losing debates does not usually result in a person changing their religion. Here is why. If I can not answer a challenge to my faith all that proves is I don’t have the answer. It does not prove there is none. It is the witness of love that changes hearts. The reason I believe is that Jesus came here and demonstrated His love for us. It changes and breaks my stony heart.

Let’s try this. All the Protestants and Catholics who are engaged in the ongoing argument promise to pray for one another. What is the eseence of what you want for your opponent in argument? Figure it out and say so. I am Catholic. What I want for all Protestants is heaven. That is what is in my will. I hope everyone receives grace, mercy and love. I hope you will live grace filled lives of holiness. Once people know that the intentions of others for them a good, it is much easier to discuss matters of faith without it becoming acrimonious and maybe even to do what Saint Paul tells us, “Be of one mind, agree on all things”.

I have a suggestion
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top