Why do Protestants...

  • Thread starter Thread starter Filius99993
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
F

Filius99993

Guest
…have regular Church services on Wednesday and/or Thursday instead of on Sunday or Saturday? There’s nothing about holding Wednesday as sacred in their Bible, and it doesn’t make much sense to hold Thursday holy without acknowledging the Eucharist. So… why?
 
Filius, I’m confused.
Do you actually mean that the main service is on Wens?
W/o one on Sunday? I’ve never heard of this in my area (se GA).

Most protestant churches here have Sunday service, Sunday eve service, and a Wens night prayer meeting.
Where is this other happening?
 
As far as I know, they have their services on Sunday and then have a service of some sort (but it seems to be more of a prayer service than the main service) during the middle of the week. I’ve never heard of the opposite happening. I don’t know why they do that, but I don’t see anything wrong with it.
 
As far as I know, they have their services on Sunday and then have a service of some sort (but it seems to be more of a prayer service than the main service) during the middle of the week. I’ve never heard of the opposite happening. I don’t know why they do that, but I don’t see anything wrong with it.
No, it’s just a “refresher” during the week. Most of the Catholic Church’s in our area do CCD on Wednesday nights. Most of the schools in this area do not schedule any activities on Wed evening so that all of the different churchs can do their religious ed, prayer services, etc. on that night.
 
in many localities Wed is acknowledged at least tacitly as “church night” so even public schools assign less or no homework and don’t schedule games or other events past six, so students can attend praise and worship, youth group or religious instruction at their various churches. so what?
 
…have regular Church services on Wednesday and/or Thursday instead of on Sunday or Saturday? There’s nothing about holding Wednesday as sacred in their Bible, and it doesn’t make much sense to hold Thursday holy without acknowledging the Eucharist. So… why?
Most Protestant churches I’m aware of have services on Sunday. Sometimes, they have extra services on Sunday evenings (in addition to Sunday mornings) and/or Wednesdays.
 
Most Protestant churches I’m aware of have services on Sunday. Sometimes, they have extra services on Sunday evenings (in addition to Sunday mornings) and/or Wednesdays.
Yep. The Christian Reformed churches that I’m familiar with have two services on Sunday (morning and evening), with another service on Wednesday night.
 
As the previous posters (to this post) have already addressed your question, I’ll take it a step further…

…did you really mean to ask “Why do they have Wednesday night services at all when it’s not in the bible?”
 
As the previous posters (to this post) have already addressed your question, I’ll take it a step further…

…did you really mean to ask “Why do they have Wednesday night services at all when it’s not in the bible?”
Kind of.

Some of the protestants I know don’t even find it necessary to go to church, and others only go on Wed-Thurs. It has never made much sense to me.
 
Yep. The Christian Reformed churches that I’m familiar with have two services on Sunday (morning and evening), with another service on Wednesday night.
The Baptist churches around where I live do the same thing. Usually most Baptists will go to both the Sunday morning and Sunday evening services, then they will go to the Wednesday evening service too.
 
Kind of.

Some of the protestants I know don’t even find it necessary to go to church, and others only go on Wed-Thurs. It has never made much sense to me.
I don’t know any Protestants who deliberately skip Sunday services and only attend Wednesday or Thursday services. Most of the Protestants I know go both days. They also go to Sunday school in addition to the Sunday service. Almost all Protestant churches have Sunday school for all ages, not just for kids.
 
I don’t know any Protestants who deliberately skip Sunday services and only attend Wednesday or Thursday services. Most of the Protestants I know go both days. They also go to Sunday school in addition to the Sunday service. Almost all Protestant churches have Sunday school for all ages, not just for kids.
I think the point is, that if they don’t go one Sunday, there’s no guilt. They are not obligated to attend every Sunday as a Catholic is obligated to attend Mass.

The OP’s question is “why?” and I don’t know that I’m qualified to answer. But they don’t have the real presence, so they are only missing a sermon, which, in a protestant church, is only one man’s opinion of whatever passage of scripture that one man chose to lecture on for that particular Sunday.
 
I think the point is, that if they don’t go one Sunday, there’s no guilt. They are not obligated to attend every Sunday as a Catholic is obligated to attend Mass.
That is true. However, historically, Protestants have usually taken seriously the need to go to church on Sundays. The Blue Laws that used to exist were a Protestant invention.
 
That is true. However, historically, Protestants have usually taken seriously the need to go to church on Sundays. The Blue Laws that used to exist were a Protestant invention.
Oh yes certainly, I’m not contesting that at all. I live in the bible belt and I know how seriously they take their church services. I’m only making the point that if, for some reason, they don’t go, it’s not the end of the world.

For instance, dd swims and we travel on weekends to out of town meets. We are the only Catholics. We are also the only ones who come to dinner late b/c we find a local Catholic church with a Saturday vigil Mass. I’m not saying we are holier than everyone else, I’m just saying that if they (at least the team mates we have) if they are out of their local element, they don’t worry about it.

Speaking of blue laws, 🙂 we grew up in a coastal town (Gulf Coast), full of Polish fishermen, very Catholic. When my sister left home for her first job, she settled in up “north” in the bible belt. One Sunday afternoon she ran a few errands, and the blue laws in her town would not allow her to purchase light bulbs or pantyhose. :confused: She was allowed to purchase everything else (wish I could remember what that was, this was 20+ years ago!), but not light bulbs:tsktsk: or pantyhose on Sunday!!

We could figure out the light bulbs: maybe changing a light bulb was considered work and work is discouraged on Sunday. But what about pantyhose? What if she needed them to wear with her “Sunday best”? :cool:
 
Speaking of blue laws, 🙂 we grew up in a coastal town (Gulf Coast), full of Polish fishermen, very Catholic. When my sister left home for her first job, she settled in up “north” in the bible belt. One Sunday afternoon she ran a few errands, and the blue laws in her town would not allow her to purchase light bulbs or pantyhose. :confused: She was allowed to purchase everything else (wish I could remember what that was, this was 20+ years ago!), but not light bulbs:tsktsk: or pantyhose on Sunday!!

We could figure out the light bulbs: maybe changing a light bulb was considered work and work is discouraged on Sunday. But what about pantyhose? What if she needed them to wear with her “Sunday best”? :cool:
That is really weird. Back here, when I was a little kid, I remember that the grocery stores were never open on Sundays, nor were the department stores. There were very few bars with Sunday licenses. About the only place open on Sunday was Lawson’s, where we would go if we ran out of milk. The stores started opening on Sunday back in the 1970’s. It was a big deal back then. Now, even liquor stores are open on Sunday, and most bars have Sunday licenses.
 
The Protestant churches that I have been to have church services on Sundays and Bible studies or choir rehearsals or youth group meetings (usually some kind of Bible study) or all three on Wednesday nights. They do not have church services on Wednesday nights.

The exception is the Episcopal church I went to, which celebrates the Holy Eucharist every day.

Also, in Texas we cannot sell alcohol before noon (if I remember correctly) on Sundays. We cannot sell alcohol after midnight or before seven am on any other day. I think we might not be allowed to sell alcohol after 10pm on Sundays, but I’m not sure.
 
Also, in Texas we cannot sell alcohol before noon (if I remember correctly) on Sundays. We cannot sell alcohol after midnight or before seven am on any other day. I think we might not be allowed to sell alcohol after 10pm on Sundays, but I’m not sure.
From this website:
CHAPTER 29. MIXED BEVERAGE LATE HOURS PERMIT
Sec. 29.01. AUTHORIZED ACTIVITIES. The holder of a mixed beverage late hours permit may sell mixed beverages on Sunday between the hours of 1:00 a.m. and 2 a.m. and on any other day between the hours of 12 midnight and 2 a.m. if the premises covered by the permit are in an area where the sale of mixed beverages during those hours is authorized by this code.
Sec. 29.02. FEE. The annual state fee for a mixed beverage late hours permit is $150.
Sec. 29.03. APPLICATION OF PROVISIONS REGULATING MIXED BEVERAGE PERMITS. All provisions of this code which apply to a mixed beverage permit also apply to a mixed beverage late hours permit.
 
Yes, I remember. Sunday school at 9am on (naturally!) Sunday. Then “worship” service at 10 am Sunday. Then Sunday night service at 7pm (which wasn’t so bad because there was more singing and less preaching). Then AWANA on Tuesday night for the kids while adults did “visitation.” Then Wednesday night prayer service.

And as our pastor often said, “IF THE DOORS OF THE CHURCH ARE OPEN YOU SHOULD BE THERE!!!” Sorry for the caps. Don’t know how else to type fire-n-brimstone oration.
 
Kind of.

Some of the protestants I know don’t even find it necessary to go to church, and others only go on Wed-Thurs. It has never made much sense to me.
Personally, the one hour a week requirement of the Catholic church is very lacking. It wouldn’t hurt every Catholic to darken the church doors a little more often.
 
Personally, the one hour a week requirement of the Catholic church is very lacking. It wouldn’t hurt every Catholic to darken the church doors a little more often.
I think you’re mistaken. Once weekly mass is an obligation. There’s nothing anywhere that I’m aware of that says mass lasts only one hour. The other obligation is to be Christ for others everywhere one is… for the 168 or so hours per week.

And by what authority does anyone “require” anything? Is it a protestant requirement to go to church at all? Where is that in the Bible?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top