Why do the catholics I meet seem uninterested?

  • Thread starter Thread starter shayneswenson
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

shayneswenson

Guest
I’m a revert. Former reformed/evangelical, and though I am in love theologically, I am less than impressed with the lack of concern, and overall uninspired, and outright rude interactions I have had with the majority of catholics I have tried to engage. I don’t mean to be offensive, and my tone in this post is not angry, entitled, or indignant. I am frankly let down. Maybe my expectations were not met so I’m upset, but honestly, I have considered returning, strictly for the fellowship, to a protestant church to supplement my lack of fellowship with committed Christians. Again I’m sorry if I offend any catholics, but I’m just expressing my genuine experiences here, and reading other posts, I’m not alone. Seems to be the norm. I realize that catholics are traditionally very conservative, and I’m sure my zeal for Christ, and my large amount of visible tattoos can really make the older folks uncomfortable. I get it. I am a tattoo artist, and have been for many years. I’m not stupid, and I realize my appearance can make some uncomfortable at first impression. I dress fashionable, but relatively conservative. No weird clothes, or piercings or hair. I do go out of my way to be approachable, and like I said, distrust and eyebrow raising comes with the territory. I have dealt with it for years and it doesn’t bother me. I don’t know if it’s that, or the fact that there are just not that many “faithful” practicing catholics I have met yet. I sorta feel unwelcome almost, and that I don’t belong. It’s a huge bummer. Any ideas as to how to connect? I’m dying for fellowship, and am a very “dive In” kinda guy, and maybe I just haven’t met the right group/people? Again, sorry if I sound rude, and any (name removed by moderator)ut is welcome.
 
I’m a revert. Former reformed/evangelical, and though I am in love theologically, I am less than impressed with the lack of concern, and overall uninspired, and outright rude interactions I have had with the majority of catholics I have tried to engage. I don’t mean to be offensive, and my tone in this post is not angry, entitled, or indignant. I am frankly let down. Maybe my expectations were not met so I’m upset, but honestly, I have considered returning, strictly for the fellowship, to a protestant church to supplement my lack of fellowship with committed Christians. Again I’m sorry if I offend any catholics, but I’m just expressing my genuine experiences here, and reading other posts, I’m not alone. Seems to be the norm. I realize that catholics are traditionally very conservative, and I’m sure my zeal for Christ, and my large amount of visible tattoos can really make the older folks uncomfortable. I get it. I am a tattoo artist, and have been for many years. I’m not stupid, and I realize my appearance can make some uncomfortable at first impression. I dress fashionable, but relatively conservative. No weird clothes, or piercings or hair. I do go out of my way to be approachable, and like I said, distrust and eyebrow raising comes with the territory. I have dealt with it for years and it doesn’t bother me. I don’t know if it’s that, or the fact that there are just not that many “faithful” practicing catholics I have met yet. I sorta feel unwelcome almost, and that I don’t belong. It’s a huge bummer. Any ideas as to how to connect? I’m dying for fellowship, and am a very “dive In” kinda guy, and maybe I just haven’t met the right group/people? Again, sorry if I sound rude, and any (name removed by moderator)ut is welcome.
 
Again, my tone is not rough in any way, and the few people that I have met that ARE committed and “into” catholicism have been extremely helpful, loving, knowledgable, and informative. No doubt about that, or my appreciation for those few diamonds in the rough. Thanks to them and their sacrificial giving of their time, energy and knowledge, especially in our RCIA program.
 
Welcome back home! 👋

Catholic parishes are not filled, like a lot of Evangelical ones, with people who are there because they chose the parish for the preaching, the singing, the Bible study, or the fellowship. They are in that parish because they live there. So, you are going to find people of every sort from the icy cold to the very devoted. Catholic tend to be family-oriented instead of community-at-large-oriented. Since most don’t know one another, they tend to associate with family members or already-made friends.

If you want to get to know people at a Catholic parish you should get involved in some small group activity/service. Most parishes have a list of groups you can join. If you’re a guy, you could check out the Knights of Columbus or similar men’s group.

There might also be a lay religious community attached to the parish, such as the Franciscans or Carmelites.

So, you might want to call the parish or consult their bulletin or talk to people involved in the kind of group you are interested in being a part of. 🙂
 
Thank you. I figured it might just be a misunderstanding of the catholic " culture" on my part.
 
I am less than impressed with the lack of concern, and overall uninspired, and outright rude interactions I have had with the majority of catholics I have tried to engage.
Could you describe some of these interaction attempts? To give some perspective on what it is you’re dealing with? :rolleyes:
 
Could you describe some of these interaction attempts? To give some perspective on what it is you’re dealing with? :rolleyes:
I am not quite sure why you are rolling your eyes. Unfortunately, it is a fact that some Catholic parishes are pretty individual-based, compared to Evangelicalism.

My advice to the OP would be maybe try to “dive into” the spiritual life of the church by the means of some kind of ministry. Choir group, bible study, Knights of Columbus, St. Vincent de Paul ministry, volunteering for Youth group etc are all great ways to really get to know some of your fellow Catholics in the pews. I think you will find the Internet is also filled with great Catholic resources and communities like this one.

God Bless you on your journey and may the Holy Spirit keep you in Christ’s church
 
I would also suggest to the OP that since you live in Eastern Washington, is it possible you live near Spokane (realizing that Washington is a large state, it is possible this is not the case)? College age students tend to be more liberal as a whole, so you might try attending services or fellowships at Gonzaga University but this is something that you would have to look into
 
I have discovered that most of the devote Catholics are quietly studying and meditating at home. They rarely share their experiences because it is their personal journey of faith and they don’t want to drag people down into their pits or make them feel inadequate when they are in a spiritually blessed patch.

The problem with us reverts is that we can be a bit of the odd one out because we are rediscovering the wonders and joys of God and the Church. I respect the people who kept the church open and pew warm for me, attend Mass with joy and reverence, support the Church but I know that community learning isn’t going to happen at my Parish. So I attend lectures or talks at the Cathedral, look out for what other Catholic parishes offer and mainly journey alone with God. I would never go to another denomination for teachings because I don’t want to have to defend my faith or learn things counter to the Church’s teachings.

I will gladly stay at my parish church because God wants me there. My personal selfish choice would be a parish with Bible Study, courses in different spirituality’s e.g. Dominican, Franciscan etc. or Church history. But it isn’t about me, its about what God wants.
 
I strongly recommend joining an active K of C group in some parish. “Dive in” kinds of guys are exactly what an active chapter wants. And they’re not going to care a thing about your tattoos as long as you don’t mind selling Tootsie Rolls for retarded children, cooking for dinners to raise money for charity, helping repair parish structures, having a beer and a bowl of chili after meetings, or saying the rosary with a bunch of other men.
 
Go try to commune (fellowship) with protestants to discover the common ground in faith! There is a challenge! I am doing this very thing and finding very few protestants willing to make ground. I get resistance and contempt with many. They are thinking I want to convert them and debate, when I just want to hear their faith in deeper areas. 🤷

But yes, someone suggested in house activity groups.👍

Michael
 
I’m a revert. Former reformed/evangelical, and though I am in love theologically, I am less than impressed with the lack of concern, and overall uninspired, and outright rude interactions I have had with the majority of catholics I have tried to engage. I don’t mean to be offensive, and my tone in this post is not angry, entitled, or indignant. I am frankly let down. Maybe my expectations were not met so I’m upset, but honestly, I have considered returning, strictly for the fellowship, to a protestant church to supplement my lack of fellowship with committed Christians. Again I’m sorry if I offend any catholics, but I’m just expressing my genuine experiences here, and reading other posts, I’m not alone. Seems to be the norm. I realize that catholics are traditionally very conservative, and I’m sure my zeal for Christ, and my large amount of visible tattoos can really make the older folks uncomfortable. I get it. I am a tattoo artist, and have been for many years. I’m not stupid, and I realize my appearance can make some uncomfortable at first impression. I dress fashionable, but relatively conservative. No weird clothes, or piercings or hair. I do go out of my way to be approachable, and like I said, distrust and eyebrow raising comes with the territory. I have dealt with it for years and it doesn’t bother me. I don’t know if it’s that, or the fact that there are just not that many “faithful” practicing catholics I have met yet. I sorta feel unwelcome almost, and that I don’t belong. It’s a huge bummer. Any ideas as to how to connect? I’m dying for fellowship, and am a very “dive In” kinda guy, and maybe I just haven’t met the right group/people? Again, sorry if I sound rude, and any (name removed by moderator)ut is welcome.
I don’t know, honestly. I’ll tell you this: I was born/raised Catholic and I kinda feel the same way that you do, I think. I get a frigid feeling from most of my fellow Catholics. I’m sure that’s not true of Catholics in many areas of the world, but I do believe it is true where I’m from. I’m a more passionate person and I have a hard time getting any kind of satisfying interaction with them. I don’t get the feeling of community that seems to be present in many Protestant organizations. It’s a stumbling block in my faith, because I feel like the kind of person that is really fueled by that kind of interaction.

So I’ll pray for you about this, I know it’s tricky.
 
I’m a revert. Former reformed/evangelical, and though I am in love theologically, I am less than impressed with the lack of concern, and overall uninspired, and outright rude interactions I have had with the majority of catholics I have tried to engage. I don’t mean to be offensive, and my tone in this post is not angry, entitled, or indignant. I am frankly let down. Maybe my expectations were not met so I’m upset, but honestly, I have considered returning, strictly for the fellowship, to a protestant church to supplement my lack of fellowship with committed Christians. Again I’m sorry if I offend any catholics, but I’m just expressing my genuine experiences here, and reading other posts, I’m not alone. Seems to be the norm. I realize that catholics are traditionally very conservative, and I’m sure my zeal for Christ, and my large amount of visible tattoos can really make the older folks uncomfortable. I get it. I am a tattoo artist, and have been for many years. I’m not stupid, and I realize my appearance can make some uncomfortable at first impression. I dress fashionable, but relatively conservative. No weird clothes, or piercings or hair. I do go out of my way to be approachable, and like I said, distrust and eyebrow raising comes with the territory. I have dealt with it for years and it doesn’t bother me. I don’t know if it’s that, or the fact that there are just not that many “faithful” practicing catholics I have met yet. I sorta feel unwelcome almost, and that I don’t belong. It’s a huge bummer. Any ideas as to how to connect? I’m dying for fellowship, and am a very “dive In” kinda guy, and maybe I just haven’t met the right group/people? Again, sorry if I sound rude, and any (name removed by moderator)ut is welcome.
My father is now a Baptist. He often mentions the “fellowship” thing. Growing up, we didn’t know many people in my parish because we didn’t live in the same school district / community as most of the people. We were a large parish which comprised of 2.5 entire school districts. Four public high schools, one Catholic high school, four public middle (jr. high) schools, one Catholic middle school, 16 public elementary schools, and one Catholic elementary school! That’s a lot. Not to mention the non-Catholic private schools. :eek:

They have Mass 5 times every Sundays, the Saturday Vigil, plus a Latin Mass one Sunday a month. At that parish, it could be easy to not see the same people every week. 😛

Most people would become friendly with others via CYO, Youth Group, Knights of Columbus, etc.

While the Parish of my youth was VERY LARGE, I do find that most Catholic parishes are larger than Protestant ones. Today, I live in an area where I know no one. A lot of people walk to Church and have known each other for years. I just try to focus on my relationship with Jesus.

However, I’ve started attending a bi-weekly Bible study and try to attend daily Mass at the parish by my office. When possible, I try to attend a Rosary and/or Novena in the evenings at my Parish (if home in time) too. It’s often a lot easier to develop “fellowship” at daily Mass, Novenas, Rosary groups, Bible studies, etc. than at Sunday Mass. I also have made it a point to try to develop relationships with the Priests and Deacons.

In summary, the best way to develop fellowship in most Catholic Parishes is to get involved in the activities/groups which take place outside of Sunday Mass.

(If it would help, please feel free to send me a private message if you would like to chat about it more.)

Good luck, God Bless & welcome home! 👍
 
I’m a revert. Former reformed/evangelical, and though I am in love theologically, I am less than impressed with the lack of concern, and overall uninspired, and outright rude interactions I have had with the majority of catholics I have tried to engage. I don’t mean to be offensive, and my tone in this post is not angry, entitled, or indignant. I am frankly let down. Maybe my expectations were not met so I’m upset, but honestly, I have considered returning, strictly for the fellowship, to a protestant church to supplement my lack of fellowship with committed Christians. Again I’m sorry if I offend any catholics, but I’m just expressing my genuine experiences here, and reading other posts, I’m not alone. Seems to be the norm. I realize that catholics are traditionally very conservative, and I’m sure my zeal for Christ, and my large amount of visible tattoos can really make the older folks uncomfortable. I get it. I am a tattoo artist, and have been for many years. I’m not stupid, and I realize my appearance can make some uncomfortable at first impression. I dress fashionable, but relatively conservative. No weird clothes, or piercings or hair. I do go out of my way to be approachable, and like I said, distrust and eyebrow raising comes with the territory. I have dealt with it for years and it doesn’t bother me. I don’t know if it’s that, or the fact that there are just not that many “faithful” practicing catholics I have met yet. I sorta feel unwelcome almost, and that I don’t belong. It’s a huge bummer. Any ideas as to how to connect? I’m dying for fellowship, and am a very “dive In” kinda guy, and maybe I just haven’t met the right group/people? Again, sorry if I sound rude, and any (name removed by moderator)ut is welcome.
Not tooting my own spirituality, but try joining a “third order” or oblate group or the Knights of Columbus. Remember, it is much easier to get to know people in a small group setting. Also, Mass isn’t for socializing–it’s for worship. People in the group may pass out at first seeing all the tattoos 😃 , but once they realize that you are a faithful Catholic, you’ll fit in just fine.🙂
 
I remember once talking to a convert; a very vivacious lady. Somebody brought up the complaint about the lack of “fellowshipping” in Catholic parishes. She remarked that she could do all of that she wanted at Starbucks, but went to church to worship God. That’s one of the reasons she joined the Church.
 
I remember once talking to a convert; a very vivacious lady. Somebody brought up the complaint about the lack of “fellowshipping” in Catholic parishes. She remarked that she could do all of that she wanted at Starbucks, but went to church to worship God. That’s one of the reasons she joined the Church.
There ya go:)
 
I remember once talking to a convert; a very vivacious lady. Somebody brought up the complaint about the lack of “fellowshipping” in Catholic parishes. She remarked that she could do all of that she wanted at Starbucks, but went to church to worship God. That’s one of the reasons she joined the Church.
Yes, Catholics tend to be more in the world that do Evangelicals, but then we don’t feel the obligation to “win” everyone we meet to our brand of Christianity, nor are we so insular within our Catholic circle. Evangelicals make lots of friends inside their churches but very few from other faith communities, unless they think they way they do.

We go to Mass to worship God in spirit and in truth, to hear his word proclaimed, and to receive the Body and Blood, Soul and Divinity of Our Lord Jesus Christ. Fellowship is fine, but it’s way down on the list of priorities for us. 🙂 We join parish groups, apostolates, Bible studies, and 3rd orders if we want to be actively involved in our faith or have more personal faith sharing.
 
I’m a revert. Former reformed/evangelical, and though I am in love theologically, I am less than impressed with the lack of concern, and overall uninspired, and outright rude interactions I have had with the majority of catholics I have tried to engage. I don’t mean to be offensive, and my tone in this post is not angry, entitled, or indignant. I am frankly let down. Maybe my expectations were not met so I’m upset, but honestly, I have considered returning, strictly for the fellowship, to a protestant church to supplement my lack of fellowship with committed Christians. Again I’m sorry if I offend any catholics, but I’m just expressing my genuine experiences here, and reading other posts, I’m not alone. Seems to be the norm. I realize that catholics are traditionally very conservative, and I’m sure my zeal for Christ, and my large amount of visible tattoos can really make the older folks uncomfortable. I get it. I am a tattoo artist, and have been for many years. I’m not stupid, and I realize my appearance can make some uncomfortable at first impression. I dress fashionable, but relatively conservative. No weird clothes, or piercings or hair. I do go out of my way to be approachable, and like I said, distrust and eyebrow raising comes with the territory. I have dealt with it for years and it doesn’t bother me. I don’t know if it’s that, or the fact that there are just not that many “faithful” practicing catholics I have met yet. I sorta feel unwelcome almost, and that I don’t belong. It’s a huge bummer. Any ideas as to how to connect? I’m dying for fellowship, and am a very “dive In” kinda guy, and maybe I just haven’t met the right group/people? Again, sorry if I sound rude, and any (name removed by moderator)ut is welcome.
I have been Catholic all my life. I’ve been a member of many catholic parishes in the U.S. and I will say that Catholics tend to be a tough crowd when trying to make new friends. A lot of catholics stick with their own and don’t go out of their comfort zone a lot. I agree with many of the suggestions to join groups. But I would be prepared to feel torn between two worlds.

Especially as a creative person, it will be difficult finding like-minded peers within the Catholic church. As a creative type, my opinion is that Catholics tend to be a stodgy bunch that immediately associate any type of creative effort with loose morals and hedonism. That being said, when you do find Catholic friends, they are usually friends for life. If you live in a large metropolitan area it should increase your odds of finding your niche.

In the end, it isn’t you, but it will take a while to get to know the people in the parish. But when you do become part of parish life, I am sure you will be a breath of fresh air and bring a unique talents and perspectives to the parish.
 
I’m with you.
I have grown up Catholic, and even in the parish school, so I took for granted being part of the parish, knowing people and being involved.
2 years ago we (husband, 2 young children) moved to a small town to a tiny Catholic parish and have had the same experience as you. Well, actually, the people in the 70+ age group are welcoming and friendly, and I am thankful for that. But, when I have tried to speak with or engage in conversation with other parents of children or people around my age, they seem cold or at least completely uninterested. They have grown up here, they have their family life here, and don’t seem interested in knowing anyone new. This includes my children–they have no friends at our parish church.
It seems that whenever people mention this problem on this forum, there are some that reply it is not necessary to form relationships with others at church, or that is not the reason they go, they go for mass. While it is true that we do not go for “fellowship” alone, from what I understand, the parish is the COMMUNITY of those who believe and worship TOGETHER, so it IS lonely when one feels like an outsider at the place you worship, and discouraging when others seem to not care you are a part of that community.
I wish I could be more encouraging, or offer suggestions of what would help. It is a sore spot for me.
IS there a Scripture Study you can join or other activity at your parish? I am in one, and I do enjoy going, though still no one my close to my age.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top