OK, but the students who know how to take advantage of the huge universities with the faculty in the National Academy of Science can do real research in real research laboratories with world-class science, and be on their way to becoming world-class scientists themselves. I know because I’ve seen it happen.
Other students need to choose their institutions a bit more carefully. I went to a small public college, while my high school classmates went to the big one. At the end of our first year, my old classmates were waiting in lines 30 deep to see their professors for a few minutes of office hours. My professors knew me by my first name, even the English professor. I’m probably unusually outgoing, but by the end of our second year, they knew all their own majors by their first name, and quite a few of the students in related majors who took their courses.
Having said that, I taught as a graduate student in a university with first-year basic classes of about 600. The professors still met one-on-one with the undergraduates who had the inititative to go and see them. For those students, there was no place on the planet that could provide the same opportunites as that huge place. It just depends on the student.
You can’t just fork over the money to some place with a beautiful campus or a very old sign out front and say “educate me”. You have to go into it like an adult, and look for your opportunities, and make the most of them. If you don’t want to do that, or if you’re too busy enjoying that your parents can’t force you to perform academically any more when there is fun to be had, you’re not going to get the same “quality education to show for it”, no matter where you go…and that includes if you stay out in the real world and get a job. Education is a “drawing out” of yourself. If you expect the world to come to you, you’re going to be disappointed. No educational reform will ever change that basic fact, and we can’t teach our kids that too young.