Why doesn't the Catholic Church take a stance against online role-playing games?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Sublime_Prince
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I play Runescape but in a different way. I cyber-preach! I type in Hail Mary’s and Our Fathers and loads of other prayers. I also sit in those “temples” and tell people to leave. Actually it works very well!
Sounds like a good way to play the game:thumbsup: 👍 👍

Fiction is fiction…but as I said before, its the “getting too caught up in in” that is the danger. When someone gets to the point where they are so invested in the game or even a soap-opera that it gets to be like reality to them…that’s dangerous. Don’t think it doesn’t happen…it does…and those people can end up just a bit “psychotic”.

There is a significant difference between playing a game and living the part. Playing is like fiction… and its ok.

Me, I like “Star Wars”…not that I read the books, but I like the movies…and have seen a couple of them several times. But they have had no effect of shaping any characteristic of my person.
 
Has anyone played Testament? I hear it is pretty good…

Oh BTW… to the OP… My dh introduced RPG to all our kids because he is a DM and next week we are going to a gaming convention… we have made an informed decision… kids learn the difference between fantasy and reality as well as good from evil playing these games.
 
Oh, c’mon, people, this is just as ridiculous that saying Harry Potter teaching witchcraft!

The gods in a roleplaying game are fiction. People are just stupid if they actually worship a runescape god. It makes sense that Jagex would invent gods of their own as not to stir controversy, since it is a fun game open to people of all religions. So inventing fictional characters makes sense. Thinking Saradomin is an actual god is like saying that Harry Potter actually existed.
 
No, you don’t actually pray to false gods. It’s a way of totaling owning noobs.😃

Runescape is totally epic. WOW is a nerd game. Harry Potter doesn’t really do anything unless and idiot or a NOOOOOOBBBBBBBBBB is watching it.
 
I play Runescape but in a different way. I cyber-preach! I type in Hail Mary’s and Our Fathers and loads of other prayers. I also sit in those “temples” and tell people to leave. Actually it works very well!
I have to say that that would work differently in Runescape. People would probably report you for spamming. And I don’t really. Just don’t say profanity or things that would lead other people to Hell.

Response to lady making thread: You really have no life whatsoever by thinking that a game should be taken away from all servants of God just because you don’t like it.

Anyway. I got 70 magic and got claws of guthix and saradomin strike at lvl 60 magic. You don’t say that automatically when you cast the spell on some noob.

All in all, maybe you should play RS or any other MMO before criticism, beause Jesus said nothing against it.
 
I am curious why the church has not taken a strong stance against some online video games while other denominations have?

I really don’t think many people outside the video game community know a great deal about what goes on in these games if they did I am 100% positive the church would be very against these types of games.

I have a weakness for these games, but I really feel that many I have played online are not healthy and are anti-christian.

Many games exist like Everquest, Diablo, God Wars, World of Warcraft, but i will use the game called Runescape for example.

In Runescape prayer is a very important part of the game. Players have to chant prayers in order to protect them from harm. These are not prayers to God, but to false Gods; the Gods that exist in runescape.

Prayer in runescape is a skill that can be raised, the higher your prayer level the more you will last in battle. I vividly remember training my prayer level for four hours straight by praying to false Gods without ceasing. This process included collecting bones, grinding them up,mixing them with slime, pooring this mixture over a statue of a false God then getting on my knees and praying to that statue continuously to gain prayer experience. Many players like myself would pray to these False Gods continuously for 4+ hours a day to raise there prayer experience as high as they could.

To gain access to high level magical spells a player has to pray to the God of his choice to gain access to that Gods “God spell”. These are the most powerful spells in the game. When a player casts a God spell he yells out “For the Glory of Sardomin!” or “For the glory of Guthix” or “For the Glory of Zamorak!”

In runescape stealing is greatly encouraged in fact it is a skill in the game the benefits the player and any player who chooses not to advance this skill is at a great disadvantage. Players steal from market stalls, guards, farmers, and many computer generated characters.

Players were for some time until recently encouraged to PK in the game. Player Killing is the process of killing another player and often stealing the other players possessions for profit. This is not often voluntary and many times not consensual. Many players have to venture into PK zones in order to complete quests in the game and have no choice.

Games like this teach the player to lie, to steal, to cheat and most of all greed is a central part of the game.

I was an odd ball playing a game most kids play, but it really concerned me playing the game how young the players I was playing with. I was worried their parents had no idea the corrupt morals games like this were teaching their children. These parents have no idea all the sins their children are committing online. You see online you can sin all you want in these games and no punishment will come to you. You can worship false Gods, steal from other players, cheat , lie , and defraud and in most cases no punishment will ever be handed down to you.

The main reason I think the church doesn’t take a stance on these games is the clergy in the catholic church at high ranking positions are all very old men who probably have never played an online video game in their life much less an online role-playing game. They have no idea about these games or much about what goes on in these games. They can only go by what they have heard. I am 100% positive if these clergy played the games online I have and have seen the false worship of Gods and the sins committed in these games they would not hesitate to take a strong stance against them.
Write a letter to your Bishop or even the Vatican. The old men you refer to are very aware of what is going on in society. Cardinal Ratzinger had something to say about the Harry Potter books. Do you think the Vatican has no computers?

thepinoycatholic.blogspot.com/2010/07/first-3d-animated-game-for-catechesis.html

Peace,
Ed
 
I’m surprised you mentioned Diablo.

Diablo, at least or especially the original, means (of course) “Devil,” in Spanish, and your mission is to defeat Diablo in the game. The context is in a medieval setting wherein you slowly purge an old Monastery (going down through its dungeon layers, then through the catacombs, and finally ending in Hell) where you battle Diablo, who’s annoying to fight but once you get familiar with his tactics easily beaten assuming you didn’t rush to fight him and are therefore poorly prepared. “Diablo” was unleashed to the world owing to a traitorous minister of your (the player’s) rightful King. This traitorous minister poisoned the (mind of the) King, then kidnapped the King’s young and only son and heir (whom you later rescue). Furthermore, the traitorous minister (Lazareth, if I recall) is highly reminiscent of the Biblical idea of a or an anti-Christ, who seeks to usurp and replace all authority in order to bring the way of the devil for his own profit. He’s clearly a Satanist insomuch as he grovels at the power of his “master,” Diablo, and does this in such a way that it infuriates the player (owing to the minister’s wicked/evil deeds). A young person may actually be a little intimidated by this bravado on the part of the wicked minister, but more often than not the player will choose to bravely push onward confident that ultimately he will be able to defeat/overcome the evil minister and even his master.

Diablo insinuated to me (when I was a young secularist/atheist) some basic monotheistic tenets and religious concepts that were hardly turn offs. Seeing as it was a game, I did not feel intellectually challenged by it nor did I feel like someone was trying to convert me. At its core was the idea of Heaven vs. Hell, Good vs. Evil. I strictly recall that one of the best items you could have was the Silks of Valour (or Virtue, if I recall), which was Roman Imperial-inspired regalia, reminiscent of what Emperor Constantine would wear ; nonetheless, that helped confirmed me (in my youth) about the positive beliefs I had in the goodness of human virtue(s), which was rarely positively encouraged or affirmed among my peers, my educators or in the media (though Gladiator and Braveheart were good for this, at least 🙂 ).

Games can have all sorts of inspirations, and are neutral like anything, and only become “good” or “evil” when used for either purpose. It is highly feasible that Diablo didn’t have a little Catholic influence, and nothing in Diablo would turn someone off from the Catholic Church.

The Lord of the Rings, for example, could at first sight or glance appear anti-Christian or at least anti-orthodox Christianity, owing to its use of fanciful creatures and fairy-tales, etc, ; however, we know for a fact that J.R.R Tolkien was not a little Catholic, and his Catholicism played a part in inspriring his work and its themes. If anything, games like Diablo and works like the Lord of the Rings are spiritually good for people, and can confirm them inwardly about basic morality, the existence of good and evil, etc., without threatening or challenging them. It can be one small step towards conversion as the reader/player explores these concepts and finds them not only un-offensive but verifiably and positively “good.”

Pax,
Tim
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top