Why don't Americans like Muslims?

  • Thread starter Thread starter MugenOne
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
M

MugenOne

Guest
By Spengler

Popular antipathy to a proposed Islamic center near Ground Zero is so fierce that even President Barack Obama, the nation’s Islamophile-in-chief, “clarified” his August 11 statement supporting the plan to say, “I will not comment on the wisdom of making the decision to put a mosque there.” It is not just a mosque, of which there are two in the neighborhood, but a symbol of Islamic presence. The most recent CNN poll shows an overwhelming 70%-29% margin of opposition.
Code:
																When liberal politicians - like the president and New York's Mayor Michael  																	Bloomberg - defend the plan, what they mean is, "We want a big Islamic  																	statement near Ground Zero as a gesture of outreach to the Muslim world." When  																	the political right denounces it, they mean, "Muslim conquerors always build a  																	mosque atop the ruins of the places they conquer, and we're not going to give the rascals  																	the satisfaction." That was predictable. 																	
																
																What is surprising is how passionately Americans oppose the Ground Zero mosque.  																	A revolt is brewing against America's liberal political elite. 																	
																
																It is hard to find consistent polling data about American attitudes towards  																	Islam. The largest polling organizations, Pew and Gallup, draw funding from  																	organizations with a vested interest in promoting a benign view of Islam.  																	Nonetheless, the results are striking: in a Gallup inquiry [1] published in  																	January 2010, Americans had an "unfavorable" view of Islam by a margin of  																	53%-42%, with 31% holding a strongly negative view. That contrasts with 15% for  																	Judaism and 4% for Christianity.
Who likes Islam, and who doesn’t? The lines appear drawn sharply. According to a 2007 Pew Foundation survey, two-thirds of liberal Democrats have a favorable view of Islam. Slightly over half of mainline (that is, liberal) Protestants view Islam favorably, but only a fifth of white evangelical Protestants.

atimes.com/atimes/Middle_East/LH17Ak01.html

Looks like liberals need to see more bombings in the name of Allah before they wake up.
 
By Spengler
Code:
															When liberal politicians - like the president and New York's Mayor Michael  																	Bloomberg - defend the plan, what they mean is, "We want a big Islamic  																	statement near Ground Zero as a gesture of outreach to the Muslim world."
Looks like liberals need to see more bombings in the name of Allah before they wake up.
Or maybe more people need to read the First Amendment to the United States Constitution. Do you want some “Worship Place Czar” telling us where we can build our churches?
 
The question is worded wrong. Perhaps we should be asking:

Would Londoners have enthused about building a monument to Hitler in Trafalgar Square? Would Americans have cheered the building of a Shinto shrine on the ruins of Pearl Harbor?

And those were wartime acts of aggression, not the slaughter of three thousand innocent civilians in peacetime.
 
The question is worded wrong. Perhaps we should be asking:

Would Londoners have enthused about building a monument to Hitler in Trafalgar Square? Would Americans have cheered the building of a Shinto shrine on the ruins of Pearl Harbor?
As far as I know; no one ever opposed the German Embassy in Belgrave Square in London; even though in London alone at least 40,000 civilians were murdered by bombing.

It is counterproductive and absurd to blame all muslims for 911; as it would be ridiculous for us to blame all Germans for the blitz. We shouldn’t penalise an entirety of a population for a minority action.

Building a Centre for Muslims near Ground Zero is not equivalent to building a statue of Hitler; it is the same as allowing Germany to have an embassy; the arguments against the ground zero Mosque ammount to nothing more than Collective Punishment and infringement on peoples human rights to assemble and freely practice religion.
 
Opposing the mosque building site isn’t necessarily anti-Muslim act. The motive behind the opposition is about sensitivity and respect.
The attacks on 9-11, and before, are against America, not against American beliefs or policies or pagans practices but America. The people behind the attacks are ALL muslim and are attacking under the muslim name, now I didn’t say all muslims are against america but clearly America was attacked by (radical)muslims, that much is FACT. I know that the only bad people here are people with hatred in their hearts for one another, that goes for both sides but we need to help ease tension and let people heal not build a mosque practically on-top of the towers that radical muslims brought down.
 
MugenOne, I think you need to choose your words more carefully, because your painting with very broad strokes when you ask a question like “Why don’t Americans like Muslims?” Your question assumes that all Americans are hate mongers, and that all Americans hate Muslims, which would be very far from the truth. I also think that I could turn this question around and ask, why don’t Muslims like Americans? Why do Muslims consider everyone but themselves infidels? Why do Muslims target and kill Americans?

Do I think that all Muslims feel this way? Absolutely not. But I also think that you shouldn’t imply that all Americans hate Muslims.

Since Iv’e turned this around, let me ask you another question. Why do Muslims not drink alcohol or view pornography, but have no problems with coming here, opening a store and stocking their shelves full of garbage like that and selling it to Americans?

I also think that probably many Americans have a hard time loving people who strap explosives to themselves and kill innocent women & children in the name of God, and fly 747’s into buildings killing thousands of innocent people in the name of God.

If you plan on answering my post, please don’t pick out one little thing Iv’e written and turn it around on me, but answer the whole post truthfully.
 
MugenOne, I think you need to choose your words more carefully, because your painting with very broad strokes when you ask a question like “Why don’t Americans like Muslims?” Your question assumes that all Americans are hate mongers, and that all Americans hate Muslims, which would be very far from the truth. I also think that I could turn this question around and ask, why don’t Muslims like Americans? Why do Muslims consider everyone but themselves infidels? Why do Muslims target and kill Americans?
MugenOne is only following forum rules by using the title of the article as the title of the thread.
So it is Spengler that is engaging in the usual race-baiting sort of diatribe with his inflammatory title.
 
I think the problem for most Americans is that building a mosque so close to ground zero will make it look like a victory flag.
 
Building a Centre for Muslims near Ground Zero is not equivalent to building a statue of Hitler; it is the same as allowing Germany to have an embassy; the arguments against the ground zero Mosque ammount to nothing more than Collective Punishment and infringement on peoples human rights to assemble and freely practice religion.
Hi,

I’d be inclined to agree if it wasn’t for the fact that their beliefs are contrary to human rights in the first place. The Muslim community certainly did not react to 9/11 in a humane way, at least here in Italy. Muslim shops in my town were party centers on the the 11th and 12th of September 2001, hardly a way to show disdain for an act of terror. I guess they were all extremists… However I have yet to hear a Muslim religious leader preach that 9/11 was a sinful act, contrary to God. I personally have never heard anyone say so. Now, I don’t read every paper but it seems odd that to never to have encountered any news to that effect.

Add to that the extremely poor record of human rights in Muslim countries, where Sharia law rules and you see why Islam cannot be protected by the 1st amendment. Would you allow a religion that preaches illegal acts? peadophilia? the inferiority of women?

Iran, Saudia Arabia, Sharia law regions of Nigeria, I surely would not want to live there, would you? What do you think of the stoning or raped women? Nice Islamic law, isn’t it? I surely would like the mosque down the road to preach something like that. I always hear that Muslims preach peace and tolerance, pity that their religion is without a formal leadership, allowing anyone to preach hate while the majority of their brothers in faith cheer.

Please excuse me if the message came over too strong but we cannot allow everything to hide behind the “religious freedom” banner.
 
I would have to agree about the cheering and partying that followed the 9-11 attacks. I was attending a university down south with a small muslim population and security had to separate them because of the partying that followed the bombings
 
MugenOne, I think you need to choose your words more carefully, because your painting with very broad strokes when you ask a question like “Why don’t Americans like Muslims?” Your question assumes that all Americans are hate mongers, and that all Americans hate Muslims, which would be very far from the truth. I also think that I could turn this question around and ask, why don’t Muslims like Americans? Why do Muslims consider everyone but themselves infidels? Why do Muslims target and kill Americans?

Do I think that all Muslims feel this way? Absolutely not. But I also think that you shouldn’t imply that all Americans hate Muslims.

Since Iv’e turned this around, let me ask you another question. Why do Muslims not drink alcohol or view pornography, but have no problems with coming here, opening a store and stocking their shelves full of garbage like that and selling it to Americans?

I also think that probably many Americans have a hard time loving people who strap explosives to themselves and kill innocent women & children in the name of God, and fly 747’s into buildings killing thousands of innocent people in the name of God.

If you plan on answering my post, please don’t pick out one little thing Iv’e written and turn it around on me, but answer the whole post truthfully.
I had one more question that I wanted to add here, and another comment as well. The question first. Why do Muslims in some mosques, even in the United States, end their prayer services by reciting the words “death to all Americans” before they leave their mosque?

The comment. I think that many Americans get upset (including me at times) when we see our rights to worship God in the public square, getting stripped away from us, and at the same time, we see all kinds of accommodations being made for Muslims so they can worship and pray. Let me give you an example of this. I live in Illinois, and within the last couple of years, the giant Christmas tree that used to be put up annually in Midway Airport is no longer allowed to be put up, because the word Christmas is associated with Christ. (how pathetic.) And at this same airport, a foot washing station and a small temple were built for all of the Muslim cab drivers, so they could go there and worship.
 
I don’t fear muslims I just recognize them as our most formidable and powerful enemy. It is just good survival instinct and the desire to see our Christian culture preserved that makes me oppose Islam.

Hilaire Beloc:
We have …seen what was the main cause of Islam’s rapid spread; a complicated and fatigued society…It is as a fact the most formidable and persistent enemy which our civilization has had…The name of Lepanto should remain in the minds of all men with a sense of history as one of the half dozen great names in the history of the Christian world…it has always seemed to me possible, and even probable, that here would be a resurrection of Islam and that our sons or our grandsons would see the renewal of that tremendous struggle between the Christian culture and what has been for more than a thousand years its greatest opponent.
Our Lady of Lepanto and St James the Moor Slayer pray for us!!
 
I live in Illinois, and within the last couple of years, the giant Christmas tree that used to be put up annually in Midway Airport is no longer allowed to be put up, because the word Christmas is associated with Christ. (how pathetic.) And at this same airport, a foot washing station and a small temple were built for all of the Muslim cab drivers, so they could go there and worship.
Oh, that’s easy to explain. Muslims are scarier, because they aren’t masochistic pacifists. When Christians protest something, all “the authorities” do is snicker and remind us to “turn the other cheek” and be good little serfs. When Muslims protest something, everybody rushes to kowtow because they’re scared about making them angry. They’re like religious bullies. Now they’re 1st Amendment bullies.

The question that needs to be asked is: Why in the world do they want to build a mosque (and “Muslim cultural center”) there, to begin with? It’s such an odd thing to do. So I can only assume that they are trying to purposefully antogonize people.

You do realize that republican governments assume that the citizenry share a set of basic common beliefs about morality and the rule of law?
 
The question that needs to be asked is: Why in the world do they want to build a mosque there, to begin with? It’s such an odd thing to do. So I can only assume that they are trying to purposefully antogonize people.
I think it was planned prior to 9/11/01 and is in the vicinity of ground zero.
You do realize that republican governments assume that the citizenry share a set of basic common beliefs about morality and the rule of law?
Yep. This is about religious liberty. We should ignore all the political demagoguery.

Y’all realize there is a Shinto shrine overlooking Pearl Harbor?
 
You do realize that republican governments assume that the citizenry share a set of basic common beliefs about morality and the rule of law?
That is a good point. I don’t have any problem with a mosque near ground zero, because, after all, it is allowed by the first amendment. I just wish that muslims would extend the same courtesy to the Christians living in their countries. Remind me again how many churches there are in the Kingdom of Saud?
 
Y’all realize there is a Shinto shrine overlooking Pearl Harbor?
Oh? No I wasn’t. Can you name it, tell us how far it is from Pearl Harbor and show the photo of it “overlooking Pearl Harbor”?

Also, was it built while we were at war with Japan or when we were allied with Japan after Japan had renounced imperialism and aggressive war?
 
And do you know that that shrine was built before Pearl Harbor, in 1921?

There is also a mosque already in use in the area, which is planning on expanding and moving closer to Ground Zero. Perhaps we should be asking why they insist on moving closer, rather than in the other direction?

But none of that is the issue.
Those were already there. No, the issue is that this is going to be a 13-story (or 15-story?) Islamic Cultural Center that is being built *new *in a place where people are coming to mourn the *recent *and horrific death of their loved ones. It is not being built *near *Ground Zero, it is being built *on *Ground Zero. The building they want was partially destroyed by airplane pieces during the attack. That is why they want precisely that building, and no other will suffice: the symbolism and the location.

This may not be illegal, but it’s an act completely lacking in compassion or empathy. This is triumphalism, and people are complaining because they are aware of that.

It’d be interesting to know where the funds are coming from.

Furthermore, not all religions are created equal. Saying that Islam is “just a religion” is like saying that Catholicisim is “just a religion”. Are we, here on Catholic Answers, actually going to pretend that religion does not have a political element, and that religious people don’t have political interests that they will pursue? Catholicism was tolerated and eventually accepted by the Protestant majority because they decided that our value system and theirs overlapped enough that we weren’t a threat to their form government. Islam has yet to pass that same test. Up until now, it has been failing miserably.

Nobody cared while the Muslim population was small, but it is now massive and growing rapidly. We are right to care. That is not Muslim-hatred, that is acting out of a sense of self-preservation. I, for one, am not a masochist. I am from Germany, so I can assure you that once their population reaches a critical size, they embark on plans to change the government and the laws to suit themselves. It is inevitable, just as it would be if Catholics could get together that sort of political clout.
 
And do you know that that shrine was built before Pearl Harbor, in 1921?

There is also a mosque already in use in the area, which is planning on expanding and moving closer to Ground Zero. Perhaps we should be asking why they insist on moving closer, rather than in the other direction?

But none of that is the issue.
Those were already there. No, the issue is that this is going to be a 13-story (or 15-story?) Islamic Cultural Center that is being built *new *in a place where people are coming to mourn the *recent *and horrific death of their loved ones. This may not be illegal, but it’s an act completely lacking in compassion or empathy. This is triumphalism, and people are complaining because they are aware of that.

It’d be interesting to know where the funds are coming from.
Hey, lets build a Catholic Church in Mecca. 😃
 
Hey, lets build a Catholic Church in Mecca. 😃
I would think the deplorable absence of religious liberty in Saudi Arabia is one of the best arguments for supporting the Cordoba House mosque.

Religious freedom is a good thing, especially for religious people.
 
Opposing the mosque building site isn’t necessarily anti-Muslim act. The motive behind the opposition is about sensitivity and respect.
The attacks on 9-11, and before, are against America, not against American beliefs or policies or pagans practices but America. The people behind the attacks are ALL muslim and are attacking under the muslim name, now I didn’t say all muslims are against america but clearly America was attacked by (radical)muslims, that much is FACT. I know that the only bad people here are people with hatred in their hearts for one another, that goes for both sides but we need to help ease tension and let people heal not build a mosque practically on-top of the towers that radical muslims brought down.
Historically speaking, Moslems have built mosques atop conquered Christian churches.

Catholic churches - as far as I can determine - are not allowed to be built in many Moslem countries. The penalty for Catholicism there is death.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top