Why God doesn't heal Dementia,Paraplegia etc?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Rozellelily
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
This is simply a re framing of the every popular “Why doesn’t God heal amputees?”

 
You need to think just a little. Obviously NOT THEIRS, but those of many others
 
am quite sure those who suffer due to chemotherapy, an amputation, or anxiety over paying their bills can offer all of that to God and He will accept it with open arms and apply it where needed to accomplish his designs upon the world
I’m quite sure of this as well. I reject any notion that it is otherwise.
 
You need to think just a little. Obviously NOT THEIRS, but those of many others
But the fact that the prayers of amputees don’t get answered calls into the question the claims that the prayers of others have been answered.

If the only prayers that get answered are those that could have occurred by chance without prayer, then maybe those answered prayers were just chance and not a result of divine intervention. It’s the difference between praying to win the lottery after buying a ticket and praying to win the lottery without buying a ticket. One has a chance of happening – prayer or no prayer – while the other will never happen even with prayer.

What I find interesting is that believers in a way are aware of this. Imagine you’re in a ditch off of a dark road. Your car won’t budge. Your phone doesn’t work. You’re miles from civilization. In that spot a believer will likely pray. In some cases the believer will offer a general prayer for safety, but I want to focus on what happens if the person praying makes a specific request to God. Will a person make a request asking that someone pass by who will see them and provide help? Absolutely. Will a person make a request of an impossible nature (e.g. levitating the car out of the ditch or teleport them home safe and sound) knowing that there is no limit to what God can do? No. Why do people in those situations, where non-miraculous solutions are still available, pray for non-miraculous things? In my opinion it’s because they understand the limitations of prayer despite Jesus claiming that with prayer they could move mountains.

For the people who say prayer helped them, there is no way to disprove or prove it truly happened; but the fact that God seems impotent to help those with missing limbs and eyes casts a very strong shadow of doubt as to whether the answered prayers were really answered or were just luck.
 
God does cure and heal all these things. Just in His own house and on His own time. That’s the challenge of faith, to maintain it when the answers are not so clear.
 
40.png
joeybaggz:
God does cure and heal all these things. Just in His own house and on His own time.
How? When you say in his own house and on his own time, do you mean after they are dead?
Exactly. It is an accepted Scriptural thought that in His house, every tear will be washed away. There will be no wheelchairs, no walkers, or canes, crutches or splints, braces, casts, contact lenses, eyeglasses, pain medication, to be found anywhere in His Kingdom. Then again, for those who don’t believe, You’re on your own!
 
The hope is in heaven. This life even if you lived to be the oldest a man or woman who ever lived this is just a moment compared to eternity. Most times the miracle is this life isn’t all their is.

All the suffering we see is being worked on. May people become clever enough to give limbs to those who don’t have them and a mind back to a person losing theirs. May people build safer cars, may people disarm land mines and stop planting them in the first place. We blame God for our own failings and do not thank God for our breakthroughs.
 
Exactly. It is an accepted Scriptural thought that in His house, every tear will be washed away. There will be no wheelchairs, no walkers, or canes, crutches or splints, braces, casts, contact lenses, eyeglasses, pain medication, to be found anywhere in His Kingdom. Then again, for those who don’t believe, You’re on your own!
Yet there are some who seemingly get cured before going to Heaven. And the dividing line is suspiciously as to what the human body can fix on its own and what it can’t. If God allegedly does answer prayers, and if the ones whose prayers get answered have ailments the body can fix, why is it that he can’t or won’t answer the prayers of the people who have ailments the human body can’t fix? Why is God so stringent on only working one side of that dividing line?
 
Believers are alive in Christ. Whether dead or alive.
@Kris34, if you’d like to take a stab at answering the questions I just asked of joeybaggz I’d be interested in reading your response. If people want to say that all will be healed in Heaven, sure I guess. That doesn’t in any way, shape, or form answer why the only people who get their prayers answered on Earth are those with ailments that the body can sometimes cure on its own.
 
Last edited:
Fr. Benedict Groeschel. He was struck by a car in Orlando, Florida in 2004. No vital signs for 45+ minutes. Nearly died three additional times in hospital. He made a miraculous recovery.

Personally, since 2008 I have been healed of one rare and aggressive cancer, then a relapse of that same cancer, then a second relapse and mutation into two rare and aggressive cancers plus a third treatment-related bone marrow cancer at the same time. Stage IV at least twice. Probably 100 tumors total. Who beats three simultaneous cancers? My case is an enigma. Medically inexplicable. Do I believe in the power of prayer? Well…yes I do.

Saint Bernadette was instrumental in my entry to the Church.

There is plenty of healing, but in some cases, it is simply not the Lord’s will. Since the Lord will grant us a glorified body, spiritual healing may always be achieved.
 
Last edited:
And the dividing line is suspiciously as to what the human body can fix on its own
Have you considered who created that human body and it’s ability to be healed? And what aids the body in healing - healing from a viral infection, medications, doctors expertise - who created those aids?
 
Thankyou for sharing your experience.

I mean no disrespect but this to me seems a bit heartless:
Christ does not simply heal for our own sake. It is a physical sign for the world of his power and love for man. He alone knows what will and will not turn the heart of those who look upon the miracle. If that heart could be turned no other way than through the miracle, then it takes place. If there is, however, another way, then it does not.
So Jesus doesn’t care less about people’s suffering but only heals them physically if it will save someone’s soul?
 
Can a person come back from the dead in 4 days? St Lucy’s eyes were restored. The body can’t do that on its own. The newer saints have a few miracles attributed to them that can’t be explained any other way. Miracles do happen. But Jesus didn’t come to rid the world of disease or injury, but to save people from sin. The few miracles done was to show who He is.
 
I don’t see any of this happening in the near future unfortunately though.
For all the talks of scientific advancement and AI and so forth,medical innovation is still very much in the dark ages.

Occasionally you will hear on the news a story how they have found a way to remove the plaques in Alzheimers or a way to create sensation where spinal nerve function has been severed but it always turns out to be sensationalism and nothing ever is implemented on a clinical level.
 
Last edited:
Look how far we have come with replacement limbs. Humans have been around according everyone 5000 years and probably longer according to most. What is the near future? I can’t believe it took thousands of years to get indoor plumbing…
 
So Jesus doesn’t care less about people’s suffering but only heals them physically if it will save someone’s soul?
I am speaking only of blatantly miraculous healings. The miracle is always a sign geared toward a higher spiritual reality. Christ also is constantly healing through means which most overlook as normal. Every day there are people whose cancer goes into remission or survive a surgery which has an almost zero chance of survival. These may be done though medical means, yes. It doesn’t mean that Christ guides the outcome. There are even those healings which have never come to light. A month ago, doctors looked at an MRI of one of my uncles on my dad’s side of the family’s brain for an unrelated reason and found out that sometime in the past he had had a rather severe stroke, however he has never had any symptoms nor is the damage it caused affecting him in any way. That is a healing which would have gone unnoticed, had they never done an MRI.
 
Last edited:
Wait – we are imitating Christ only when we suffer persecution.
Not so 🙂 Pope St John Paul II, St Therese of Liseaux, St Faustina, and many, many others have offered up their suffering through their illness. We can offer our suffering to Christ in a mystical way for the intercession of souls. Any bedridden and shut-in Catholic can be a fierce warrior through their submission to God in their suffering and their prayers.

This is covered pretty extensively in St Faustina’s Diary but the idea goes back centuries in Tradition.
 

This may interest you, I just glanced at it as I’m off to work now but looked like it may be relevent if not just ignore it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top