Why is God's Silent?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Dave_B
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
D

Dave_B

Guest
God has never spoken to me audibly. I guess he hasnt spoken to you either.

Why is this?

According to the Bible God has spoken to and spoken through prophets.

Why choose fallible, sinful people to do his communicating?

You would expect a better method of communication would be directly i.e. to speak to each and every one of us directly.

God could implant his perfect message directly into every brain simultaneously.

This would by-pass the need for evangelists of the contradictory world religions.

Then we would all have certain proof of God, and all know exactly what we need to know to be saved, and a clear and perfect understanding of God, life and the universe.

Yet God remains silent. Your thoughts?
 
Pope Francis:

“Finding God in all things is not an ‘empirical eureka.’ When we desire to encounter God, we would like to verify him immediately by an empirical method. But you cannot meet God this way. God is found in the gentle breeze perceived by Elijah. The senses that find God are the ones St. Ignatius called spiritual senses. Ignatius asks us to open our spiritual sensitivity to encounter God beyond a purely empirical approach. A contemplative attitude is necessary: it is the feeling that you are moving along the good path of understanding and affection toward things and situations. Profound peace, spiritual consolation, love of God and love of all things in God—this is the sign that you are on this right path.” - americamagazine.org/pope-interview
 
Are you prepared and willing to give up all you have and serve him? Anyone who has heard Him becomes a priest, prophet or something similar.
 
Does the book he helped write not talking to you enough? Or do you require the use of lips ?
 
Are you prepared and willing to give up all you have and serve him? Anyone who has heard Him becomes a priest, prophet or something similar.
Similar? Imam, rabbi, hindu holy man, street preacher?
 
Maybe he has spoken and you have just not listened?
I was thinking that clear and unambiguous instructions would be ideal. That way no-one would be in dispute over what his instructions were. God’s existence would be as obvious as the sky being blue or the trees green.
 
Hebrews 10:16

“This is the covenant I will make with them
after that time, says the Lord.
I will put my laws in their hearts,
and I will write them on their minds.”
 
I was thinking that clear and unambiguous instructions would be ideal. That way no-one would be in dispute over what his instructions were. God’s existence would be as obvious as the sky being blue or the trees green.
Yes. It would prevent a lot of conflicts (and deaths).
 
He has spoken to me on occasion.
More often it is my “guardian angel”.

Whether He speaks to you plainly or not is mainly due to whether you really
need Him to approach you in that manner and whether anything of value would be accomplished by it.

Most folks tend to be more respectful of Him through His silence, and
actually take more effort to seek Him out.

Would it not terrify you if He actually did start speaking plainly to you?

According to the visionaries at Medjugorje, some time in spring in the next few years
God is going to have a personal “heart to heart” with everyone on the planet. The visionaries have said it would be the most terrify experience you’ll likely ever have.
God will not pull His punches and will tell each and every person exactly what the state of their soul is. Likely to be very informative and very unpleasant (for most).
 
If he would force his path of salvation into everyone then that would eliminate God’s gift of free will. You have the freedom to be an agnostic and question the existence of a higher being, BUT you also have the freedom to give up everything in this world, open your heart and your ears,and listen to the voice of God.

You sit here and complain about the existence of God yet you do nothing to find Him. Take time out of your day, sit in silence, and ask the Lord this question with no doubt and nothing else in your mind and with an Open Heart “If you are really there Lord, please show me.” And, from personal experience, it may not happen on the first day and it may not happen the first week, but take the Freedom that YOU have and discover the Lord. Sitting around doubting and questioning is good but it’s not how God likes to communicate to us.** Be silent with the Freedom YOU have.**
 
I was thinking that clear and unambiguous instructions would be ideal. That way no-one would be in dispute over what his instructions were. God’s existence would be as obvious as the sky being blue or the trees green.
Suppose he gave you very clear and very unambiguous instructions? That would seem to place a final moral burden on you to follow those instructions to the letter. What if you were not capable of so doing? You would be absolutely culpable - you could not plead ignorance.

Which entails two things.
  1. God is not clear and unambiguous because he knows you would not be capable of carrying those out.
  2. God is giving you a break by working with you slowly and in small steps to get you where you need to be in time if you “work with him.”
So perhaps relentlessly seeking those instructions that make you incrementally more capable of carrying out what would be the “final” ones is the way to go.

Perhaps not biting off more than you can chew is a wise practice in this case.
 
Suppose he gave you very clear and very unambiguous instructions? That would seem to place a final moral burden on you to follow those instructions to the letter. What if you were not capable of so doing? You would be absolutely culpable - you could not plead ignorance.

Which entails two things.
  1. God is not clear and unambiguous because he knows you would not be capable of carrying those out.
  2. God is giving you a break by working with you slowly and in small steps to get you where you need to be in time if you “work with him.”
So perhaps relentlessly seeking those instructions that make you incrementally more capable of carrying out what would be the “final” ones is the way to go.

Perhaps not biting off more than you can chew is a wise practice in this case.
Errr, this is what those in the anti-terrorist forces call radicalization. Under no circumstances whatsoever should anyone relentlessly seek instructions that make them incrementally more capable of carrying out whatever they imagine God’s instructions to be. That’s exactly how suicide bombers become suicide bombers.
 
God has never spoken to me audibly. I guess he hasnt spoken to you either.

Why is this?

You would expect a better method of communication would be directly i.e. to speak to each and every one of us directly.

God could implant his perfect message directly into every brain simultaneously.


Then we would all have certain proof of God, …
As an agnostic, are you looking for God to use your sense of hearing, the vibrations of your inner ear to be certain of proof of God?

Would this audible voice be heard by those who suffer deafness?

While you consider it a better method of communication - to audibly speak to each person - would that make proof for everyone? Are you sure everyone would have certain proof at that point?

Are there people who need no proof - yet believe fully? Those who hear with something besides the vibrations of their inner ear.

What about the angels - with no inner ear for hearing? The angels have proof of being in God’s presence, yet a third of the angels turned from God.

Do you want to hear Him audibly or have His message implanted into your brain?

When He implants His “perfect message directly into every brain simultaneously,” how do you define simultaneously? All people live at different times and their brains are created as they are created - not simultaneously. The time line of people is a very long stretch of time - so simultaneously doesn’t fit a time line - but God is outside of time.

If you are looking for God, I pray you hear His voice. God’s blessings to you.
 
Your concept requires proof. Proof runs counter to faith. God is not a God purely or merely of signs, but of faith.

“Now, faith is the substance of things hoped for, the evidence of things that are not seen” - Hebrews 11:1. There is no better definition of faith.

Lest we forget that God very clearly showed the ancient Hebrews His presence and power - yet they turned their backs and rejected him in the desert.

Part of God’s love of us is His absolute preservation of our freedom. He does not force us to love Him, but desires that we choose to love Him.

You want to hear from God? Go before Christ Himself - either in the Tabernacle or exposed in the Blessed Sacrament. Tell him of your doubts and ask Him to reveal His presence to you. The, be as patient with Him as He has been with you.

And, as Fr. Benedict Groeschel says, “when you become aware that He is there, you will be changed.”
 
I was thinking that clear and unambiguous instructions would be ideal. That way no-one would be in dispute over what his instructions were. God’s existence would be as obvious as the sky being blue or the trees green.
There’s just this one little problem with what you ask here, and that is the fact that it’s already been done and we know the results. There were two people for whom God’s existence was as obvious as the sky being blue or the trees green. God did for those two people exactly what you ask here and gave them a clear and unambiguous instruction:

“You are free to eat from any of the trees of the garden except the tree of knowledge of good and evil. From that tree you shall not eat; when you eat from it you shall die.”

And yet, they still chose to disobey and eat the fruit of the tree of knowledge of good and evil.

Knowledge and experience won’t stop you from doubting God or his instructions. If we decide that we want to do something wrong, then we will do it and damn the consequences. That’s something all of us know, both from the example of others and from our own example.

We see it in every child who is told to not touch a hot pot on the stove because he will burn his hand, touches the hot pot anyway, and burns his hand. We see it in every girl who has been told by her parents to not be promiscuous because she might get pregnant, is promiscuous anyway, and gets pregnant. We see it in every young couple who is told not to shack up, does it anyway, and then has to go through the pain of the eventual separation. We see it in every drug addict or alcoholic who knew that those things were not really an escape from whatever pain they were experiencing, but who turned to them anyway out of fear and desperation and now finds themselves trapped by addiction. We see it in every student who waits until the last minute to do an assignment, in every employee who slacks off at work, in every parent who doesn’t make time for their children, in every child who doesn’t care for and honor their parents, and so on.

All of us are in there somewhere. What we need to deal with all of that isn’t primarily knowledge and a list of instructions, because we’ll just disregard anything we see as an obstacle to exercising our will toward whatever the heck we feel like doing. What we really need are love, forgiveness, and healing, so that we may eventually come to leave our pride behind and enter into the perfect joy that God has prepared for each and every one of us. A joy that we can attain if we will only choose to accept it instead of letting our pride lead us to look elsewhere and settle for something less than perfect, simply because it’s something we personally created for ourselves rather than what someone else (ie, God) created for us.

I pray that you are one day willing to open yourself to Christ, to experience and accept his love, forgiveness, and healing, and through him be led to the joy that God has prepared for you.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top