WHY is homosexuality a sin?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Goldenhope
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Probably because the couple loves one another and wants to spend the rest of there life together, companionship, they want someone to share the ups and downs of life with. Not everyone can have a baby and not everyone has the genetics that make procreation an intelligent decision.
God can intend a couple, who have a bad genetic match to marry but never intend for them to procreate children naturally. Other options are available, like adoption or PGD-IVF. Its the couple’s choice to follow there conscience and do what they feel is best. No one is mandated to have babies and the way you break down marriage into nothing more than sex and babies, as if nothing else matters… Just sad. The reproductive organs only serve the purpose of having a baby sometimes only once or twice in a persons life, unless your very Catholic or Quiverfull, in that case 6 - 15+. Plus, the reproductive system can result in the creation of individuals with some nasty diseases, who suffer greatly, when the wrong genetic combination is made. Common sense would say its best to avoid passing on terrible diseases when the risks are known, like: EB “butterfly syndrome”, Tay Sachs, SCID, Krabbes, HD, HSCR, CF, Sickle Cell, MS, etc…
Two things - one does not have to get married to spend his or her life with another person.

Second, all of the other examples you list show an openness to life. As others have said, marital relations do not have to (and most often don’t) result in procreation. But, the relations have to be open to procreation. An infertile couple may very well be open to life; it is God who prevents them from conceiving. Their relations would be licit.

I have never stated that the sole purpose of marriage is “sex and babies.” Like the OP, you are twisting what I have said. The Church teaches that there are two purposes to sex: unity and openness to life. Sex is just one dynamic of the marital sacrament. A very important one, but still only one. As I and several others have stated, including with citations to the Catechism, because homosexual sex cannot ever be ordered toward procreation, it is sinful.

I understand that people have a hard time with this. I’ve had a hard time with it. But, just because it is difficult, doesn’t make it untrue.
 
Probably because the couple loves one another and wants to spend the rest of there life together, companionship, they want someone to share the ups and downs of life with. Not everyone can have a baby and not everyone has the genetics that make procreation an intelligent decision.
God can intend a couple, who have a bad genetic match to marry but never intend for them to procreate children naturally. Other options are available, like adoption or PGD-IVF. Its the couple’s choice to follow there conscience and do what they feel is best. No one is mandated to have babies and the way you break down marriage into nothing more than sex and babies, as if nothing else matters… Just sad. The reproductive organs only serve the purpose of having a baby sometimes only once or twice in a persons life, unless your very Catholic or Quiverfull, in that case 6 - 15+. Plus, the reproductive system can result in the creation of individuals with some nasty diseases, who suffer greatly, when the wrong genetic combination is made. Common sense would say its best to avoid passing on terrible diseases when the risks are known, like: EB “butterfly syndrome”, Tay Sachs, SCID, Krabbes, HD, HSCR, CF, Sickle Cell, MS, etc…
I just wanted to point out that your post seems to take the position that the Catholic Church is wrong in their teachings yet you freely state…
God can intend a couple, who have a bad genetic match to marry but never intend for them to procreate children naturally.
Now the Church has given good Biblical evidence why they teach what they teach in regards to marriage. Could you please give us the Biblical evidence of your statement here?

I also found it very interesting that you used the phrases “do what they feel is best” and “Common sense would say”. I have discovered that this generation tends to think those terms can be used interchangeably. Maybe try using a little common in thinking about marriage as a covenant from God and applying some of that feeling to the deformed children that you don’t view as a gift from God.

God Bless
 
Very simply put, it’s a misuse of the sexual organs. What were these made for? What is their purpose?

Our bodies were made in God’s image and with them we can be co-creators of new life. That means they are not simply ours to do with whatever we want. We need to respect our bodies. Using a part in a way contrary to its purpose is disrespectful to us and to God.

(This applies to more than just sexuality, by the way.)
What is your view on people who say, “well so and so is not in nature either”.
 
Any sexual activity outside the confines of a sacramental marriage is a sin. There is no such thing as a sacramental homosexual marriage.

You can say “how sad” all you want, but you aren’t expressing a moral position or ethical truth. You are expressing your personal preference. Placing one’s personal preference above the will of God as explained by his holy Church is also a sin.
what about civil marriages?
 
What is your view on people who say, “well so and so is not in nature either”.
I would ask them to explain, because it’s not clear what they mean. Natural law refers to the order and purpose of things, not merely what is observed (that confusion already popped up on this thread.)

If the argument is more a Christian Science argument, about not pursuing medical treatment because it’s “not natural,” or because of the faulty view that sickness and suffering are due to insufficient faith, that’s a different thing. Restoring our bodies to their proper functioning is a great good. That’s the goal of good medicine and therapeutic practices.

What’s morally iffy or outright immoral is when we seek to.break what’s working (contraception, sterilization) or circumvent it to our own ends (e.g. IVF, which doesn’t cure infertility.)
 
Everytime I ask this, people say “It’s in the Bible”, without providing context or explanation, and start (mis)quoting verses.
What is wrong with two men/women loving each other? How can God regard love as an (as some Christians say of homosexuals) “abomination”?
I don’t believe God ever told us why it was a sin, just that it is. He did not create a man and man women an women. See God does not have to explain himself to anyone. By the way God never said you could not love eachother. He said you cannot have sex with each other. I love many women, but do not want to have sex with them.
 
No, we were not made in the image of Christ, our souls were made in the image of God. Christ is God made man - not the other way around: men were not made in the image of Christ, Christ choose to appear in the image of man.
Christ true nature is divine - and therefore does not possess a physical body: the Word made Himself Flesh - it was not flesh already, and probably stopped being flesh once He returned to Heaven.
Man is made in the image of God, both body and soul. Body and soul are an inseparable unity in a human being.

Two bible verses come to mind that observe this reality. (the verses don’t create this reality, they proclaim it)
“Let us make man in our image.”
This plural language points to the Trinity. God is a communion of inter-personal love. Man is made to reflect that communion. Hence male and female bodies are images of that union. Man and woman image, or signify, that union as no other union can. This is why marriage is called the primordial sacrament. A sacrament is sign of a deeper reality.

If we are in the imago dei, we must know who God is. God self identifies as “I Am Who Am”. Or in other words, “I am existence itself”, or “I Am what it is to be”. It is so chock full of mystery that words are hard to come by.

But if we are to be in God’s image, we must exist. The marriage of a man and woman uniquely procreates human existence with God. A homosexual union can not do that. Whatever good elements other unions or relationships might have, they are not of the profound nature of the union of a man and woman.

The union of a man and woman is uniquely ordered to Trinitarian loving, creative, unity.
 
I can’t help but think we’re being trolled here.
The longer this goes the more likely that seems.

Four pages in and I have yet to see evidence the OP is asking in good faith (i.e. genuinely looking for answers from other Catholics), as opposed to looking to bash on Catholics who follow Church teaching.
 
Not accepted in the RCC. You must be man and women.
im talking about a justice of peace.

also, what is marriage exactly? at what point does a legal contract between two men or two women become same sex marriage?
 
If Jesus truly did supersede the Law, why did He not supersede the parts about homosexuality as well?
Also, I am not dismissing the Bible: I am simply showing you that quite a number of its “divinely inspired” parts are actually not so divinely inspired - otherwise, why would He need to send us the Son to subvert them in the first place? He does not change His mind…
And as such, if this bits are not so quite inerrant, pheraps the bit about homosexuality is not so divinely inspired as well?
(Encapsulating and paraphrasing from the teachings of Jesus)
*These *passages of the old law were for that time, while *those *passages are forever. You need no longer refrain from eating shellfish and pork. You need no longer circumcise your sons.
But you still must not lie, nor steal, nor murder, and marriage is one man and one woman, so long as they both live.

Christ did not need to set aside the entire Old Testament in order supersede some parts of it.

And Christ did not ‘subvert’ the Old Testament. He is God. He *gave *us the Old Testament. He has authority to tell us that certain rules were for the time and certain others are forever.
 
No, we were not made in the image of Christ, our souls were made in the image of God. Christ is God made man - not the other way around: men were not made in the image of Christ, Christ choose to appear in the image of man.
Christ true nature is divine - and therefore does not possess a physical body: the Word made Himself Flesh - it was not flesh already, and probably stopped being flesh once He returned to Heaven.
Okay, I didn’t notice this one till I had already responded to a later post.

Jesus Christ was born in the flesh in Bethlehem of Judea. He did not appear in the image of man.
He became man
Christ is truly God and truly man. He possesses a living body, and no, he did not abandon that body when he re-entered Heaven, His body is now glorified, but it is still flesh, To assert otherwise is to deny the Truth.

And the purpose of sex within marriage is twofold. Procreation and unity. To deliberately make one impossible in order to enjoy the other without it, is to pervert the intent and purpose of marriage and of sex within marriage.
Procreation is impossible between two men or between two women. Therefore to engage in homosexual activity is to deny the possibility of the procreative function while demanding to enjoy the pleasure associated with it.
 
My question about God not changing His mind was rethorical.
Also, while I had never considered this “slow learning” idea, I find it interesting - which begs the question: you said they were not ready for the “turn the other cheek” and as such He gave the people an easier - yet brutal - law of “an eye for an eye”. What if we are simply not judged ready to understand and accept same-sex relationships as “not sinful” and we’re being told this while we “grow”?
We have been “ready for this” since the time of Christ. Or do you think the Israelites were not ready when they were given the prohibition against homosexual acts at the time of Moses? If we’re “not ready for it” now that’s not because it’s too soon but because we have decided to stubbornly refuse this truth.
 
im talking about a justice of peace.

also, what is marriage exactly? at what point does a legal contract between two men or two women become same sex marriage?
Marriage is when a man and women give themselves freely to the other.

As far as your second question when they get a marriage license.
 
What is sad that you can’t imagine human relationships that could sustain you for a lifetime that don’t involve sex.
I have friends, and I have no intention on having sex with any of them. A platonic relationship is NOT the same as a romantic one. Besides, when I marry, the basis of my marriage will NOT be sex. Just like the relationship I’ve had is NOT based around sex or being physical. It will be mutual respect and caring about that man because I love him for him, not his body. Sex is just an add on that comes with marriage.

No, what’s sad is that for you and others on these forums, what makes a marriage boils down ultimately to what two people do with there sex organs.
Now the Church has given good Biblical evidence why they teach what they teach in regards to marriage. Could you please give us the Biblical evidence of your statement here?
What evidence? Onan’s sin was disobedience, not contraception. And Gods command to Adam and Eve to “fruitful and multiply”, was meant for well, Adam and Eve, not every generation following.
I also found it very interesting that you used the phrases “do what they feel is best” and “Common sense would say”. I have discovered that this generation tends to think those terms can be used interchangeably. Maybe try using a little common in thinking about marriage as a covenant from God and applying some of that feeling to the deformed children that you don’t view as a gift from God.
Try I’m one of those deformed children. What I’ve been through, seen others worse than me go through and seen the horror of a few of the diseases I listed above, I do not agree. If you choose to think that me and others who think like me, “don’t understand the value of suffering little children” and that nothing should be done prevent the “gift” of a painful genetic disease, be my guest.

To those of use who’ve lived with one or more of the diseases listed above, or know people who are, we know better. If it can be prevented, do it. Prevention does not = those with that disease are not children of God or that those of us with one or more of those conditions should’ve never been born, though we might wish we hadn’t been. Prevention is about avoiding passing on the torch. It takes a selfless person place a child’s wellbeing over there own animal like, biological drive to reproduce.
 
Two things - one does not have to get married to spend his or her life with another person. .
Yes, that’s called platonic friendships, like roommates. Though, I doubt two people who hold romantic feelings for each another would find cohabiting a wise decision, especially if there relationship wasn’t “allowed” to progress further.
As others have said, marital relations do not have to (and most often don’t) result in procreation. But, the relations have to be open to procreation. An infertile couple may very well be open to life; it is God who prevents them from conceiving. Their relations would be licit.

I have never stated that the sole purpose of marriage is “sex and babies.” Like the OP, you are twisting what I have said. The Church teaches that there are two purposes to sex: unity and openness to life. Sex is just one dynamic of the marital sacrament. A very important one, but still only one. As I and several others have stated, including with citations to the Catechism, because homosexual sex cannot ever be ordered toward procreation, it is sinful. .
I’m not twisting words.

In Catholicism, the purpose of marriage is structured around sex and procreation. According to the Catholic Church, a marriage is legitimized (made valid) if a couple builds there marriage around the desire to have children through sexual intercourse, it doesn’t matter if they are infertile, since the couples actions are structured according to, what the Catholic Church teaches is marriage’s purpose, to create and raise children and families.

For, as long as the couple has the appropriate equipment (sex organs) to have male-female sex, and are willing to possibly get pregnant with each sex act, the results are unimportant. Thus, people, according to Catholic Church, who don’t desire children or can’t procreate (via sex) can’t get married and if they do, there marriage isn’t valid and they commit adultery when they have sex with there spouse. It doesn’t matter if you love a person, and want to spend life with them, if you don’t meet that criteria you can’t get married.

To Catholics, marriage is directed towards and exists solely as a way to ensure the survival of the human race.

In short, in Catholicism, marriages purpose ultimately boils down to what two people do with there sex organs: how they have sex, when they have sex, what there sex is used for. Unity involves sex (thus why the impotent and homosexuals can’t marry). Procreation involves sex (thus why impotent, homosexuals and anyone who doesn’t want biological kids are barred from marriage). Freely giving each other to one refers to sex and procreation.

Bottom line is, a Catholic marriage is defined by sex. It’s what a "real/Catholic " marriage revolves around.
 
What evidence? Onan’s sin was disobedience, not contraception. And Gods command to Adam and Eve to “fruitful and multiply”, was meant for well, Adam and Eve, not every generation following.
Thank you for the response. I apologize, I thought we were discussing same sex marriage vs. true marriage. I didn’t realize the conversation switched to contraception. When it comes to contraception I submit to the authority of the Church because I have not studied this and do not fully understand the teaching as of yet.
Try I’m one of those deformed children. What I’ve been through, seen others worse than me go through and seen the horror of a few of the diseases I listed above, I do not agree. If you choose to think that me and others who think like me, “don’t understand the value of suffering little children” and that nothing should be done prevent the “gift” of a painful genetic disease, be my guest.
To those of use who’ve lived with one or more of the diseases listed above, or know people who are, we know better. If it can be prevented, do it. Prevention does not = those with that disease are not children of God or that those of us with one or more of those conditions should’ve never been born, though we might wish we hadn’t been. Prevention is about avoiding passing on the torch. It takes a selfless person place a child’s wellbeing over there own animal like, biological drive to reproduce.
I am so sorry for the pain and suffering that you must endure. I to suffer with daily pain but it is not from a deformity, so I can not say I can put myself in your situation. I do not think that you don’t understand the pain and the anguish. I just don’t believe God gave me the authority to make the choice of who lives and who dies.

I totally understand and agree with what you are saying here.
It takes a selfless person place a child’s wellbeing over there own animal like, biological drive to reproduce
I also agree with the Church when she teaches that in these cases abstinence is the best course of action. If you honestly think about your statement contraception does not make the person any less selfless. Contraception is not a 100% guarantee of not becoming pregnant.

God Bless
 
Yes, that’s called platonic friendships, like roommates. Though, I doubt two people who hold romantic feelings for each another would find cohabiting a wise decision, especially if there relationship wasn’t “allowed” to progress further.
it doesn’t matter if they are infertile, since the couples actions are structured according to, what the Catholic Church teaches is marriage’s purpose, to create and raise children and families.
Thus, people, according to Catholic Church, who don’t desire children or can’t procreate (via sex) can’t get married and if they do, there marriage isn’t valid and they commit adultery when they have sex with there spouse.
I think you and I are in disagreement because you seem to be equating a relationship status with the marital sacrament. I don’t think they are necessarily the same, although they often are.

The Church teaches that there are two purposes to marriage (the sacrament): the good of the spouses and procreation. CIC 1055.1. The purpose of sex, an essential but not sole aspect of marriage, is also twofold: unity and procreation.

Let’s think about why a sterile couple can marry, but an impotent cannot. Catechism and Canon law state that marriage is ordered to the unity of the spouses and procreation. A sterile couple can be unified, whereas the impotent couple cannot. Thus, an essential element of marriage, unity, is lost. This is not something a bunch of old virgins made up. Jesus, in quoting Genesis, says that a man leaves his father and mother, is joined to his wife, and the two become one flesh. Matthew 19:4-6.

I am having two difficulties. The first is with your position is the assertion that marriage is only about procreation. That is not accurate. Scripture tells spouses how to treat each other, and those passages do not talk about sex. (1 Peter 3:1-7; Ephesians 5:21-32; Colossians 3:18-21). Yes, sex is extremely important, but the marriage sacrament and the married life is more than just sex.

The second difficulty I am having is that you seem to think that a couple should be able to be validly married in the Church if the couple does not want to have children or cannot. As noted above, inability to procreate isn’t necessarily an impediment, although it can be.

I get that some couples do not want to have children at all, perhaps for very good reasons. If a couple is not open to life ever, regardless of how valid the reason, then the course of action most consistent with Church teaching (as noted by others) is probably abstinence. And, you don’t need to be married to be abstinent. You can still have emotional support, commitment, etc. while being abstinent and without violating Church teaching.
 
I am so sorry for the pain and suffering that you must endure. I just don’t believe God gave me the authority to make the choice of who lives and who dies.

I also agree with the Church when she teaches that in these cases abstinence is the best course of action. If you honestly think about your statement contraception does not make the person any less selfless. Contraception is not a 100% guarantee of not becoming pregnant.

God Bless
Seconded. I recognize this is a painful issue for you, and I hope you find peace.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top