WHY is homosexuality a sin?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Goldenhope
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Marriage is when a man and women give themselves freely to the other.

As far as your second question when they get a marriage license.
So its about the titles? So its about the same gender having the same title as husband and wife?
 
property, inheritance, and decision making authority.
The Christian sense of marriage recognizes those elements in the context of the sacrament nature of marriage. That’s why we don’t call anything other than the union of a man and woman a marriage, because the sacramental nature is missing.

Society in general has varying definitions of marriage. Hence the question.
 
The Christian sense of marriage recognizes those elements in the context of the sacrament nature of marriage. That’s why we don’t call anything other than the union of a man and woman a marriage, because the sacramental nature is missing.

Society in general has varying definitions of marriage. Hence the question.
Are you against civil unions for same gender?
 
Are you against civil unions for same gender?
Here’s what I am for:
I am for the existence and flourishing of human beings and families. So I am for the recognition of the marriage of a man and woman for what it is: a unique union unlike any other.
To the extent that civil unions attempt to mimic marriage, they are objectionable.
In our culture, the thrust is to make homosexual union “just like” marriage, or “the same as” marriage, which they intrinsically are not. I am for seeing reality as it is.

While recognizing the positive aspects of relationships in general, deception can’t be condoned or productive. Deception causes un-reason and injustice to reign, despite the veneer of equal rights it’s cloaked in.
 
Here’s what I am for:
I am for the existence and flourishing of human beings and families. So I am for the recognition of the marriage of a man and woman for what it is: a unique union unlike any other.
To the extent that civil unions attempt to mimic marriage, they are objectionable.
In our culture, the thrust is to make homosexual union “just like” marriage, or “the same as” marriage, which they intrinsically are not. I am for seeing reality as it is.

While recognizing the positive aspects of relationships in general, deception can’t be condoned or productive. Deception causes un-reason and injustice to reign, despite the veneer of equal rights it’s cloaked in.
What do people mean by union? I find it nebulous. If I changed my last name to that of a close friend, that wouldnt be a marriage.

Does union mean officiant like religious or civil leader?
 
So its about the titles? So its about the same gender having the same title as husband and wife?
Not at all. If you want a marriage certificate in title only go to the court house and go for it. You are married by the law.

If you want a true marriage by the RCC you will accept what the Church teaches about a true marriage, etc man woman etc.

The RCC does not recogonize a marriage certificate as a true marriage in the eyes of the Church. And it will not marry same sex.
 
property, inheritance, and decision making authority.
My Mom has 3 houses in my name, we aren’t married, I have pow over her when she can no longer make decisions and she is leaving me whats left.
 
Not at all. If you want a marriage certificate in title only go to the court house and go for it. You are married by the law.

If you want a true marriage by the RCC you will accept what the Church teaches about a true marriage, etc man woman etc.

The RCC does not recogonize a marriage certificate as a true marriage in the eyes of the Church. And it will not marry same sex.
Married meaning? To me its a very nebulous and multifaceted word.
 
What do people mean by union? I find it nebulous. If I changed my last name to that of a close friend, that wouldnt be a marriage.

Does union mean officiant like religious or civil leader?
Really?

We are talking sexuality.
Union.
Human beings are a unity of body and soul. Surely you can flesh this out. (pun intended).
 
Really?

We are talking sexuality.
Union.
Human beings are a unity of body and soul. Surely you can flesh this out. (pun intended).
bible.org/seriespage/13-nature-marriage-union
The act of sexual intercourse never, in itself, constituted marriage.538 In the Bible, premarital sex, if discovered, led to a forced marriage unless the father of the woman insisted otherwise (Exod. 22:16 f.; Deut. 22:28 f.). The legal bond gave the only proper moral context for sexual union (Gen. 2:24).
It would seem by consideration of this that the existence of a “one-flesh” relation does not determine the existence of marriage. It may call for it (marriage) in the case of “premarital sex,” but it is not the marriage itself. It is a “right of marriage.” The most we could say is that it is necessary, but not sufficient to make a marriage.
 
I just wanted to point out that bible.org shouldn’t be any Catholics number 1 source for Catholic teaching.

The problem we have here is you have a site that picks and chooses from the Bible to back up what it wants to teach. Then you have the reader picking and choosing from their incomplete teachings.

The one thing I will say though, about the bible.org argument, is that they repeatedly used the the words “husband and wife” and “man and woman”. Therefore, unless you pick and choose around these terms, in no way can you use that link to back up same sex unions.

God Bless
 
I just wanted to point out that bible.org shouldn’t be any Catholics number 1 source for Catholic teaching.

The problem we have here is you have a site that picks and chooses from the Bible to back up what it wants to teach. Then you have the reader picking and choosing from their incomplete teachings.

The one thing I will say though, about the bible.org argument, is that they repeatedly used the the words “husband and wife” and “man and woman”. Therefore, unless you pick and choose around these terms, in no way can you use that link to back up same sex unions.

God Bless
Legal union seems nebulous to me. Do you agree?
 
Legal union seems nebulous to me. Do you agree?
You usage of the word nebulous confused me.

I went a head and look up the definition of nebulous because the only time I’ve ever heard that word used was on Star Trek.

It can mean in the form of a cloud or it can mean unclear. Star Trek used the former definition which I recognize, I’m guessing you mean the later?

That being said I would need more information before I agree or disagree with you. Why do you feel it is nebulous? Sure the term legal union might seem unclear, which is probably why I never use the term.
 
I think it is also important to point out that homosexual acts are sinful even in heterosexual marriages. For example, fellatio may not reach the point of climax even in a heterosexual marriage.
I am a bit confused by your comment. How is fellation in a heterosexual marriage, a homosexual act?

It also seems that you are saying that fellatio is ok as long as a climax is not reached.

What is wrong with fellatio in a heterosexual marriage?
 
You usage of the word nebulous confused me.

I went a head and look up the definition of nebulous because the only time I’ve ever heard that word used was on Star Trek.

It can mean in the form of a cloud or it can mean unclear. Star Trek used the former definition which I recognize, I’m guessing you mean the later?

That being said I would need more information before I agree or disagree with you. Why do you feel it is nebulous? Sure the term legal union might seem unclear, which is probably why I never use the term.
What about the term legal union is unclear?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top