Why is Smoking Sinful?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Lawrence178
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Incense cigarettes? Hmmmm, never heard of those before. šŸ˜‰
Clove Cigarettes? Maybe? 😃

Ever wonder how funny it is that cigarettes used to be thought of as being ā€˜sexy’ and alluring? At one time it was the ā€˜thing to do’, then as years past there developed the consensus that is was for ā€˜bad’ (wild) people only to do. Now a days, I’d have to say, it seems there is this hint of disgust with the mention that someone is a smoker. It seems to be something that is very much thought down upon. … Or maybe that is just my own personal observation.
 
Clove Cigarettes? Maybe? 😃

Ever wonder how funny it is that cigarettes used to be thought of as being ā€˜sexy’ and alluring? At one time it was the ā€˜thing to do’, then as years past there developed the consensus that is was for ā€˜bad’ (wild) people only to do. Now a days, I’d have to say, it seems there is this hint of disgust with the mention that someone is a smoker. It seems to be something that is very much thought down upon. … Or maybe that is just my own personal observation.
Agree, but look at the source of this disgust:

Smoking out; Gay Marriage In; Abortion on Demand, Women Priests !!
 
Agree, but look at the source of this disgust:

Smoking out; Gay Marriage In; Abortion on Demand, Women Priests !!
Technically, Holy Orders cannot be conferred upon women. So it would be incorrect to call the members of the organization Roman Catholic Womenpriests ā€œpriests.ā€
 
Agree, but look at the source of this disgust:

Smoking out; Gay Marriage In; Abortion on Demand, Women Priests !!
Fashions in morals do change! And secular attitudes tend to be subjective & on many occasions, puritanical. People tend to believe that if someone else is doing something (smoking, eating meat, hunting, etc) it is a sin, but if I do it or approve of it (gay marriage, abortion, women priests) it is not a sin.
 
Agree, but look at the source of this disgust:

Smoking out; Gay Marriage In; Abortion on Demand, Women Priests !!
Technically, Holy Orders cannot be conferred upon women. So it would be incorrect to call the members of the organization Roman Catholic Womenpriests ā€œpriests.ā€
Fashions in morals do change! And secular attitudes tend to be subjective & on many occasions, puritanical. People tend to believe that if someone else is doing something (smoking, eating meat, hunting, etc) it is a sin, but if I do it or approve of it (gay marriage, abortion, women priests) it is not a sin.
Agree… Would that be what is called being swept up in the spirit of the age? Otherwise known as ā€œworldlinessā€? I would think that the closer one is to God the less influenced by the spirit of the age or worldliness they are… Yet everyone is defined by the era they lived in regardless. I have heard too that in every era the Holy Spirit is working on something too, I’d assume, countering that agenda which Satan is trying to push.

I wouldn’t claim smoking as a sin, however I do put it in the category of ā€œnear occasion of sinā€ because it has been found that it is not so good for one’s body and we are supposed to not abuse it. It takes a certain amount of denial of that truth to light one up and put it to your mouth. If you didn’t know it was unhealthy then it wouldn’t be such a possible sin… My 93 year old grandmother smoked since she was 14, ate very healthy and took good care of herself otherwise. She was always healthy right up to the last 8 years of her life. Tobacco effects people differently. It depends on genes and lifestyle choices I’m sure.
 
My 93 year old grandmother smoked since she was 14, ate very healthy and took good care of herself otherwise. She was always healthy right up to the last 8 years of her life. Tobacco effects people differently. It depends on genes and lifestyle choices I’m sure.
One of my aunts was almost 90 when she died - but the cigarettes didn’t kill her - didn’t affect her health at all. The last time I saw her was at her 85th birthday party. She looked years younger and was very active. When I told her how good she looked, she smiled - rather smugly - and said, ā€œAnd I’m still smoking!ā€ 😃

Me, on the other hand, had problems for the last 10 years or so that I smoked - chronic cough, lots of colds, stomach ulcers. But I kept smoking for 2 reasons - I was addicted and smoking kept me slim (every time I had quit for more than a month I had gained weight).

I am now a fat non-smoker (about 21 years tobacco free!) but I’m getting my diet under control. In the last couple of years I’ve lost 75 pounds - just 40 more to go!
 
A hundred years ago when I was single and in my 20’s šŸ˜› I went with a group of friends to Hawaii for 2 weeks. 6 of us shared the accommodations and we had a great trip. When I set up the trip, my mother, a smoker, complained how much money I was about to blow on a 2 week trip to Hawaii. It got me thinking. I calculated how much she spent on cigarettes a month times 12 and found out that she was spending a bit more, per year, on cigarettes than I was on my trip to Hawaii. Isn’t that shocking?

Let’s say a 2 parent family had one smoker. If one parent said that they worked hard all year and every winter they were going with friends to Hawaii, regardless of what other expenses and sacrifices were done throughout the year, how would that go over? Yet parents do smoke and that money goes up ā€˜in smoke’, regardless of expenses through the year. I found with my mother’s addictions, that her addiction money never got touched, you can be sure! Other expenses would have to wait. It seems like quite an exercise in selfishness.

Is it a sin? We all will come before God to give an account for our lives, for what we have done, and what we failed to do. It should make one shiver. Smoking certainly is an exercise in selfishness and addiction. (When we have that first cigarette, we have no idea if we will become addicted. Saying ā€˜once in a while won’t hurt’ is flirting with disaster, like driving drunk, it doesn’t kill everybody.) If only we would be so determined to employ our talents to good rather than to what would hurt us and others, we would become saints.
 
I’ve heard it mentioned that people who smoke hold onto anger and resentment. If that is true, then the reasons for smoking (unforgiveness) would be sinful.
 
One of my aunts was almost 90 when she died - but the cigarettes didn’t kill her - didn’t affect her health at all. The last time I saw her was at her 85th birthday party. She looked years younger and was very active. When I told her how good she looked, she smiled - rather smugly - and said, ā€œAnd I’m still smoking!ā€ 😃

Me, on the other hand, had problems for the last 10 years or so that I smoked - chronic cough, lots of colds, stomach ulcers. But I kept smoking for 2 reasons - I was addicted and smoking kept me slim (every time I had quit for more than a month I had gained weight).

I am now a fat non-smoker (about 21 years tobacco free!) but I’m getting my diet under control. In the last couple of years I’ve lost 75 pounds - just 40 more to go!
Congratulations Bonnie ! šŸ‘
 
I look at it this way. We all know smoking is bad for our health and eventually we will get a disease or something from it and it will kill us. The bible says the wages of sin is death.

Is the devil happy that we smoke? Absolutely because there’s another excuse for him to give us an illness that will kill us and in the meantime make our lives less enjoyable once we get sick. What is the devils Job? To kill, steal and destroy. Having us sick is a way of stealing life from us. Therefore it must be a sin of some kind. Probably along the lines of our bodies are a temple of the Holy Spirit and we are poisoning it with tobacco.

The pleasure we get from smoking is among the pleasures of this world that have nothing to do with spirituality or Jesus so therefore it’s a lure of the devil. Smoking gives a sence of relaxation which is a counterfeit for what the Holy Spirit gives us. Like drinking alcohol. ā€œBe drunk not with wine but with the Holy Spirit.ā€ It’s not in line with what God wants for us so it MUST be sinful.
Your argument that Satan wants us to die does not follow. Satan only wants us to die if we die and then join him in eternal suffering. Merely doing things which might cause our death doesn’t particularly bother God or the Enemy–it’s the state of our soul (and where we’re headed after we die) that counts.

Another facet of this issue is intriguing to consider when we talk about how our societies perceive smoking. If smoking causes common disgust among most people, then it could be that publicly might give rise to scandal and ruin any positive perception of a Catholic smoker’s morals and good works. Thus, if a Catholic chooses to smoke, he should be certain to keep control of the pleasure and also try to smoke mostly in private or in front of people who aren’t bothered by it.
 
ehow.com/about_6591127_effect-secondary-smoking-platelet-count.html

Inhaled secondary smoke includes the same toxic chemicals that are inhaled by smokers, including more than 60 chemical compounds which are known human carcinogens, or cancer-causing agents.

ehow.com/info_8389426_physical-effects-cigarette.html

Cigarette smoking has a detrimental long-term and short-term impact on health. The impact of the ingestion of nicotine can be seen on all major organ systems of the body. …

Moreover, secondhand smoke is the cause of roughly 50,000 deaths per year. The devastation to the body and to the economy is serious.
 
Smoking is not a sin ! …but we can, through reasoning ,lead anything we do into it being a sin. From putting on fake fingernails, to starting the engine of your car, to turning on your furnace because you are cold…and now we find out how much arsenic we have been poisoning our children with by giving them orange juice.
 
Smoking is not a sin ! …but we can, through reasoning ,lead anything we do into it being a sin. From putting on fake fingernails, to starting the engine of your car, to turning on your furnace because you are cold…and now we find out how much arsenic we have been poisoning our children with by giving them orange juice.
I respectfully disagree. Would you like to explain how putting on fake fingernails, starting your car or turning on your furnace is a sin?
 
I respectfully disagree. Would you like to explain how putting on fake fingernails, starting your car or turning on your furnace is a sin?
Do not think we should go there, could turn posts into a forever thing. The chemicals used, the pollution you put into the environment every time you do any of these actions, you are poisoning us all. The money wasted on makeup that could be given to feed the hungry all for the sake of vanity, the trips to the ā€œbeauty salonā€ā€™ it is not sin?? All is vanity except to love The Lord and Him alone to serve. Anyone who says they are without sin is a liar. But it so much easier to point out the speck in someone else’s eye than remove the log that is in your own.

…and on, and on…this is just the tip of the iceberg.
 
I respectfully disagree. Would you like to explain how putting on fake fingernails, starting your car or turning on your furnace is a sin?
Would you like to explain how smoking tobacco is a sin? No one here has adequately explained that one yet.
 
Would you like to explain how smoking tobacco is a sin? No one here has adequately explained that one yet.
In post #7 and 30. If that wasn’t adequate, that fine.
I grew up with a parent with addictions and knew what it was like to live with them. To stay sober and clean is a gift I give myself and my family. It’s hard for me to hear a rationalization that voluntarily taking on an addiction doesn’t involve our sinful human nature. It’s a choice we do with our own free will (it’s not forced on us) and it’s a bad one.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top