Why must we be forgiven by a priest?

  • Thread starter Thread starter DrewC
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Hi Brosam.
So the “analogy of Scripture” is the primary principle of hermeneutics.

Do you mean the “rule of faith”, or “regula fidei” or “kanon tes pisteos”, the ancient principle by which the beliefs have to be considered in relation to the core tenets of the faith ?

Or by "analogy of scripture we are to understand ( de facto) a practice by which I read the whole Scripture according to …the interpretation I like of some verses I like ?
For sure, we had the Bible through the Church, but … you did not receive that “analogy of scripture” through Her.

Or by “analogy of Scripture” you mean “reading the Bible as a whole , according to the unity of the all ?” Then, you know, in Greek, “as a whole”, sounds “kath’olon”, from which …catholic, catholicism.

So, if you do practice this hexegesis, good for you. 👍
I do hope this is the meaning of “analogy of scripture” for you, and you escape the sad de facto application of the so called principle of the “analogy of scripture” that I mentioned before.

So, did I get more or less what the “primary principle of hermeneutics” is for those who hold to Sola Scriptura ? By the way, where is the expression “analogy of scripture” in Scripture ?
pneuma07, excellent post, but I think you may have blown a couple million fuses in the poor guys head with it.

🙂
 
You posted about hermeneutics. Are you not aware that you are interpreting also?
Sure.
The difference is that Catholics conduct hermeneutics according to the apostolic tradition,and you conduct yours without any knowledge of what happened in the first 1500 years of the Church
The difference is that I’m using sound hermeneutic principles while you’ve already admitted that “the majority of Catholics don’t know the basic principles of hermeneutics. I think the majority of them would not be able to give an interpretation of the word.”

See post 56 of this thread.
There is only One Church, brosam.
I agree. And it is arrogant of you to claim that yours is the only church, while we are not a part of the church.
Your ecclesiastical community, as much as you wish to believe it is somehow separate from the One Chuch that Jesus founded, is not.
And the Bible says otherwise. As usual, I’m going to have to go with God’s word over yours.
This is not true, brosam. How could they? when it was the Catholic doctrine that was represented in the NT as Catholics wrote it?
What you believe Roman Catholics wrote and what Roman Catholicism commonly teaches are not the same thing.
Anyhow, we can discuss any discrepancies you seem to find. If things appear discrepant, it is because you either don’t understand scripture properly, or you don’t understand Catholic Teaching properly. However, lets focus on one at a time, and this thread is about the Sacrament of Reconciliation.
I’ve been studying the scriptures for twenty years and not one person has ever pointed out anything I’ve taught that is wrong. Likewise, I aced (and am acing) my seminary classes.

Now, if you’re going to say that I don’t understand Roman Catholic teaching, then that is to admit that this organization you claim is infallible, is God’s own mouthpiece, was incompetent to teach me in all of the years they had me.
By the way, how do you account for the fact that the Orthodox, who have no love lost on Romans, practice this sacrament, which they also received from the Aposltes? The fact that they do so proves this is not a “Roman” invention.
I don’t. Like I’ve explained to you many times now, our doctrine isn’t based on what others believe, but on what the Bible says.
Why do you think Jesus gave the power to forgive sins to men?
I’ve already addressed this.
I know that Jesus replaced the Levitical priesthood with His own.
Then why do you follow a priesthood based on the priesthood that you admit that Jesus did away with?
There is no distinction between the two, brosam.
I see. So then, you believe that your priests are God?

I don’t believe that, but it’s certainly more plausible that believing that a wafer is God or that you keep Christ’s physical body in a “tabernacle”.
You misunderstand what the communion of saints is about, and that is an issue for another thread. When we go to the priest, we are going before Christ. The priest is acting in the person of Christ for us.
Again, therein lies the difference. You go to the priest believing you go to Christ. We go to Christ.
 
And what does it prove or disprove?
It proves that even a Roman Catholic has to admit that Roman Catholics don’t understand basic hermeneutic principles. Thus, their interpretations are suspect.
You still haven’t addressed John 20:22-23
Actually, I addressed it quite a while back.
Since you are having a hard time answering
I didn’t have a hard time answering. I answered it right away.
We are waiting for your infallible answer.
Thank you for your confidence in me but I’m just a man. I’m no more infallible than your pope.
 
Actually, I addressed it quite a while back.

I didn’t have a hard time answering. I answered it right away.
Could you please try again? Maybe a little slower this time?
Thank you for your confidence in me but I’m just a man. I’m no more infallible than your pope.
I have zero confidence in you.

Do you have the “Keys to the Kingdom of Heaven” as Jesus gave them to St. Peter in Matthew 16:18?

Are you the “Pillar and foundation of truth” as mentioned in 1 Tim 3:15?

Jesus, being the good Shepperd, told St. Peter to “feed”, “tend”, “feed” His flock…tell me how would Jesus DELEGATE those tasks of Shepard to His servants without some sort of special grace? (ie: infallibility). Do you claim to have been given this grace also?

Jesus said to his appointed disciples, “Whoever listens to you listens to me. Whoever rejects you rejects me. And whoever rejects me rejects the one who sent me ” Luke 10:16
Are you the person I should be listening too?
Christ clearly says that we must be listening to someone, the question is WHO? You or perhaps something that goes back 2000 years that was founded by Christ: the Church.
hmmm…now thats a hard one. Lets hold a committee and discuss this further.
 
I had a problem with this not too long ago as well until the wonderful people on this site quoted many Bible verses that back up Sacramental Confession which they also quoted for you. Jesus gave his Apostles the power to forgive our sins and it has been passed down to our Priests. Personally, I confess directly to God and to a Priest in confession. We don’t 100% know that confessing directly to God isn’t sufficient but IMHO why take that chance? This is our salvation we are dealing with. Personally, I feel so cleansed after Confession and from what I’ve seen on this board, most people feel the same way. 🙂
 
Do you have the “Keys to the Kingdom of Heaven” as Jesus gave them to St. Peter in Matthew 16:18?
Yes.
Are you the “Pillar and foundation of truth” as mentioned in 1 Tim 3:15?
I’m a part of it, yes.
Jesus, being the good Shepperd, told St. Peter to “feed”, “tend”, “feed” His flock…tell me how would Jesus DELEGATE those tasks of Shepard to His servants without some sort of special grace? (ie: infallibility). Do you claim to have been given this grace also?
By your logic, yes.
Jesus said to his appointed disciples, “Whoever listens to you listens to me. Whoever rejects you rejects me. And whoever rejects me rejects the one who sent me ” Luke 10:16
Are you the person I should be listening too?
I’m one of the people you should be listening to.
Christ clearly says that we must be listening to someone, the question is WHO?
Given that it’s referring to the Gospel, you should listen to those who are preaching the Gospel.
You or perhaps something that goes back 2000 years that was founded by Christ: the Church.
hmmm…now thats a hard one. Lets hold a committee and discuss this further.
Actually, I’m a part of the church.
 
krissy:
I had a problem with this not too long ago as well until the wonderful people on this site quoted many Bible verses that back up Sacramental Confession which they also quoted for you.
Actually, the only thing they’ve quoted for me is a bunch of prooftexts.
Jesus gave his Deciples the power to forgive our sins and it has been passed down to our Priests.
So you say. I’m afraid I’m going to have to take the Bible’s word over yours.
We don’t 100% know that confessing directly to God isn’t sufficient but IMHO why take that chance?
So then, you believe there’s a chance that the passage I cited for you might be wrong? Good to know you have such a high view of God’s word.
 
Given that it’s referring to the Gospel, you should listen to those who are preaching the Gospel.
But you are not preaching the Gospel of Christ. You are preaching the Gospel of brosam and whatever his pastor/friends/Jack Chick taught him.
 
So then, you believe there’s a chance that the passage I cited for you might be wrong? Good to know you have such a high view of God’s word.
<referring to 100% forgiveness if we confess directly to God>

Try telling that to Eliphaz and his two friends.

God would not forgive them unless Job INTERCEDED FOR THEM.
Job 42: 7-11

So if you were those guys and had brosam’s gospel, guess what, you would not have been forgiven buddy.
 
And where in that passage does Jesus talk about the throne of grace?

You don’t know what “how do you come to that conclusion” means?

:rolleyes: No, I didn’t ask you if you believe in analogies. I asked if you believe in the analogy of scripture.
Where in Scripture may I find the phrase “analogy of Scripture”?
 
by "analogy of Scripture we are to understand ( de facto) a practice by which I read the whole Scripture according to …the interpretation I like of some verses I like ?
For sure, we had the Bible through the Church, but … you did not receive that “analogy of Scripture” through Her.

Or by “analogy of Scripture” you mean “reading the Bible as a whole , according to the unity of the all ?” Then, you know, in Greek, “as a whole”, sounds “kath’olon”, from which …Catholic, Catholicism. :hmmm:

So, if you do practice this hexegesis, good for you. 👍
I do hope this is the meaning of “analogy of Scripture” for you, and you escape the sad de facto application that I mentioned before.

So, did I get more or less what the “primary principle of hermeneutics” is for those who hold to Sola Scriptura ? By the way, where is the expression “analogy of Scripture” in Scripture ?
Now, we know you mean “analogy of Scripture”. Sure, you know it was elaborated in order to get along with the newborn Solascripturaism. By which I am compelled to postulate the Bible ( read "myself " ) as the only interpreter of the Bible. ( And I am compelled to postulate, unbiblically, the perspicuity of the Bible). Being not Solascripturaists, many Catholics have not been taught the “analogy of Scripture”. Since this appears to upset you so strongly, are you now confirmed that they are not Christians ? 🙂

Now, could you go on answering my first post ?
 
hermeneutic
“interpretive,” 1678, from Gk. hermeneutikos “interpreting,” from hermeneutes “interpreter,” from hermeneuein “to interpret,” considered ultimately a derivative of Hermes, as the tutelary divinity of speech, writing, and eloquence.
Always be wary when someone uses jargon where English would do.

We Catholics tend to leave interpretation to professionals.

To do otherwise is to proliferate heresy and schism.
 
<referring to 100% forgiveness if we confess directly to God>

Try telling that to Eliphaz and his two friends.

God would not forgive them unless Job INTERCEDED FOR THEM.
Job 42: 7-11

So if you were those guys and had brosam’s gospel, guess what, you would not have been forgiven buddy.
Oh, I see. So then, Roman Catholics believe that they’re still under the Old Covenant? That would certainly explain why they have a priesthood based on the old Levitical priesthood.
 
Oh, I see. So then, Roman Catholics believe that they’re still under the Old Covenant? That would certainly explain why they have a priesthood based on the old Levitical priesthood.
That is not a “sound hermeneutic interpretation” of the passage I quoted.
 
No he wasn’t. However, he also insisted that his followers should depend on him to tell them what the scriptures say because they couldn’t understand them.
Like a protestant minister? Funny, because he was. You brought it up, first.

If you don’t need someone to interpreiate scripture, why have ministers? Why not go to you faith community gatherings and just read your bible if interpretation is unimportant? Just you and your bible, nobody stand between the two of you.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top