No, that’s the truth according to God’s word, which I posted for him.
You posted about hermeneutics. Are you not aware that you are interpreting also? The difference is that Catholics conduct hermeneutics according to the apostolic tradition,and you conduct yours without any knowledge of what happened in the first 1500 years of the Church
First of all, the NT authors were Jews, not Roman Catholics.
I agree they were not Roman Catholics. The Roman Rite did not develop until many centuries later. I also agree that most of the NT authors were Jews, if not all. Luke may have been a Gentile. However, in spite of the fact that they tried their best to remain Jewish, they were evetually expelled from synagogue and Temple as a heretical sect. The Catholic Church was born on Pentecost, and has continued in Apostolic Tradition unto the present day. There is only One Church, brosam. Your ecclesiastical community, as much as you wish to believe it is somehow separate from the One Chuch that Jesus founded, is not.
Second, there are many Roman Catholic doctrines that contradict scripture.
This is not true, brosam. How could they? when it was the Catholic doctrine that was represented in the NT as Catholics wrote it? Anyhow, we can discuss any discrepancies you seem to find. If things appear discrepant, it is because you either don’t understand scripture properly, or you don’t understand Catholic Teaching properly. However, lets focus on one at a time, and this thread is about the Sacrament of Reconciliation.
By the way, how do you account for the fact that the Orthodox, who have no love lost on Romans, practice this sacrament, which they also received from the Aposltes? The fact that they do so proves this is not a “Roman” invention.
Actually, that’s referring to accountability between Christians, not the fanciful idea that we can go to a man who will forgive us.
Why do you think Jesus gave the power to forgive sins to men?
How is this “fanciful”?
Same answer I gave last five times you asked this question.
Perhaps I have not read all of the thread?
Actually, there is. Jesus is Jesus. The priest is just a man.
Certainly, but a man empowered by the gift and calling of God, which means he can do things an “ordinary” man cannot do.
You do know that the priesthood was done away with, right? Old Covenant…New Covenant…ring any bells?
I know that Jesus replaced the Levitical priesthood with His own.
I know that Jesus empowered His apostles with priestly duties, one of them the power to forgive sins.
And therein lies the difference. The priest represents Jesus to you. Jesus represents Jesus to us.
There is no distinction between the two, brosam. We see the light of Christ in the face of believers, and those persons who have been given special gifts by the HS are appreciated for those gifts. You should understand this, because you claim to be the reicipient of such gifts!
They may very well be, but that doesn’t change the fact that the passage tells us to go before the throne of grace, not to go to a priest or a dead “saint” and ask them to go before the throne of grace for us.
You misunderstand what the communion of saints is about, and that is an issue for another thread. When we go to the priest, we are going before Christ. The priest is acting in the person of Christ for us.