Why must we be forgiven by a priest?

  • Thread starter Thread starter DrewC
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Before I answer that. . .
Brosam, don’t keep us in suspense! 👍

If I had to guess, I would say that you suscribe to the tradition that this passage means that the disciples who have now received the Holy Spirit are commissioned to preach the Gospel, and those who receive the Gospel are forgiven their sins and those who reject the Gospel do not obtain forgivenss from God.

But that is just a guess. It can be found in Matthew Henry’s commentary which dates to the early 18th century. Did this interpretation exist earlier than that? Do you know when it first appeared?

VC
 
Based upon what Jesus said earlier in the passage I quoted.
And where in that passage does Jesus talk about the throne of grace?
I’m not sure exactly what you mean but let me guess.
You don’t know what “how do you come to that conclusion” means?
You asked me if we believe in Analogy
:rolleyes: No, I didn’t ask you if you believe in analogies. I asked if you believe in the analogy of scripture.
 
“Plain language”? If it were plain language, then it would actually mention confession to men for the forgiveness of sins. It doesn’t.
For me (and the Church) this is plain language. This is nothing other than a responsibility bestowed on the apostles and their successors. If they were to not go out and forgive (and sometimes retain) sin, then they would be disobedient to Christ himself.

We don’t see the exact steps that we as believers need to perform, if that is what you are looking for, but Christ is very clear that this is something he expects from the apostles (and their successors).
Before I answer that, tell me this. As a Roman Catholic, do you believe in the analogy of scripture?
I’m not sure what you are asking. Do I believe the analogies that Christ illustrates in the Bible? Of course. Do I believe that there are other analogies that can be drawn from various passages in the Bible? Of course.
 
For me (and the Church) this is plain language.
You’re reading something into the text that isn’t there. That’s eisegesis, not “plain language”.
I’m not sure what you are asking.
I’m asking if you believe in the analogy of scripture, not if you believe in analogies in scripture.
 
I’m asking if you believe in the analogy of scripture, not if you believe in analogies in scripture.
Would you please explain what “analogy of scripture” means? Clearly the other posters responding don’t know what you mean.
 
You’re reading something into the text that isn’t there. That’s eisegesis, not “plain language”.
This is your opinion that I am reading into it?
I’m asking if you believe in the analogy of scripture, not if you believe in analogies in scripture.
How about just answering my original question?👍
 
Confession and Forgiveness

Some people object to the Sacrament of Reconciliation (commonly called “Confession”) on the basis that they only need to confess their sins directly to God rather than to a priest. Is this perspective correct? Let’s see what the Bible has to say.

Leviticus 5:5-6
5 " 'When anyone is guilty in any of these ways, he must confess in what way he has sinned 6 and, as a penalty for the sin he has committed, he must bring to the LORD a female lamb or goat from the flock as a sin offering; and the priest shall make atonement for him for his sin.

“The priest shall make atonement.” Clearly in the Old Testament, the priesthood existed to offer sacrifices and make atonement for the sins committed by the people. Does this idea continue in the New Testament?

Hebrews 10:1
1 The law is only a shadow of the good things that are coming—not the realities themselves.

The Old Testament prefigures and foreshadows New Testament truths; the Old is revealed more fully in the New. So, what does the New Testament teach us about confession of sin?

1 John 1:9
9 If we confess our sins, he is faithful and just and will forgive us our sins and purify us from all unrighteousness.

We should confess our sins, and God will forgive us, but do we confess our sins to God alone?

James 5:13-16
13 Is any one of you in trouble? He should pray. Is anyone happy? Let him sing songs of praise. 14 Is any one of you sick? He should call the elders of the church to pray over him and anoint him with oil in the name of the Lord. 15 And the prayer offered in faith will make the sick person well; the Lord will raise him up. If he has sinned, he will be forgiven. 16 Therefore confess your sins to each other and pray for each other so that you may be healed.

Here the word of God tells us to call the elders (the Greek word is presbuteroi, or “presbyter”, from which the English word “priest” is derived. So, in this context, James is telling us to send for the priests who will pray over someone who is sick, and if he has sinned, he will be forgiven. Recalling the passage from Leviticus above, we see there is a strong parallel between the priests of the Old Testament who made atonement for sin and the presbyters or priests of the New Testament to whom we confess sins for forgiveness. But this sounds like blasphemy! Can men really forgive sins? This same question is asked in the New Testament.

Mark 2:5-7
5 When Jesus saw their faith, he said to the paralytic, “Son, your sins are forgiven.” 6Now some teachers of the law were sitting there, thinking to themselves, 7"Why does this fellow talk like that? He’s blaspheming! Who can forgive sins but God alone?"

Who can forgive sins but God alone? This question is often asked by those who seek to deny the sacrament of confession. However, note that this question is asked by the scribes who did not accept Jesus. Those who quote this passage find themselves on the side of those who rejected the Messiah. There’s more to the story, however; let’s consider the same incident from the book of Matthew.

Matthew 9:1-7
1 Jesus stepped into a boat, crossed over and came to his own town. 2Some men brought to him a paralytic, lying on a mat. When Jesus saw their faith, he said to the paralytic, “Take heart, son; your sins are forgiven.” 3 At this, some of the teachers of the law said to themselves, “This fellow is blaspheming!” 4 Knowing their thoughts, Jesus said, “Why do you entertain evil thoughts in your hearts? 5Which is easier: to say, ‘Your sins are forgiven,’ or to say, ‘Get up and walk’? 6But so that you may know that the Son of Man has authority on earth to forgive sins…” Then he said to the paralytic, “Get up, take your mat and go home.” 7And the man got up and went home. 8When the crowd saw this, they were filled with awe; and they praised God, who had given such authority to men.

The Bible teaches that God had given the authority to forgive sins “to men”. Note that this is not “to a man” but “to men” – plural. So, it is not only Jesus who has authority to forgive sins – “men” have this authority, also. This sounds like a “hard teaching”…is there confirmation of this in the Bible?

(cont.)
 
John 20:21-23
21 Again Jesus said,"Peace be with you! As the Father has sent me, I am sending you."22 And with that he breathed on them and said, “Receive the Holy Spirit. 23 If you forgive anyone his sins, they are forgiven; if you do not forgive them, they are not forgiven.”

How did God send Jesus into the world? With the authority to forgive sins as we saw in Matthew 9:6. How does Jesus send the Apostles? In the same way that the Father had sent Him…with the authority to forgive sins as we have just seen in John 20:23. How could the Apostles obey the commandment of Jesus to forgive sins unless they heard these sins confessed?

2 Corinthians 2:10
10To whom ye forgive any thing, I forgive also: for if I forgave any thing, to whom I forgave it, for your sakes forgave I it in the person of Christ; (KJV)

And to whom you have pardoned any thing, I also. For, what I have pardoned, if I have pardoned any thing, for your sakes have I done it in the person of Christ. (Douay Rheims)

Only God can forgive sins, but He has chosen to do so through the ordained men of the priesthood and the Sacrament of Reconciliation that He Himself instituted.

Hope this helps. :tiphat:
 
Confession [in front of a priest] is God’s remedy for self-deception and self-indulgence. Confession allows us to mortify the pride of the flesh and deliver it up to shame and death through Christ. In confession the Christian is conformed to the death of Christ.
“Through the word of absolution, we rise as new men totally dependent on the mercy of God.” [Boenhoeffer]
 
This is your opinion that I am reading into it?
Yes. Based on the fact that the text does not say what you claim it does, that is my opinion.
How about just answering my original question?👍
Do you or do you not believe in the analogy of scripture? Why is this such a hard question for you to answer?

The answer is either “yes” or it is “no”.
 
Would you please explain what “analogy of scripture” means? Clearly the other posters responding don’t know what you mean.
Sure they do. They’re Roman Catholics. They gave us the Bible, remember? Surely you can’t be suggesting that they don’t know the primary principle of hermeneutics.
 
But that’s just it! You can go straight to God. Anyone who tells you that you must go to God through them isn’t telling you the truth.
Would that be the truth according to brosam?
Ask yourself, am I going to go by what Roman Catholicism tells me? Or am I going to go by what the Bible says?
This is a thinking error, brosam, and a false dichotomy. The Catholic Church wrote the NT, and nothing within it’s pages contradicts Catholic Doctrine and practice.
The Bible is very clear that we go directly to God. No priests, no Mary. Just us going directly to God.
Is that why it says to “confess your sins to one another”? How did you think the Apostles were going to forgive people their sins if they did not know what they were?
Just look at Hebrews 4:11-16:
Notice that it says let us come boldly unto the throne of grace, not “let us go to our priest to speak on behalf of the throne of grace” or “let us ask Mary to go to the throne of grace and intercede for us”.
You are setting up false dichotomies again. there is no distinction between going to a priest and going to Jesus. The priest represents Jesus to us. Asking others for intercession does not “subtract” in any way from Jesus as our mediator. This is the way that Jesus set it up, that He would work through the people He appointed.
It’s us going to the throne of grace.
Do you think that the priests and saints are not before the throne of grace?
 
I’m not sure what you are asking. Do I believe the analogies that Christ illustrates in the Bible? Of course. Do I believe that there are other analogies that can be drawn from various passages in the Bible? Of course.
He believes that any interpretation of scripture that supports Catholic doctrine is more appropriately understood as an analogy. He is going to use this substrate of analogy to get you to see why you should abandon your “Romish errors” which he considers heresies.
 
Well, according to the Church’s teachings, the priest represents God. It’s always God who forgives. The priest absolves the sins in the name of God.
 
Would that be the truth according to brosam?
No, that’s the truth according to God’s word, which I posted for him.
This is a thinking error, brosam, and a false dichotomy. The Catholic Church wrote the NT, and nothing within it’s pages contradicts Catholic Doctrine and practice.
First of all, the NT authors were Jews, not Roman Catholics.

Second, there are many Roman Catholic doctrines that contradict scripture.
Is that why it says to “confess your sins to one another”?
Actually, that’s referring to accountability between Christians, not the fanciful idea that we can go to a man who will forgive us.
How did you think the Apostles were going to forgive people their sins if they did not know what they were?
Same answer I gave last five times you asked this question.
You are setting up false dichotomies again. there is no distinction between going to a priest and going to Jesus.
Actually, there is. Jesus is Jesus. The priest is just a man.

You do know that the priesthood was done away with, right? Old Covenant…New Covenant…ring any bells?
The priest represents Jesus to us.
And therein lies the difference. The priest represents Jesus to you. Jesus represents Jesus to us.
Do you think that the priests and saints are not before the throne of grace?
They may very well be, but that doesn’t change the fact that the passage tells us to go before the throne of grace, not to go to a priest or a dead “saint” and ask them to go before the throne of grace for us.
 
Sure they do. They’re Roman Catholics. They gave us the Bible, remember? Surely you can’t be suggesting that they don’t know the primary principle of hermeneutics.
You are in error (again, brosam!) that “Roman Catholics” gave us the Bible. The Roman Rite did not develop for centuries after the Catholic Church wrote and defined the canonical books.

I would say that the majority of Catholics don’t know the basic principles of hermeneutics. I think the majority of them would not be able to give an interpretation of the word.

In answer to your question, here is a good article on Catholic interpretation of scripture. This article will answer your question, which I have now seen posted in several threads, about whether Catholics believe in the analogy of scripture.

catholic.com/thisrock/2004/0405bt.asp
 
I would say that the majority of Catholics don’t know the basic principles of hermeneutics. I think the majority of them would not be able to give an interpretation of the word.
WOW! That’s quite a stunning admission.
 
No, that’s the truth according to God’s word, which I posted for him.
You posted about hermeneutics. Are you not aware that you are interpreting also? The difference is that Catholics conduct hermeneutics according to the apostolic tradition,and you conduct yours without any knowledge of what happened in the first 1500 years of the Church
First of all, the NT authors were Jews, not Roman Catholics.
I agree they were not Roman Catholics. The Roman Rite did not develop until many centuries later. I also agree that most of the NT authors were Jews, if not all. Luke may have been a Gentile. However, in spite of the fact that they tried their best to remain Jewish, they were evetually expelled from synagogue and Temple as a heretical sect. The Catholic Church was born on Pentecost, and has continued in Apostolic Tradition unto the present day. There is only One Church, brosam. Your ecclesiastical community, as much as you wish to believe it is somehow separate from the One Chuch that Jesus founded, is not.
Second, there are many Roman Catholic doctrines that contradict scripture.
This is not true, brosam. How could they? when it was the Catholic doctrine that was represented in the NT as Catholics wrote it? Anyhow, we can discuss any discrepancies you seem to find. If things appear discrepant, it is because you either don’t understand scripture properly, or you don’t understand Catholic Teaching properly. However, lets focus on one at a time, and this thread is about the Sacrament of Reconciliation.

By the way, how do you account for the fact that the Orthodox, who have no love lost on Romans, practice this sacrament, which they also received from the Aposltes? The fact that they do so proves this is not a “Roman” invention.
Actually, that’s referring to accountability between Christians, not the fanciful idea that we can go to a man who will forgive us.
Why do you think Jesus gave the power to forgive sins to men?
How is this “fanciful”?
Same answer I gave last five times you asked this question.
Perhaps I have not read all of the thread?
Actually, there is. Jesus is Jesus. The priest is just a man.
Certainly, but a man empowered by the gift and calling of God, which means he can do things an “ordinary” man cannot do.
You do know that the priesthood was done away with, right? Old Covenant…New Covenant…ring any bells?
I know that Jesus replaced the Levitical priesthood with His own.
I know that Jesus empowered His apostles with priestly duties, one of them the power to forgive sins.
And therein lies the difference. The priest represents Jesus to you. Jesus represents Jesus to us.
There is no distinction between the two, brosam. We see the light of Christ in the face of believers, and those persons who have been given special gifts by the HS are appreciated for those gifts. You should understand this, because you claim to be the reicipient of such gifts!
They may very well be, but that doesn’t change the fact that the passage tells us to go before the throne of grace, not to go to a priest or a dead “saint” and ask them to go before the throne of grace for us.
You misunderstand what the communion of saints is about, and that is an issue for another thread. When we go to the priest, we are going before Christ. The priest is acting in the person of Christ for us.
 
WOW! That’s quite a stunning admission.
And what does it prove or disprove?

I would say 100% of Protestants that don’t believe in Confession clearly can’t read and likewise, have no sound principles of interpretation. MOST Christians THROUGHOUT the history of Christianity COULD NOT READ and about 75% of Christians in Africa TODAY cannot read and hence do not posses “basic principles of hermeneutics”. This just goes to prove that SOLA SCRIPTURA, the doctrine that never existed before Wycliffe (~14th century) and wasn’t even made popular (due to the lack of printing press) before Luther is a far cry from the way Christians should be basing their theology/moral conduct. [not to mention it still requires that a person has 1) access to a bible 2) can read greek/aramiac/latin 3) has liesure time 4) money 5) educated which like I mentioned above wipes out all Christians in Africa. Thank God they have the Church to teach them]

You still haven’t addressed John 20:22-23

I’ll quote it again:

John 20:22-23
When he had said this, he breathed on them; and he said to them: Receive ye the Holy Ghost. Whose sins you shall forgive, they are forgiven them; and whose sins you shall retain, they are retained.

Since you are having a hard time answering this tell me:
  • Who are the “you” that I have underlined in red referring too?
  • On the surface, who is are the persons doing the forgiving?
If you answered “the apostles” or “the disciples” maybe you can answer this question protestant Christian:
  • How would the Apostles know what sins to forgive and retain if the sins of the person were not somehow revealed to them? (like CONFESSED)
We are waiting for your infallible answer.
 
Sure they do. They’re Roman Catholics. They gave us the Bible, remember? Surely you can’t be suggesting that they don’t know the primary principle of hermeneutics.
Hi Brosam.
So the “analogy of Scripture” is the primary principle of hermeneutics.

Do you mean the “rule of faith”, ( “regula fidei” or “kanon tes pisteos” )?

Or by "analogy of Scripture we are to understand ( de facto) a practice by which I read the whole Scripture according to …the interpretation I like of some verses I like ?
For sure, we had the Bible through the Church, but … you did not receive that “analogy of Scripture” through Her.

Or by “analogy of Scripture” you mean “reading the Bible as a whole , according to the unity of the all ?” Then, you know, in Greek, “as a whole”, sounds “kath’olon”, from which …Catholic, Catholicism. :hmmm:

So, if you do practice this hexegesis, good for you. 👍
I do hope this is the meaning of “analogy of Scripture” for you, and you escape the sad de facto application that I mentioned before.

So, did I get more or less what the “primary principle of hermeneutics” is for those who hold to Sola Scriptura ? By the way, where is the expression “analogy of Scripture” in Scripture ?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top