Why should Bush be impeached?

  • Thread starter Thread starter NotWorthy
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
40.png
2shelbys:
Taxes were paid on those items when they were aquired and now they are taxed again before the next of kin can have what is left of them?

The people hardest hit by this extortion are families of farmers who can not afford to keep the farm when the owner dies.
First of all, it is a myth about the family farmer. I notice that those who like to support the repeal of the inheritance tax hide behind folks like my uncle, a dairy farmer. But the truth is that it’s all a lie. A canaard. They can’t even find farms that have been affected by the inheritance tax but they keep repeating the lie over and over again until other people pick it up and start repeating it.

Second of all, as money passes from hands to hands in our economy, it is often taxed. Money does not get stamped one time and then never get taxed again. I’d argue that the inheritor is no different from a lottery winner; having done nothing to earn the money.

But the more important question is what kind of society would choose to tax earned money and not tax inherited money? What kind of nation would we be to so strongly signal that we are promoting a permanent, inheriting class?
 
40.png
Thekla:
But the more important question is what kind of society would choose to tax earned money and not tax inherited money?
To answer your question: A society that respects private property.

Not real familiar with estate taxes, eh? If I earn enough money over the course of my life that I have 500k in the bank when I die–that money is a part of my estate and it’s taxed when the estate is settled. THEN if I decide to leave my estate to my 3 kids they get their share AFTER the estate tax is PAID and THEN they pay additional taxes on the money.
What kind of nation would we be to so strongly signal that we are promoting a permanent, inheriting class?
We’d be a nation who encourages wealth creation, property ownership, fiscal freedom to decide what/who gets the money we earned or inherited (because it’s not the state’s money).

A better, more productive nation, IMO.
 
40.png
Thekla:
First of all, it is a myth about the family farmer. I notice that those who like to support the repeal of the inheritance tax hide behind folks like my uncle, a dairy farmer. But the truth is that it’s all a lie. A canaard. They can’t even find farms that have been affected by the inheritance tax but they keep repeating the lie over and over again until other people pick it up and start repeating it.

Second of all, as money passes from hands to hands in our economy, it is often taxed. Money does not get stamped one time and then never get taxed again. I’d argue that the inheritor is no different from a lottery winner; having done nothing to earn the money.

But the more important question is what kind of society would choose to tax earned money and not tax inherited money? What kind of nation would we be to so strongly signal that we are promoting a permanent, inheriting class?
Since I am a CPA who does over 500 tax returns a year(and have been doing so for 25 years) Ill give you my perspective. The question really is "what kind of society taxes ones income** twice**? "Thats what the Estate tax does. As one accumulates wealth over their lifetime they are taxed on it. What the estate tax does is tax it againofiten at a rate higher tha it was taxed in the first place.

Their is no rationale for the estate tax other than class warfare. You acknowledge that with your comment about a “permanaet inheriting class” I assume you view is one should put in a lifetime of hard work so as to the fruits of their labor passes (at leat 48% of it) to the Govt ? I would rather leave it to my kids. I most certainly dont hink you or the Gvot sould have any say whatsoever who get my estate when I die.

I have seen more times than i like to remeber viable farms and businesses ripped apart, assets sold, employees laid of ,all in the name of giving the Govt one last opportunity to seize your income. Fortunately, due to the reforms of the last few years ,we dont see a lot of this anymore.
 
40.png
estesbob:
Since I am a CPA who does over 500 tax returns a year(and have been doing so for 25 years) Ill give you my perspective. The question really is "what kind of society taxes ones income** twice**? "Thats what the Estate tax does. As one accumulates wealth over their lifetime they are taxed on it. What the estate tax does is tax it againofiten at a rate higher tha it was taxed in the first place.

Their is no rationale for the estate tax other than class warfare. You acknowledge that with your comment about a “permanaet inheriting class” I assume you view is one should put in a lifetime of hard work so as to the fruits of their labor passes (at leat 48% of it) to the Govt ? I would rather leave it to my kids. I most certainly dont hink you or the Gvot sould have any say whatsoever who get my estate when I die.

You are absolutely right about the estate tax. And it does not affect just the rich, Thekla. My Mom worked hard all her life, raised four kids on her own, was successful after a fashion and denied herself things so that she could “leave something to her kids”. The money had been taxed to the max already. It amazes me how liberals think they have a right to this kind of money. Class warfare to be sure.
I have seen more times than i like to remeber viable farms and businesses ripped apart, assets sold, employees laid of ,all in the name of giving the Govt one last opportunity to seize your income. Fortunately, due to the reforms of the last few years ,we dont see a lot of this anymore.
 
40.png
estesbob:
Since I am a CPA who does over 500 tax returns a year(and have been doing so for 25 years) Ill give you my perspective. The question really is "what kind of society taxes ones income** twice**? "Thats what the Estate tax does.
You see, you and I don’t even agree on the following sentence that you wrote, “What kind of society taxes ones income twice?” The first time it’s taxed, you are alive and the second time you are dead. So the “ones” that you talk about isn’t even on Earth anymore.

Since you are a CPA, you are well aware that the inheritance tax kicks in at a significantly higher number than it used to and that couples are able to give each of their children more than $20,000/annually now while they are still alive.

I think that there is a tremendous need by many people to see the value of their life measured by the value of their estate upon their death. But in the end, it’s just money. We’ve been kidding my father that it seems that the older he gets, the “tighter” he gets; increasingly intent to leave behind an ever larger and larger inheritance to his children.

But when my father is gone, I won’t consider any tax that must be paid charged to him, but rather to me. And unlike some, I consider that tax no different than a tax on lottery winners; the difference being that I won a sort of genetic lottery.

I’m happy to talk tax policy, but the original question on this thread had to do with why people so dislike (the poster used the word 'hate") Mr. Bush and his policies. And again I go back to the fact that we see a misguided, and possibly immoral, financial policy. Using the tax system and federal programs to further enrich the elite in this country while driving the nation into debt.
 
40.png
thestickman:
Not real familiar with estate taxes, eh? If I earn enough money over the course of my life that I have 500k in the bank when I die–that money is a part of my estate and it’s taxed when the estate is settled. THEN if I decide to leave my estate to my 3 kids they get their share AFTER the estate tax is PAID and THEN they pay additional taxes on the money.
$500,000? Where have you been? Apparently you are the one unfamiliar with estate taxes. The first $1,500,000 is essentially “tax” free beginning in 2004. ****
 
40.png
Thekla:
Using the tax system and federal programs to further enrich the elite in this country while driving the nation into debt.
Which is an invalid statement. The reality is, tax receipts to the federal government have INCREASED since the tax increases went into effect. The economy has GROWN. More people are working now in America than ever before in the history of the nation.

Tax payers are getting to keep more of their own $$$ which is ALWAYS a good and moral thing, IMO.

The leftists in America want to see Bush impeached because he has defeated them at every turn, IMO. The left complains about the economy–it’s grown anyway. The left complained about letting tax payers keep more of their own money–the economy had grown and jobs have been created anyway. The left complains abot Bush’s foriegn policy–50 million people are free from tyranny now that weren’t before as direct result of those policies. The left complains about the debt while never wishing to reduce spending on programs which creates government dependence–and the economy continues to grow, jobs are created anyway.

IMO, the left wants Bush impeached because they are so woefully lost. They offer only class warfare whine and moan to go with their bigotry towards people of color and they’re losing their ability to main that voter block as more black Americans incomes continue to rise.

IMO, the left needs Bush impeached because they have nothing else. Their hatred (a term I seldom ever use) for personal responsibility, belief in God, Catholic teaching, the poor in America, freedom for other nations, and their contempt for the military, IMO is as clearly seen as their dislike for President Bush.

Thankfully, they’ve been losing their grip on power since 1994 and are losing influence with the groups of people they used to be able to count on each election.

IMO, of course:)
 
Thekla said:
$500,000? Where have you been? Apparently you are the one unfamiliar with estate taxes. The first $1,500,000 is essentially “tax” free beginning in 2004. ****

ESSENTIALLY is the operative word here. It has already been taxed once.
 
40.png
Thekla:
You see, you and I don’t even agree on the following sentence that you wrote, “What kind of society taxes ones income twice?” The first time it’s taxed, you are alive and the second time you are dead. So the “ones” that you talk about isn’t even on Earth anymore…
Thats some of the most convoluted reasoning I’ve seen in a long time.
Since you are a CPA, you are well aware that the inheritance tax kicks in at a significantly higher number than it used to and that couples are able to give each of their children more than $20,000/annually now while they are still alive…
Actually its $22,000, assuming you have a spouse.,but so what?
I think that there is a tremendous need by many people to see the value of their life measured by the value of their estate upon their death. But in the end, it’s just money. We’ve been kidding my father that it seems that the older he gets, the “tighter” he gets; increasingly intent to leave behind an ever larger and larger inheritance to his children…
Money that you feel the Govt has the right to sieze even thoughts already been taxed. I suspect that your Father doesnt have a taxable Estate-even under the Laws before Bush reformed them. It is easy to be magnaminous with other peoples money.
But when my father is gone, I won’t consider any tax that must be paid charged to him, but rather to me. And unlike some, I consider that tax no different than a tax on lottery winners; the difference being that I won a sort of genetic lottery.

I’m happy to talk tax policy, but the original question on this thread had to do with why people so dislike (the poster used the word 'hate") Mr. Bush and his policies. And again I go back to the fact that we see a misguided, and possibly immoral, financial policy. Using the tax system and federal programs to further enrich the elite in this country while driving the nation into debt.
You go ahead and consider it any way you want-just leave my money and my kids alone. The tax system doesnt enrich the elite- unless you go acribe to the Democorat view of money-that it ALL beloings to the Govt and the tax sysstem decides how much of the their money we get to keep.
 
Thekla said:
$500,000? Where have you been? Apparently you are the one unfamiliar with estate taxes. The first $1,500,000 is essentially “tax” free beginning in 2004.

Actually it is 2,000,000. Goes to 3,500,000 in 2009 and disappears in 2010. If nothing is done it goes back inot effect at the pre reform levels in 2011. I always tell my clients to avoid their kids in 2010-it can save their kids a LOT of money if they pass away in 2010 rather than 2011.http://forums.catholic-questions.org/images/icons/icon7.gif
 
How valid is the point that Taxing the Rich only effects rich, anyway?!?

Most of us (at least us older people) probably remember when they raised the Luxury taxes in the 80’s(?). The government thought it would be great to add taxes to all the yachts made down in Florida. You know, a good way to stick it to “the man”. What happened? Rich people stopped buying yachts, and all the yacht manufacturers had to lay off the average Joe.

That’s why tax reductions “for the rich” benefit so many of us. If the rich are spending money on things, then somebody has to provide those “things”.

Capital Gains Taxes? Raising them just discourages investing in stocks. Those investments often help the little guy start up businesses.

Notworthy
 
40.png
estesbob:
Actually it is 2,000,000. Goes to 3,500,000 in 2009 and disappears in 2010. If nothing is done it goes back inot effect at the pre reform levels in 2011. I always tell my clients to avoid their kids in 2010-it can save their kids a LOT of money if they pass away in 2010 rather than 2011.http://forums.catholic-questions.org/images/icons/icon7.gif
Actually, it is. It’s just seemed to be going up exponentially since 2001 when it was just under $700,000. And for parents out there, both you and your spouse can give each child $11,000 (or isn’t it now $12,000) annually with no tax ramifications.

Just think. If you have three kids, in just 5 years you can give away $330,000 (make that $360,000) tax free. So get to it.
 
40.png
estesbob:
I suspect that your Father doesnt have a taxable Estate-even under the Laws before Bush reformed them. It is easy to be magnaminous with other peoples money.
Not that you are correct, but why would you think that? There are many, many people in this country who take issue with further repeal of the estate tax. Just listen to Warren Buffet and Bill Gates. There are a lot of people who are affected by the estate tax who consider it a moral issue. To me, it’s really weird to hear people not affected by the estate tax, fighting for the estates of millionaires. Kind of comical when you think about it.

And since this strange scale has been put into effect with the sunset provisions, the year in which someone dies can make, what some might consider, a big difference.

Don’t forget, if you have a seven figure estate, you may want to consider a bypass trust. Personally, I think that people should spend most of it and make sure their kids work.
 
Thekla said:
$500,000? Where have you been? Apparently you are the one unfamiliar with estate taxes. The first $1,500,000 is essentially “tax” free beginning in 2004.

Psst…it was an example🙂
 
40.png
Thekla:
Not that you are correct, but why would you think that? There are many, many people in this country who take issue with further repeal of the estate tax. Just listen to Warren Buffet and Bill Gates. There are a lot of people who are affected by the estate tax who consider it a moral issue. To me, it’s really weird to hear people not affected by the estate tax, fighting for the estates of millionaires. Kind of comical when you think about it.
It’s really odd, actually. So many Americans seem so perturbed by which taxes the richest 1% or 2% are paying. Hint : these people have the means to stick up for themselves. They already own the tv channels, the media, meet with the government regularly. They don’t need your support. How about thinking about the poorest people one in a while?

Or to put it another way : would Jesus be sticking up for the right for Rupert Murdoch’s or Bill Gates’ children to not have to pay tax on their estate (I like Bill Gates’ position on this, by the way), or would he be worried about what is happening to the people at the bottom of society?

Inheritance is an antithesis to ‘you get what you work for’. Proper principled capitalists should find something else to stress about.

Mike
 
Al Masetti:
Mike,

You have to stop making stuff up.
  • Al
P.S. I apologize if I’m rude, but really…
Well, I’m still waiting. What exactly was I making up?

Mike
 
40.png
thestickman:
Psst…it was an example🙂
Hmmm. I’m not sure that I agree with that. You first suggested that I am “Not real familiar with estate taxes, eh?” and then you used the “example” of having an estate of $500,000 subject to the estate tax. An “example” four times lower than the $2,000,000 figure for '06. I’m sure that you can understand why I believe that you, not I, were the one unfamiliar with the estate tax.🙂
 
WARNING

Keep the thread civil and don’t make assumptions about each other’s knowledge or beliefs.
 
40.png
Thekla:
Hmmm. I’m not sure that I agree with that. You first suggested that I am “Not real familiar with estate taxes, eh?” and then you used the “example” of having an estate of $500,000 subject to the estate tax. An “example” four times lower than the $2,000,000 figure for '06. I’m sure that you can understand why I believe that you, not I, were the one unfamiliar with the estate tax.🙂
Yep, an example which shows how immoral, IMO, the estate tax actually is. Whether the cut off is 20 million or 100 million or if only 3 people in the country have to pay it–it’s immoral, IMO.
 
40.png
thestickman:
Yep, an example which shows how immoral, IMO, the estate tax actually is. Whether the cut off is 20 million or 100 million or if only 3 people in the country have to pay it–it’s immoral, IMO.
Why? Is paying taxes fundamentally imoral, in your opinion? And if so, how is govenment supposed to exist?

If government is not fundamentally immoral, then neither is paying taxes. The moral question then should not be as to whether any taxes should be paid, but as to how that tax burden should be distributed. To my mind, the most moral taxation scheme is the one which places the most burden on those whom can most afford it, and the least on those who can least afford it. Under this scheme, I can’t see how the estate tax is immoral. Perhaps you can suggest an alternative, more moral means of making up the difference in revenue we would lose by killing the estate tax?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top