Why should Bush be impeached?

  • Thread starter Thread starter NotWorthy
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Ani Ibi:
Tax breaks to businesses create jobs so that the poor can get off welfare. Are you suggesting that the poor should not have the dignity of working? Are you suggesting that the poor be kept in place and serve only the role of bolstering the political profile of Democrat noblesse-oblige?
If you support a flat tax, though, keeping the poor down is essentially what will happen. What kind of an incentive is it to be poor, work hard, and then have the government take away your hard earned money at a rate 52 times greater than it takes away that of the man born to wealth? As Thekla pointed out, basic expenses would cost disproportionately more under a flat tax as you move down the income scale. Sounds more dispiriting than incentive building.

Also, being from country with VAT, maybe you could answer the question I asked earlier as to whether there are additional taxes besides the sales tax? I’d appreciate your experience of living in a country with a national sales tax.
…
As far as any of this having to do with impeachment, probably not much unless the president is caught cheating on his taxes.
 
40.png
NotWorthy:
It’s funny, but a lot (I know, a lot, but not all) of these people that make these statements have moved a LOT of their money offshore where they don’t pay the same tax rate, or even close to the same.
Notworthy
You are talking personal wealth as opposed to income. Also a lot of the “offshore” stuff has been done ala Enron - American businesses. But as with anything, when there are loopholes, you get rid of the loophole, you don’t get rid of the rope.
 
40.png
Thekla:
I was glad to see this acknowledgment from you; that the dislike and low regard for Mr. Bush likely stems from **policy **and isn’t just some personal thing.
For some, certainly.
There are reasons that the majority of Americans see the country as moving in the wrong direction
:rotfl:What pro-left polling data did ya pull that notion from?
The finanical well-being of the country is a very serious concern and, over time, Mr. Bush has created an image of himself as someone who will use tax policy and federal programs to further enrich the elite while at the same time driving the nation into crushing debt
Actually that’s factually incorrect. Liberals and leftists have been trying to paint him as such since the 2000 election race. Since then, they’ve become more shrill in their declarations and have lost ground each election cycle. In 2002, Democrats lost the Senate. The leftists-liberal complaint about Bush and his tax policy was repeated in 2004 and Bush was not only re-elected but the left lost more Senate seats.

And the crushing debt with regard to taxation is hilarious, IMO, considering the pace of job creation and receipts to the federal treasury have increased since being inacted.
And then there is Iraq…
Which liberals and leftists continue trying paint as a failure when it’s been, in fact, a HUGE success.
IMO, should the left continue to complaining as it has these last 5 years regarding taxes and on the Iraq matter as it has for the last 3–2006 will be the election cycle where Democrats lose more seats in the Senate and the House.
 
40.png
thestickman:
IMO, should the left continue to complaining as it has these last 5 years regarding taxes and on the Iraq matter as it has for the last 3–2006 will be the election cycle where Democrats lose more seats in the Senate and the House.
And then the concept ‘shrill’ will take on new meaning. Well, ‘meaning’ is an exaggeration. Take on more shrillness is more accurate. 🙂
 
Philip P:
If you support a flat tax, though, keeping the poor down is essentially what will happen.
Nope. It will be liberating as poor people will have the choice to spend their money as they see fit and decide how much of it they will pay in taxes via their own spending.
What kind of an incentive is it to be poor, work hard, and then have the government take away your hard earned money at a rate 52 times greater than it takes away that of the man born to wealth?
The reality will be, poor people will be able to choose, on their own what taxes they will pay by what they decide to spend their own money on. The government won’t be taking it out of their paychecks as is done now.

As someone who’s been poor, I could care less what a rich person pays in taxes. It’s not the responsibility of the rich to put food on my family’s table–so I will never care what they pay. Being rich is a cross I’m grateful I don’t have to bear.
As Thekla pointed out, basic expenses would cost disproportionately more under a flat tax as you move down the income scale.
You are correct. Hence it would be 100% up to the people to decide where they want to reside in such a system. If I am more productive and increase my income thru hard work, steadfastness and determination I will pay less of my income in taxes.
Sounds more dispiriting than incentive building.
IMO, this can only be true if you resent or covet the wealth of others.
Also, being from country with VAT, maybe you could answer the question I asked earlier as to whether there are additional taxes besides the sales tax?
No VAT here in America so I cannot answer you there.
 
40.png
thestickman:
:rotfl:What pro-left polling data did ya pull that notion from?
Well I tried to go to the “well” here and find you a FOX News poll, but they apparently gave up on the question back in 2003 with 47% to 40% indicating that the nation was on the wrong track.
Code:
  **     FOX News/Opinion Dynamics Poll**.      Nov. 18-19, 2003. N=900 registered voters      nationwide. MoE ± 3.

            [right].
[/right]
"Considering how things are today, would you say that the U.S. is generally headed in the right direction, or is it off on the wrong track?"
Code:
      **Right
Direction**          **Wrong
Track**          **Not
Sure**     
 
       
 
      %          %          %                
       
      11/18-19/03          40          47          13                
       
      6/3-4/03          54          33          13
inhttp://www.pollingreport.com/right2.htm

If you do a little research:rotfl:, you will find that the current data tends to run from the mid-fifties to the mid-sixties - the wrong track/wrong direction. Pick whatever right-wing pollsters you want but remember they tend to track a few points higher in the president’s direction.:yup:
 
40.png
Thekla:
Well I tried to go to the “well” here and find you a FOX News poll, but they apparently gave up on the question back in 2003 with 47% to 40% indicating that the nation was on the wrong track.
:rotfl:Which goes to show how useful polls are when they’re not done on election day by voters. As I recall, the last poll with voters Bush won:)
 
thestickman said:
:rotfl:Which goes to show how useful polls are when they’re not done on election day by voters. As I recall, the last poll with voters Bush won:)

I found what you were looking for. It’s Gallup’s (right-wing - per your preference) latest numbers.
Code:
  **     Gallup Poll**.      Jan. 9-12,      2006. N=1,003 adults nationwide. MoE ± 3.      [<GRAPHIC>](http://www.pollingreport.com/national.htm#Country)

        [right].
[/right]
"In general, are you satisfied or dissatisfied with the way things are going in the United States at this time?"
Code:
        [right]     .
[/right]
Code:
            **Satisfied**          **Dissatisfied**          **     Unsure**     
 
       
                     %               %               %     
 
       
   1/9-12/06

       36          61          3
Sniff! 61% dissatisfied. That is a stinky number.
 
Yes. Bush said at the very begining that there would be hard work and sacrifice. As that has turned out to be true and Bush wasn’t talking through his hat, I would expect his polls to go down somewhat as the aversion to hard work and sacrifice kicks in. Fortunately and to American’s credit, it is not decisive.

Scott
 
NotWorthy

No, I don’t think he should be impeached, but perhaps another election should be called as this is a serious matter that calls for a re-vote.

Andy
 
Ani Ibi:
Tax breaks to businesses create jobs so that the poor can get off welfare. Are you suggesting that the poor should not have the dignity of working? Are you suggesting that the poor be kept in place and serve only the role of bolstering the political profile of Democrat noblesse-oblige?
First, I’ve never heard of a private company that had a program to hire welfare recipients. The rich have little regard for the poor and disabled. Second, companies want bright and attractive people, not people in need. Fortune 500 companies prefer selfishness to dignity.
 
40.png
st.jerome:
The rich have little regard for the poor and disabled. Companies want bright and attractive people, not people in need. Fortune 500 companies prefer selfishness to dignity.
Evidence to support these declarations?
 
40.png
AndyF:
NotWorthy

No, I don’t think he should be impeached, but perhaps another election should be called as this is a serious matter that calls for a re-vote.

Andy
No such thing as a re-vote in the Constitution. Good luck on putting such an amendment in:)
 
40.png
st.jerome:
Enron, for one. Merril Lynch, Citibank, TWA…
Those are the names of companies. Not evidence of “The rich have little regard for the poor and disabled”, as you asserted. Nor is it evidence of “Fortune 500 companies prefer selfishness to dignity.”

I will grant those companies and other do want “Companies want bright and attractive people”–something I see no problem with–but this is no evidence the companies don’t want “people in need.” In fact, I’m 100% certain these companies are interested in hiring the best, and brightest folks to operate their businesses.

Which is not a bad, nor immoral thing. Nor is it evidence to validate your assertions.
 
Thekla said:
:rotfl:Next thing you’ll be bringing out Steve Forbes Jr. I don’t need to read the “flat-taxers;” I’m quite familiar with their campaign.

They can do math, but beyond that I find their ideas for tax policy to be immoral.

Based on the example you gave, you are not. The fair tax (which is not a flat tax) isn’t immoral at all. Give it a read sometime.

BTW…the people of Estonia believe Steve Forbes is a genius. They’ve used the flat tax for ten years to much success.
 
I have been away for a while and it is amazing where this thread has gone while I have been gone. It would seem to have strayed far off topic but it really has not as I will explain at the end of this post.

The class envy and jealousy displayed by the libs here is very telling. I will not bother to address all of the amazingly wrong things posted here since others are doing so very well but I will address a few:
Using the tax system and federal programs to further enrich the elite in this country while driving the nation into debt.
This is right out of the outdated leftist playbook that stopped working long ago.
Just listen to Warren Buffet and Bill Gates.
Who have shaltered the majority of their wealth from taxation using trusts and other vehicles.
Asking the lower income family to pay a tax that impacts their family at a rate 52 times greater than the high income family, and having that as the only tax, is many things, but fair is not one of them.
The problem with your fairness argument continues with the fact that the wealthy earner would benefit from the government at a rate 52 times higher than the low wage earner.
Creative mathmatics like this are silly. If people are taxed at the same rate they are taxed AT THE SAME RATE, period. The difference is not that one family is benefitting from any “government rate” but from their own efforts. Opportunity to succeed is what this country was built on and punishing that success in search of unachievable “equality” would destroy the economy and the nation. It is nothing more than communism through legislation. It has been tried by many nations and has failed miserably everywhere it has been tried.
The wealth I am able to accumulate is all thanks to the resources available thanks to society - e.g roads, access to education, etc. I made use of these resources…
And there is the difference. You “made use of these resources”. Should you be punished for doing so? Should you have the fruits of your labors taken away and given to others who did not bother to make use of those same resources in the false hope of making everyone “equal”?
To all those people convinced that they are “self-made” without the government’s help,…
And you fail to recognize that those people are “self-made” in that they chose to use the opportunities available to them and WORK to improve their lives. This is one of the most common fallicies of the leftist argument. They believe that all of the “rich” in this country just inherited their wealth as though they “won the lottery”. The fact is that the majority of “rich” people in this country did not inherit their money, they EARNED it.
What kind of an incentive is it to be poor, work hard, and then have the government take away your hard earned money at a rate 52 times greater than it takes away that of the man born to wealth?
The real question is what incentive is there to put forth effort and work if the fruits of your labor are going to be confiscated and given to those who choose not to put forth any effort in an attempt to make them “equal”?
Also a lot of the “offshore” stuff has been done ala Enron - American businesses.
Ah, the evil american businesses again. Just ignore the fact that all of the leftist politicians who want all of our money make use of the same loopholes to avoid taxes themselves.

I said I would explain why all of this tax talk is not off-topic and here is why. The libs on this thread have un-intentionally admitted why they hate Bush so much and think he should be impeached. Because he is too american. He does not support the communist economic policies that they do. He does not support punishing those who achieved success and at the same supported the economy. He does not support rewarding inaction or laziness. And please do not give me that nonsense about some people not having opportunites. I personally know people who grew up in the poorest areas of the city who, through education and hard work, achieved success and raised themselves out of poverty. One of them came from a one-parent family and that one parent was on welfare. They did not inherit their wealth. They WORKED. It can be done by any able-bodied person who wishes to do so and anyone who chooses not to do so does not deserve to receive the fruits of someone else’s labors.

That is the reson they hate Bush. He supports the American way of life and of doing things and they do not.
 
40.png
st.jerome:
First, I’ve never heard of a private company that had a program to hire welfare recipients.
You are suggesting that there has to be a private-company program before welfare recipients can find jobs. That is absurd and demonstrates your covert noblesse oblige and condescension toward welfare recipients.

If a welfare recipient wants to find a job why should he or she be stopped just to fit a socialist talking point over latte at Starbucks?

Welfare recipients have varying backgrounds, experiences, and skills. They will find jobs according to their qualifications. And God bless them for breaking free of the stereotypes which the Left promotes in their regard.
40.png
st.jerome:
The rich have little regard for the poor and disabled.
In the absence of evidence, this is quite astonishing bashing on the basis of nothing moer than membership in a group, in this case, the rich. Exactly how do you know that the rich have little regard for the poor and disabled?
40.png
st.jerome:
Second, companies want bright and attractive people, not people in need.
People in need are not bright and attractive? Since when?
40.png
st.jerome:
Fortune 500 companies prefer selfishness to dignity.
Wow, it really looks to me that you have it in for the rich. How many rich folks do you know that you can speak with such conviction? Or is knowledge not necessary for conviction?
 
40.png
AndyF:
No, I don’t think he should be impeached, but perhaps another election should be called as this is a serious matter that calls for a re-vote.
I’m Canadian. Can someone explain to me how a revote can be called without first impeaching the President? Can someone also explain to me the evidence necessary to impeach the President? Can someone then apply that hard data to the situation in which the current President finds himself? As opposed to the previous one?

Thank you. :tiphat:
 
First off, it is important to realize that Impeachment is a political process, not a criminal process. It is in place within the US Constitution as a vehicle to remove a president.

If the president is removed with this process the Vice President takes his place until the next scheduled election. There is no revote.

The authority for impeachment and the process is established in the US Constitution in Article 2:

*The President, Vice President and all civil officers of the United States, shall be removed from office on impeachment for, and conviction of, treason, bribery, or other high crimes and misdemeanors. *–U.S. Constitution, Article 2, Section 4

The Impeachment Process in a Nutshell
  1. The House Judiciary Committee deliberates over whether to initiate an impeachment inquiry.
  2. The Judiciary Committee adopts a resolution seeking authority from the entire House of Representatives to conduct an inquiry. Before voting, the House debates and considers the resolution. Approval requires a majority vote.
  3. The Judiciary Committee conducts an impeachment inquiry, possibly through public hearings. At the conclusion of the inquiry, articles of impeachment are prepared. They must be approved by a majority of the Committee.
  4. The House of Representatives considers and debates the articles of impeachment. A majority vote of the entire House is required to pass each article. Once an article is approved, the President is, technically speaking, “impeached” – that is subject to trial in the Senate.
  5. The Senate holds trial on the articles of impeachment approved by the House. The Senate sits as a jury while the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court presides over the trial.
  6. At the conclusion of the trial, the Senate votes on whether to remove the President from office. A two-thirds vote by the Members present in the Senate is required for removal.
  7. If the President is removed, the Vice-President assumes the Presidency under the chain of succession established by Amendment XXV.
President Clinton

President Clinton was accused of lying to a Grand Jury, a crime. With perjury and obstruction of justice having been found as approved charges by the House of Representatives, Senate Majority Leader Trent Lott announced that President Clinton’s impeachment trial would begin in the Senate on Thursday, January 7, 1999. Clinton was officially “impeached” – that is subject to trial in the Senate.
In making their case against the President, House prosecutors accused Clinton of “willful, premeditated, deliberate corruption of the nation’s system of justice through perjury and obstruction of justice.” Clinton’s lawyers countered: “The House Republicans’ case ends as it began, an unsubstantiated, circumstantial case that does not meet the constitutional standard to remove the President from office.”

On Article 1, the charge of perjury, 55 senators, including 10 Republicans and all 45 Democrats voted not guilty. On Article 3, obstruction of justice, the Senate split evenly, 50 for and 50 against the President. With the necessary two-thirds majority not having been achieved, the President was acquitted on both charges and served out the remainder of his term of office.

To this date, only two other Presidents have faced Articles of Impeachment–Andrew Johnson in 1868 and Richard Nixon in 1974. In Johnson’s case, the Senate’s vote fell short of the necessary two-thirds, while Nixon resigned before the House could vote on the Articles.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top