Why Spouse before Children?

  • Thread starter Thread starter CHCatholic
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Well. As long as my mommy loves me most, other mothers can love their spouses more than their children… 😉
 
One more thing. I’d like to address the pattern I see sometimes, in which people marry without really knowing their future spouse that much or really caring to know.
Where did you address this. I seem to disagree with this idea. I think people cohabitate specifically because they want to really know the person they’re marrying really well prior to marrying. This isn’t a good thing, but there is a point that there are things you can’t know prior to living together. You just can’t. You can know a person’s ideals and character, but that isn’t the same as knowing their bad habits that they may not even recognize themselves.

I think prior to marriage, a dating relationship is a very special friendship. The success of the marriage has far more to do with the couple’s character, their shared values and their mutual commitment to the insitution of marriage. Beyond that, there really isn’t much else.

I mean, my parents were engaged 3 months after they met, married a year after they met, engaged in premarital sex and were just out of highschool. They’ve been married happily for 32 years. Why? Is it because they’re soulmates? No. Is it because they dated prudently? Definitely not. All I can point to is their shared religion, shared values and their commitment to marriage. That’s it. They just took a greater risk by originally by leaving their brains at the door and following their brainless hearts while they were dating. I think that’s also why surprisng people in cultures with arranged marriages (so long as the culture’s aren’t degrading to women) actually have very low divorce rates and indeed have marriages where couples deeply love each other.

Anyway none of what you said seemed to actually address what you said it would nor did it seem to support the idea that idoltry or romantic love is a secular concept.
 
Three, and I don’t want to offend anyone who has ever lost a spouse or a child, but this is my perspective. If I lost a child it would be heartbreaking, devastating, and change who I am as a person forever. But, I would have my husband to lean on and be there for me, and he would have me. If I lost him I would in many ways be alone. My child could not be there for me or support me emotionally through that. I would be alone in my grief and suddenly have a family to raise on my own.
I think this situation depends on the age of the child. Teenagers who lose a parent often become very resilient. When there is more than one child, the family appears to do better. Likewise, parents who lose their only child are far worse off than parents who have multiple children and one of them dies.

On a side note, a child who loses their parents is an orphan, and a married person who loses their spouse is a widow, but there is no word for a parent who loses a child. This is because it should never happen, and our history and culture have never developed a concept of dealing with it. This is no coincidence.

I have a tattoo on my right arm with my ex-wife’s son’s name. He was 3 years old when he died. I don’t know which is worse, but what we went through was bad enough.
 
There are so, so many different scenarios that could be pulled out to highlight different ideas about who we should love more. I think it’s not like that at all.

I once asked my Mum how much she loved me. She answered “with all of my love”. I asked her how that was possible, because she had to love my brothers and my Dad and lots of other people too. She said she loved them with all of her love too. I asked how. She just said “Love is like that”.

I read a book called “A mother’s rule of life”. It helps mothers to view their role as a kind of vocation, and to prioritise. It has helped me immensely to be everything to everyone in my family. The book puts God first, yourself second, your spouse third, kids fourth and the household stuff last.

This does not mean you allocate more time to the higher priorities, but more that you make sure you have provided what is needed for them. God always comes first. Make sure that your day includes prayer and worship, learning etc, whatever you must do to fulfil your obligation to God.

Put yourself second - look after yourself. If you are completely worn out, you are useless to everyone else. Doesn’t mean spend heaps of time pampering yourself, but it does mean don’t neglect yourself.

Spouse comes third, above children. You married your spouse before any children came along and you made vows to love, honour, cherish etc. You need to stand by the vows you made. If children enter the equation, they will take up a lot of your time, but your spouse needs you as well, just as you need him. Not in terms of time, but in terms of priority. For example, you might not do anything for hubby while the kids are awake, but once they are asleep, you can make yourself available to him to listen to his stories about the day, or whatever he needs at that time. He might help you with the kids and then give you some of his time (putting your needs above the children’s, without necessarily taking away anything they need from him). You might only need to give hubby five minutes on a particular day, or he may not need anything from you at all on a day. It’s more about making sure a lower priority does not usurp the place of a higher one. If you find yourself completely focused on the kids and then when they are asleep you are so tired you can’t give anything to hubby, then you probably need to rethink things. Or if housework gets in the way of your responsibilities to the kids or hubby or God.

If nothing gets in the way of anything, then there’s no issue.

You could think of it in terms of a business, where mum and dad are the upper management and the kids are lower in the organisation. If the upper management are being put below the workers, then the whole business is in danger of going awry.

Obviously cases of neglect or abuse require different treatment, but in a normal relationship, I think this works.

If a situation arose where I was pushed to choose between child and spouse, that is, if my child wanted me to go against my husband, it would very much depend on the situation. I can disagree with my husband without neglecting him or failing to love him properly. I don’t believe it’s healthy for a child to see themselves as more important than their father, but their father could also be wrong about something.

If my husband told me to choose between him and the kids, I’d tell him to stop being so melodramatic.😛

To sum up: love is not measured in amount of time given, or in taking sides. Love is (in a nutshell) the desire to get a person to Heaven. So we desire our own salvation first and foremost and should never compromise that for anyone. Then we should strive to help our spouse to get to Heaven. Then our children. By helping our spouse to get to Heaven, it rubs off on the kids too, so they are more likely to remain faithful.
 
I understand you ought to always love your spouse before you children, just as you love God more than your spouse, but what are some practical reasons I can give as to why. Of course your children are a result of your love for your spouse, but that doesn’t really explain why it should remain. I just need some practical explanations as to why and I can’t really think of any.
Because your spouse is your life partner. You become ONE with your spouse in the sacrament of matrimony. Children will grow up, move away, get married and start families of their own. Your spouse is your life partner, your other half - the person you will grow old with.
 
Where did you address this. I seem to disagree with this idea. I think people cohabitate specifically because they want to really know the person they’re marrying really well prior to marrying. This isn’t a good thing, but there is a point that there are things you can’t know prior to living together. You just can’t. You can know a person’s ideals and character, but that isn’t the same as knowing their bad habits that they may not even recognize themselves.
First, let’s not get into cohabitation. I’m dead-opposed to premarital sex and far away from suggesting any illicit get-to-knows. What I’m talking about is that people marry without paying attention to the other’s personality. They stick with what’s attractive, including the very prospect of having a partner, and ignore the red flags. They possibly don’t even see them because they aren’t paying attention. Keeping a more or less level head instead of jumping head-on into water with a bluebird would have spared many a woman a lot of misery, including a number of my friends I’ve consoled in difficult times.

The inherent uncertainty you’re talking about, as well as the risk of error in any judgement regarding a person’s character, does not justify adopting the conclusion that we just don’t know the other person so we shouldn’t be trying. We should actually be putting a lot of conscious effort into judicious discernment.
I think prior to marriage, a dating relationship is a very special friendship. The success of the marriage has far more to do with the couple’s character, their shared values and their mutual commitment to the insitution of marriage. Beyond that, there really isn’t much else.
And how are you going to know about the shared values and the mutual commitment to the institution of marriage? You surely can’t take people’s word on that, not even if they pass polygraph (that they believe they are this way doesn’t mean they really are).
I mean, my parents were engaged 3 months after they met, married a year after they met, engaged in premarital sex and were just out of highschool. They’ve been married happily for 32 years. Why? Is it because they’re soulmates? No. Is it because they dated prudently? Definitely not. All I can point to is their shared religion, shared values and their commitment to marriage. That’s it. They just took a greater risk by originally by leaving their brains at the door and following their brainless hearts while they were dating. I think that’s also why surprisng people in cultures with arranged marriages (so long as the culture’s aren’t degrading to women) actually have very low divorce rates and indeed have marriages where couples deeply love each other.
In cultures with arranged marriages, divorce is so stigmatised that people won’t go there. It could be very different if they had the option. As for your parents’ example, everybody was brought up that way, hence the odds were better. In this day and age, you just can’t marry someone you’ve only just met, been attracted to and had a slip of judgement with.
Anyway none of what you said seemed to actually address what you said it would nor did it seem to support the idea that idoltry or romantic love is a secular concept.
I’m sorry but I don’t seem to be able to deduct your logic. Perhaps try to rearrange your points and rephrase them, I will be able to answer then.

Wanting warmth and affection is not idolatry (look into the Song of Songs if you have any doubts). What is secular is the idea that “love” (a cover for sensual attraction) is an excuse for not following moral principles. And that is wrong. Idolatry is worshipping a creature before the Creator. Certainly marrying out of love does not even begin to go there and you can’t honestly make that point with any credibility. Finally, my point was that people were marrying without good discernment, leading to trouble in their marriages (and yes, if both of them were sufficiently committed to the indissolubility of marriage, this would lead to difficulties but not to divorce). If they aren’t attracted to their spouse, don’t feel a connection, don’t feel the need for companionship, then no wonder they prefer to invest themselves wholly in the children, ignoring the spouse. And some people want just that because they don’t even imagine that marriage can be better than continually scoffing at each other and only finding solace in children.
 
First, let’s not get into cohabitation. I’m dead-opposed to premarital sex and far away from suggesting any illicit get-to-knows. What I’m talking about is that people marry without paying attention to the other’s personality.
Who does that anymore? Do you realize that the average age for a woman to get married today is when she’s nearly 27 years old and that the average age for a man is 29? Moreover, the marriage rate is at an all time low. Couples are trying to get to know each other. They’re just trying to get to know each other TOO MUCH and for TOO LONG.
The inherent uncertainty you’re talking about, as well as the risk of error in any judgement regarding a person’s character, does not justify adopting the conclusion that we just don’t know the other person so we shouldn’t be trying. We should actually be putting a lot of conscious effort into judicious discernment.
Where on earth did you get the impression that that was my conclusion? My point is simply that there is a limit. Getting married IS a leap of faith. Dating is about looking before you leap, but there is no special way of dating that will guarentee that your marriage will be easy.
And how are you going to know about the shared values and the mutual commitment to the institution of marriage? You surely can’t take people’s word on that, not even if they pass polygraph (that they believe they are this way doesn’t mean they really are).
Am I advocating we just fill out online profiles and marry someone merely because we like what they said on their online profile? Uh NO!!!
In cultures with arranged marriages, divorce is so stigmatised that people won’t go there. It could be very different if they had the option.
My point was not that they have lower divorce rates, but that actually surprising the predictor in marital happiness has very little to do with whether or not the marriage was arranged or whether the couple fell in love first. They’re not all a bunch of people utterly miserable because their parents’ forced them into marriages and now they can’t get divorced. First off, there are a lot of cultural expectations of men and women’s roles. This can be confining but it can also reduce points of contension between a couple. They know what is expected of them and grew up disciplined to fulfill their marital duties. Meanwhile their parents’ are not emotionally biased. They’re not wearing rose colored glasses. As such turning prospects away is not an issue.

Of course the arranged marriage system has its own flaws, too. Money can be overemphasized. Cultures can be very demeaning to women (marrying girls when they’re 13 and what not). But not all cultures with arranged marriages are like that. The value in understanding that arranged marriages can indeed be healthy and loving is in realizing that the closeness and intimacy a couple can feel in marriage is simply the result of loving each other well. The action comes first and then the bond. Its a sincere love, but is not romantic love. However it is the same type of love that all married couples must learn to love each other with if they are to have a healthy marriage.
As for your parents’ example, everybody was brought up that way, hence the odds were better.
My parents were not raised that way! My parents were far more of the generation that was stupidly rushing into things. My grandparents advised them to date longer and to wait till they were older. The priest even advised them to wait. They were straight out told that they were niave, and making the wrong decision.
In this day and age, you just can’t marry someone you’ve only just met, been attracted to and had a slip of judgement with.
In this day and age? As if there is something special about one generation over another. I’m not advocating marrying someone you just met. Dating is definitely looking before you leap, but today test and obsess and wait and wait and wait and delay and delay and delay. I do think there is a point where discerning has to end. I’d say a bigger problem is that people aren’t discerning. Dating becomes a means to an end. It becomes a way to gain the emotional benefits and joys of marriage (perhaps without overtly sinning) without bolting the escape door shut with marriage. Its basically a way to get around the fact that marriage is for life. “Oh well hey I’m not married so breaking up and moving on isn’t wrong. I’m free.”
If they aren’t attracted to their spouse, don’t feel a connection, don’t feel the need for companionship, then no wonder they prefer to invest themselves wholly in the children, ignoring the spouse. And some people want just that because they don’t even imagine that marriage can be better than continually scoffing at each other and only finding solace in children.
If they are ignoring their spouse, they are not loving their children and they are not fulfilling their marital vows. Marriage is not a lifelong commitment to be roommates with benefits who raise children together.

You know maybe the reason we disagreed with the test because the idea of being tempted to abandon your spouse and find solace in your children sounds completely foriegn to me. I mean, I know a woman at my former place of employment who constantly went on and on about how great her husband was, and then was non-stop complaining about her children and telling everyone “get married but don’t have children. It was the worst decision in my life to have children.”

But again this just seems to indicate that the link between loving children and loving your spouse is so connected its practically the same thing. That said, I’m sure we choose that answer because children are far needier than adults.
 
Everyone that I know loves their children more than their spouses.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top