Why young couples aren't getting married

  • Thread starter Thread starter TheTrueCentrist
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
If concern over divorce is a reason as why some couples are not getting married, they should be concerned about the studies which show that if they do decide to get married cohabiting couples have higher divorce rates than those who did not cohabitate before marriage.
 
I lived with my wife for five years before we got married. There were various reasons:

-We spent pretty much every evening together; we figured moving it together made sense. We were not quite ready to commit to marriage at that point though.

-It made financial sense. If we lived together we could split the rent, utility bills, groceries, etc. It was much more affordable than each having our own place.

-We had no moral objections to it. Neither of us are religious which I imagine is the case with many other young couples these days.

After living together for a number of years we learned a lot about eachother and decided that we wanted to dedicate our lives to eachother. Contrary to what some are saying, before we were married I never felt that I had any lack of commitment to her. I made more money than she did so I paid far more than half of the bills, and essentially treated her like my wife. I always considered the relationship permanent. Not being religious we didn’t feel we necessarily needed a government stamp on our relationship to make it “official”. I would imagine our situation is not that different from many others.

I also know many Catholic couples who lived together before marriage. The priest who married some friends of ours even told the women to use her parents address when filling out forms so that it wasn’t obvious.
So why did you get married?
 
I also know many Catholic couples who lived together before marriage. The priest who married some friends of ours even told the women to use her parents address when filling out forms so that it wasn’t obvious.
I’ll admit that I’m Catholic and lived with my husband for two years before we married. Why? Because of what Rence said:
but divorce is even more expensive. Not only that, I’ve seen some pretty ugly breakups. It’s much easier to exit when you’re not married.
I’d not been married before, but my husband had. And we’re still, 10 years after the divorce decree was signed, paying his attorney so he can keep joint custody of his daughters. And that’s just the monetary pain. The psychological fallout is another hideous ball of wax. Without writing a book about his divorce and its fallout, I’ll just say that his attorney - with 25 years of family law experience - admits that my husband’s is the second worst divorce she’s ever handled.

I’m not saying that living together unmarried was in any way moral. In an ideal world we’d both been first timers with no children, unburdened by past mistakes. But our lives were what they were and we, especially him, wanted to be absolutely certain before marriage that there wasn’t some glaring personal defect that would prevent a sane lifetime commitment.

For us living together wasn’t about being able to have unfettered sex or the option of just picking up and moving on when things got rough. We were 100% committed to each other, his daughters, and our family. We attended Mass weekly without receiving Communion, and I went to regular Confession. After much penance, prayer, reflection, and gentle coaxing by our priest, we realized t hat we didn’t have any moral choice but to enter into the Sacrament of Marriage, so we did.

When we met with our priest the first time to start the marriage ball rolling, he knew we were living together. There were some politely awkward moments, and we danced around the issue with both him and the wonderful couple who guided us through our pre-marital sessions, Evenings of the Engaged. When the topic of cohabitation came up in EE, the husband revealed that he had a daughter from a previous, live-in relationship. And the other engaged couple who shared our sessions was pregnant. But there we were, sinners all, just trying to do the right thing and be the best Catholic we could be.
 
I’ll admit that I’m Catholic and lived with my husband for two years before we married. Why? Because of what Rence said:

I’d not been married before, but my husband had. And we’re still, 10 years after the divorce decree was signed, paying his attorney so he can keep joint custody of his daughters. And that’s just the monetary pain. The psychological fallout is another hideous ball of wax. Without writing a book about his divorce and its fallout, I’ll just say that his attorney - with 25 years of family law experience - admits that my husband’s is the second worst divorce she’s ever handled.

I’m not saying that living together unmarried was in any way moral. In an ideal world we’d both been first timers with no children, unburdened by past mistakes. But our lives were what they were and we, especially him, wanted to be absolutely certain before marriage that there wasn’t some glaring personal defect that would prevent a sane lifetime commitment.

For us living together wasn’t about being able to have unfettered sex or the option of just picking up and moving on when things got rough. We were 100% committed to each other, his daughters, and our family. We attended Mass weekly without receiving Communion, and I went to regular Confession. After much penance, prayer, reflection, and gentle coaxing by our priest, we realized that we didn’t have any moral choice but to enter into the Sacrament of Marriage, so we did.

When we met with our priest the first time to start the marriage ball rolling, he knew we were living together. There were some politely awkward moments, and we danced around the issue with both him and the wonderful couple who guided us through our pre-marital sessions, Evenings of the Engaged. When the topic of cohabitation came up in EE, the husband revealed that he had a daughter from a previous, live-in relationship. And the other engaged couple who shared our sessions was pregnant. But there we were, sinners all, just trying to do the right thing and be the best Catholic we could be.
 
I would add one more simple rule: Learn to keep your word and do it while you are young. Whether or not you keep your word is the number one factor in your credit rating, and the lifetime difference between good credit and bad credit is around $200,000. That alone would be the difference between a difficult retirement and more comfortable retirement.

It also flies in the face of today’s “try it before your buy it” culture that couples who cohabit before marriage have a higher divorce rate than those who do not. If you have ever played sports your coach has told you that you play the way you practice. If you live together without a commitment, you learn to live without commitment. Divorce is an easy option for those who never had a solid commitment in the first place.
Good advice, Trader. 👍🙂
 
I’ll admit that I’m Catholic and lived with my husband for two years before we married. Why? Because of what Rence said:

I’d not been married before, but my husband had. And we’re still, 10 years after the divorce decree was signed, paying his attorney so he can keep joint custody of his daughters. And that’s just the monetary pain. The psychological fallout is another hideous ball of wax. Without writing a book about his divorce and its fallout, I’ll just say that his attorney - with 25 years of family law experience - admits that my husband’s is the second worst divorce she’s ever handled.
I don’t think I’ll ever understand how people can be so ugly to each other: married people, divorcing people, long since divorced people. It weighs heavy on my mind and heart.

I hope and pray that your hubby’s ex finds another hobby and gives you and him some peace.
 
I’ll admit that I’m Catholic and lived with my husband for two years before we married. Why? Because of what Rence said:

I’d not been married before, but my husband had. And we’re still, 10 years after the divorce decree was signed, paying his attorney so he can keep joint custody of his daughters. And that’s just the monetary pain. The psychological fallout is another hideous ball of wax. Without writing a book about his divorce and its fallout, I’ll just say that his attorney - with 25 years of family law experience - admits that my husband’s is the second worst divorce she’s ever handled.

I’m not saying that living together unmarried was in any way moral. In an ideal world we’d both been first timers with no children, unburdened by past mistakes. But our lives were what they were and we, especially him, wanted to be absolutely certain before marriage that there wasn’t some glaring personal defect that would prevent a sane lifetime commitment.
However, living together unmarried is a big financial risk as well. People don’t understand that marriage is actually protection (pr at least was before no fault divorce). If you move into your boy/girl friend’s house and you go through a bad break up, guess what, you are not getting your stuff back, unless you can prove it is yours, with a big ol’ expensive fight in court. If you are married the property is marital property and thus subject to division.

If you have kids while living with your girl friend and go through a bad break up, guess what men, you might have to sue just to get a paternity ruling (if your names not on the birth cert). Not to mention getting visitation or any sort of custody. Ladies you will have to sue for child support.

If your name isn’t on the lease or title, or you don’t have a land lord-tenant relationship, you could find yourself homeless with little or no legal recourse.
In the same vein, if your partner dies, you could also be very quickly homeless.

I guess my point is, that with marriage comes some perks and protections. These are generally ones you could legally set up without being married, but I am guessing most people don’t. Thus one is still taking a huge financial risk by living with a “partner” without the benefits of the marriage protection or even the marriage commitment.

The only real financial benefit is that most cohabitating couples keep their bank accounts and incomes separate. Thus the partner can’t deplete the accounts or ruin the credit if the other. (unless they steal their identities).
 
I’ll admit that I’m Catholic and lived with my husband for two years before we married. Why? Because of what Rence said:

I’d not been married before, but my husband had. And we’re still, 10 years after the divorce decree was signed, paying his attorney so he can keep joint custody of his daughters. And that’s just the monetary pain. The psychological fallout is another hideous ball of wax. Without writing a book about his divorce and its fallout, I’ll just say that his attorney - with 25 years of family law experience - admits that my husband’s is the second worst divorce she’s ever handled.

I’m not saying that living together unmarried was in any way moral. In an ideal world we’d both been first timers with no children, unburdened by past mistakes. But our lives were what they were and we, especially him, wanted to be absolutely certain before marriage that there wasn’t some glaring personal defect that would prevent a sane lifetime commitment.

For us living together wasn’t about being able to have unfettered sex or the option of just picking up and moving on when things got rough. We were 100% committed to each other, his daughters, and our family. We attended Mass weekly without receiving Communion, and I went to regular Confession. After much penance, prayer, reflection, and gentle coaxing by our priest, we realized t hat we didn’t have any moral choice but to enter into the Sacrament of Marriage, so we did.

When we met with our priest the first time to start the marriage ball rolling, he knew we were living together. There were some politely awkward moments, and we danced around the issue with both him and the wonderful couple who guided us through our pre-marital sessions, Evenings of the Engaged. When the topic of cohabitation came up in EE, the husband revealed that he had a daughter from a previous, live-in relationship. And the other engaged couple who shared our sessions was pregnant. But there we were, sinners all, just trying to do the right thing and be the best Catholic we could be.
Do you think any of that would have been easier had he lived with and had children with the woman without being married?
 
However, living together unmarried is a big financial risk as well.
You’re right Jilly4ski, there are risks with both. But it’s easier to make a clean break without being legally tied to someone.

If you move into your boy/friend’s house and there is abuse in the relationship, you can gather your things and leave. You can do this when you’re married too, but your hubby can try to hold you back legally with threats of taking you to court for abandonment (like my dad threatened my mom every time she tried to leave). Even with everything deemed as marital property, you have to go through a whole lot to get it back, unless it was yours before you married, and if you took it with you when you left.

When my mom was married to my dad, he used to threaten that if she left or filed for divorce, he would take us kids out of the country where she would never see us again, and she had reason to believe him – he held her against her will in a foreign country on their honeymoon. So being married can offer little help in those cases. But not being married, and traveling abroad protects one from being held against their will by their spouse due to dual-citizenship.

Married or cohabiting, one has to fight for custody and visitation rights.
If your name isn’t on the lease or title, or you don’t have a land lord-tenant relationship, you could find yourself homeless with little or no legal recourse.
In the same vein, if your partner dies, you could also be very quickly homeless.
On the flipside, it can seem like forever to get rid of someone you want gone if there are homestead laws that protect them, married or not. I made sure before I moved to my current state that there are no homestead laws that would hinder me from evicting someone I didn’t want living on the same property as myself.
I guess my point is, that with marriage comes some perks and protections. These are generally ones you could legally set up without being married, but I am guessing most people don’t. Thus one is still taking a huge financial risk by living with a “partner” without the benefits of the marriage protection or even the marriage commitment.
You’re right, marriage comes with perks and protections, but those perks and protections that were supposed to protect both parties sometimes becomes a burden on an innocent party. Let’s face it, when someone wants to make your life miserable, they’ll try and they’ll work the system too.
The only real financial benefit is that most cohabitating couples keep their bank accounts and incomes separate. Thus the partner can’t deplete the accounts or ruin the credit if the other. (unless they steal their identities).
I learned real young to put a checking account and a savings account in a trust that will never become marital property. My home is also in a trust.

When my mom got incapacitated with illness, her husband depleted the accounts and cancelled the credit cards on the day she returned from the hospital, thinking that he was leaving her penniless. I think he lost his mind, but that’s another story that proves ‘anything can happen’. Anyway, we had to go to court to get it straightened out, but in a nutshell, she had enough money to get by but it took over a year to get it done. Perhaps if she was in dire straights financially, the courts wouldn’t have taken so long. But believe me, taking care of one’s very sick mom and bringing her back to health, while battling her hubby was a nightmare…and a very big eye-opener.

Anything can happen, and truthfully despite feeling safer by co-habitating instead of legally married, breakups are difficult either way. I just totally understand the rationale of not wanting to be married.
 
Because our lives more or less became one and we want the same things out of life. We decided we wanted to formally declare it as a lifelong commitment.
But you said before you were married you never felt you had any lack of committment to her.
 
But you said before you were married you never felt you had any lack of committment to her.
You’re right, I did feel that way. That doesn’t mean that I didn’t want to get married someday. I didn’t have any lack of commitment to her, but I still wanted to see how well we worked while living together for a long period of time. Over those five years we experienced some ups and downs and I think we both learned a lot.
 
Do you think any of that would have been easier had he lived with and had children with the woman without being married?
Hi Sam,

In my husband’s case, it would have been financially beneficial for him to have never been married to his ex-wife. Absolutely, and for many reasons. For example, while they legally separated and after he’d moved out of their house, his ex-wife sold off tens of thousands of dollars worth of community property (jewelery, furniture, tools, a car, etc.), and he never saw a dime of the proceeds and didn’t have much legal recourse. Had they not been married and she sold things that he’d purchased, paid for with his own money, she’d have been breaking the law in our state.

I don’t know all the details because I wasn’t there, but his parents went through it all with him and sank more than 150K of their retirement in attorney fees (2 different attorneys, as a matter of fact: one in our jurisdiction and the other in the county she’s living in now). And these aren’t rich people; it wiped out a goodly chunk of their retirement. We’re paying them back as much and as fast as we can, and ther are days I wonder if we’ll ever get there.

Anyway, knowing what I know from his experience I absolutely understand the ‘once bitten, twice’ mindset when it comes to financially tying youself to another person in our society.

Luna
 
Hi Sam,

In my husband’s case, it would have been financially beneficial for him to have never been married to his ex-wife. Absolutely, and for many reasons. For example, while they legally separated and after he’d moved out of their house, his ex-wife sold off tens of thousands of dollars worth of community property (jewelery, furniture, tools, a car, etc.), and he never saw a dime of the proceeds and didn’t have much legal recourse. Had they not been married and she sold things that he’d purchased, paid for with his own money, she’d have been breaking the law in our state.

I don’t know all the details because I wasn’t there, but if you want whole story, you can talk with his mother and father about it. They went through it all with him and sank more than 50K of their retirement in attorney fees defending their son against her in the divorce. A decade later they’re still incredibly bitter about it; I’ve politely told them that I can’t hear about it anymore, so their looking for someone to dish the dirt with. 🙂
It is sad, but if the separated without being married and left the house without taking all of his stuff, she could have done the same and he still would not have any legal recourse.(he would have to prove that he had purchased with his own money with recipes or witnesses, very difficult and very expensive to do, especially if she burned all his papers). It could have been even more difficult and expensive to gain even partial custody of the kids had they not been married.
 
It is sad, but if the separated without being married and left the house without taking all of his stuff, she could have done the same and he still would not have any legal recourse.(he would have to prove that he had purchased with his own money with recipes or witnesses, very difficult and very expensive to do, especially if she burned all his papers). It could have been even more difficult and expensive to gain even partial custody of the kids had they not been married.
Without spilling his whole sorrdid divorce mess out on the Internet, simply understand that he believes, his attorneys believe, and therefore I believe that he have much more property and way more money than he does now if he’d lived with his ex rather than married her, kids or no.
 
You’re right, I did feel that way. That doesn’t mean that I didn’t want to get married someday. ** I didn’t have any lack of commitment to her, but I still wanted to see how well we worked while living together for a long period of time**. Over those five years we experienced some ups and downs and I think we both learned a lot.
Um…if you “wanted to see how well you worked while living together for a long period of time” before committing to marriage, then you had a “lack of commitment.” 😃
 
Um…if you “wanted to see how well you worked while living together for a long period of time” before committing to marriage, then you had a “lack of commitment.” 😃
Just like taking a test drive isn’t a commitment to buy the car.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top