Why?

[STT]

Meaningless option = wrong…Meaningful option = right.

Because there is only one right option then we are not free.

(Or, it is made easy for us to be free! ).

Yes, when there is only one option.

Meaningful option = right…Less meaningful but still meaningful option = less right but still right.

Yes.

Because both are meaningful options just at various levels of meaning then we have a choice to be free.

Yes.

Don’t be concerned. This last few paragraphs is more beneficial as it is clearer to see what you mean.

Yes.

You are applying ‘meaning’ to define an objective good?

Yes. You are brilliant.

Not to worry. I have a better idea now where you are with your last few answers.

Yes.

I was thinking that you were saying that you only have freedom if you have wrong choices that are objectively evil. But I don’t think this is what you are saying now…

You are not saying that evil helps to define freedom.

You are saying that freedom comes with the ability to choose good choices?

Correct?

No, freedom comes with the ability to choose good and evil.

Not necessarily. Maybe before.

No, except the previous comment.

Sorry for late reply to your PM.

No problem. Be cool.

 

[friardchips]

Yes, when there is only one option.

Yes.

Yes.

Yes.

Yes. You are brilliant.

No, just team work!

Yes.

No, freedom comes with the ability to choose good and evil.

Ah, it was going so well. On what level of consciousness do you think evil needs to exist in order for us to be free?

No, except the previous comment.

No problem. Be cool.

Thanks!

When we have reached a sensible conclusion on the definition of freedom then then we could move immediately onto tackling the thread-subject.

 

[STT]

Ah, it was going so well. On what level of consciousness do you think evil needs to exist in order for us to be free?

Evil might exist depending on situation. We are free regardless whether evil exist or not.

When we have reached a sensible conclusion on the definition of freedom then then we could move immediately onto tackling the thread-subject.

Good.

 

[friardchips]

"friardchips:

You are saying that freedom comes with the ability to choose good choices?

STT:

No, freedom comes with the ability to choose good and evil.

Evil might exist depending on situation. We are free regardless whether evil exist or not.

While it might look as if your last two statements are contradictory, in fact, they are not, because while you are saying that freedom comes with the human ability to choose between good and evil it is the case that evil does not have to be realised because it can exist just as a possibility rather than a reality? Correct?

 

[STT]

While it might look as if your last two statements are contradictory, in fact, they are not, because while you are saying that freedom comes with the human ability to choose between good and evil it is the case that evil does not have to be realised because it can exist just as a possibility rather than a reality? Correct?

Yes.