These may be your opinions, however, the Church does not use the term “tolerated”. Cremation is permitted, and is not discouraged.
scborromeo.org/ccc/para/2301.htm
**2301 **Autopsies can be morally permitted for legal inquests or scientific research. The free gift of organs after death is legitimate and can be meritorious.
The Church permits cremation, provided that it does not demonstrate a denial of faith in the resurrection of the body.
Please try to “tolerate” my use of my own words in giving some historical connectivity and continuity to the topic at hand. It’s a nuanced topic and my choice of words we deliberate to give some insight into tenor of the Church’s RECENT change in PERMITTING cremation – while still holding to burial as a PREFERRED means to reverence the dead. A blind cut and paste of the Catholic Catechism that is “dead” to the changing history of the matter while technically correct is rather legalistic as well as parochial to that history. If you want a more legalistic tone then go to cannon law and there you will see that what I am saying is correct - traditional burial is preferred and cremation is permitted.
I suspect you have your own emotional reasons for advocating your personal idea that that cremation is equally accepted to to our ancient Catholic burial traditions. But the truth is it is not - at least among the older clergy who were ordained before Vatican II. The Church STILL has a preference for Catholic burial over cremation even though it is not stated in the Catechism. The Catechism is also new since Trent and has never been intended to be a repository of tradition. It is only recently that The Church has broken with its 2,000 years of funeral tradition to change its perspective on cremation. Newer still is the Church’s laxing of ecclesial restrictions to even permit the cremated remains to be brought into The Church during the funeral mass.
From early Christian days cremation was viewed as a **pagan practice **and a denial of the doctrine of the Resurrection. That’s why **cremation was expressly forbidden **by the Catholic Church until recent years.
In 1963, an Instruction from the Holy Office (now the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith) lifted the ban on cremation by **allowing it in certain circumstances **provided that the reasons for choosing cremation were not contrary to Christian belief. However,
burial of the body was clearly to be preferred. No allowance was made for any prayer or ritual to be used with the cremated remains. In other words, all services were to be in the presence of the body of the deceased, with cremation allowed only afterwards.
The Church performed its Rite of Committal at the grave site. The remains were NOT permitted in the funeral mass before the blessed sacrament. The Catholic Church has always had the utmost respect and reverence for the human body and the prayers of the funeral liturgy reflect this.
In the revised funeral rites of 1969, Ordo Exsequiarum, mandated by Vatican II, a further step was taken to allow for the Committal Rite to take place at the crematorium or grave site: “Funeral rites are to be granted to those who have chosen cremation, unless there is evidence that their choice was dictated by anti-Christian motives…The funeral is to be celebrated…in a way that clearly expresses the Church’s preference for burying the dead…that forestalls any danger of scandalizing or shocking the faithful” (#15). The presumption was that the funeral Mass would be celebrated in the presence of the body with cremation held off until later.
In the 1983 revision of the Code of Canon Law,
the traditional practice was reinforced. “
The Church earnestly recommends that the pious custom of burying the bodies of the dead be observed; it does not, however, forbid cremation unless it has been chosen for reasons which are contrary to Christian teaching” (Canon 1176).
The further revised funeral rites, Order of Christian Funerals, in use since 1989, maintain this tradition of preference for burial of the body: “Since in Baptism the body was marked with the seal of the Trinity and became the temple of the Holy Spirit, Christians respect and honor the bodies of the dead and the places where they rest…” (#19).
**In the United States up until 1997, the Order of Christian Funerals clearly indicated that if cremation had been chosen, cremated remains were not to be brought into church for the funeral Mass. Even now this is permitted only in cases where special circumstances warrant it and the bishop approves. The reasoning is that the funeral rites are intended to honor the body of the deceased. **
More here:
Cremation:
New Options for Catholics
James