Will there be material objects in heaven?

  • Thread starter Thread starter bibleguy180
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
B

bibleguy180

Guest
Someone told me there will be. Which I suppose makes sense, since Mary, Jesus, Enoch, and Elijah still have their bodies. Right? Or am I wrong? Is there an official Church teaching?
 
We probably wouldn’t call them “material objects”. The bodies which have been assumed into heaven have been transformed – changed by grace.
 
My understanding is that your body will be reunited with your soul and you will have a glorified body. One much better than you can imagine. Since we have bodies we will be able to do things like we do today.

We should be able to eat if we desire, taste a good wine or even go horseback riding if you like. The boundries of Heaven are without limit.

Above all you will be able to see God and praise Him in person. You will be able to walk with the Communion of Saints and know all about them and talk with them.

I really believe we cannot truly comprehend what Jesus has prepared for those worth of Heaven. I think that is why so many of us are doing our best to get there. I know God loves us and wants us to spend eternity with Him.
 
The catechism is silent on this. Musing on the subject, I recall Jesus’ words “I have food of which you do not know” (John 4:32). I call to mind that he passed through locked doors after the resurrection (John 20:19, 20:26). I know that He walked atop water (John 6:19), and was not recognizable in His glorified body (John 20:15-16, Luke 24:15-16) until He chose to reveal Himself. He was “carried” up to heaven (Acts 1:9). Thus, our glorified bodies will likely be immune to the worldly laws of physics and thermodynamics. We may be nourished eternally, in body as well as in spirit. Death entered the world through Adam’s sin. Once in heaven, we are in a perfect state and will not be subject to the limitations of this mortal body. We will not age, nor will we have an age, as we will exist outside of time, as God does. The cells of our bodies will no longer die and need replacement, indicating that food may be unnecessary. No cellular replacement means no bathroom breaks, since our bodies will produce no waste. We likely will not require sleep, since that has a purely natural function. There will be no “getting up on the wrong side of the bed” if one needs no sleep. No bad days, not even bad hair days. Once in the supernatural, all is changed.
 
JDaniel said:
Maybe, like a shirt?

😊

jd
Click to expand...
Oh, I see. You mean an object that is established and perceived by God and perceived by men. But what is meant by adding the word “material”?

(I’m playing Berkeley, of course. It’s great fun.) 😃
 
Technically, the definition of “material” is “having parts”. Simple substances which are not divisible are immaterial. Anything which is divisible is material. Anyway…

Yes, there will be material objects in Heaven. The only material objects that we know of for certain will be the resurrected bodies (and those already present). The Church is very clear that our resurrected bodies will be real material bodies (in fact, the exact same bodies we had while on earth).
 
Katholish said:
Technically, the definition of “material” is “having parts”. Simple substances which are not divisible are immaterial. Anything which is divisible is material.
Click to expand...
See, now this is interesting (and it’s why I asked the question). I’ve rarely heard a discrete definition of “material”, only intuitive ones. But intuitive definitions all fall prey to epistemological traps, like those of Berkeley.

Having parts, eh? It follows that two immaterial things, combined, makes a material thing? That is a strange conclusion. (Sounds like Leibniz, in fact).

I do like that your definition has clear boundaries, though.
The Church is very clear that our resurrected bodies will be real material bodies (in fact, the exact same bodies we had while on earth).
Click to expand...
Yes, but what qualifies them as the “exact same”? Not the atoms, of course. The arrangement of atoms? At what moment in time? The DNA? But this changes too. It seems that we’re looking for the “form” of the body here, but then again the form of the body would be a simple: the soul. Ah, perplexity! 🙂
 
PAboy57 said:
We should be able to eat if we desire, taste a good wine or even go horseback riding if you like. The boundries of Heaven are without limit.
.
Click to expand...
Are you sure about this? So I’ll be able to sip merlot and get 18 holes in on pebble beach before I worship God in person?

I thought the beatific vision consistent “solely” of the perpetual worship and vision of God in a state of bliss. Is this incorrect?
 
Prodigal_Son
Having parts, eh? It follows that two immaterial things, combined, makes a material thing? That is a strange conclusion. (Sounds like Leibniz, in fact).
Click to expand...
If I recall correctly, the definition of matter as “having parts” was first Aristotle’s, or at least I think that is were I picked it up. I don’t think that it does follow that two immaterial things could be combined into a material thing, for anything that is capable of being substantially unitied in the manner we are talking of, would also be capable of being divided. This definition is certainly not meant to resemble structure of monads in any sense (sorry Leibniz)!
Yes, but what qualifies them as the “exact same”? Not the atoms, of course. The arrangement of atoms? At what moment in time? The DNA? But this changes too. It seems that we’re looking for the “form” of the body here, but then again the form of the body would be a simple: the soul. Ah, perplexity!
Click to expand...
That is, of course, a perfectly valid question and one which the Church has not yet defined.
 
Yes, our bodies will be reunited with us in Heaven, they will be the same bodies we had here on earth but, glorified. Meaning we will, in Heaven, possess the life, body included, that we were always meant to have. There will be no horseback riding, only praising God, LOL! But, the book of revelation also shows how the angels had trumpets, seals, an incense thing, and also an altar in front of God.

;)Oh, and Jesus said that he had a house and it has many rooms, lol, so, we might be staying in a sweet mansion for all eternity, chilling in the pool with the Holy Ghost while Jesus grills burgers and the Father gets a nice tan!😉 I want to live across the hall from JP2 and Mother Angelica:thumbsup: LOL
 
UponTheAltar said:
Yes, our bodies will be reunited with us in Heaven, they will be the same bodies we had here on earth but, glorified. Meaning we will, in Heaven, possess the life, body included, that we were always meant to have. There will be no horseback riding, only praising God, LOL! But, the book of revelation also shows how the angels had trumpets, seals, an incense thing, and also an altar in front of God.

;)Oh, and Jesus said that he had a house and it has many rooms, lol, so, we might be staying in a sweet mansion for all eternity, chilling in the pool with the Holy Ghost while Jesus grills burgers and the Father gets a nice tan!😉 I want to live across the hall from JP2 and Mother Angelica:thumbsup: LOL
Click to expand...
Your wrong. Jesus is a vegetarian, and you know it! 😃
 
Katholish said:
If I recall correctly, the definition of matter as “having parts” was first Aristotle’s, or at least I think that is were I picked it up. I don’t think that it does follow that two immaterial things could be combined into a material thing, for anything that is capable of being substantially unitied in the manner we are talking of, would also be capable of being divided.
Click to expand...
Does this mean that the Aristotelian is committed to the claim that matter is infinitely divisible?
 
bibleguy180 said:
Someone told me there will be. Which I suppose makes sense, since Mary, Jesus, Enoch, and Elijah still have their bodies. Right? Or am I wrong? Is there an official Church teaching?
Click to expand...
Even in this life material objects exist primarily in our mind! We infer that they exist from our perceptions but we have direct knowledge only of our inner experiences. All the most important aspects of existence are intangible: truth, goodness, freedom, justice, beauty and love. Material objects are important but less important than spiritual realities. The Resurrection indicates that the entire universe will be glorified like the body of Christ. How can heaven lack the wonder and beauty that exists on earth - and in time and space?
 
Prodigal_Son said:
Does this mean that the Aristotelian is committed to the claim that matter is infinitely divisible?
Click to expand...
Committed insofar as defending that definition, I should think so. I haven’t read enough of Aristotle’s works on the natural sciences to know what he thinks of atomism. Certainly the notion of an atom, or base particle which was not divisible was around at at his time, and he probably comments on it one way or another, I am just not familiar with it myself.
 
Coincidentally (or better yet, “providentially”) I read a reflection from St. Augustine just yesterday regarding whether we see God with our real eyes in heaven – and he talks about material things in heaven.
St. Augustine’s conclusion was that material things are in heaven, but no matter where we look we see God in them.
So, I stand corrected, sort of.
St. Augustine (cited by Fr. Benedict Groeschel) points out that God will create a “new heavens and new earth” – so this “new earth” will have a “material” structure of sorts.

As a side topic … it leads me to think that what we call “material” really isn’t what the word has come to mean. In other words, if everything which is material is infused with God’s presence (even at the atomic level or in the energy that binds material objects) then why not have material objects in heaven? I had never thought about that before.
 
reggieM said:
St. Augustine’s conclusion was that material things are in heaven, but no matter where we look we see God in them. As a side topic … it leads me to think that what we call “material” really isn’t what the word has come to mean. In other words, if everything which is material is infused with God’s presence (even at the atomic level or in the energy that binds material objects) then why not have material objects in heaven? I had never thought about that before.
Click to expand...
Perhaps, after all of the covetousness on this earth, we will finally see material as being God’s rather as ours.
 
It is apparent from Scripture that there has to be food and drink in Heaven. Jesus, Himself, said at the Last Supper: “Amen I say to you, that I will drink no more of the fruit of the vine, until that day when I shall drink it new in the kingdom of God.” (Mark 14:25)

God has provided well for us when we consider the marvelous seed that produces the bounty of numerous fruits and vegetables. We have been given governance over the animal world. All of this was made evident in the creation account in Genesis. What God has created can not be lost, as matter is not lost but becomes energy, for God contains all. We will be given our portion in Heaven, and our cup shall be overflowing.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top