women priests

  • Thread starter Thread starter mmmtoasty
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Do you actually think St. Paul is speaking literally? Last time I checked, I was actually still male. As of at least this morning, my wife was actually still female. I’ve also met both Jews and Greeks. Rather than distort Scripture to fit your a priori conclusion, why not actually reading the Apostle Paul in context?

Here you go: Click Here.

As has already been pointed out at least once, St. Paul isn’t discussing gender issues. He’s explaining that people who are Christians are heirs to the kingdom.

I never said not list them. I said it wouldn’t be necessary for me to prepare to eat crow, which is sensible since your argument has no merit.

You apply a conditional if and then admit the condition will never occur. IOW, you have no rationale. Your “rationale” has no more substance than me claiming that if Velveeta Slices are money then I’ve got a nice chunk of change sitting in my refrigerator.

Ah, yes. My adherence to the Church must because I’m too hidebound to listen to reason, not because you’re wrong.

:rolleyes:

It has nothing to do with reading God’s mind. It has to do with God’s revelation to man.

And that guidance says infallibly that women cannot receive the Sacrament of Holy Orders.

True, but only the Magesterium enjoys the charism of infallibility. Therefore, when the Church has spoken infallibly, any contradiction is necessarily wrong.

– Mark L. Chance.
Well, I didn’t think I’d make dent with you. However, you can say I’m wrong all you want, but what it comes down to is your opinion vs mine. You are entitled to it, just as I am entitled to mine.

BTW, acting like a jerk with some of your sarcastic comments just decreases your creditability. If you can’t debate without acting like that, just stay on the sidelines will you?

Now I’ve grown bored with this, so I’ll disengage from this thread.
 
Hope you can listen to one of Father Corapi’s talks which includes the reasons why women can’t become priests.

He mentions it’s similar to the reason why men don’t become pregnant.

Keep learning about the faith!
I dont understand why there are no women priests. Can women even become priets?
 
I dont understand why there are no women priests. Can women even become priets?
The Bible teaches against this.
See the following,
specific prohibitions against women having “authority over men” (1 Tim 2:11-13 , 1Tim.3:2-6 3:2; Titus 1:6; 1 Cor 14:34-35).

God bless,
jean8
 
Ludmila Javorova - her story is here at this link:
beliefnet.com/story/79/story_7920_1.html

Her story tears big holes in the outdated (and chauvinistic) notion that women can’t serve the Lord as Priests. Funny how you never hear about her…seems like someone wants to keep the good old boys in charge.

Jesus saw fit to choose a woman (Mary Magdalene) to go to His apostles and spread the Good News about His resurrection and ascension. Obviously He did not have any weird hang-ups about women being leaders in the Faith.

God Bless!
 
I am a woman. I serve and love my church with all I have and always will. I believe that Our Lord loves us all equally and calls us ALL to serve Him and his flock.
The gifts and talents He has given each of us, male and female, are meant to be instruments of His will, love, and grace in our world.
That said, I hope and pray that I NEVER see the day that a woman is ordained into the priesthood.
Our Lord welcomed all of us into the living church. He welcomed, loved, and ministered to women, children, men, sinners, saints, gentiles, Jews, EVERYONE. He left his church with a mission, each of us has a part in that mission. The priesthood He ordained to men. But, just as on that first Easter, He revealed His resurrection to the women, who helped the twelve chosen ministers spread the glorious good news of our salvation. And so it continues.
 
In a marriage, can a woman be the Groom?
I am kind of confused. Jesus is known as the Bridegroom of the Church…the church is the people which are made up of both men and women. So I guess if you are a guy, you should consider yourself a bride ? Well bust my britches, I have never thought of it this way… Wow - that is a very liberal position to take in this forum!👍

Just kidding - we can’t be fire and brimstone all the time.😉

God Bless!
 
Jesus saw fit to choose a woman (Mary Magdalene) to go to His apostles and spread the Good News about His resurrection and ascension. Obviously He did not have any weird hang-ups about women being leaders in the Faith.
No, he had no problem with women being leaders in faith, He in fact was instructed by only one person other than God the Father throughout the entire Bible and then was expected to obey: His mother. But then, she wasn’t a priest either, was she? What makes people think that priests are the most important Catholics, and so therefore women can never hold that position? I’m not saying priests aren’t important Catholics, it’s not different then men not being able to give birth. It has nothing to do with status, intellectualism, or inferiority, it simply has to do with the person’s gender.
 
I am kind of confused. Jesus is known as the Bridegroom of the Church…the church is the people which are made up of both men and women. So I guess if you are a guy, you should consider yourself a bride ?
Unto myself I’m not a Church - but just a part of it. (See 1 Corinthians 27)

But unto himself, a priest is the Bridegroom. That’s why He can say “This is my body” for the Eucharist, and that’s why He can hear confession and say “I absolve you of your sins”. (I realise that this makes us crazy in Protestant eyes.)
Well bust my britches…
hehe - How cool is that. I can’t wait to use those words in a post of my own… :cool:
 
Her story tears big holes in the outdated (and chauvinistic)…
:rolleyes:
…notion that women can’t serve the Lord as Priests.
Assuming the story is even true, she wasn’t actually ordained since a woman cannot receive the Sacrament of Ordination.
Funny how you never hear about her…seems like someone wants to keep the good old boys in charge.
:rolleyes:
Jesus saw fit to choose a woman (Mary Magdalene) to go to His apostles and spread the Good News about His resurrection and ascension. Obviously He did not have any weird hang-ups about women being leaders in the Faith.
“Being leaders” equals “being priests”? All leaders in the Church are priests?

– Mark L. Chance.
 
Ludmila Javorova - her story is here at this link:
beliefnet.com/story/79/story_7920_1.html

Her story tears big holes in the outdated (and chauvinistic) notion that women can’t serve the Lord as Priests. Funny how you never hear about her…seems like someone wants to keep the good old boys in charge.

Jesus saw fit to choose a woman (Mary Magdalene) to go to His apostles and spread the Good News about His resurrection and ascension. Obviously He did not have any weird hang-ups about women being leaders in the Faith.

God Bless!
Your statement seems to imply that Mary Magdalene was a leader in the earlier church. If I understand you correctly, could you please point me to some primary source documents or secondary sources that substantiate this claim.

Peace,
DCD
 
Well I guess your own concupiscence will keep you out of the catholic church for a very, very long time.

I really don’t foresee this changing at all…👍

Hopefully you’ll come to your senses before the Warning and the Miracle…hopefully before the Chastisement.

Pax Domini sit semper vobiscum. 👍
i’ll just keep trusting in Jesus’ actions of sending out women as His messengers.

i’ll just keep trusting in His actions of lifting women up instead of allowing them to be oppressed and thought of as second class.

i’ll just keep on not judging some one else’s experience of God with my own. (as in, when a woman says she feels a calling to be a minister/priest… i will not deny her experience because it doesn’t fit with my theology. the messiahship of Christ didn’t fit with paul’s theology, but he had to change his thinking because of his experience).

as long as i fall on the side of loving and building others up, i think i’ll be just fine with Jesus.
 
i’ll just keep trusting in Jesus’ actions of sending out women as His messengers.

i’ll just keep trusting in His actions of lifting women up instead of allowing them to be oppressed and thought of as second class.

i’ll just keep on not judging some one else’s experience of God with my own. (as in, when a woman says she feels a calling to be a minister/priest… i will not deny her experience because it doesn’t fit with my theology. the messiahship of Christ didn’t fit with paul’s theology, but he had to change his thinking because of his experience).

as long as i fall on the side of loving and building others up, i think i’ll be just fine with Jesus.
Women are not being treated as second class just because they can’t be priests.

If a woman wants to be a minister, there are Protestant denominations she’d feel at home in.
 
Does this mean that women can also be fathers and sons and uncles too? :rolleyes:
in the same way men can be Christ’s “bride”.

bernard of clairvaux spoke of this repeatedly and it freaked out his fellow monks.

God has feminine qualities as well as masculine. we were created in the image of God… male and female. we both bear the image because God has both aspects.
 
It’ll never happen. A woman priest is a contradiction to the Catholic Church. The day a woman priest is allowed is the day the Catholic Church becomes Protestant.
but not really to the actions of Jesus. the priesthood within Christianity is based on a succession from the apostles. an “apostle” simply means “one who is sent” (different from a disciple as one who follows). Jesus sent out women to carry His message frequently. if He sent them, they are apostles and can be priests.
A priest shares in Christ’s nuptial relationship with the Church - A priest becomes the Groom. A woman can’t become a Groom.
but a man can become a bride. the church is the bride of Christ but so is each and every one of us (see bernard of clairvaux amongst others). so, if a man can be a bride, why can’t a women function as the groom’s representative (for the priest is not the groom, but His representative).
If a woman becomes a priests, then - effectively - we are saying that the priest is not a Groom to the Church. And then we have to deny the 2000 years of Church Tradition.
the priest IS NOT the groom to the church, Jesus is. the priest simply represents Him or stands in His place.
What are your thoughts on same-sex marriages? I ask this question because the answer will be same for women priests.
it’s not really the same issue. in the physical world, two men or two women together cannot produce children. but a woman is more than capable of producing spiritual children and we are talking about the spiritual world.
 
there are plenty of women who would disagree with you on this. catholic women at that!
Well, if they disagree with the Church’s teachings on this, can they really be called Catholic? Before I was confirmed, I had to orally state that I believed and professed all that the Church teaches.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top