Women: Work or Home?

  • Thread starter Thread starter migurl
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I’m infertile anyway, so I’ll be off to work. If I were somehow, by the grace of God to conceive, my hubby would take care of the baby during the day and I’d help out after hours. He’s a Realtor, and so his schedule is a bit more pliable than mine. I’m a chemist, and I’m pretty sure children + noxious chemicals = problem.
 
40.png
tcay584:
I’m a chemist, and I’m pretty sure children + noxious chemicals = problem.
Maybe YOU could help me prepare for my chemistry midterm!😃
 
40.png
cargopilot:
That was the single best thing we’ve ever done. .
What a great story. Thanks.

Let me preface my comments by saying there are exceptions to every rule. And the rule is not that women should stay home, but that women WANT to stay home (that is assuming there are children in the family).

Let’s face it, God created us in certain ways. Generally women want to stay home. A recent NY Times article cited a survey of college women. 80% of them said they wanted to stop working or work part-time after having children.

Young children want their mothers. Most automatically go to mom for comfort. Its when Mom is unavailable that they settle (yes settle) for Dad.

Lastly, women generally don’t want their husbands to be stay-at-home Dad’s. It just isn’t attractive to them. Women want their husbands to be providers, not the provided for.

In my own life I’ve watched my wife become a completely different person. When we met she was adamant about never having children. It took a few years, but within the space of a month she went from that attitude to wanting a child more than anything else in the world. While we don’t have kids yet, she has immersed herself in caring for other people’s children thorugh babysitting. She is so good at it, these parents even take her advice on behavior problems they are addressing. This from a woman who denied the possibility of caring for children just six years ago.

Also, if you doubt that women want to stay at home with their children think about working women you know who have had a baby. How many of them wanted to return to work after a maternity leave. I have heard of a couple, but I’ve never met one.
 
I am a sahm of six. Being a wife(#1 vow) and mother was the vocation I was called to follow. When we married, my vocation became marriage. When we became pregnant, my vocation took the add-on of motherhood. Prior to children I was a highly paid executive—and even more than the pay was the clout that came with the job.

I certainly had my share of depressing times—yes, thinking it was the winter blues or holiday bah humbugs. But then I realized I wasn’t spending time in prayer. A daily routine of prayer and scripture study helps you to stay in touch with God’s Will for you and your vocation.

I dislike voting all or none or even in between. I do wish to encourage daily time spent in conversation with the Lord and honesty with ourselves(and that entails digging deep, asking the Lord to show us our true selves and true intentions). My doubts about whether this is what the Lord wants me to do were erased once I began to pray on a daily basis. And He is the one who gets me through those trying time of sah motherhood.

God has Blessed all Moms—let’s take that blessing and Rejoice!
 
Women should stay home and be submissive to their husbands. In Corinthians, St. Paul states that the Husband shall be the provider and the wife the homemaker.
Before radical feminists–when women stayed home and raised their children the divorce rate was much lower but in today’s time when both Husband and Wife are working to pay for uneeded “toys” divorce rates are sky- high and children are not getting the religious education they need!
 
I am due to marry in just under two years. I will work - I have secured a place on a very good graduate scheme in the UK’s civil service. My H2B will also be working hopefully on a similar scheme with a good salary. We have obviously discussed the issue of children and it has been decided that if we are blessed with our own or if we adopt we will both continue to work and dependant on financial issues we will either hire a nanny 9-5 or my H2B will work from home for a while. My mother and father both work and they have since we were adopted and my mother has always worked 8-6 (shes a school teacher) and my father has always run a business from home.

I am a strong believer that a woman can either work or stay at home BUT it should be here choice.

I am marrying my partner in 2008 (we will have graduated and worked for 12 mths by then - I want to pay for my own wedding and be able to have bought my own house before marrying) and we will be in a financial position to have bought a house each and one between us thus being able to secure a good retirement (I am some what of a realist when it comes to life and in the UK getting on the housing ladder can be hard so I plan to ensure we are in that position before I say I do although we obviously won’t live together until I get that ring!)

The view of a womans place has changed over the last 2000 years but we should still remember that many women did work - in the fields, on the farm, making clothes, etc - some worked in the home and some worked outside of it (although they did take the children with them) this is because financially for most people women needed to work! And this can be traced back to the ‘cave-man’!

Women are lucky if they don’t need to work but I no I couldnt stay at home - I need stimulation and being at home cooking, cleaning etc would not give me that! - But I will hire a cleaner!
 
I have never done this poll thing before, so if it doesn’t work right, I apologize. Anyways, I was reading another thread and the issue of stay at home mom vs working mom came up. So, I ask, should women stay home to take care of home and children or should they work? Are there times when one or the other must be done or is it merely up to the woman? Does it even matter?
To me, it isn’t a black or white issue. I think the wife/mother should do what’s best for her family–Just as a husband/father should do what’s best for his family.

Being a wife and mother is a vocation. In order to be a really good at it, that job has to come before any other considerations. The Church tells us this is how we become holy, this is why marriage is a sacrament.

I didn’t feel I had the option to vote in your poll, because none of the choices reflect my opinion.
Peace in Christ,
Ann
 
I couldn’t vote… my feelings sort of fall in between the options…

I think it should be a family decision based on individual family needs.

My thoughts fall between…
“Women should only work if they have to”
and
“It doesn’t matter which, as long as she chooses it.”

“Have to” is a difficult statement to discuss, because the “need” to work could be a mixture of financial AND emotional/mental requirements to not be pent up at home all day long. I’d, personally, have a very difficult time emotionally/mentally if I didn’t have the opportunity to challenge my brain. I would go nuts.

But I also don’t like “as long as she chooses it”, because I think there should be a *reason *for this choice, and that it needs to be a *mutual *decision within the family (between the husband and wife)…

Just my thoughts… 🙂
 
I wouldn’t feel like it. I have many “hobbies” that if I needed to or felt the desire to bring in money or keep busy if my children were off at school, I could. I have plenty of skills and I am graduating from college in 1.5 yrs. We have been together for almost 3 yrs now and I know that he doesn’t want me giong to work. I also know that if I wanted to work part time at my kids school (a private Catholic school) I could. I could teach math, writing etc (they don’t need to be certified I think, because it is funded by the parish) I could even be his secretary if he and his father start working together on a regular basis. We have a very clear understanding of what each of us wants and needs in regards to work. We communicate very well.
I have been doing mother stuff since I was 9, so this is normal for me, I just can’t wait til I get to make the rules!!!
Someone made comments about her husband saying things about “his money”. Yeah, get right on that, let him know that you do a lot and earn that money too. He needs to know that w/o you being home, you woudn’t be able to do all that you do, so he might not even have most of that money cuz he’d have to pay a babysitter. My fiance has been adamant that I never say “your truck” or “your money” He has told me since he got his new truck that it is “ours”. He is so cool that way.
Be careful with your assumptions… Catholic schools usually DO require certifications… 😉
 
That has a hint of “relativism” in it. If a woman works simply because she wants to, it is wrong. A child’s and a family’s need come before one person’s desire to be at work. If a woman has to work for finacial reasons or because her job has bette health coverage, fine, but we can’t use the “if it works for you it’s ok” shield because it may appear to work on the surface, but 20 yrs from now when your kids are all grown up and they come to you and say “I really wish we would have spent more time together Mom” HOw would that make you feel knowing that you worked only for self-fulfillment?
I wanted to comment on this as well… because I believe that the “reason” a woman “has” to work may be more complicated than “financial reasons or health coverage”…
I do believe there is a mental/emotional need for some women to work.

I have also had first hand experience with my mother being adament about staying at home with us… yet, I can’t say I fully benefited from it due to her massive bouts with depression. Now, looking back at my childhood… I WISH my mom would have gotten out of the house for the sake of us kids… so she could focus her emotional outlet somewhere else. Having a depressed stay at home mom isn’t good either.

Maybe I’m overcompensating for my own difficult childhood… but I do believe having a job has helped me be a better mother.
 
Hmm. This is kind of moot for us right now, as we’ll be hitting the 3-year infertility point in June. I’ve taken advantage of the inability to have children and have gone back to grad school (the silver lining on the very, very dark cloud of infertility), which I had wanted to do but was willing to forgo to have kids. There’s no point in me sitting at home alone all day and mourning my lost fertility. When we are at a point when we can afford to adopt, then we’ll revisit the issue.
 
I cannot answer because of the word “should.” I work and my husband stays at home taking care of the baby. Why? Because I can make enough money to survive as I have more experience then he does. Would I rather stay at home? Yes. But, will I willingly sacrifice this want so my family can survive? Yes.
Glad to find someone in the same situation as we are. I’m a nurse (read – steady income, benefits, etc). DH has his own business as an appraiser and realtor. Decent money, but SPORADIC. We opted for me to go part time, while he stayed home with the baby. I’d love to have the situation reversed, but it’s just not in the cards right now. That’s my long term financial goal.

Dianna
 
I am starting my fourth month of being a SAHM. Previously, I worked the job for the steady income and health insurance “benefits”. In return, I also received extra stress, an outrageous fuel bill for the commute and only an hour or two (at best) with my kids each day. IMHO, a lousy scenario.

While I was pregnant with baby #3, the years of asking my DH to move “back home” paid off. We took a serious look at the situation, did the math and made the move. The change in our two older children is AMAZING! They love having their mama home and now I am getting to see our son do all of those firsts that I missed with the “girls”. 🙂

I would like to encourage anyone who is thinking about it to step out in faith and make the SAHM move. Yes, things can get tight financially. But, God always provides for our needs (not necessarily our wants…)👍
 
I cannot answer because of the word “should.” I work and my husband stays at home taking care of the baby. Why? Because I can make enough money to survive as I have more experience then he does. Would I rather stay at home? Yes. But, will I willingly sacrifice this want so my family can survive? Yes.
I think that either parent that stays at home is good. We have friends ( a couple) and he stays at home with the 3 children and she is the one that works.

I am a stay at home mom, I would love to work, but I prefer to stay with my children. My husband likes that, too.

My husband grew up with a working mother (she is now 76) and he is the youngest. She always worked just to make extra money. She now regrets not staying at home when her children were little. She says that she would have preferred to have eaten rice and beans most of the days, back then, in exchange for been with her kids while growing up.

I am an only child and my mother didn’t get a job until I got married!! My father and I encouraged her to. She is now very happy with her job!

Bottomline, I have read and heard that the most important years of a child’s life is the first three years, therefore, those are the years that the child needs the most of the mother.
 
I think you can be independent and stay home. The key is to have options if something were to go wrong. I personally think you should have a degree or a certification in something, so if the worst happens (divorce/death/unemployment) there will be a backup source of income. 👍
I applaud to that!

Bravo!!!

That is the best that one as a wife/mother can do. Just prepare for the worst. That is what I had in mind all my life. I told myself that I wanted to stay at home with my children, however, I needed to prepare myself for the worst (death, illness…etc…) and so I did. I obtained a 4 year college degree and a teacher certification!
 
Quite some time ago, I needed a little sign form God to tell me something wasn’t just right. Actually, God had to hit me with a 2x4, multiple times, to get my attention. I wasn’t being a man by providing for my wife.

One day, the job of picking up my very young child from daycare fell to me. I arrived a little early, so I thought it’d be fun just to peek-in and watch my child in the daycare room. What I saw was a surly ‘care-giver’ reading a magazine, pausing just long enough to say “shut-up” or “stop that” to any offending little kid. My child was just circling a table with a blank stare, just marking time. The scene saddened me, greatly. It all didn’t come clear at that moment, but this was the impetus for what follows.

On arriving home, my dear wife was also ‘beat’ from a hard day at work. She was fixing us a frozen pizza for supper and complaining that the house was a wreck. (She’s a neat-freak, so that bothers her, while I don’t care about that stuff, too much.) As usual, the laundry and dishes were piling up. (OK, this is where you all rip on me for not helping around the house, as I should.)

After putting a cranky child to bed, I’m hoping for a break in a 2 week romantic ‘dry spell’. Once again, she’s too tired, and not in the mood… A fight breaks out, so neither one of us get’s much sleep, anyway.

Repeat the above procedure, in various forms, over and over again.

Then, one early morning, it all became very clear. My poor wife was working at least two full-time jobs. She was simply overworked and not a happy camper. Now, if Momma ain’t happy, nobody’s happy. Right then and there, I decided I was going to convince her to quit her job. We could live without it, we could just cut back, waaaay back.

So, for the next few weeks, I carefully gathered information to build my case. I prepared answers for every possible argument she could have. I was doing everything I could to get ready to ‘sell’ her on my idea. Now I’m ready, but how do I start the proposal? I just forgot I was going to smoothly finesse it… You know when you say something, and it wasn’t at all how you wanted to say it, but now it’s too late? That was me. I just ‘told’ her to quit her job.

Boy! Was I surprised when she said “OK, I’ll quit my job and be a stay at home Mom…It’s all I ever wanted.” I didn’t have to ‘sell’ anything. All that preparation and thought on how to convince her was completely unnecessary.

That was the single best thing we’ve ever done. We’re all much, much happier. Sure, the loss of her income was tough, but we just cut back. On the other hand, you would be surprised how much money a SAHM can save. There are many hidden costs associated with the working Mom. She takes care of all the finances, I give her my paycheck and she gives me a twenty every week. I don’t know where she stashes the money, and I don’t care. The kid’s happy, the house sparkles, the food’s better and she is in the ‘mood’ more than ever.http://forums.catholic-questions.org/images/icons/icon10.gif All the cut-backs were such a small price to pay.

I still worry that she gets bored, or might think she wasted a fine college degree, but she is always quick to remind me that she’s not bored. She says, there’s always something to do. Now she guards her position like a hawk. I don’t think she’ll want to return to the workforce, ever again.
My hero, too!
 
I planned on working after my children were born, what I didn’t plan on was the way I’d feel after having them.
When I left my eldest in the university child care centre one day, while I went to an induction day-I planned to start university full-time-something strange happened-my heart broke-I missed her-I thought about what she was doing-I grieved for her absence.
I never did that degree after all.
When my third was born, I went back to my job , and the whole time I was away-9 hours-she did not feed-despite the gallons of breastmilk I had pumped. Physcologically I was distraught-my full breasts leaked milk, and my brain asked “where is your baby?”.I missed her and she needed me.I couldn’t focus on what I was doing in work-I was a lousy employee and a lousy mother.I quit that day.
I can’t speak for others, but I know when my husband goes to work after his Paternity leave, he doesn’t tear his heart out, he doesn’t worry, isn’t anxious-sure he misses us-but he is not crippled by it. His breasts don’t swell up to feed the baby-he is not looking around every two minutes to pick up that child.
 
I think it should be up to the woman. there are some women out there who do not want to stay at home. if a woman does choose to be a stay at home mom it is a great choice and i have nothing but the upmost respect for any woman that chooses this. there is no harder job than being a stay at home parent. when i lost my job a few years ago i had to stay at home with my kids for two months in between interviews, that was the hardest i ever worked in my life.
 
I wanted to comment on this as well… because I believe that the “reason” a woman “has” to work may be more complicated than “financial reasons or health coverage”…
I do believe there is a mental/emotional need for some women to work.

I have also had first hand experience with my mother being adament about staying at home with us… yet, I can’t say I fully benefited from it due to her massive bouts with depression. Now, looking back at my childhood… I WISH my mom would have gotten out of the house for the sake of us kids… so she could focus her emotional outlet somewhere else. Having a depressed stay at home mom isn’t good either.

Maybe I’m overcompensating for my own difficult childhood… but I do believe having a job has helped me be a better mother.
I would definitely agree! While I am only TOO excited to be a full-time SAHM, I have a few friends who work and have young babies. Granted, they only work part-time, but they need it or they’d go crazy! I’ve been told by so many that while staying at home is very fulfilling, it can also get incredibly lonely. I know from my own experience, my mom worked until I was about 5 or 6 and I turned out fine :). I was glad she was home after that, but I don’t feel like it really affected me at all when she was working early on.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top