Woolwich attack

  • Thread starter Thread starter johnmarson
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
It’s disgusting.
The poor victims blood all over his hands, and they keep showing it. On CNN, Fox, Drudge.
What ever happened to decency and discretion?
They were lost in the race for ratings.

It’s our fault for tolerating it. Frog and the slow boil.:mad:
 
They were lost in the race for ratings.

It’s our fault for tolerating it. Frog and the slow boil.:mad:
I don’t know, I listened to Pamela Geller, the Atlas Shrugs blog owner.

She was saying perhaps what was needed was “expunging”, iow cleaning up the Koran, that the Muslims basically need a Vatican II but since they have so many different sects, I don’t think that’s possible.
 
I don’t know, I listened to Pamela Geller, the Atlas Shrugs blog owner.

She was saying perhaps what was needed was “expunging”, iow cleaning up the Koran,** that the Muslims basically need a Vatican I**I but since they have so many different sects, I don’t think that’s possible.
The problem is different Imams interpret the quran differently, sure there are similarities but I know of a mosque in Sydney there is a firebrand Imam preaching and promoting what some would label terrorism but they would justify as righteous response and then suburbs away there is another Imam who condemns suicide bombers and riots etc. They are preaching from the same book.

They also don’t have a figurehead such as the Pope or a central body like the Vatican with its various Congregations and Magisterium and Bishops to formulate; introduce and then enforce something like Vatican II.

I do feel like it’s the ‘crazies’ for want of a better word who stuff it up for everyone else. Ali my muslim friend at work, his mosque was defaced after 9/11 said that they were “just getting back to normality and then the ‘crazies’ come out in Boston and London and demolish the lives of innocent families and screw things up for the rest of us.”
 
Set aside the Islam/terror angle for a moment. Can anyone imagine something like this having happened there, say, 100 years ago? I mean two men hacking a soldier to pieces with machetes in public, unmolested by the nearby crowd of gawkers?
That’s the worst part of this incident. A whole crowd of people just stood there watching and taking pictures with their cell phones as a man was hacked to death right in front of them.
 
Different news services give differing versions - a group of locals surrounded the second attacker, someone tried to help the man, and a youth leader reasoned with the other man until police arrived.

As for standing around taking pictures. If you were faced by someone with bloody hands who had just killed violently and was holding the murder weapons, would you REALLY get within reach of his weapons, or would you show presence of mind to DOCUMENT what was happening to give to the police.
 
Different news services give differing versions - a group of locals surrounded the second attacker, someone tried to help the man, and a youth leader reasoned with the other man until police arrived.

As for standing around taking pictures. If you were faced by someone with bloody hands who had just killed violently and was holding the murder weapons, would you REALLY get within reach of his weapons, or would you show presence of mind to DOCUMENT what was happening to give to the police.
You say it well, it’s a bit stunning, that one lady did talk to the guy with bloody hands.
 
I don’t know, I listened to Pamela Geller, the Atlas Shrugs blog owner.

She was saying perhaps what was needed was “expunging”, iow cleaning up the Koran, that the Muslims basically need a Vatican II but since they have so many different sects, I don’t think that’s possible.
She obviously knows little about the Catholic Church or Vatican 2 to make such an uninformed, unknowledgable comment.
She also knows even less about Muslims.
 
Different news services give differing versions - a group of locals surrounded the second attacker, someone tried to help the man, and a youth leader reasoned with the other man until police arrived.

As for standing around taking pictures. If you were faced by someone with bloody hands who had just killed violently and was holding the murder weapons, would you REALLY get within reach of his weapons, or would you show presence of mind to DOCUMENT what was happening to give to the police.
I guess none of us know for sure what our reaction would be until something like that would actually happen. look at the people in boston that rushed to help the injured even though 2 explosions had already gone off. they all could have run the other way in fear or a 3rd or 4th explosion. the person recording one of the TERRORISTS on the cellphone was very brave. I don’t think I could have stood there and calmly recorded especially when he started with his jihadist rant. this was an act of terrorism and a soldier was murdered in this terrorist act as far as I am concerned.
 
MSNBC Host: London Muslim Butchers “Are Just Murderers” And Not Terrorists

Even though the perpetrators proclaimed they did this for Islam.
Chris Hayes was correct. This act, though horrible and thoroughly disgusting, cannot be properly called terrorism.

See…Glenn Greenwald

Was the London killing of a British soldier ‘terrorism’?

Excerpt…

What definition of the term includes this horrific act of violence but excludes the acts of the US, the UK and its allies?

*The US, the UK and its allies have repeatedly killed Muslim civilians over the past decade (and before that), but defenders of those governments insist that this cannot be “terrorism” because it is combatants, not civilians, who are the targets. Can it really be the case that when western nations continuously kill Muslim civilians, that’s not “terrorism”, but when Muslims kill western soldiers, that is terrorism? Amazingly, the US has even imprisoned people at Guantanamo and elsewhere on accusations of “terrorism” who are accused of nothing more than engaging in violence against US soldiers who invaded their country. *
 
Chris Hayes was correct. This act, though horrible and thoroughly disgusting, cannot be properly called terrorism.

See…Glenn Greenwald

Was the London killing of a British soldier ‘terrorism’?

Excerpt…

What definition of the term includes this horrific act of violence but excludes the acts of the US, the UK and its allies?

The US, the UK and its allies have repeatedly killed Muslim civilians over the past decade (and before that), but defenders of those governments insist that this cannot be “terrorism” because it is combatants, not civilians, who are the targets. Can it really be the case that when western nations continuously kill Muslim civilians, that’s not “terrorism”, but when Muslims kill western soldiers, that is terrorism?
Amazingly, the US has even imprisoned people at Guantanamo and elsewhere on accusations of “terrorism” who are accused of nothing more than engaging in violence* against US soldiers who invaded their country. *
A man was brutally murdered. I absolutely do not see the need of semantics here. In the court of law verbal threat that is used to instill fear for ones life is a "terroristic threat."I don’t see the point to dance around the word “terrorism.”

Evil is evil and what that terrorist did was evil, no if and or buts about it. I don’t see the purpose of defending a terrorist either, a person who defends a terrorist and tries to rationalize his actions to where it is acceptable behaviour is doing the work of the devil.
 
A man was brutally murdered. I absolutely do not see the need of semantics here. In the court of law verbal threat that is used to instill fear for ones life is a "terroristic threat."I don’t see the point to dance around the word “terrorism.”

Evil is evil and what that terrorist did was evil, no if and or buts about it. I don’t see the purpose of defending a terrorist either, a person who defends a terrorist and tries to rationalize his actions to where it is acceptable behaviour is doing the work of the devil.
The Prime Minister of the United Kingdom calls it Terrorist, I will go with that.

Meanwhile, a Hmong man, Kham Xiong, the Hmong are the mountain tribal people depicted in the Grand Torino movie with Clint Eastwood was killed in the Fort Hood shooting but the administration won’t call this act terrorism. Thus, survivors, his children are denied the same benefits as the shooter.

Let’s not forget, these drones are probably of more danger to innocent civilians too and seems to be the forte of this administration. I wonder if Chris Hayes and MSNBC will go off on this.
 
A man was brutally murdered. I absolutely do not see the need of semantics here. In the court of law verbal threat that is used to instill fear for ones life is a "terroristic threat."I don’t see the point to dance around the word “terrorism.”

Evil is evil and what that terrorist did was evil, no if and or buts about it. I don’t see the purpose of defending a terrorist either, a person who defends a terrorist and tries to rationalize his actions to where it is acceptable behaviour is doing the work of the devil.
I think if GNJSDad wants to call US/UK forces terrorists as well, that is the poster’s right. However, what occurred in London is terrorism period. No matter what side does it.
 
I wonder what the excuse is for not calling this terrorism in all the places, the West is not, in Nigeria, in Sudan, in Indonesia, in India, in Egypt, and on and on.
 
A man was brutally murdered.
On that, we all agree.
John Paul Jones:
I absolutely do not see the need of semantics here. In the court of law verbal threat that is used to instill fear for ones life is a "terroristic threat."I don’t see the point to dance around the word “terrorism.”
That may be true in a court of law, but in the court of public opinion and discourse, the use of the word “terrorism” has broad and profound implications.

From the article I linked…

…there are few terms - if there are any - that pack the political, cultural and emotional punch that “terrorism” provides. When it comes to the actions of western governments, it is a conversation-stopper, justifying virtually anything those governments want to do. It’s a term that is used to start wars, engage in sustained military action, send people to prison for decades or life, to target suspects for due-process-free execution, shield government actions behind a wall of secrecy, and instantly shape public perceptions around the world. It matters what the definition of the term is, or whether there is a consistent and coherent definition. It matters a great deal.

There is ample scholarship proving that the term has no such clear or consistently applied meaning (see the penultimate section here, and my interview with Remi Brulin here). It is very hard to escape the conclusion that, operationally, the term has no real definition at this point beyond “violence engaged in by Muslims in retaliation against western violence toward Muslims”. When media reports yesterday began saying that “there are indications that this may be act of terror”, it seems clear that what was really meant was: “there are indications that the perpetrators were Muslims driven by political grievances against the west” (earlier this month, an elderly British Muslim was stabbed to death in an apparent anti-Muslim hate crime and nobody called that “terrorism”). Put another way, the term at this point seems to have no function other than propagandistically and legally legitimizing the violence of western states against Muslims while delegitimizing any and all violence done in return to those states.

John Paul Jones:
I don’t see the purpose of defending a terrorist
Neither do I. We agree on that much.
 
Honor killings in the news again
Ten male relatives strangled and beat an Egyptian mother and two daughters and threw their bodies in the Nile, police say.
LUXOR, Egypt — A mother and two daughters were allegedly killed by male relatives in southern Egypt who believed they’d had affairs, the latest apparent example of so-called “honor killings” in which women are slain for violating traditional morals in the conservative region, a security official said Friday.
Respect others, love others but also be aware of their acts.
 
When I heard about this I was shocked, angered, and saddened. But when I think about it, incidents like this really are not all that surprising. There are Islamic extremists out there who are more than willing to commit terroristic acts like this. There are also people of other religions who are terrorists. But just because its not surprising looking back at it doesn’t mean I condone it. Not by any means!!! I absolutely condemn this! I do hope and pray for the terrorist/murderer(s) repentance, conversion, and salvation though. We are to love everyone, even our enemies. That doesn’t mean we condone their acts. Indeed we should condemn acts like this. However, we should still hope for their salvation.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top