Working mothers 'do no harm to children's behaviour'

  • Thread starter Thread starter LemonAndLime
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
L

LemonAndLime

Guest
There is no evidence of ill-effects on children’s social and emotional behaviour if their mothers work during the early years, a study suggests.

University College London researchers studied data on 12,000 children and said the best arrangement was where both parents lived at home and worked.

Girls whose mothers did not work showed more difficulties at age five than those with employed mothers, they said.

Other studies show children of working mothers are more likely to be obese.

The new study examined information on the children over a period of five years - although it was limited to those whose ethnicity was classed as white.

bbc.co.uk/news/education-14247472
 
To hear a lot of people, you’d think we working mothers are the cause of the fall of Western Civilization.
Oh of course. The “breakdown of the family”, caused by women working, is the cause of contraception, abortion, homosexuality…
 
ALL mothers are ‘working mothers’.

And prior to the 20th century, even in the Western World, more than 50% of the people lived a rural lifestyle. . .and that meant things like subsistance farming and household ‘chores’ that took hours to do and plenty of elbow grease.

Factoring in the Great Depression and world war II’s demands on the work force, more mothers than not in ALL classes but the most wealthy worked even in the 20th century. Only in a very short period of time in the U.S. (longer in Brittain where the whole thing started with the Victorians 😃 aided by the ability of even the lower classes to hire at least one servant due to a large population and a ‘shift’ from rural to urban living) was there a time for the middle and upper class to have mom ‘not working’ (and that 'non working mom even in 1950 or 1960 was usually quite busy running the scout troup, fixing dinner, sewing and cleaning and helping dad). Lower class and ethnic women were usually ‘working moms’ by necessity.

The only real problem came about when a large workforce of women (boomers) came onto the scene and were told they needed to 'bring home the bacon and fry it up in a pan both, started out joyfully, and then with the crashing of marriages and high divorce rates found themselves in dead end jobs with little security, lots of competition, having to pay out for other mothers to take care of their children, while the father walked off with the new trophy wife and a better standard of living.
 
ALL mothers are ‘working mothers’.
This not strictly true, there are a small number of lazy mothers out there. I know one person who should have either never had kids, or given what she had up for adoption. And now she wonders why they never call on mother’s day.
 
It would be interesting to hear how the teachers report the behavioural differences between the children whose mothers worked ouside the home vs those whose mothers were home with them during the early years(this study only took into accont the observations of mothers).

Considering that the stay at home moms have much more time to observe and interact with their children than the mothers who work outside the home, would it not also follow that they would be that much more likely to perceive and report those behavioural issues mentioned? Perhaps the working moms have just not had the opportunity to witness and become concerned over these behaviours.🤷
 
Oh of course. The “breakdown of the family”, caused by women working, is the cause of contraception, abortion, homosexuality…
truancy, divorce, men not attending Mass, STIs, adolescent acne, the dreaded “latchkey kid”, high unemployment, the national debt, female alter servers…

Does the list of calamities caused by wage-earning wives and mothers ever end?😉
 
There is no evidence of ill-effects on children’s social and emotional behaviour if their mothers work during the early years, a study suggests.

University College London researchers studied data on 12,000 children and said the best arrangement was where both parents lived at home and worked.

Girls whose mothers did not work showed more difficulties at age five than those with employed mothers, they said.

Other studies show children of working mothers are more likely to be obese.

The new study examined information on the children over a period of five years - although it was limited to those whose ethnicity was classed as white.

bbc.co.uk/news/education-14247472
This study is nothing new. Previous studies, on a somewhat smaller scale, have suggested that mothers who work out of the home have a positive influence on their daughters’ self-confidence and provide them with higher aspirations for their own lives. The positive effect of working mothers on their sons is not as strong; however, neither is it negative. And this influence seems to apply to a variety of ethnic groups.
 
Considering that the stay at home moms have much more time to observe and interact with their children than the mothers who work outside the home, would it not also follow that they would be that much more likely to perceive and report those behavioural issues mentioned? Perhaps the working moms have just not had the opportunity to witness and become concerned over these behaviours.🤷
For every working mother who’s too wrapped up in her job to notice or become concerned about her kids’ behavior problems - at school or elsewhere - I’ll show you a SAHM who’s too busy going to the mall with her girlfriends and getting mani/pedis to notice or care about her kids deteriorating behavior.

Oh, there aren’t very many SAHMs who are that wrapped up in themselves? Well, there aren’t too many working moms, either.

Besides, for every mom who’s charged with observing her kids, there’s a dad in there somewhere. Let him step up to the plate.
 
Based on my own experience, I don’t believe this study. I am not against ‘working mothers’, but working and putting kids in daycare is far from ideal. I realize that many women have to work, and I’m not critical of them, but when my wife ran a small daycare out of our home, we knew when a kid had been a ‘daycare kid’, because of the way that they would act. They were aggressive.
 
There is no evidence of ill-effects on children’s social and emotional behaviour if their mothers work during the early years, a study suggests.

University College London researchers studied data on 12,000 children and said the best arrangement was where both parents lived at home and worked.

Girls whose mothers did not work showed more difficulties at age five than those with employed mothers, they said.

Other studies show children of working mothers are more likely to be obese.

The new study examined information on the children over a period of five years - although it was limited to those whose ethnicity was classed as white.

bbc.co.uk/news/education-14247472
This may be a good study but maybe not.A study may show that there are no ill effects but they probably don’t show all the moral effects.For instance they may not show if children with working parents swear more than other children.Or miss Mass on Sunday more.Afterall what’s more important.A child who does good in school or a child who is a very moral person.
 
This may be a good study but maybe not.A study may show that there are no ill effects but they probably don’t show all the moral effects.For instance they may not show if children with working parents swear more than other children.Or miss Mass on Sunday more.Afterall what’s more important.A child who does good in school or a child who is a very moral person.
I imagine that this is a field where there are a lot of measurement problems, just due to the nature of what is being studied. Unfortunately we do not have access to the full study, so it is hard to make much in the way of comments one way or another.
 
This may be a good study but maybe not.A study may show that there are no ill effects but they probably don’t show all the moral effects.For instance they may not show if children with working parents swear more than other children.Or miss Mass on Sunday more.Afterall what’s more important.A child who does good in school or a child who is a very moral person.
Are you implying that a mother who works is more likely to have immoral children?
 
I imagine that this is a field where there are a lot of measurement problems, just due to the nature of what is being studied. Unfortunately we do not have access to the full study, so** it is hard to make much in the way of comments one way or another.**
AND that is the facts!!!..👍👍
 
But judgment needs / requires the full study.

Without it, we are left to interpretations only.
This is almost a first on CAF. It only really happens when people who disagree with the article can find nothing in it to use against the findings.

No one has any further comments/opinions? :eek:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top