Worship vs veneration

  • Thread starter Thread starter domestichippie
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Understood. But - it is important to recognize that Scripture points to “Church” as authoritative. It points to a single, unified, visible and authoritative body. So the natural growth of study should be from scripture out into the writings and teachings of the Church.

I guess that this is a sticking point for me. Those who want to restrict teaching to Scripture tend to ignore what Scripture says about Church structure. They want to hold to Sola Scriptura, but then want to ignore the many references in the NT pointing quite clearly toward a unified and visible and authoritative Church.
Guess I’ve been in too many discussions where each side sits behind their barricade and shoots bible quotes at each other with no way to resolve the matter.
So - I tend to eventually challenge them on “biblical” description of authority as recorded in the NT…The model called fro IN Scripture is clearly the Catholic/EO councilior and authoritative model - not the “invisible church” model…
The protestant is more than willing to argue many points of doctrine and insist on “bible references” but then falls silent on the matter of the matter of what Scripture tells us about Church structure and authority…

Sorry - I’m rambling and ranting a bit…I’ll shut up now…

Peace
James
Please don’t shut up if you have more valuable info. Studying these things my husband and I have different hang ups. Also it really me doing the studying and bringing these things forward.
based on the fact that the doctrine of sols scriptural is not biblical (circular logic) we have both come to the conclusion that God’s people must interpret scripture and be guided by the holy spirit. My husband doesn’t see that any institution has more authority or special gift to do that any better than himself or other people he “feels” is correct.

Maybe its a guy thing.lol
 
Please don’t shut up if you have more valuable info. Studying these things my husband and I have different hang ups. Also it really me doing the studying and bringing these things forward.
Well - OK…If you really want me to…but don’t say I didn’t warn you…(laughs evilly -bwaahaahaahaa)😃
Based on the fact that the doctrine of sola scriptura is not biblical (circular logic) we have both come to the conclusion that God’s people must interpret scripture and be guided by the holy spirit.
You have come to a good and sound conclusion. Now this needs to be taken to the next level.
When you say that, “God’s people must interpret Scripture…guided by the Holy Spirit”, are you referring to individuals interpreting privately for themselves - or do you mean “as a group” (ekklesia) coming together to interpret. This is a very important point and distinction. Paul praised the Bereans for studying Scripture…but did they do this privately or as a group?
In Mt 18:15-18 we see Jesus giving instruction to the Apostles on how to deal with issues and conflicts that might come up in the “Church” (ekklesia in the Greek). In reading this passage it is important to recognize that, since teaching a false doctrine (different Gospel) is a sin, the “sin” referred to in vs 15 can certainly include doctrinal disputes. So, as we see the process unfold, we find that when problems cannot be settled quietly the issue is brought before “The Church”. We are then instructed to “Listen to The Church” on pain of separation from the community - the body of believers.
Jesus makes a truly remarkable statement here - one which He makes one other time in the Gospels…He grants His authority to the Church to “bind or loose”. What may they “bind or loose? Jesus says they may bind or loose"whatever”. A very broad authority indeed - given to “The Church”, not to individuals.

Now in many protestant traditions (so I’ve been told) this passage is read as meaning the “local community” not a “universal” community…But what about when two local communities are at odds with each other? Again we turn to the bible. This time to Acts 15 where we see the instructions of Mt 18 played out beautifully. The trouble starts because the Jewish Christians and the Gentile Christians in Antioch disagree over what is required to be a Christian. We can just see this in our mind’s eye…They argue, they debate, they point to Scripture etc…eventually Paul is brought into the discussion and not even he can resolve the matter. So - what do they do? They send a delegation to Jerusalem to meet with the “Elders of the Church”. There, after much debate, a decision is reached. The decision there is not limited to a single local community, but is authoritative throughout the Church - everywhere. That is, Universally (katholikos = catholic)

As additional evidence of the NT pointing to a visible and authoritative Church, I could add Jesus prayer that we be one as He and the Father are one. I could also add the several verses in the NT letters that call for unity, praising with one voice, being of one mind, of avoiding dissensions etc…All of which point to a visible unity with authority exercised through council .
This is precisely the model used by both of the ancient Christian Churches, the RC and the EO.

Now - when I am discussing authority with someone - this is the point where I ask them to provide equally compelling bible references for the “invisible church”, “local community”, “private interpretation” model. The conversation almost always falls silent shortly after that.

Think about how differently Acts 15 would have been written if the local community - non-authoritative - private interpretation model were in effect. There would be no Council of Jerusalem and Antioch would wind up with two separate communities (one Jewish Christian and one Gentile Christian) each holding and teaching differing doctrines on what is necessary for salvation.
My husband doesn’t see that any institution has more authority or special gift to do that any better than himself or other people he “feels” is correct.
Your husband makes a very common mistake. He sees the “institution” as somehow separate from the community. Yet “institutions” are “instituted” by the community to uphold the principles of the community and for the good of the community.
The Church structure does not exist to “impose” but rather to listen, to teach, to protect, to defend, to propagate the known Truths of the Gospel that were usually arrived at through councilior discussion (formal or informal).
In addition the Church provides a structure and a forum for discussion and debate, for review and careful development of teachings. Far from being restrictive in this, the institutions and offices of the Church provide a great freedom to explore, not only scripture, but also all of the great writings and Spirit guided understandings and teachings down through nearly 2 millenia.
A great writer and convert to Catholicism, G.K. Chesterton wrote that, “if the Catholic Church has built walls, they are walls around a playground”.

One more thing about the whole idea of being of one mind, united in Christ as He is united with the Father…Such unity in doctrine should be the goal of every true Christian. Humility and a desire to truly follow Christ demands of us that we seek unity one with the other. Institutions, councils etc all speak to this desire of Christians to be One as Jesus and our Heavenly Father are one.

I’ve written a lot here…and I hope I am not too far off the topics that you wish to discuss.
But you asked for it…😃
Feel free to ask any questions you might have.

Peace
James
 
.

Now in many protestant traditions (so I’ve been told) this passage is read as meaning the “local community” not a “universal” community…But what about when two local communities are at odds with each other?
A recent bible study on James is what made me sart asking these queastions in the first place.

The house I grew up inwas non denominational christian. And while they had no real bible knowledge. (It was mixed in with stuff they’d read and movies they’d watched) I’ve only been and actual Christian for 6 years. I read through the bible, devoured it really and had my queastions not always answered. For the lst several years my husband and I have been trying to find a church. We found our current church and like it but it took a long time to get there.

Many churches we saw things that outright contradict what the bible says. the churches I’ve seen insists that all people who are filled with the holy spirit are able to discern these things. but to me it seems to boil down to feeling and"The heart is deceitful above all things, and desperately sick; who can understand it?" Certainly I think there are some things God reveals on an individual basis and certainly he it not limited to the one denominaton or another…but there are definately things that are outright crazy and I’m not sure we can always trust ourselves to be honest about our own desires effecting how we see God. While I know as a nonchristian there was always something in the back of my mind that knew these things were wrong it was very easy to discredited them even on the shakiest intellectual ground based on feeling.

Its a big scary snowball. If I trust that I need and greater earthbound authority who its that? If its the Catholic church how do I know? If it is then all my other objection are rendered insufficient since I can believe what the church teaches? Even on matters such as mary and the saints.

My husband and I think very differently he has a tendency to be over confident, me over humble. The very fact that I am a christian at all shows me admiting my own ignorrance about who God is. Also I find authority comforting.

What funny is we did this study on jonah, then James. Both leading me in the direction of “God tell me where to go and what to do” and in less than 2 months this is where I end up
 
So as I’m exploring Catholicism I’m warming to idea of Mary. Ive even been praying the rosary and find it beneficial. I’m beginjng to bring dome of these findings to my husband who is convinced Catholics worship Mary.
Some Catholics DO worship Mary. I’ve read some prayers to Mary that made my hair curl. But that’s not what the Church teaches. Get your husband a catechism, or you can find it online.

As far as the saints go, maybe you can look at it like this: There are people who have been perfected, who have glorified bodies, who see everything now with the perfect perspective of Heaven. Obviously they aren’t dead; they’re more alive than we are because they are complete!

If you were a marathon runner and you met an Olympic gold medalist in running you would have great respect for that person. And if they could put a good word in for you with their “Coach” well heck yes!
 
Its a big scary snowball. If I trust that I need and greater earthbound authority who its that? If its the Catholic church how do I know? If it is then all my other objection are rendered insufficient since I can believe what the church teaches? Even on matters such as mary and the saints.
It IS a big scary snowball. I’m a former Protesant, so I know where you’re coming from. You are exactly right when you say that the authority of the Church is the first and only domino that has to fall. Part of what helped trust the magesterium was coming to realize how much I already depended on the Catholic church, even as a Protestant. Have you taken a look at how we got the canon of Scripture? I accepted the Bible in its form as the authoritative and inspired Word of God, was it such a stretch to accept the authority of those who decided which books to put in the bible in the first place?

Or the doctrine of the Trinity, or that Jesus had two wills, or that Satan is a fallen angel, etc., etc. I might be able to make a pretty Good argument from scripture for those doctrines, because I know them, but is that what I would get from the Bible if I read it cold? Why do you think the JWs and LDS miss that stuff?

Another thing that really helped me was reading the early church fathers. I tried to read about them, but I found that it was hard for both Protestant and Catholic writers not to press their views. I wanted to hear it straight from the horses mouth. And I discovered that those first Christians looked a heck of a lot like the Catholic church.

Please pm if you need help, or are feeling overwhelmed or frustrated. Even if you don’t end up coming into the Church, you’ll be doing a great service to the Body of Christ just LEARNING about the Catholic faith and being able to dispel untruths about it.
 
A recent bible study on James is what made me sart asking these questions in the first place.
There is much good in the book of James.
The house I grew up in was non denominational christian. And while they had no real bible knowledge. (It was mixed in with stuff they’d read and movies they’d watched) I’ve only been and actual Christian for 6 years. I read through the bible, devoured it really and had my questions not always answered. For the last several years my husband and I have been trying to find a church. We found our current church and like it but it took a long time to get there.
Many churches we saw things that outright contradict what the bible says.
And yet I’m sure that most/all of those churches held to some form of Sola Scriptura. Even though each church taught different things…
The churches I’ve seen insist that all people who are filled with the holy spirit are able to discern these things.
I would not dispute this idea in the least…The problem is - how does one determine who is “filled with the Holy Spirit” and who is filled with a less than holy spirit?
A preacher in one church teaches one thing while the preacher two blocks over teaches the complete opposite and both claim Scriptural support for their positions…How to resolve this dilemma??
But to me it seems to boil down to feeling and"The heart is deceitful above all things, and desperately sick; who can understand it?" Certainly I think there are some things God reveals on an individual basis and certainly he it not limited to the one denomination or another…but there are definitely things that are outright crazy and I’m not sure we can always trust ourselves to be honest about our own desires effecting how we see God.
Bingo In the above you hit the nail on the head as to why Jesus did not give us a book, nor did he give us an individual to follow (other than himself). Instead He gave us a “Church” with the authority to Bind and Loose - whatever.
St Paul reenforces this when he says that it is the Church that is the pillar and foundation of Truth. (1 Tim 3:15) and again when he says, "…through the church the manifold wisdom of God might now be made known to the principalities and powers in the heavenly places.(Eph 3:10)
The Church, the Ekklesia, community - is the protector against the errors that individuals can easily fall into.
You mention above that God does reveal things on an individual basis and this is absolutely true. But the way we test this - to see if our revelation is true is through the Church - the ekklesia…Again I refer to the passages in Mt 18:15-18 and Acts 15. The combined wisdom and working of the Holy Spirit among the community keeps the Gospel safe.
Its a big scary snowball. If I trust that I need and greater earthbound authority who its that? If its the Catholic church how do I know? If it is then all my other objection are rendered insufficient since I can believe what the church teaches? Even on matters such as Mary and the saints.
Indeed. And this is the reason I mentioned the matter of authority as the one crucial issue that needs to be addressed. It will take time so be patient with yourself.
You mentioned the need to start with Scripture to answer your husband’s questions, and that is what I did in discussing authority as well. The writers of the NT books as well as the history of the early Church BOTH point to the authoritative Church. Even after the Split between Rome and the EO, there was no idea of “private interpretation” of scriptures. This did not come about until the reformation…
So for 1500 years - from the council of Jerusalem onward the model has been an authoritative, councilior, Church seeking to fulfill Christ’s prayer that we be one as he and the Father are one.
My husband and I think very differently he has a tendency to be over confident, me over humble. The very fact that I am a christian at all shows me admitting my own ignorance about who God is. Also I find authority comforting.
It does indeed require great humility, and I think great courage, to submit to the authority of the Church.
One of the really difficult hurdles to overcome can be getting away form the idea of “the Church” being some sort of power broker, lording over us poor souls in the pews. Instead we need to recognize the Church’s magisterium (teaching office) for what it is. The storehouse for 2000 years of study and teaching and the debating and discussion forum for matters of concern within the church. It is an organic development of the community - not something imposed on the community…
What’s funny is we did this study on Jonah, then James. Both leading me in the direction of “God tell me where to go and what to do” and in less than 2 months this is where I end up
I hope we are being helpful.

Peace
James
 
I would argue that fidelity, obedience (not in a negative sense), and unconditional love are not poor examples to follow. However, I assume your focus on her perpetual virginity is just a bit of humor regarding the conjugal act, and would say in that case, the priest did not do a very good job explaining what a Catholic marriage entails.🙂
Indeed there was an element of humour in my question. But if one is looking for a role model, it seems logical to me to use someone who was fully involved in whatever you are talking about, rather than have to resort to metaphor to make the role model fit. That’s the point of role models. I have always liked the Catholic euphemism ‘conjugal act’, and have been known to invite Mrs Hokomai to join me in one!
 
Some Catholics DO worship Mary. I’ve read some prayers to Mary that made my hair curl. But that’s not what the Church teaches. Get your husband a catechism, or you can find it online.

As far as the saints go, maybe you can look at it like this: There are people who have been perfected, who have glorified bodies, who see everything now with the perfect perspective of Heaven. Obviously they aren’t dead; they’re more alive than we are because they are complete!

If you were a marathon runner and you met an Olympic gold medalist in running you would have great respect for that person. And if they could put a good word in for you with their “Coach” well heck yes!
Lol. I have to say it. Catechism: there’s an app for that:)
 
I think that Mary is the perfect model for all Christian women to emulate. That said, we definitely do not worship her. We venerate her. There is a huge difference between worship and veneration.
 
I think that Mary is the perfect model for all Christian women to emulate. That said, we definitely do not worship her. We venerate her. There is a huge difference between worship and veneration.
If this is true, Holly then all Christian women should be virgins. Otherwise she is not a model to emulate in all things, only in some.
 
If this is true, Holly then all Christian women should be virgins. Otherwise she is not a model to emulate in all things, only in some.
that’s ridiculous. Holly didn’t say in all things anyway.

she was the Mother of God, not an ordinary woman.

you can come as close to her ideal as you can/want.

missing the mark doesn’t lessen the ideal.
 
that’s ridiculous. Holly didn’t say in all things anyway.

she was the Mother of God, not an ordinary woman.

you can come as close to her ideal as you can/want.

missing the mark doesn’t lessen the ideal.
So it is ideal to be a married virgin?
 
So it is ideal to be a married virgin?
It is Ideal to Love God above all else. To be true to that Love in whatever vocation and/or station in life that we are called to.
Mary fits that description as does Joseph her earthly spouse.

We can all agree that, under most circumstances being a “married virgin” is not going to work out to well. However - under circumstances that are not normal it might work out just fine. So the “Married Virgin” issue is not really a deal breaker in the “Role Model” department.

Perhaps the thing to consider here is how the Love of Mary AND Joseph for God and for each other works in concert to make the whole matter of sex a non-issue
Mary was betrothed to Joseph and we can assume she was entirely willing to fulfill her duties as his wife. We have no reason to think otherwise. Same with Joseph.
However, things changed when Mary learned of God’s plan for her. They changed for her AND for her betrothed, Joseph. They both discovered that their married life was going to be unique in that they were going to be raising the Son of God and Savior of mankind as their own child.

Their Love of God above all things allowed them to accept this change in their plans.
Their Love for each other allowed them to accept the conditions that went along with that acceptance.

This is the “role model” aspect - Love and obedience to God in whatever circumstance one finds oneself in - and - Love and respect for any significant others in your life.

So - the perfection of Mary as role model is not contained in the sex act, but in Her Love for God and for Joseph. Likewise the perfection of Joseph as a role model lies in his love for God and for Mary by respecting her position as the Mother of the Son of God.
Love - not sex - is the key…

Peace
James
 
So it is ideal to be a married virgin?
I’m not sure if you’re arguing just to argue, or if you are really wondering how the Virgin Mary could be a role models for wives.

Jesus is our model for marriage too, and he was never even married. Husbands are to love wives the same way that Jesus loved us, that he died for us. Is every man supposed to jump in front of a car for his wife?

The Bible doesn’t even say much about Mary, so we really don’t know how she lived, or what kind of a wife she was. How then are we supposed to emulate her?

We are supposed to conform to them in character, attitude and intent. Perhaps emulate is the wrong word, since it means to imitate. Yes we can imitate to some extent, but not much. Not because they were both virgins but because they were both sinless.
 
Please don’t jack my thread. Start a new one if you want to argue about this.
My apologies. I thought I was on topic. As an outsider with a Catholic background I have always been a bit perplexed by the protestant objections to Marian devotion. as I understand it, Catholics think that God can intervene in the material world, so they pray for physical things to happen (cancer to be cured etc). They also think God can do things in the spiritual world (forgiveness of sins etc), in which they include what I think of as higher brain functioning (resistance to temptation etc). They also believe in eternal life, and in the concurrent existence of those who are in heaven, having already died, or headed there directly in the case of Mary, and those of us on earth. Those in heaven can be communicated to, so it makes sense to ask them to pray for us, just as Catholics ask living people to pray for us. This increases the likelihood of God responding in some way. I have never seen any suggestion from a Catholic source that they think Mary can intervene directly, other than by asking God to do so. The only logical objection I can see to this, if we take the existence of Mary, God, and us as givens, is either that Mary is not in heaven (e.g. not yet raised), or is unable to pray, or unwilling to do so, or that God will not hear her prayers. The use of statues is a different thing, and is believed by Catholics to be merely a symbolic use. in the same way that protestants use a cross to symbolise their faith. They don’t think it is actually faith, just a symbol.

Of course, as I am an unbeliever these are simply observations from outside. I hope that unjacks your thread! 🙂
 
My apologies. I thought I was on topic. As an outsider with a Catholic background I have always been a bit perplexed by the protestant objections to Marian devotion. as I understand it, Catholics think that God can intervene in the material world, so they pray for physical things to happen (cancer to be cured etc). They also think God can do things in the spiritual world (forgiveness of sins etc), in which they include what I think of as higher brain functioning (resistance to temptation etc). They also believe in eternal life, and in the concurrent existence of those who are in heaven, having already died, or headed there directly in the case of Mary, and those of us on earth. Those in heaven can be communicated to, so it makes sense to ask them to pray for us, just as Catholics ask living people to pray for us. This increases the likelihood of God responding in some way. I have never seen any suggestion from a Catholic source that they think Mary can intervene directly, other than by asking God to do so. The only logical objection I can see to this, if we take the existence of Mary, God, and us as givens, is either that Mary is not in heaven (e.g. not yet raised), or is unable to pray, or unwilling to do so, or that God will not hear her prayers. The use of statues is a different thing, and is believed by Catholics to be merely a symbolic use. in the same way that protestants use a cross to symbolise their faith. They don’t think it is
the topic was about the difference between praying and worshiping actually faith, just a symbol.

Of course, as I am an unbeliever these are simply observations from outside. I hope that unjacks your thread! 🙂
The topic was the difference between worship and simply praying to Mary. Not the value of Marys exemple to women.
 
The topic was the difference between worship and simply praying to Mary. Not the value of Marys example to women.
I understood the point and am happy to avoid issues you feel are outside this. Hence my last post. You may be missing the point that Catholics in my understanding pray to Mary seeking her intercession because she is held to be a role model and, as an exemplar of human behaviour, is better able to intercede with God than less perfect humans. This is not a different topic, but the reason Catholics ask Mary to pray for them more often than they do Rory O’Catholic down the street. I hope you get some more responses from believing Catholics to develop the point from their perspective.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top