Please don’t shut up if you have more valuable info. Studying these things my husband and I have different hang ups. Also it really me doing the studying and bringing these things forward.
Well - OK…If you really want me to…but don’t say I didn’t warn you…(laughs evilly -bwaahaahaahaa)
Based on the fact that the doctrine of sola scriptura is not biblical (circular logic) we have both come to the conclusion that God’s people must interpret scripture and be guided by the holy spirit.
You have come to a good and sound conclusion. Now this needs to be taken to the next level.
When you say that, “God’s people must interpret Scripture…guided by the Holy Spirit”, are you referring to individuals interpreting privately for themselves - or do you mean “as a group” (ekklesia) coming together to interpret. This is a very important point and distinction. Paul praised the Bereans for studying Scripture…but did they do this privately or as a group?
In Mt 18:15-18 we see Jesus giving instruction to the Apostles on how to deal with issues and conflicts that might come up in the “Church” (ekklesia in the Greek). In reading this passage it is important to recognize that, since teaching a false doctrine (different Gospel) is a sin, the “sin” referred to in vs 15 can certainly include doctrinal disputes. So, as we see the process unfold, we find that when problems cannot be settled quietly the issue is brought before “The Church”. We are then instructed to “Listen to The Church” on pain of separation from the community - the body of believers.
Jesus makes a truly remarkable statement here - one which He makes one other time in the Gospels…He grants His authority to the Church to “bind or loose”. What may they “bind or loose? Jesus says they may bind or loose"whatever”. A very broad authority indeed - given to “The Church”, not to individuals.
Now in many protestant traditions (so I’ve been told) this passage is read as meaning the “local community” not a “universal” community…But what about when two local communities are at odds with each other? Again we turn to the bible. This time to Acts 15 where we see the instructions of Mt 18 played out beautifully. The trouble starts because the Jewish Christians and the Gentile Christians in Antioch disagree over what is required to be a Christian. We can just see this in our mind’s eye…They argue, they debate, they point to Scripture etc…eventually Paul is brought into the discussion and not even he can resolve the matter. So - what do they do? They send a delegation to Jerusalem to meet with the “Elders of the Church”. There, after much debate, a decision is reached. The decision there is not limited to a single local community, but is authoritative throughout the Church - everywhere. That is, Universally (katholikos = catholic)
As additional evidence of the NT pointing to a visible and authoritative Church, I could add Jesus prayer that we be one as He and the Father are one. I could also add the several verses in the NT letters that call for unity, praising with one voice, being of one mind, of avoiding dissensions etc…All of which point to a visible unity with authority exercised through council .
This is precisely the model used by
both of the ancient Christian Churches, the RC and the EO.
Now - when I am discussing authority with someone - this is the point where I ask them to provide equally compelling bible references for the “invisible church”, “local community”, “private interpretation” model. The conversation almost always falls silent shortly after that.
Think about how differently Acts 15 would have been written if the local community - non-authoritative - private interpretation model were in effect. There would be no Council of Jerusalem and Antioch would wind up with two separate communities (one Jewish Christian and one Gentile Christian) each holding and teaching differing doctrines on what is necessary for salvation.
My husband doesn’t see that any institution has more authority or special gift to do that any better than himself or other people he “feels” is correct.
Your husband makes a very common mistake. He sees the “institution” as somehow separate from the community. Yet “institutions” are “instituted”
by the community to uphold the principles of the community and for the good of the community.
The Church structure does not exist to “impose” but rather to listen, to teach, to protect, to defend, to propagate the known Truths of the Gospel that were usually arrived at through councilior discussion (formal or informal).
In addition the Church provides a structure and a forum for discussion and debate, for review and careful development of teachings. Far from being restrictive in this, the institutions and offices of the Church provide a great freedom to explore, not only scripture, but also all of the great writings and Spirit guided understandings and teachings down through nearly 2 millenia.
A great writer and convert to Catholicism, G.K. Chesterton wrote that, “if the Catholic Church has built walls, they are walls around a playground”.
One more thing about the whole idea of being of one mind, united in Christ as He is united with the Father…
Such unity in doctrine should be the goal of every true Christian. Humility and a desire to truly follow Christ demands of us that we seek unity one with the other. Institutions, councils etc all speak to this desire of Christians to be One as Jesus and our Heavenly Father are one.
I’ve written a lot here…and I hope I am not too far off the topics that you wish to discuss.
But you asked for it…

Feel free to ask any questions you might have.
Peace
James