A
AlanFromWichita
Guest
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/20a17/20a1714b4440876ff9ec31d77e5b3cfdd66c544e" alt="40.png"
The reaction to what? Finding that someone is less than Fully Assenting, or the reaction to being called “cafeteria Catholic” in a clearly, unambiguously pejorative way?The reaction should be fraternal correction.
If you’re talking about the way to correct an alleged CC, then what is an example of fraternal correction when one encounters one? Getting back to the thread title, do you consider calling a person a “cafeteria Catholic” with contempt conveyed either explicitly, implicitly, or by societal convention, an absolute example of fraternal correction, a negative example of fraternal correction, or does it vary depending on the circumstances?
Please assume for the sake of this question that we are not talking about just plain good-natured bantering and mock insults, but an honest attempt to help remove the log from the brother’s eye?
Alan