Why can’t God create miracles that are ‘strong evidence’ to an atheist? If he wants us to believe, he should do something about it.
God has provided compelling enough evidence to convert countless atheists over the course of history. Sometimes He gives this evidence in the form of a personal supernatural encounter, sometimes in the form of philosophical proof, and sometimes an objective experience or proof that they cannot explain away. He reaches out to atheists in many ways and proves His reality to them. Many atheists eventually convert to Christianity or Catholicism.
However, you are right that God could do MORE. He could provide such impressive wonders that everyone on Earth would have no choice whatsoever but to believe. But He doesn’t behave in that way.
The reason is that He wants us to have freedom. He doesn’t want to force us to worship Him or choose Him. He wants us to choose to love Him freely. If He proved Himself in such ways that everyone was forced to believe, whether they wanted to or not, then they would not have truly given their hearts to Him and they would have no choice in whether or not to give themselves to Him (even as He gave Himself to them, on the Cross). Many would conclude, “well, that’s it, God exists, so I guess I have to believe in Him and do what He wants.”
God wants everyone to desire Him and come to Him with love, freely. So whenever someone really wants God, they seek Him, and they find Him. He gives them enough evidence, or He speaks to them directly – He reveals Himself in some sufficient way to inspire faith in their hearts. But when people
don’t want to know God, He gives them the freedom in this life to choose
not to come to Him, live in His Life or love Him. He gives sufficient evidence to reach out to those that really want Him, while He hides Himself enough that those who don’t want Him have the freedom to continue to reject Him.
And among those who seek God, there are false seekers of God and true seekers of God. There are people who claim to be seeking God, but will only accept a God who fits into a certain pre-conceived description, and thus these people sometimes rule out the real God because they are more attached to their current beliefs about Him, and aren’t willing to humbly seek the reality, even if it differs from what they now believe. They are more attached to mistaken beliefs about God than they are to the search for truth, so they wouldn’t let go of their errors even if the truth was presented in a highly compelling way. To a large extent, you know, people believe what they desire in their hearts to believe.
Also, there are people who think of themselves as seeking God, but who prefer themselves, their own lifestyles, their own way of doing things, sinful habits or possessions to any truth or reality that might require sacrifice of them, or might require them to put God ahead of these things. So these people also may be seeking God, but they shut Him out of their lives by preferring other things and not being willing to seriously consider a reality or truth that contradicts what they have or want right now.
Then there are seekers after God who are really willing to put Him before everything and seek Him first, and He is most important to them. These people are humble. God gives these people whatever they need to convince them of the truth, and if they don’t have enough evidence given them in this life, they will nonetheless be saved because they put Truth first in their lives and sought it first. Christ is Truth, so when they sought truth so sincerely and faithfully, even if they did not find it in this life because it was not well presented to them or they never came in contact with Catholicism, by putting truth first, they were putting Christ first in their lives. He said not only, “I am the Omega,” but also, “I am the Way,” so these people seeking truth are already on the way of truth, living for Christ. So they inherit Him.
He said in the Gospels that everyone who seeks finds. Everyone who really is interested in truth and willing to conform themselves to it even if they don’t like it will be saved. They are the real seekers. But those that aren’t seeking it don’t really want it, and they won’t join God when they die because they never actually wanted to be with Him.
In summary,
I apologize that my responses to you are lackluster. I am demotived when discussing religious evidence. Religious evidence is hocus pocus. Not because of the ‘weak vs poor evidence’ debate, but because it is not important to the purpose of religion - living a happy life.
I don’t understand what you said here. Could you clarify it for me?
Is Father Pio a fraud, is the Buddha real? The one who asks these questions is like the man shot with an arrow. He asks where it came from, and what material it is, before letting anyone pull it out.
edit: And that youtube link / Can’t watch here in the office as we have a companywide firewall on youtube. I am willing to debate a few evidences further if you wish, but note that it is not important.
Dr. Ricardo Castañón, P.H.D., gave this presentation at a Faith and Science Conference. The actual presentation is an hour long. What was provided in the link I gave you is only a clip from it.
The man was an atheistic scientist, but he converted to Catholicism after spending years studying the human brain, Eucharistic Miracles and some of the seers of the Catholic Church. This helped him to find the relationship between faith and reason.