Wrong religion vs. the right one

  • Thread starter Thread starter cho_pilo
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
OP: The key ideas here to recall are that God is just; hence God is reasonable, Christianity is “a reasonable religion”, etc. He’s not going to punish you for anything other than what you’re responsible for.

That being said, you should have some idea of what you are responsible for: You have the obligation to seek truth, i.e. to not be lazy and accept whatever the television says, Lady Gaga sings, or celebrities speculate… You have the obligation to help others, not to go through life with blinders on.

So if you continually seek truth and help others, you either will wind up as a Christian (doing all those things that God commands because you’ll want to please God, like being Baptized and receiving the Eucharist) or else continue along that path until you die, at which point you will meet Jesus at the moment of your death, and “finally become a Christian then”, so to speak. (I’m speaking a bit loosely here.)

(“Seeking truth”, by the way, generally includes learning about your reality, about life on earth: Studying philosophy and history, and learning about what is happening and what has happened … Studying history, for example, leads one to realize that Jesus was crucified, and did resurrect from the dead, and hence that Mohammedanism – so called “Islam” – is a false religion, as it denies these historical realities, among many others, etc.)
 
Dear cho pilo,

You remember how I was talking about the fact that the Eucharist, bread and wine, once consecrated by a priest, becomes literally the Flesh and Blood of Jesus? It only continues to appear as bread and wine, while in reality it is Flesh and Blood? Well, sometimes, the Lord has proven this reality for all the world to see by performing what is called a “Eucharistic Miracle.” In these cases, at the moment when a priest consecrates the bread and wine and it turns into Flesh and Blood, the Lord removes the appearance of bread and wine so that everyone can see it is Flesh and Blood. Then He leaves the Eucharistic Host continuing to appear as Flesh and Blood.

Scientific studies are then done, verifying that these visibly transformed Hosts are real human flesh and blood, taken from a man’s heart tissue, that they all have the same blood type, AB, and other characteristics. A host that recently was made by God to visibly appear as Flesh and Blood in Buenos Aires has had scientific studies performed on it, and they were able to also prove that the heart tissue was still alive while they were doing their studies on it, and the man it had come from was tortured severely (Christ was Crucified, and it was His Living Heart they were studying, and it is this that is given to us in the Eucharist). You can view a reasonably short youtube video on this subject, here: youtube.com/watch?v=qbg_dhI4XCs

Here’s a website that contains stories, information and photos of many Eucharistic Miracles. It shows a Vatican exhibition of many of the Eucharistic Miracles of our history: therealpresence.org/eucharst/mir/engl_mir.htm

For a larger collection of Eucharistic Miracles, and the evidence verifying their reality, one can purchase Joan Cruz’s book on Eucharistic Miracles. She also has written a book called “The Incorruptibles,” which details the available information about many extremely holy saints whose bodies have never decayed, though they were not mummified, and no preservation techniques were implemented. Some of the saints are called “incorruptibles,” because their bodies, even though often exposed to water or damp for long periods of time, or to lime or other agents that increase the rate of decay, never in fact decayed. This is a fulfillment of the prophecy in Psalms that the Lord will not see fit to have His holy one endure corruption. The holy one is Christ, Who was raised from the dead, but the saints are the people on Earth who are most conformed to His likeness, and as a gift to them and a special sign of favor, God sometimes keeps their bodies from ever experiencing corruption either. So they remain here on Earth, not decayed, looking as though they are just sleeping. Sometimes they grow dry or hard over the course of centuries, and in some cases there is some slight decay or discoloration, but they remain intact and not decayed. You can read more about this miraculous phenomenon on these websites:

catholicapologetics.info/library/gallery/incorrupt/incorrupt.htm
fisheaters.com/relics.html
incorruptibles.info/

The phenomenon of incorruptibility only occurs to Catholic saints. Not to Protestants or to any non-Christians. It is therefore a proof that God particularly favors the Catholic Church and has given her a particular gift of holiness.
 
Another topic worth knowing about, regarding the saints, is the mystical phenomenon known as the stigmata. A saint or other deeply devout Catholic is given by God an extraordinary degree of union with Jesus’ Passion. They experience piercing pain in their bodies, in those parts of the body where the Lord was wounded. Blood flows from wounds that physically appear on their bodies in these places, nail holes in the hands and feet, lash marks on their backs and sometimes wounds on their heads where the crown of thorns pierced Christ. The wounds open on their own and then close on their own, without any medical intervention. Usually the wounds of the stigmatist appear for a few hours on Fridays (the day of the Lord’s Passion), or during Church seasons or holy days particularly designated to the suffering of Christ. This phenomenon has occurred many times in history, and the only verifiable cases have involved Catholics, especially saints. St. Francis of Assisi was the first person recorded as having experienced this form of mystical union with Christ’s Passion, in the Medieval Ages.

The Catholic Encyclopedia has the following article on the stigmata:
newadvent.org/cathen/14294b.htm

There have been hundreds of Catholic stigmatists documented in history. Their wounds, which have many times been proven were NOT self-inflicted, are a testimony to the truth of the Catholic faith. If Christ did not die for our sins and rise again, there would be no point in God uniting all these people with His Passion in so visceral and physical a way. Nor would there be a reason for the spiritual forms of union with His Passion they have endured . . . many saints and mystics have endured union with His Passion spiritually, or in ecstasy, going through tremendous pains in union with Him, bringing forth the grace of His Passion to help the lives of others, through these sacrificial prayers. The sufferings they endured in spirit were often much more severe than physical sufferings. All of this proves that the Passion and Resurrection of Christ conquered sin and raises us all to new life, if we believe in Him. It is testimony to the truth of the Catholic faith.

There are many, many other evidences I can point you to, by which God has shown that the Catholic faith is true.

For instance, we have thousands of canonized saints, and most of these saints performed many miracles. Some of these miracles had to be proven to be real, supernatural miracles by careful investigations of the Vatican, before the saints could be canonized. God has uniquely favored the Catholic Church with a particular abundance of miracles. The reality of God, of God’s love for humanity, and of His particular favor to those who follow Him most faithfully in the Catholic Church, is all proven by the reality of these miracles.

Here are miracles from a few Catholic saints:

padrepio.catholicwebservices.com/ENGLISH/Miracles.htm
catholicism.org/br-andre.html
newadvent.org/cathen/08520b.htm
stgemmagalgani.com/2010/09/miracles-of-saint-gemma-galgani.html

I could keep going on and on with more evidence . . . I’ve listed above some of the large categories of evidence one could look at, though. There’s a ton more detail that one could go into, with each category. For instance, I’ve only brought up a few of the miracles of St. Padre Pio, St. Andre Bessette, St. Gemma Galgani, and St. Joseph Cupertino, but there were many more and there is a ton of confirmation one can look at, for these miracles, and these are only four saints out of thousands. And then there are the prophecies of the canonized saints, so many of which have been fulfilled, against all the odds. Many other mystical phenomenon as well surrounded them, which I haven’t even touched on at all.

And I haven’t even spoken at all about the miracles of the Immaculate Conception at Lourdes, the Miraculous Medal, the image of Our Lady of Guadaloupe, or the Shroud of Turin. Or about how our Lady of Siluva, through a series of apparitions, converted the entire country of Lithuania (which was Calvinist) to Catholicism, and Our Lady of Guadaloupe converted vast numbers of Mexicans from Aztec barbarism to Catholicism.

My posts above have only scratched the surface of the evidence proving the truth of the Catholic faith. Tell me if you want more, or have questions about what I said above, or any other comments!
 
My posts above have only scratched the surface of the evidence proving the truth of the Catholic faith. Tell me if you want more, or have questions about what I said above, or any other comments!
Lief Erikson - I appreciate your posts. The main problem is that of which constitutes proof or evidence. Many or all of your examples are not evidence to me or to some. You need to understand why before continuing. I suggest wikipedia “burden of proof” or even start at “evidence” and spend a few months researching this until you understand why I don’t see eye to eye with the evidence suggested in your posts.
 
Lief Erikson - I appreciate your posts. The main problem is that of which constitutes proof or evidence. Many or all of your examples are not evidence to me or to some. You need to understand why before continuing. I suggest wikipedia “burden of proof” or even start at “evidence” and spend a few months researching this until you understand why I don’t see eye to eye with the evidence suggested in your posts.
Dear cho pilo,

I would love to understand why the signs I have given you are not compelling to you. But I want to understand from you why you feel the way you do, rather than going on a quest for months to try to prove my way of thinking incorrect. Would you please explain to me why these proofs don’t seem to be evidence to you?

I have spent a lot of time writing for you in this thread, so would you please do me this favor? 🙂 I’d appreciate it very much!

With love and respect,

Lief
 
Dear cho pilo,

I would love to understand why the signs I have given you are not compelling to you. But I want to understand from you why you feel the way you do, rather than going on a quest for months to try to prove my way of thinking incorrect. Would you please explain to me why these proofs don’t seem to be evidence to you?

I have spent a lot of time writing for you in this thread, so would you please do me this favor? 🙂 I’d appreciate it very much!

With love and respect,

Lief
I clicked a random link from your post:

padrepio.catholicwebservices.com/ENGLISH/Miracles.htm
One miracle that has been identified as Padre Pio’s first miracle occurred in 1908. At that time he lived in the monastery of Montefusco. One day he gathered chestnuts growing in a nearby forest into a bag and sent the bag to Pietrelcina to his aunt Daria. She always had a great affection for him. The woman received and ate the chestnuts. She saved the bag as a souvenir. A few days later she was looking for something in a drawer where her husband usually kept the gun powder. It was in the evening so she used a candle to light up the room when suddenly the drawer caught on fire, and aunt Daria’s face got burned. After a moment, she took the bag father Pio sent and put it on her face. Immediately, her pain disappeared and no wound or burn mark remained on her face.
Is this compelling evidence or not? What is the criteria for proof?

The first question that pops into my mind when I read it was - why should I believe that? Who wrote it? Where does the story come from and why should I believe that it really happened?

Perhaps Father Pio was motivated by fame and fabricated the story. Why am I to assume he should be trusted?

Maybe the woman was no expert on burns - it is quite possible she felt the heat of the fire but it was not enough to burn her. She instantly felt relief possibly because the bag was cold.
A good woman’s husband was very sick. The woman ran to the convent, but she asked herself, “How do I reach father Pio?" She had to wait for at least three days if she wanted to meet him for a confession. So during the Mass she stood-up and walked from one side of the Church to the other. Finally, she decided to tell Our Lady what her problem was and asked at the same moment for Padre Pio’s help. After the Mass, she started to move into the Church again, in order to reach Father Pio. Finally, she managed to reach the famous corridor where Father Pio had to pass. As soon as father Pio watched her, he said: “Woman with a little faith, when will you finally ask for my help? Do you think I am deaf? You have already told me it five times when you were in front of me, at my back, on my right and on my left. I understood! I understood! …Go home! Everything is OK." She went home and found her husband was healed.
Did Father Pio cure her husband, or did the husband’s immune system or the medicine finally work. It could have been good timing.

All of Father Pio’s miracles are easily debatable. They do not constitute as evidence.

I think the same could be said for almost any source of evidence you posted.

Rather than refer to Wikipedia which is maybe a little lame - get the book “A Guide to Critical Thinking” I think it is around the 11th edition by now so a pleasure to read. I wholeheartedly recommend it.
 
=cho pilo;7854831]Are the consequence infinite, irrepairable? Does one have to “get it right in this one lifetime or burn in hell forever”?
  • If these are the feared consequences, … 🤷
GREAT Q:thumbsup:

Certainly “One MUST get it right!”,

BUT what does “right” mean and what is “right?”

Not up to writting a book at the moment; so here are the chapter headings
  1. Is right…RIGHT?
  2. Can I actually know “right”?
  3. Do I haveta Know “right”"
  4. How can I possibily Know 'right"?
  5. How important is it to know “right”?
  6. Who determines “right”?
  7. Is their ONLY ONE “right”?
  8. What happens of I don’t like “right”?
  9. What happens if I don;t like “right” but do it anyway?
  10. Why is every chapter a Question?
God Bless,
Pat
 
Rather than refer to Wikipedia which is maybe a little lame - get the book “A Guide to Critical Thinking” I think it is around the 11th edition by now so a pleasure to read. I wholeheartedly recommend it.
I received an A in a university course on critical thinking and debate, and have studied evidence. One of my professors told me that if he and I ever were in a debate, he hoped he would be on my side. If there’s a section in the book, “A Guide to Critical Thinking,” that shows in a logical way that miracles cannot exist or be proven beyond reasonable doubt, I’d be glad to read it, if you post it here.

I am curious. Why do you believe that all of what I have sent you is “not evidence”?
I clicked a random link from your post:

padrepio.catholicwebservices.com/ENGLISH/Miracles.htm

Is this compelling evidence or not? What is the criteria for proof?

The first question that pops into my mind when I read it was - why should I believe that? Who wrote it? Where does the story come from and why should I believe that it really happened?
Very sound, valid questions. I don’t know the sources for the stories on the website. I tend to believe them because many very knowledgeable and thorough people, including both Vatican experts and non-Catholic researchers, have investigated Padre Pio’s life and miracles, and have found a great deal of proof that many miracles attributed to him are genuine. Though I know there are skeptics who are incredulous of all miracles or supernatural phenomenon, and through bias, they will assume everything is false no matter what, and will cling to anything other than the supernatural or spiritual explanation, no matter how feeble their arguments are.
Perhaps Father Pio was motivated by fame and fabricated the story. Why am I to assume he should be trusted?
Because of how tremendous his love for people was. He spent twelve hours a day in the confessional, during long periods of his life. That is very painful! It is extremely hard on the body to endure day after day of sitting in one position on a wooden plank, hearing the worst things about people’s lives being poured out to you for absolution, for years.

Also, Padre Pio laid down his life for others, suffering terribly in body and soul for love of other people.* You know, in the Catholic Church, we believe that suffering can be offered up as a prayer to heal others, draw them into holiness or in other ways change their lives for the better. People sometimes have flagellated themselves or fasted for long periods of time, or spent all night in prayer for people, making these sacrificial prayers out of love for others. Padre Pio lashed himself three days a week, and war the cilice. When he was a child, he slept with a rock as his pillow and deliberately deprived himself of food, even though his family had meager rations already. He did this all for love of God and souls, believing that through these sacrificial prayers made in union with the Passion of Christ, sinners would be converted. Padre Pio’s quarters in his religious order also were extremely stark and austere, though huge amounts of money passed through his hands, because he was responsible for building a hospital project for the injured of World War 2, a project he started and spearheaded to completion. Padre Pio had great integrity and suffered much for love of people and of God.

Padre Pio’ss humility was also extreme. He lived in a tough Capuchin religious order, but he humbly obeyed all the orders he was given by his superiors, without complaint. When his superiors doubted his mystical gifts, they put him in isolation from the outside world for TEN YEARS, and he remained in isolation, cut off from all the people he had been helping and many people he loved. He submitted to this ten years of isolation, out of obedience. He could have left the religious house and formed his own church, like rejected false mystics have done, out of various loyal followers. He conquered his self-will by submitting to these ten years of isolation out of obedience. During those ten years, he endured many accusations from fellow religious of having invented the phenomenon he was experiencing and pouring out to others, but he was silent when accused and criticized, and would not defend himself. All this takes great humility.
 
Did Father Pio cure her husband, or did the husband’s immune system or the medicine finally work. It could have been good timing.
I accept that one could argue some of Padre Pio’s miracles might have been merely “good timing.” The same is surely true with some of the miracles of other saints, as well. Some miracles could be very clearly only understood as miraculous whereas others could be interpreted as having natural explanations.
michaeljournal.org:
The “flying monk”
It is impossible to do justice to the entire array of miracles worked by Padre Pio. They are endless, and they have transcended his death. One day, recounts Ruffin, a priest named Padre Constantino “entered Pio’s room and was struck by what he saw. ‘His countenance was shining with a rosy flame of light such as I had never seen before and shall, I think, never see again. It was but for an instant, but I shall never forget it.’ This phenomenon was observed in Moses when he came down from Sinai with the two tables of the Law in his hands.”
As for the sky phenomenon: “There are many stories concerning allied pilots who attempted to bomb San Giovanni but were stopped by an apparition of a ‘monk’ standing in the air with his arms outstretched,” says Ruffin. “There are fliers who swore that they had sighted a figure in the sky, sometimes normal size, sometimes gigantic, usually in the form of a monk or priest. The sightings were too frequent and the reports came from too many sources to be totally discounted. Several people from Foggia, where thousands were killed in the air raids, said that a bomb, falling into a room where they had huddled, landed near a photograph of Padre Pio. They claimed that when it exploded, it ‘burst like a soap bubble.’ Others reported that while bombs were raining down upon the city, they cried, ‘Padre Pio, you have to save us!’ While they were speaking, a bomb fell into their midst, but did not explode.”
Bernardo Rosini, a general of the Italian Air Force, told a story: “At Bari was located the general command of the U.S. Air Force. I know several officers who told me of having been saved by Padre Pio during air missions.
“One day,” General Rosini continued, “an American commander wanted to lead a squadron of bombers himself to destroy the German arms depository of war material that was located at San Giovanni Rotondo. The commander related that as he approached the target, he and his pilots saw rising in the sky the figure of a friar with his hands held outward. The bombs released of their own accord, falling in the woods, and the planes completely reversed course without any intervention by the pilots.”
Someone told the commanding general that in a convent at this little town of San Giovanni Rotondo, there lived a saintly man, a friar in the odor of sanctity. At war’s end, the general wanted to go meet this person. “He was accompanied by several pilots,” Rosini continued. “He went to the convent of the Capuchins. As soon as he crossed the threshold of the sacrisity, he found himself in front of several friars, among whom he immediately recognized the one who had ‘stopped’ his planes. Padre Pio went forward to meet him, and putting his hand on his shoulder, he said, `So, you’re the one who wanted to get rid of us all!’”

Of all of Padre Pio’s healings, one of the most remarkable may have been a blind girl from the Palermo area named Gemma DiGiorgio. (See pictures above, the day of her First Communion.) “I had no pupils in my eyes,” said Gemma in 1971, several years after Padre Pio’s death. “I had no sight at all. When I was three months old, my mother took me to a very famous eye doctor in Palermo. He told her that, without pupils, I would never be able to see.”
In 1946, when the girl was seven, a nun took it upon herself to write Padre Pio on her behalf, and received a note saying that the girl should be brought to Padre Pio in San Giovanni Rotundo. That’s exactly what Gemma’s grandmother did: brought the girl to see the famous monk, who heard the child’s First Confession and gave her her First Communion — then made the Sign of the Cross on her eyes. After the blessing, Gemma was able to see.
Continued in the next post . . .
 
michaeljournal.org:
The eye reappears
More astounding still may be the thoroughly-documented cure of a construction worker named Giovanni Savino, who was severely injured on February 15, 1949, in a dynamite mishap. When Dr. Guglielmo San- guinetti, a physican, and Padre Raffaele, another Capuchin, and Father Dominic Meyer rushed to the injured man’s side, “all three men noted that among Savino’s numerous injuries, his right eye was gone entirely. They agreed that ‘the socket was empty’,” reports biographer Bernard Ruffin. Other doctors confirmed that the eye was completely annihilated and the other one badly damaged.
It looked like Savino was also going to be totally blind. For three days, the worker lay on a hospital bed with his head and face bandaged. When a surgeon entered the room three days later, Savino reported that Padre Pio had visited him — something Savino recognized because he had detected the beautiful aroma so often reported around the priest. A week later, at about one a.m. on February 25, 1949, Savino felt a slap on the right side of his face — the side where the eye was completely gone. “I asked, ‘Who touched me?’” testified Savino. “There was nobody. Again I smelled the aroma of Padre Pio. It was beautiful.”
When later the ophthalmologist — an atheist — came to examine the remaining eye, there was a shock. “To their amazement,” writes Ruffin, “the doctors found that his shattered face was fully healed and covered with new skin. Savino, however, was most delighted at the fact that he could see. ‘I can see you!’ he said excitedly to the eye specialist.”
And indeed, as is medically documented, the doctor saw, to his “utter astonishment”, that Savino had his right eye back. Somehow, the eye had materialized. (“Now I believe too,” exclaimed the doctor, “because of what my own hands have touched!”) As Ruffin notes, it’s one thing when diseases disappear; this is exciting. It’s tremendous to hear of diabetes or arthritis or even cancer leaving a person. “For a missing part of the body to be restored, however, is another matter,” noted the expert biographer.
It is not rational to say that all Padre Pio’s miracles “do not constitute evidence.” For even if a situation arose where one could make a strong case against one of them, one would still be debating against evidence. Perhaps the evidence is “weak,” “poor,” or even “completely flawed,” but to say it is not evidence at all is not true. If there wasn’t any evidence whatsoever, there would be nothing to debate about. The question is how good the evidence is, not whether or not it exists. For it is indisputable that vast numbers of people claim Padre Pio performed real miracles. They bring up testimonies of people who experienced the miracles, as well as medical proofs of supernatural healings and of the stigmata Padre Pio experienced, and eyewitnesses to various other phenomenon like bilocation or levitation involving Padre Pio. It would be close-minded to say that all of this is simply “not evidence,” because one doesn’t believe in such things.
I think the same could be said for almost any source of evidence you posted.
I hope you are not the sort of person that will judge every article I’ve sent you without having even read them. Though I admit that several of them aren’t written to persuade skeptics. I wasn’t aware that that was your attitude, when I sent them to you.

I definitely recommend you read this article on Zeitoun, and the watch the following youtube presentation on the Eucharistic Miracle in Buennos Aires, at any rate:

youtube.com/watch?v=qbg_dhI4XCs

zeitun-eg.org/zeitoun1.ht

The Archbishop’s statement about the apparitions of Betania, which I sent you above in an earlier post, and the Catholic Encyclopedia article on stigmatists, are also written in a thorough fashion, covering these phenomenon.
 
Because I am an atheist, I do not believe that there is such a thing as a “right religion.” There are literally hundreds and hundreds of religions on this Earth that people practice, so it would be impossible, literally speaking, to “know” which one is the correct religion, if there is one. However, I do believe that there are religions that will benefit you more than others. I think, obviously, Catholicism is going to benefit you more than LeVeyan Satanism or old Norse religions. Practicing an old Norse religion is not going to teach you how to be moral (even though morality is a choice). There are no life lessons with Norse mythology, just stories that mean absolutely nothing. Christianity has a lot more history, especially Catholicism. So please, do not fret over this. You’re worrying yourself for no reason. Just continue believing what you believe and carry on. Sorry if that sounds harsh, but things like this are hard to address.
 
Hi greeny93,

I’m so happy that you are interested in RICA because you will find it informing.
You sound like an intelligent person searching for truth with an open mind.

Many people have been atheists and eventually become some of the most
avid Christians once they know what it is really about and hear the real
story. One thing I might suggest is, say these words as much as you
can thru out the day,

“God, if it is true that you exist, please convince me of it”.

You don’t have to mean them. If you do, all the better. But say the words
anyway. You are interested in RICA because your searching and not quite
certain about reality and non reality of all this. You will be pleasantly surprised
with the results these words will bring to your understanding.

I’m sure all our brethern, Protestant, Islamic, Jewish, Catholic, and I know the
rest as well are pulling for you.​

“I know the sun is shinning even when it isn’t shinning.” Christian hymn
 
I received an A in a university course on critical thinking and debate, and have studied evidence. One of my professors told me that if he and I ever were in a debate, he hoped he would be on my side. If there’s a section in the book, “A Guide to Critical Thinking,” that shows in a logical way that miracles cannot exist or be proven beyond reasonable doubt, I’d be glad to read it, if you post it here.
It is most beneficial if you go through the entire book, as it is has university-level tasks that guide the reader to understanding. Homework and so forth. It is not only relevant to religion and I think it costs under $20. It’s the best book I ever bought, and I read it something like 5 times before I was 20. If you don’t want to read it, so be it. But by reading it you will understand my thoughts on your thoughts 100%.
I am curious. Why do you believe that all of what I have sent you is “not evidence”?
Sorry you are right I should have been more careful. It is evidence, just not evidence that convinces me. I bite my tongue.
I hope you are not the sort of person that will judge every article I’ve sent you without having even read them.
No judgement. And you’re right I did not read everything you linked to me. I said ‘I think’ because I have read near all the evidence there is for miracles and so forth as I was born a Christian, and am no longer one. I am no longer one due to thorough research. I don’t feel the need to go detail by detail so much, as one’s views on the quality of evidence will be near isomorphic across the board.
I read through it, and as a business-minded person, I can see how a hired magician could create loads of money for years to come with an act like this. There is a defined motive, and plausible scenarios like bright rooftop lights with an actor, and all-too-willing-to-believe observers.

The photos could have been themselves doctored. But I think what I first said was true.​

Why can’t God create miracles that are ‘strong evidence’ to an atheist? If he wants us to believe, he should do something about it.

In summary,

I apologize that my responses to you are lackluster. I am demotived when discussing religious evidence. Religious evidence is hocus pocus. Not because of the ‘weak vs poor evidence’ debate, but because it is not important to the purpose of religion - living a happy life.

Is Father Pio a fraud, is the Buddha real? The one who asks these questions is like the man shot with an arrow. He asks where it came from, and what material it is, before letting anyone pull it out.

edit: And that youtube link / Can’t watch here in the office as we have a companywide firewall on youtube. I am willing to debate a few evidences further if you wish, but note that it is not important.
 
It is most beneficial if you go through the entire book, as it is has university-level tasks that guide the reader to understanding. Homework and so forth. It is not only relevant to religion and I think it costs under $20. It’s the best book I ever bought, and I read it something like 5 times before I was 20. If you don’t want to read it, so be it. But by reading it you will understand my thoughts on your thoughts 100%.
I’m sure it’s a good book, but you’re right, I don’t want to read it. However, would you do me a favor?

I’ve taken a good deal of time to write up for you some of the reasons I believe as I do. You seem to believe that critical thinking and logical reasoning rule out the possibility of miracles. Would you do me the favor of explaining why you think the way you do, on this?

Is there a quote in the book, which you could post here, that explains in a clearly logical way why there cannot be miracles? I am curious why you believe what you do on this. Requiring that I buy a book on a subject I’ve already studied, a book that I don’t believe will prove me wrong, in order to try to prove myself wrong, isn’t very useful to me, though I know you respect the book very much. Would you answer my question directly, instead?
Sorry you are right I should have been more careful. It is evidence, just not evidence that convinces me. I bite my tongue.

No judgement. And you’re right I did not read everything you linked to me. I said ‘I think’ because I have read near all the evidence there is for miracles and so forth as I was born a Christian, and am no longer one. I am no longer one due to thorough research. I don’t feel the need to go detail by detail so much, as one’s views on the quality of evidence will be near isomorphic across the board.
What books did you read, in your research?
I read through it, and as a business-minded person, I can see how a hired magician could create loads of money for years to come with an act like this. There is a defined motive, and plausible scenarios like bright rooftop lights with an actor, and all-too-willing-to-believe observers.
You haven’t looked into this phenomenon at all. Scientific studies have been done on the Eucharistic Hosts. All Eucharistic Hosts have blood type AB, and are human flesh taken from a human heart with surgical precision. Some experts have been able to trace from signs of stress on the heart and such that the man the heart belonged to was tortured severely. The surgical precision with which the heart was cut did not exist in the centuries many of these Hosts date from. In the case of the Eucharist of Lanciano, they found that the globs of flesh weigh the same amount if one of them is on the scale as if all of them were on the scale together – a mystery that defies physics. The Eucharistic Host from Buennos Aires was found to be a living heart that was still alive while it was being examined. This stunned the scientist studying it (who was not aware he was studying a Eucharist, at the time).

Also, what you say requires a massive conspiracy theory and impinges on the characters of a great many priests without evidence.

What you just said reminds me of the atheists’ conspiracy theories about the Miracle of the Holy Fire in Jerusalem. Each Easter, in the Church of the Holy Sepulchre, around the tomb of Jesus Christ, the patriarch of Jerusalem goes into the church with unlit candles. A luminous flame, sometimes shaped like a dove, appears out of nowhere, floats over to the candles and lights them for him. The candles of other people, including many onlookers, spontaneously light also. Sometimes the luminous dove or hovering flame flies out and lights the unlit torches or candles of many other people who are present.

This miracle has been occurring regularly in the Church of the Holy Sepulchre on Easter for 2,000 years. The first written record of it is in the 4th century, describing how this miracle started happening in the 1st century with the Apostle Peter. There are many records of this miracle from the 4th century to the present. The enormity of the conspiracy theory required to explain this phenomenon is immense. All the patriarchs of Jerusalem for 2,000 years, including some extremely holy and virtuous men, would have to have been liars. Also, candles have been being catching aflame spontaneously since the early days of the miracle, long before the existence of trick candles, matches or lighters. There have always been large numbers of witnesses of these phenomenon. So the kinds of atheistic conspiracy theories surrounding the Miracle of the Holy Fire have to be very outlandish. So much so I considered for a while writing a fiction book to make fun of them, a book that has a premise that the conspiracy theories are true, and then goes on to show the ludicrous extremes the Orthodox Church had to go to in order to keep the miracle’s cover and keep it going.
The photos could have been themselves doctored. But I think what I first said was true.
Many of these Eucharistic Miracles are visible to all. All you have to do is go to the local church where the Eucharist is kept and it’s kept out where the public can see it, or paraded out for veneration from time to time. So doctoring the photos would be pointless. Besides, why doctor the photos if you’re going to allow scientists to do studies on the Hosts? The Church has allowed numerous scientific studies on the Hosts, as it is interested in examining these phenomenon.
 

Why can’t God create miracles that are ‘strong evidence’ to an atheist? If he wants us to believe, he should do something about it.
God has provided compelling enough evidence to convert countless atheists over the course of history. Sometimes He gives this evidence in the form of a personal supernatural encounter, sometimes in the form of philosophical proof, and sometimes an objective experience or proof that they cannot explain away. He reaches out to atheists in many ways and proves His reality to them. Many atheists eventually convert to Christianity or Catholicism.

However, you are right that God could do MORE. He could provide such impressive wonders that everyone on Earth would have no choice whatsoever but to believe. But He doesn’t behave in that way.

The reason is that He wants us to have freedom. He doesn’t want to force us to worship Him or choose Him. He wants us to choose to love Him freely. If He proved Himself in such ways that everyone was forced to believe, whether they wanted to or not, then they would not have truly given their hearts to Him and they would have no choice in whether or not to give themselves to Him (even as He gave Himself to them, on the Cross). Many would conclude, “well, that’s it, God exists, so I guess I have to believe in Him and do what He wants.”

God wants everyone to desire Him and come to Him with love, freely. So whenever someone really wants God, they seek Him, and they find Him. He gives them enough evidence, or He speaks to them directly – He reveals Himself in some sufficient way to inspire faith in their hearts. But when people don’t want to know God, He gives them the freedom in this life to choose not to come to Him, live in His Life or love Him. He gives sufficient evidence to reach out to those that really want Him, while He hides Himself enough that those who don’t want Him have the freedom to continue to reject Him.

And among those who seek God, there are false seekers of God and true seekers of God. There are people who claim to be seeking God, but will only accept a God who fits into a certain pre-conceived description, and thus these people sometimes rule out the real God because they are more attached to their current beliefs about Him, and aren’t willing to humbly seek the reality, even if it differs from what they now believe. They are more attached to mistaken beliefs about God than they are to the search for truth, so they wouldn’t let go of their errors even if the truth was presented in a highly compelling way. To a large extent, you know, people believe what they desire in their hearts to believe.

Also, there are people who think of themselves as seeking God, but who prefer themselves, their own lifestyles, their own way of doing things, sinful habits or possessions to any truth or reality that might require sacrifice of them, or might require them to put God ahead of these things. So these people also may be seeking God, but they shut Him out of their lives by preferring other things and not being willing to seriously consider a reality or truth that contradicts what they have or want right now.

Then there are seekers after God who are really willing to put Him before everything and seek Him first, and He is most important to them. These people are humble. God gives these people whatever they need to convince them of the truth, and if they don’t have enough evidence given them in this life, they will nonetheless be saved because they put Truth first in their lives and sought it first. Christ is Truth, so when they sought truth so sincerely and faithfully, even if they did not find it in this life because it was not well presented to them or they never came in contact with Catholicism, by putting truth first, they were putting Christ first in their lives. He said not only, “I am the Omega,” but also, “I am the Way,” so these people seeking truth are already on the way of truth, living for Christ. So they inherit Him.

He said in the Gospels that everyone who seeks finds. Everyone who really is interested in truth and willing to conform themselves to it even if they don’t like it will be saved. They are the real seekers. But those that aren’t seeking it don’t really want it, and they won’t join God when they die because they never actually wanted to be with Him.
In summary,

I apologize that my responses to you are lackluster. I am demotived when discussing religious evidence. Religious evidence is hocus pocus. Not because of the ‘weak vs poor evidence’ debate, but because it is not important to the purpose of religion - living a happy life.
I don’t understand what you said here. Could you clarify it for me?
Is Father Pio a fraud, is the Buddha real? The one who asks these questions is like the man shot with an arrow. He asks where it came from, and what material it is, before letting anyone pull it out.

edit: And that youtube link / Can’t watch here in the office as we have a companywide firewall on youtube. I am willing to debate a few evidences further if you wish, but note that it is not important.
Dr. Ricardo Castañón, P.H.D., gave this presentation at a Faith and Science Conference. The actual presentation is an hour long. What was provided in the link I gave you is only a clip from it.

The man was an atheistic scientist, but he converted to Catholicism after spending years studying the human brain, Eucharistic Miracles and some of the seers of the Catholic Church. This helped him to find the relationship between faith and reason.
 
=greeny93;7873500]Because I am an atheist, I do not believe that there is such a thing as a “right religion.” There are literally hundreds and hundreds of religions on this Earth that people practice, so it would be impossible, literally speaking, to “know” which one is the correct religion, if there is one. However, I do believe that there are religions that will benefit you more than others. I think, obviously, Catholicism is going to benefit you more than LeVeyan Satanism or old Norse religions. Practicing an old Norse religion is not going to teach you how to be moral (even though morality is a choice). There are no life lessons with Norse mythology, just stories that mean absolutely nothing. Christianity has a lot more history, especially Catholicism. So please, do not fret over this. You’re worrying yourself for no reason. Just continue believing what you believe and carry on. Sorry if that sounds harsh, but things like this are hard to address.
So friend why bother yourself being on a catholic Forum?

We’re glad your here but curious as to why you are here?

There is, was and always will be just one God. In the Biblr from the first page to the last period; One God; One faith and as of the Visitation of Christ ONLY one Church was and is God’s desire.

WHY? God’s Will; but being a God of Love and Mercy he allows everyone to chose what THEY wnat. The End-RESULTS will not be the same; but we have equal opportunity to chose for ourselves.

Tell me friend; do you have a Mind; Intellect and Freewill? What color are they, what shape; size, weight? Where do they come from?

God Bless you; hang around maybe; JUST MAYBE you’ll discover stuff you didn’t know:D

Pat
 
You seem to believe that critical thinking and logical reasoning rule out the possibility of miracles.
No, critical thinking does not rule out the possibility of miracles. Anything is possible. However CT shows the examples thus far to be unconvincing. This is due to weak evidence.
Is there a quote in the book,
Sorry the book is not with me. I ditched all my books to lighten my load as I pedaled through Manila a few months ago.

Again, miracles are possible. However the evidence for them is unconvincing.
What books did you read, in your research?
A guide to Critical Thinking helped me the most. I never read a book on miracles - my research was done on the Internet over a span of a few years in my early teens.
Eucharistic Host
Please show me the evidence for transubstantiation. You may have seen some flesh - but have you actually seen the bread poof into a heart?

Millions go to Vegas to be fooled by magicians.
This stunned the scientist studying it
Give me a name and their credentials. First show me evidence the scientist is achieved in something scientific. Then let me read his words on religion.
Many of these Eucharistic Miracles are visible to all.
And no I don’t believe they are doctored photos. I believe it was a show comparable to a magician’s.
Also, what you say requires a massive conspiracy theory and impinges on the characters of a great many priests without evidence.
But my theory is more likely. Because there is a clear motive, and a method to carry it out. I don’t need to rely on the supernatural to explain it.
his miracle has been occurring regularly in the Church of the Holy Sepulchre on Easter for 2,000 years.
Have you witnessed this first-hand? I might be persuaded if I did, otherwise not.
He wants us to have freedom
He doesn’t want to force us to worship Him
He wants us to choose to love Him freely
God wants everyone to desire Him and come to Him with love, freely
He gives sufficient evidence
He speaks to them directly
He reveals Himself in some sufficient way to inspire faith in their hearts.
He hides Himself enough
He draws a subtle line in the sand, revealing just enough (weak evidence) to encourage those true seekers, and discourage the rest (because the rest seek strong evidence.) It is that simple.
I don’t understand what you said here. Could you clarify it for me?
My replies are in haste. They are not thoroughly thought out word by word. This is because I am not motivated to do so. I apologize my posts are not more convincing to you or elegant or however one may put it.

The bottom line is whether one believes in miracles or not is unimportant. What is important is leading a happy life. The belief in miracles does not in any way effect one’s happiness. Religion should be about living a happy life - not about believing in miracles.

To the question of miracles - provide me with strong evidence or give up says my rational mind.
 
Tell me friend; do you have a Mind; Intellect and Freewill? What color are they, what shape; size, weight? Where do they come from?
Interesting questions. The idea of mind as a “thing” is an illusion. Mind is a function of the brain.

Definitions please.
 
=greeny93;7873500]Because I am an atheist, I do not believe that there is such a thing as a “right religion.” There are literally hundreds and hundreds of religions on this Earth that people practice, so it would be impossible, literally speaking, to “know” which one is the correct religion, if there is one. However, I do believe that there are religions that will benefit you more than others. I think, obviously, Catholicism is going to benefit you more than LeVeyan Satanism or old Norse religions. Practicing an old Norse religion is not going to teach you how to be moral (even though morality is a choice). There are no life lessons with Norse mythology, just stories that mean absolutely nothing. Christianity has a lot more history, especially Catholicism. So please, do not fret over this. You’re worrying yourself for no reason. Just continue believing what you believe and carry on. Sorry if that sounds harsh, but things like this are hard to address.
One would and could conclude such a thing; but it is based on a false Premise:

One God [ONLY] One Faith set of beliefs [ONLY] has a Tradition of God’s Will for MANY **thousands of years ** The Entire Bible; First page to last period speaks of this logical Truth.

For example was their one who made thge stars, another the moon, another the sun another earth? How i it they never got in each others way?

How is it with BILLIONS of stars and plantes only ONE can be CONFIRMED as supporting Life? And on this One Planet why ONLY ONE species that can LOVE? Humanity alone has a mind; Intellect and FREEWILL necessary for such to take place.

Atheism seems to me to have a great many holes in it; and I don’t seem them being plugged.

God Bless,
Pat
 
No, critical thinking does not rule out the possibility of miracles. Anything is possible. However CT shows the examples thus far to be unconvincing. This is due to weak evidence.
Then why were so many of the world’s most brilliant minds, including St. Paul of Tarsus, St. Augustine, the Venerable Bede, Roger Bacon (who devised the scientific method), St. Albert the Great, Saints Cyril and Methodius, St. Thomas Aquinas (who explained cause and effect relationships), Nicolaus Copernicus, Galileo Galilei (in spite of his trial), Blessed Nicolas Steno, Johann Gutenberg, Isaac Newton, Leonardo da Vinci, Gregor Mendel, “the father of modern genetics,” Louis Pasteur, James Prescott Joule, Antoine Henri Becquerel, etc. etc. etc., devout Catholics?

These people examined their beliefs carefully and had compelling reasons for believing as they did. They didn’t merely “flirt” with religion, by any means. A vast number of other, less brilliant, believers, also have strong reasons for believing as they do.

I’ve listed for you some of the grand miracles of Church history. Zeitoun, Fatima, Betania, Lourdes, the Eucharistic Miracles, the stigmatists, as well as a handful of the great wonderworkers of Catholic history. Padre Pio and the Curé d’Ars are particularly good examples here, because they are so modern and so exhaustively studied, but there are dozens of other great miracle workers whose lives are strong reasons for belief. Nobel Prize winning author and Medieval historian Sigrid Undset converted to Catholicism because of her extensive studies on the lives of the Medieval mystics, for example.

Miracles such as these are well studied and verified, and can convince true reason. But it is possible for people to cling to skepticism as though it’s a religion, and not believe what all the evidence points to, in spite of a miracle being obviously the most logical interpretation of the evidence. Skeptics are many times very unreasonable, even though they think themselves the most reasonable and enlightened. Often, if they can come up with any far-fetched means of ditching the miraculous explanation, they will hold to that, no matter how unlikely, and as if this “miracle” was the only such reported and well supported event of its kind in Earth history. And if they can’t come up with any explanation of the evidence, they’ll just say, “it’s a mystery,” and go on believing that miracles don’t happen. I’ve seen both these attitudes, and the irrationality of it is very frustrating.
Sorry the book is not with me. I ditched all my books to lighten my load as I pedaled through Manila a few months ago.
Okay.
Again, miracles are possible. However the evidence for them is unconvincing.
What you mean is that what you’ve read so far has not been sufficient to convince you (which hasn’t included any books, but only Internet searches). What many of the world’s most brilliant minds have seen, studied or experienced has been sufficient to convince them, though. What many less brilliant people, like me, have seen, studied and experienced (some firsthand and some through people I know are trustworthy) has been enough to convince us. We aren’t all hanging on weak evidence or unreasonable faith. But a truth doesn’t have to be proven in a test tube to be credible and reasonably believed. Who can prove their parents’ or children’s love for them? There are many things about life, some of which are the most important aspects of life, and we trust in them daily, without scientific proof. There is very good and strong reason to believe in these truths, though our evidence in these cases is not scientific. Even so, there is a lot of evidence supporting Catholicism, such as eyewitness testimony of various supernatural events (and we can examine the eyewitnesses for credibility) that doesn’t require science to be credible.

Though Eucharistic fasts, Eucharistic miracles, stigmata and the like are scientifically verifiable and have been scientifically studied, and sometimes discredited by science, and other times authenticated by it.
A guide to Critical Thinking helped me the most. I never read a book on miracles - my research was done on the Internet over a span of a few years in my early teens.
That’s fine, and a fair start, but hardly sufficient for you to make the kinds of sweeping claims you’ve made about all miracles, including many big ones that I’ve presented to you, and which you haven’t researched at all.
Please show me the evidence for transubstantiation. You may have seen some flesh - but have you actually seen the bread poof into a heart?

Millions go to Vegas to be fooled by magicians.
The articles I’ve presented to you have given names and dates for studies, and have outlined the conclusions they’ve been able to make about the Eucharistic Miracles.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top