Wrong religion vs. the right one

  • Thread starter Thread starter cho_pilo
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
cho pilo:
He draws a subtle line in the sand, revealing just enough (weak evidence) to encourage those true seekers,
That’s not what I said. It’s overwhelmingly sufficient evidence for me. For many others, too! But we are “open” to the possibility of the supernatural, whereas you presume everything you hear about the supernatural is false, and are willing to assume the truth of any skeptical theory you hear rather than seriously consider the possibility that God is intervening. That’s prejudice masquerading as reason.
cho pilo:
and discourage the rest (because the rest seek strong evidence.) It is that simple.
He gives plentiful evidence to those who desire Him and seek Him. To those that are closed to Him, though, He allows them sufficient wiggle room to irrationally deny and reject Him.
cho pilo:
My replies are in haste. They are not thoroughly thought out word by word. This is because I am not motivated to do so. I apologize my posts are not more convincing to you or elegant or however one may put it.
That’s completely okay; I have no issues with it :).

cho pilo said:
----
The bottom line is whether one believes in miracles or not is unimportant. What is important is leading a happy life.

No, what is important is living a truly loving life, a truly holy life. Happiness is secondary to doing what is right and being a good person. Many of the best people have suffered and died for their beliefs (like Martin Luther King Jr.), because they were so actively good, and they didn’t make their own happiness the ideal of their religion.

Religion is not just a set of rules, though. True religion is a relationship with a Person, and He infuses His Life into us to draw us into this holiness and deeper and deeper union with Him. That is the journey of sanctification, the way of the cross, the mystical road into the Heart of Christ. He infuses us with grace and supernatural help, as we pray, fast, do good works and seek Him, and through this special help He provides, we become increasingly holy.

Jesus proved His identity through one incredible miracle: His Resurrection. His other miracles proved His identity in a secondary way. He uses miracles to reach us, as well as philosophy, and for other people, science, etc. He reaches out to us through many different means to prove the truth of the Catholic faith to us, so that we can know Him in His fullness, in the Eucharist.
cho pilo:
The belief in miracles does not in any way effect one’s happiness. Religion should be about living a happy life - not about believing in miracles.
Belief in miracles does affect our happiness massively. Because we believe in the Resurrection of Christ, we believe that we will be raised if we follow Him. So we follow Him and we find deeper and deeper union with Him in this life, and this relationship spills overwhelming joy into the lives of many! 🙂 Without faith in His Resurrection, we would not come to Him in the Eucharist and receive His fullness. The Eucharist is the gem of all delights.
 
Give me a name
Dr. Ricardo Castañón Gomez, P.H.D., gave the following presentation at a Faith and Science Conference in Mexico City. The man was an atheistic scientist, but he converted to Catholicism after spending years studying the human brain, Eucharistic Miracles and some of the seers of the Catholic Church. This helped him to find the relationship between faith and reason, which I believe he describes in the presentation.

The following is Part 2 of his presentation: video.google.com/videoplay?docid=9179467206976930820# It’s about an hour long. It starts discussing Eucharistic miracles about 23 minutes in. The prior 23 minutes are about effusions of human blood, and crystal clear water and olive oil from statues and images, scientific studies done to verify these things, and such. After that, he discusses Eucharistic Miracles.

Here are a few books he’s published, which are sold on Amazon: amazon.com/s?ie=UTF8&rh=n%3A283155%2Ck%3ARicardo%20Castañon&page=1
and their credentials. First show me evidence the scientist is achieved in something scientific. Then let me read his words on religion.
Here’s a short Wikipedia article about him:

Ricardo Castañón Gómez (25 de agosto de 1948) es un Neuropsicofisiólogo boliviano. Es Doctor en Psicología Clínica, realizó estudios universitarios en Alemania e Italia. Es especializado en Medicina psicosomática, Neuropsicofísiología cognitiva.
Asimismo, realizó estudios de especialidad de Psicoterapia en Londres, Patologías en Lyon-Francia, Toxicodependencias en Berkeley-California, Bioquímica en Wheil - Alemania, Psicología aplicada en Lovaina-Bélgica. Es autor de 13 libros y más de 400 artículos de ciencia y divulgación.

es.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ricardo_Castañón_Gómez

Just google his name and you’ll find lots of websites talking about him and his work.

His Facebook page describes his expertise and accomplishments at greater length:

Es Doctor en Psicología Clínica, realizó estudios universitarios en
Alemania e Italia. Es especializado en Medicina psicosomática,
Neuropsicofísiología cognitiva.
Asimismo, realizó estudios de especialidad de Psicoterapia en Londres,
Patologías en Lyon-Francia, Toxicodependencias en Berkeley-California,
Bioquímica en Wheil - Alemania, Psicología aplicada en Lovaina-Bélgica.
Es autor de 13 libros y más de 400 artículos de ciencia y divulgación. Ha
dictado conferencias en la Universidad de Georgetown en Washington, en
la Universidad de Austin, en el Banco Interamericano de Desarrollo,
Universidad Politécnica de Madrid, Universidad de Valladolid, Saint
Joseph College de Sydney.Australia. Con el mismo motivo ha visitado,
Corea, Egipto, Israel, EEUU, Europa y las Américas realizando hasta el
presente más de 1000 conferencias.
Por su aporte científico ha sido distinguido con el Esculapio de Plata por el
Comité de Defensa Civil de las Naciones Unidas y es Académico de la
Legión de Oro, correspondiente a la Academia Tiberina de Roma.
Actualmente es Presidente e investigador del “Grupo Internacional para la
Paz”, con sede en Madrid, una organización privada, sin fines de lucro,
interesada en promover la relación existente entre la ciencia y los valores
interiores del hombre.
El Dr. Ricardo Castañón Gómez, psicólogo clínico con conocimiento especializado en la relación entre el cerebro y el comportamiento humano, ha llevado adelante una investigación acerca de las hostias que han sangrado en 1996 en Buenos Aires - Argentina; luego de más de cinco años de estudio e investigación se ha llegado a la conclusión que las muestras de las hostias son músculo de corazón.

I don’t have English translations for the Spanish.
cho pilo:
And no I don’t believe they are doctored photos. I believe it was a show comparable to a magician’s.
Judging before examining is not scientific or rational. Many scientists have examined these phenomenon in depth, like the science expert in the link I’ve provided, and have found fascinating and inexplicable results. Prejudice can close people from finding truth and from discovering what can give them the most joy. Be careful with these matters, and not so cavalier.
cho pilo:
But my theory is more likely. Because there is a clear motive, and a method to carry it out. I don’t need to rely on the supernatural to explain it.
I’ll wait till you’ve listened to the youtube link I provided you earlier, or watched the longer presentation above, before responding.
cho pilo:
Have you witnessed this first-hand? I might be persuaded if I did, otherwise not.
I haven’t witnessed this miracle firsthand, but I think the recorded experiences of crowds of people for 2,000 years should be strong enough to convince any rational person.

I’ve witnessed other things firsthand, though, and there are lots of close friends of mine, as well as less close acquaintances, who have experienced other extraordinary things firsthand.
 
=cho pilo;7878910]Interesting questions. The idea of mind as a “thing” is an illusion. Mind is a function of the brain.
Definitions please.
Indeed it is. ANd the Mind, Intellect, FREEWILL and SOUL [animator of life fo this discussion] are all Spiritual Things. We can show they exist but not quantify them.

So if science is correct? “Like must come from like,” what then is the Origin of these Spirtual things?

God Bless,
Pat
 
Are the consequence infinite, irrepairable? Does one have to “get it right in this one lifetime or burn in hell forever”?
  • If these are the feared consequences, … 🤷
Just read the plain words of Romans 8:19 and then read James 1:27 for God’s definition of religion; that is “pure religion”, as in how God defines “pure”- katharos in the Greek and its meaning in James context:
  1. free from corrupt desire, from sin and guilt
  2. free from every admixture of what is false, sincere genuine
  3. blameless, innocent
  4. unstained with the guilt of anything
May God’s grace be with you!
 
Because I am an atheist, I do not believe that there is such a thing as a “right religion.” There are literally hundreds and hundreds of religions on this Earth that people practice, so it would be impossible, literally speaking, to “know” which one is the correct religion, if there is one. However, I do believe that there are religions that will benefit you more than others. I think, obviously, Catholicism is going to benefit you more than LeVeyan Satanism or old Norse religions. Practicing an old Norse religion is not going to teach you how to be moral (even though morality is a choice). There are no life lessons with Norse mythology, just stories that mean absolutely nothing. Christianity has a lot more history, especially Catholicism. So please, do not fret over this. You’re worrying yourself for no reason. Just continue believing what you believe and carry on. Sorry if that sounds harsh, but things like this are hard to address.
All people have always believed in G0d or higher power.Its natural to man realize there is something that created him and this universe in which he exists.Its only recently that with the advance in science that man is now coming to doubt that there is a higher power.But with all the theories and new discoveries they still can’t prove that we just happened along out of total nothingness.Man by his nature will continue to hunt for evidence that God is simply a creation of man to explain that which he can’t explain.Those same people are willing to believe Christ never came or that man has made a God out of Jesus to decieve people and control them.Which is of course utterly rediculous since the people in the highest positions have nnothing.The Church as an organization is worth a lot but the clergy have no personal money of their own to speak of.The Pope doesn’t throw wild parties or have any secret swiss bank accounts.There really aren’t that many dominate religions.Actually Muslim,Christianity,Buddism,jewish ,and hinduism is about it.and muslim,Christianity and Jewish all have the same root.
 
That’s not what I said. It’s overwhelmingly sufficient evidence for me. For many others, too! But we are “open” to the possibility of the supernatural, whereas you presume everything you hear about the supernatural is false, and are willing to assume the truth of any skeptical theory you hear rather than seriously consider the possibility that God is intervening. That’s prejudice masquerading as reason.

He gives plentiful evidence to those who desire Him and seek Him. To those that are closed to Him, though, He allows them sufficient wiggle room to irrationally deny and reject Him.
Can you teach me how to become insensitive like that?

It must be great to not care about others!
 
Indeed it is. ANd the Mind, Intellect, FREEWILL and SOUL [animator of life fo this discussion] are all Spiritual Things. We can show they exist but not quantify them.

So if science is correct? “Like must come from like,” what then is the Origin of these Spirtual things?

God Bless,
Pat
You can show that souls exist? Go for it! 🙂 (joking)

If physicalism is the one and only true understanding of “how things really are”,
and the only things physicalists say can be talked about have color, shape, size, weight and such, ie., are empirically measurable,
then the question about the existence of mind, intellect and free will and whether we can talk about them at all and consider them as existing entities
is perfectly rational.

If mind, intellect and free will do not have color, shape, size, weight, etc.,
then physicalists should not talk about them!

So, for example, if a physicalist would utter a sentence like “You must be out of your mind!” or “You are of lesser intelligence than I” they are in fact talking complete nonsense, since they are referring to phenomena which they themselves claim do not exist.

If someone wants to be a physicalist reductionist - then by all means, they should go all the way in being so!
 
=cho pilo;7882171]You can show that souls exist? Go for it! 🙂 (joking)
If physicalism is the one and only true understanding of “how things really are”,
and the only things physicalists say can be talked about have color, shape, size, weight and such, ie., are empirically measurable,
then the question about the existence of mind, intellect and free will and whether we can talk about them at all and consider them as existing entities
is perfectly rational.
If mind, intellect and free will do not have color, shape, size, weight, etc.,
then physicalists should not talk about them!
So, for example, if a physicalist would utter a sentence like “You must be out of your mind!” or “You are of lesser intelligence than I” they are in fact talking complete nonsense, since they are referring to phenomena which they themselves claim do not exist.
If someone wants to be a physicalist reductionist - then by all means, they should go all the way in being so!
Excellent thought!👍

God Bless you,

Pat
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Lief Erikson
That’s not what I said. It’s overwhelmingly sufficient evidence for me. For many others, too! But we are “open” to the possibility of the supernatural, whereas you presume everything you hear about the supernatural is false, and are willing to assume the truth of any skeptical theory you hear rather than seriously consider the possibility that God is intervening. That’s prejudice masquerading as reason.
Cho, I do care about you. I’ve spent many hours writing to you and researching for your sake because I care, and some hours praying for you as well. At Mass, on Monday, I cried while praying for you to Jesus in the Eucharist. I sincerely care about you, and that is the reason I wrote to you as I did. If I didn’t care, I probably wouldn’t have.

I occasionally criticize my friends and family, or other people I know, when I see them as doing something wrong and I think they have the maturity to correct this. I try to examine my own behavior for faults frequently and to pay attention when others criticize me, as you just have done.

I am glad when people criticize me, too, and thank-you for what you just said. My pride causes me to not like hearing I’m wrong, so I don’t always respond well when contradicted. I do want to become a better person, though, and I won’t become better if I don’t get criticized and if I don’t think carefully about what others say when they do correct me. I believe God wants us all to constantly become better people, so we would do well to help one another to grow. Often this means offering encouragement and praise, but sometimes it also calls for criticism or voicing disagreement. Do you feel this way, at all?

I personally don’t see the purpose of conversation as being to feel good, but to grow and learn. That’s my perspective. Though maybe I am wrong.

In several of your comments in this thread, you have presumed that articles I’ve sent you about major, well supported miracles with large numbers of witnesses or studies done on them, are mistaken or fraudulent and not worth reading. You’ve judged what I sent you and assumed that it’s wrong without having even looked at it. Even if you found during your early Internet investigation that some (or many) miracles are false or poorly supported, that doesn’t put you in a position where you can reasonably judge and condemn everything, including what you haven’t studied. You haven’t even read any books on any of the greatest miracles. If you condemn before examining, or look at evidence with a bias against one side and in favor of another, you aren’t demonstrating reason but prejudice. That’s something I wanted to offer you, to consider, if you would. It’s my point of view. Maybe I’m wrong.

If you see more faults in me, in addition to rudeness, I would be glad if you shared them with me. I will think about what you’ve said. Thank-you again for responding as you did.

God bless us.

Lief
 
Originally Posted by cho pilo
Are the consequence infinite, irrepairable? Does one have to “get it right in this one lifetime or burn in hell forever”?
  • If these are the feared consequences,
The RESPONCE
Just read the plain words of Romans 8:19 and then read James 1:27 for God’s definition of religion; that is “pure religion”, as in how God defines “pure”- katharos in the Greek and its meaning in James context:
  1. free from corrupt desire, from sin and guilt
  2. free from every admixture of what is false, sincere genuine
  3. blameless, innocent
  4. unstained with the guilt of anything
May God’s grace be with you!
**Facts

God obligates Himself to OFFER sufficient grace fro EVERYONE to attain salvation. More refuse the graces than do accept them.

One God: always was and Always will be
One Faith [set of religious beliefs] ditto
One church [diito from ist to last page of the ENTIRE Bible]

So anyone who willfully does not meet these basic requirements chooses to put themselves at GREAT spiritual peril.

And YES; one physical life =One chance and ONE chance ONLY to get it RIGHT the first time.**

God Bless,
Pat
 
Facts

God obligates Himself to OFFER sufficient grace fro EVERYONE to attain salvation. More refuse the graces than do accept them.

One God: always was and Always will be
One Faith [set of religious beliefs] ditto
One church [diito from ist to last page of the ENTIRE Bible]

So anyone who willfully does not meet these basic requirements chooses to put themselves at GREAT spiritual peril.

And YES; one physical life =One chance and ONE chance ONLY to get it RIGHT the first time.

God Bless,
Pat
If that were true, then everyone would be saved - that is universalism you described and liberal theology. Remember a DEAD person cannot revive himself can he? If God revives, then there is a new creation in Christ Jesus. How many seek after God? Why? See above.
 
=Sonny69;7883762]If that were true, then everyone would be saved - that is universalism you described and liberal theology. Remember a DEAD person cannot revive himself can he? If God revives, then there is a new creation in Christ Jesus. How many seek after God? Why? See above.
So my friend, you would do me a GREAT honor if you would show me:
  1. WHERE I was wrong in post #51? [specifically please]. What I shared is supportable by the Bible.
  2. On what foundation do you place your views?
I’m WAY TOOOOO OLD to be perfect [anymore]. 😃

God Bless you, I look forward to hearing your views.

Pat
 
Cho, I do care about you. I’ve spent many hours writing to you and researching for your sake because I care, and some hours praying for you as well. At Mass, on Monday, I cried while praying for you to Jesus in the Eucharist. I sincerely care about you, and that is the reason I wrote to you as I did. If I didn’t care, I probably wouldn’t have.

I occasionally criticize my friends and family, or other people I know, when I see them as doing something wrong and I think they have the maturity to correct this. I try to examine my own behavior for faults frequently and to pay attention when others criticize me, as you just have done.

I am glad when people criticize me, too, and thank-you for what you just said. My pride causes me to not like hearing I’m wrong, so I don’t always respond well when contradicted. I do want to become a better person, though, and I won’t become better if I don’t get criticized and if I don’t think carefully about what others say when they do correct me. I believe God wants us all to constantly become better people, so we would do well to help one another to grow. Often this means offering encouragement and praise, but sometimes it also calls for criticism or voicing disagreement. Do you feel this way, at all?

I personally don’t see the purpose of conversation as being to feel good, but to grow and learn. That’s my perspective. Though maybe I am wrong.

In several of your comments in this thread, you have presumed that articles I’ve sent you about major, well supported miracles with large numbers of witnesses or studies done on them, are mistaken or fraudulent and not worth reading. You’ve judged what I sent you and assumed that it’s wrong without having even looked at it. Even if you found during your early Internet investigation that some (or many) miracles are false or poorly supported, that doesn’t put you in a position where you can reasonably judge and condemn everything, including what you haven’t studied. You haven’t even read any books on any of the greatest miracles. If you condemn before examining, or look at evidence with a bias against one side and in favor of another, you aren’t demonstrating reason but prejudice. That’s something I wanted to offer you, to consider, if you would. It’s my point of view. Maybe I’m wrong.

If you see more faults in me, in addition to rudeness, I would be glad if you shared them with me. I will think about what you’ve said. Thank-you again for responding as you did.

God bless us.

Lief
Lief,

Thank your for caring. I appreciate your kind words. Perhaps the debate of miracles is pointless unless the other person understands their religious setting.

Without a religious interpretation, some oddities are just oddities, not miracles.
 
So my friend, you would do me a GREAT honor if you would show me:
  1. WHERE I was wrong in post #51? [specifically please]. What I shared is supportable by the Bible.
  2. On what foundation do you place your views?
I’m WAY TOOOOO OLD to be perfect [anymore]. 😃

God Bless you, I look forward to hearing your views.

Pat
If you are too old as you indicated, then you would not have anything to do with what I would have to say. Can you read your bible and miss the clear teaching of election?

OR
But their minds were hardened; for until this very day at the reading of the old covenant the same veil remains unlifted, because it is removed in Christ.

by a new and living way which He inaugurated for us through the veil, that is, His flesh,

**He {the Father} predestined us to adoption as sons **through Jesus Christ to Himself, according to the kind intention of His will,

The Father’s will, not man’s will - however the people drawn by the Father to the Son; He, the Father, via the Holy Spirit changes the man’s will by raising him from the spiritually dead to newness of life in Christ Jesus; therefore the new creation seeks earnestly after God according to His will.

Just as it is written: “**I will **put My Spirit within you **and cause you **to walk in My statutes, **and you will **be careful to observe My ordinances.”

AND

“Moreover, **I will save you **from all your uncleanness;” {ALL not some, but again ALL-It is finished!} “I, the LORD, have spoken and will do it.”

also we have obtained an inheritance, **having been predestined according to His purpose {His purpose, not ours - thank God!}**who **works all things **after the counsel of His will,

So to answer your question if the Lord, Himself did not make it clear enough; you confuse His saving grace, which is given only to His elect - but all people receive His grace in measure. His love abounds to all of man, but His special love falls only upon the elect.

Man is without excuse and is accountable and the doctrine of election is also written - so how does one reconcile the two - you don’t. The apparent paradox will be shown as right and just when God reveals them to us & we will all agree. They are like an analogy of two tracks of the train running parallel to each other and in the looking at them in the far distance {future}; they come together.

May God’s peace and His grace rest upon and within you!
 
Lief,

Thank your for caring. I appreciate your kind words. Perhaps the debate of miracles is pointless unless the other person understands their religious setting.

Without a religious interpretation, some oddities are just oddities, not miracles.
That is true. Yet the reverse is also true, that some oddities are so extreme that they demand a religious interpretation. The events in Zietoun, which I cited before, are I believe a good example of such a case. So are the events at Fatima. The fact that the apostles died for their belief that they had seen Jesus Christ resurrected from the dead, had spoken with Him and had eaten meals with Him after His resurrection, also is an “oddity” that cries out for faith.

The Eucharistic Miracle of Buennos Aires, which I cited for you, and numerous other Eucharistic Miracles, are further incredible events that call strongly for a religious interpretation. People who haven’t studied them at all can dismiss them out of hand without thinking about them, because they are sure to begin with that a miracle did not take place. But they are not acting as reasonable people but as prejudiced people, when they make negative unsupported assumptions to dispose of the evidence.

Religious people sometimes can be too gullible in accepting miracle stories, yet skeptical people also can be too gullible in giving credence to any argument they read that purports to discredit a miracle. I probably tend toward the gullible, myself, because I’ve seen miracles in my life and so have many of my friends and family, who I know to be trustworthy. So because of my life experience and upbringing, I tend to know that such things happen and therefore am not surprised when I hear similar things from other people.

I’ve met plenty of people who tend toward the incredulous, though, and automatically distrust everything they hear, or give preference to any non-religious explanation they can come up with, however absurd. This is another form of gullibility and bias.

Skeptics are often gullible in accepting out of hand the skeptical arguments they hear, without investigation, while religious people also can be gullible in accepting what they hear too readily.

I’ve seen skeptical arguments win in some debates, and religious arguments win in others.

We live in a very big, complicated world. It’s good to be open minded.
 
=Lief Erikson;7939835]That is true. Yet the reverse is also true, that some oddities are so extreme that they demand a religious interpretation. The events in Zietoun, which I cited before, are I believe a good example of such a case. So are the events at Fatima. The fact that the apostles died for their belief that they had seen Jesus Christ resurrected from the dead, had spoken with Him and had eaten meals with Him after His resurrection, also is an “oddity” that cries out for faith.
The Eucharistic Miracle of Buennos Aires, which I cited for you, and numerous other Eucharistic Miracles, are further incredible events that call strongly for a religious interpretation. People who haven’t studied them at all can dismiss them out of hand without thinking about them, because they are sure to begin with that a miracle did not take place. But they are not acting as reasonable people but as prejudiced people, when they make negative unsupported assumptions to dispose of the evidence.
Religious people sometimes can be too gullible in accepting miracle stories, yet skeptical people also can be too gullible in giving credence to any argument they read that purports to discredit a miracle. I probably tend toward the gullible, myself, because I’ve seen miracles in my life and so have many of my friends and family, who I know to be trustworthy. So because of my life experience and upbringing, I tend to know that such things happen and therefore am not surprised when I hear similar things from other people.
I’ve met plenty of people who tend toward the incredulous, though, and automatically distrust everything they hear, or give preference to any non-religious explanation they can come up with, however absurd. This is another form of gullibility and bias.
Skeptics are often gullible in accepting out of hand the skeptical arguments they hear, without investigation, while religious people also can be gullible in accepting what they hear too readily.
I’ve seen skeptical arguments win in some debates, and religious arguments win in others.
We live in a very big, complicated world. It’s good to be open minded.
It helps to understand that Miracales take three forms: The most common being physical;
then mental [addictions and mental health issues], and most powerfully spiritual. Issues like hardcore protestants gaining Wisdom, Understading and Faith that may have alluded them for a long period of time.

Father Hardon said the Spiritual are the most astounding:thumbsup:

God Bless,
Pat
 
It helps to understand that Miracales take three forms: The most common being physical;
then mental [addictions and mental health issues], and most powerfully spiritual. Issues like hardcore protestants gaining Wisdom, Understading and Faith that may have alluded them for a long period of time.

Father Hardon said the Spiritual are the most astounding:thumbsup:
They certainly delight my soul the most :). Spiritual miracles have the most glorious and long-term consequences. These can impart eternal life, and it is visibly beautiful in this life, as well as the next.

Grrr! You’ve reminded me of Heaven, and I’m not there yet! :crying:
 
=Sonny69;7885729]If you are too old as you indicated, then you would not have anything to do with what I would have to say. Can you read your bible and miss the clear teaching of election?
OR
But their minds were hardened; for until this very day at the reading of the old covenant the same veil remains unlifted, because it is removed in Christ.
by a new and living way which He inaugurated for us through the veil, that is, His flesh,
My dear friend in Christ. I HAVE read my Bible MANY TIMES:D

And I can see that you have read your’s too. GREAT! So then you have read John 3:5 and John 3:36. And what about Mt. 16:19, and John 20:19-23, supported by John 14: 16-17, and John 17:15-19. And you have read that it is absolutely necessary to KEEP the Commandments if one is to get into heaven. And of course there is James Chapter Two. And of coruse you underatand and accept 2nd. Tim. 3:16-17? And That Matt. 28:19-20 make the above essentail?

OH!, and you’ve read the 100+ places in the NT alone that speaks of ONLY one Church and One Faith [set of beliefs] Eph.4:1-7.

Romans chapter 10 tells us that Faith [understanding] comes from what is TAUGHT not what is read. And when Phillip overcame the Eunech and asked him:"sir do you understand what you are reading?; the Eunech replied…“how can I unless someone explains it to me?”

Sorry I can’t supply all of the verse references as I’m doing this from my old memory.

Could we agree that NO one part of the Bible can CONTRADICT another teaching? Were this permitted [completely W/O logic or biblical support]
**He {the Father} predestined us to adoption as sons **through Jesus Christ to Himself, according to the kind intention of His will,
The Father’s will, not man’s will - however the people drawn by the Father to the Son; He, the Father, via the Holy Spirit changes the man’s will by raising him from the spiritually dead to newness of life in Christ Jesus; therefore the new creation seeks earnestly after God according to His will.
Predestination is as you choose to understand it an absolute impossibility! It denies God’s perfection [creating humanity with a mind, intellect and freewill] in order to choose for ourselves [and thereby] prove our love for Him or DISTAIN of Him.[Our choice]. It also does not permit humanity the opportunity to uise the very attributes God gives humanity forn the precise [not only] purpose of deciding for ourselves where we spend eternity.

See Isa.43: 7 and 21, and Isa. 55:7-8 for bible conformation of this.

“Moreover, **I will save you **from all your uncleanness;” {ALL not some, but again ALL-It is finished!} “I, the LORD, have spoken and will do it.”

Correcly understood this means: Christ has the power too; not that it’s a done deal. If it were then why does Jesus say “Keep my Commnadments if you wich to be saved?” And why 1 John 1:8-10; 1 John 5:16-17 and John 20: 19-23 and Mt. 16:19? AND WHERE DOES IT SAY “IT IS FINISHED” WHEN SPEAKING OF ONES SALVATION?
So to answer your question if the Lord, Himself did not make it clear enough; you confuse His saving grace, which is given only to His elect - but all people receive His grace in measure. His love abounds to all of man, but His special love falls only upon the elect.
Actually friend you MAY have this part right W/O knowing it. “His ellect” are those who actually do ALL that he commands. [Hint hint]. And grace abounds ONLY through the Sacraments available in and through His One Faith; One God; One Church.

Here’s a CHALLANGE for you. If you can provide evidence that Yahweh or Christ at any time or any place desired more than one set of beliefs; One God and Only one Temple/ Church… I’ll accept your positions as valid.

THANK YOU my friend for your reply. And I look forward to you’re responce to my comments.

Love and prayers,
Pat
 
That would be a trivialization of religion/religiousness.
I don’t understand what you mean. Could you explain it?

If you mean that religion is more than miracles, I agree. At the same time, some events are so extraordinary and evidently miraculous that they call for a religious interpretation, I believe.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top