Yet Another "NFP Stuggles" Thread

  • Thread starter Thread starter Lookouts
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
And this is one of the ridiculous answers given. There must be a CCC playbook on how to give a comeback. Is this someohow supposed to change the reality of a couples’ lives? Who are you or anyone else or even the church to tell a couple that what they are experienceing is not real, or is lessened somehow because “the church says so”, or no one has died without having sex, or offer it up, or anything else?

There are huge, negative impacts on marriages where there is limited to no sexual intimacy. Just because the church pretends it isn’t supposed to be that way does not change reality in the least. Maybe no one has died from not having sex, but the emotional impact can be worse.
However, emmar has already been offered sympathy, empathy, suggestions on how to improve her situation. What krista said is the truth, and once all the above has been given, and the person continues to be angry, and feels it is unfair, all we can offer is the truth, because nothing else we say to that person seems to matter.

Also this issue is not really about NFP. This couple successfully used NFP in the past. It is rather about the spouse’s depression and irrational (and some rational) fears. They wouldn’t have to abstain, but even if they do, there are other ways to be intimate with ones spouse than sex.

To the OP, I would suggest that it is your wife’s depression that is speaking when she makes outrageous statements about abstaining until menopause, and I would not take it too personally. (Easier said than done I know). Give her cycles some time to regulate (maybe even chart them yourself) and when her depression becomes less of a problem and she can see that her cycle is relatively normal then you can return the the discussion of NFP.
 
There are huge, negative impacts on marriages where there is limited to no sexual intimacy. Just because the church pretends it isn’t supposed to be that way does not change reality in the least. Maybe no one has died from not having sex, but the emotional impact can be worse.
The Church does not ignore that sex is an important part of marriage, in fact, I am venturing to guess that this is why NFP is ok, because the Church knows that sex is an important part of marriage, and even in times of difficulty that may cause there to be serious/just/grave reasons to avoid, it is good for the couple to be able to participate in the marital act. If not, complete abstinence would be the only choice. Heck, the Church knows that sex is such an important part of marriage that people that cannot have sex cannot get married!

I know blessed JPII mentioned in one of his books (maybe it was when he was still Karol Wojtyla) that it can be more difficult for married couples to abstain than for unmarried couples to do so.

Now, having to abstain is a big cross some of us will have to bear. Crosses are not meant to pull us away from Christ, nor to tear up our marriage. It really depends on how we embrace it. I’ll tell you what, though, sometimes if others are suffering because of not knowing how to embrace their crosses, some of it could fall on our own backs for not evangelizing enough.
 
Right, but I thought people had the decency not to pick on me in this thread over something I said months ago on another thread and have thus stated that I now want to keep private.
I know I’m just jumping right in here, but I actually have been following this thread and other NFP threads, just never contributed much.

I do agree. I think as a natural progression of life, it is expected that people will change and evolve through the years. Hopefully, it is for the better. 🙂 I was definitely not the same at 18 as I was at 28 and any other age. My views on certain things and even how I handled discussing situations have even changed from few years ago. I’m even certain that some things I posted here from a few years ago, or even a few months ago, may not be my opinion today or has modified slightly. Unless a person is consistent up through the most recent post, I don’t think it is wise to just assume that the person still has the same views even from a few months ago, especially when a person does explicitly express they would like to keep some things private. There is something unsavory when people do search for individual’s past posts to try to either prove a point against them. They should only focus on the opinions and statements expressed on that particular thread.
 
Okay, so NFP doesn’t work for them and I will give you the benefit of doubt that they have exhausted ALL the doctors, NFP instructors, and every other channel available to see WHY NFP doesn’t seem to work for them.

Still, why does that mean that they have to abstain for 20-30 years? Is their situation not EVER going to change? Are they NEVER going to find them in a position where they could extend the generosity to accept another child? EVER?

Now how often do you think it happens that 1. a couple struggles making NFP work. 2. they exhaust all methods of help and NFP still doesn’t work for them, and 3. their just/serious reasons for for needing to avoid a pregnancy NEVER changes?
Man, and I’m only on page 4 of this thread.

We have been following NFP for most of probably 15 years. No, that is not total abstinence, though it feels like it at times. Our financial situation has not changed for many, many years; NFP will never go away.

Generosity to accept another child? I find this arrogance and sanctimony, whether from posters or the church. So couples who cannot afford more children are not generous? This is the problem with church teachings on sex and NFP - more kids = a more generous family or a more Catholic family, or that somehow, for some reason, couples should just have more kids and God will send the house and paycheck. It is why many Catholics have issues with church dictates on sex. It is why other faiths wonder why Catholics have hangups about sex. It is why I believe that church teachings on sex are designed to scare Catholics into compliance and keep having babies.
 
Right, this is the part I don’t get, too, Jea.

If pregnancy = death then isn’t the only OBVIOUS choice abstinence? Because ANY form of birth control can fail.
Presuming intercourse is the chosen means of intimacy.
 
Why is the husband always blamed?
I’m not blaming anyone. I am stating a fact that if pregnancy is going to result in death that is obviously the woman that is at risk. I suppose she could be the one wanting sex but it seems unlikely as self-preservation is something that is almost reflexive.

You seem angry. Who is the Church to tell us? The Vicar of Christ? The one who will hold the keys to the kingdom of Heaven until Christ returns? All of that sounds like someone I want to follow. If you do not that is obviously your choice, but please don’t encourage others to sin so that you don’t feel so alone. And if you don’t agree but do it anyway, well that is commendable but please try to work out your anger so that you don’t lead others to sin.
 
emmar and Debora123:

You have just proven the point that people are trying to make for you here. Marriage is HARD WORK, but you wanted this part of it to be breezy and easy. When I presented our *very *tough circumstances you both said, “I’m glad it is so easy for you.” Seriously?!?

No one believes that marriage is easy. However, for some couples, NFP and church teachings are easy; for others, they are not.

Please look at what you are doing. You blaming NFP for something that has absolutely nothing to do with NFP. Contraception will tear you apart. *Not *contracepting will bring you together! That is a fact that our society of broken marriages, has proven!

Maybe you believe, or are repeating what you are told, that NFP has nothing to do with issues. Who are you to say that to couples struggling with it? It is nice to hear that not contracepting supposedly brings couples together, but it is not always the case. It may well be the goal in the end, but it is not reality for many couples.

My life is tough, day in and day out. My cycles are *insanely *wonky, extremely difficult to interpret, and my reasons for periodic continence are serious enough to warrant a LOT of abstinence!

It is my health problems, my reasons for needing to not conceive that are tough, though. NFP is a GIFT! If I used a condom, my health problems remain. Sure, I would be having a lot more sex, but it would be empty sex. Tell me how empty sex would improve an already good marriage?

Who is deciding that it is empty sex? The church says it is because the semen doesn’t land where it is supposed to, but that is all. Does that mean that couples do not find intercourse fulfilling? The point is no one, church included, can tell couples what they are experiencing is not real, just because it isn’t supposed to be.

Please, please, I beg you both to look at the untruths you are believing. Please don’t spread these untruths that “NFP hurts marriage.”

It is not an “untruth” if it is what is happening. Maybe NFP does not hurt a marriage, but the lack of sexual intimacy because of church teachings combined with NFP can and does hurt a marriage. Why do you want to not tell THAT truth?

Our culture is already so broken! Contraception is deadly to marriage! Please, please don’t do this! You are making my work doubly hard to have to unteach all of the misinformation you are spreading. There are times after the two of you post that my PM inbox lights up like someone lit it on fire. People are believing you and they are going into marriage contracepting.

NFP is not the problem. It is information and abstinence. That is all. If *abstinence *is a problem in a marriage, they need MORE of it, not less, whether they are fertile or not.

More of something that is already creating problems?

God’s design is perfect! If He wants you to abstain more, why wouldn’t you? Yes, it is tough to do God’s will in all aspects of our lives. Why would our sex life be any different? If I were to come on here and whine and moan that I don’t really want to abstain sometimes, would that make it better? I have been here for years and everyone who reads KNOWS that I wanted to have a lot of kids. Sex makes babies! I wanted a lot of kids, so I obviously planned to do a lot of practicing to get there!

But that isn’t God’s will for me. There is nothing to gain by blaming the gift of NFP for where my will doesn’t match God’s will. So far, God hasn’t called us to total abstinence. Yay, us. But if He does, then so be it. He has a plan in letting me have chronic pain. I probably won’t know that plan if or until I get to heaven.

I am just asking the one thing. Please don’t blame NFP for the problems in your marriage. The world doesn’t need another voice supporting contraception. Satan and secular culture are plenty loud as it is.
This is the pat line - surely NFP cannot be a problem because the church says it is not supposed to be one. Again, it may not be NFP alone, but it most definitely is NFP combined with church teachings.
 
All of these threads tend to confuse me and make me question what to expect regarding NFP. I’m getting married in a few months and have been charting for several years, because I had a health problem and wanted to figure it out. I’m thankful for the knowledge that I have and that there is a moral way to space births.
Ok, I’m going to be blunt with you. The fact of the matter is: marriage is hard and the children situation is difficult too. On the one hand, children are a blessing. And on the other hand, it’s foolish to deny that pregnancies and additional pregnancies don’t stress out many couples for a variety of reasons, all of which are incredibly important to each family.

But the truth is NFP is not that easy to learn, otherwise more people would embrace it. It has a very poor reputation as being ineffective and unreliable. As a nurse, I can’t get a word in edgewise most of the time with regards to NFP because people don’t even want to hear it. And the truth is, NFP Is a burden on many people because they feel constrained by it. But there’s a whole other group of people out there that love it: it teaches them a lot about their body, and they can tell right away when something’s wrong, and they like the whole method.

But the truth also stands that ABCs especially the ones that go inside your body, are not good for women. I’m not even arguing the religious aspect of it, I’ll leave that to others. They’re better at supporting the religious aspect anyway. I don’t believe for a minute that ABCs destroys marriage, that’s something that hasn’t been proven. But I can argue the medical aspect of it. Just like some people like NFP, some like ABCs and don’t suffer any adverse effects from it, and don’t worry about the potential risks. But just like NFP, some hate ABCs because they suffer the adverse effects (and shop around trying various forms of ABCs and in many cases give up and get their tubes tied or stop taking anything and get pregnant, and I’ve seen both many times). In addition, some suffer the more serious side effects and throw clots and end up with pulmonary embolism or stroke, which of course is usually not given a thought until it’s too late. We can argue about the cancer causing side effects, but then ABCs have been proven to hinder other cancers as well.

But make no mistake that as you get older it will behoove you to do something other than ABCs, and that’s a fact. The older we get the more physical baggage we carry around and modern day medicine has provided us the means to live way beyond our life expectancy. In other words, the longer a woman takes ABCs, the more detrimental to her health because her risk factors go up. That’s a fact, take it or leave it. And I know those who don’t suffer the side effects and have no apparent risk factors, they will leave it, and that’s okay. You can’t push people and that’s the way it is. And in today’s society more women are showing risks younger and younger. I’m only 42 and am on 3 different BP medications which makes me not a candidate for birth control anyway. Good for those who don’t have those risk factors…enjoy it because you will later in life – because that’s part of life.

What is boils down to is that no matter what you decide to do, it will be hard. I don’t think it was supposed to be hard like some people say, but I think it’s part of life. I don’t believe God is sitting on an anthill with a magnifying glass and puppet strings micromanaging every single thing on earth. But I do believe He intervenes if you ask Him to. That said, I don’t think he points to couple123 and says, “you’re having a baby today”. I think he lets life operate and sex=potential pregnancy. That’s biology 101. You’ll find in life that you’re going to have to go through periods of abstinence whether due to illness, or fatigue or other factors that enter life. And if NFP does one thing, it prepares the couple for those periods later.

You’re not going to know how you feel about NFP until you try it, so don’t stress about it. You won’t know if you can successfully use it until you try it, so don’t stress about it. You may be one of the resources for people a year from now. Who knows. Regardless, you don’t have any other options if you wish to be in communion with the Church. And frankly some people dont’ agree with that and dismiss it. So I point to the health aspects. If one doesn’t believe the religious aspects, you’re beating a dead horse going that angle IMOHO…again, I’ll leave that to others who can beat it death and enjoy it because I don’t. I don’t like struggling to move mountains, I’d rather smooth out a mole-hill. But that’s me.
Our pre-marital class spent about five minutes talking about NFP, and they used such veiled references that I don’t think anyone else in the room even knew what they were talking about.
It is also a fact that NFP is not widely taught, despte the :pshaw: from some members here. I think it’s rare to find someone who knows about NFP in real life, and it depends on your parish and diocese. And if someone doesn’t have a foundation, they will not know to look further. People are not going to look for new and improved ways to burden themselves so it’s kind of laughable (to me) to think that someone will try to make things harder without the foundation of knowledge that you have. If you don’t know what to look for you’re not going to go looking for it. You’re right to self-study. I love the book, “Taking Charge of your Fertility” and if you can actually talk to an instructor it’s all the better. It’s rare to find a doctor who will support NFP.
 
I don’t have any idea what situations my soon to be husband and I will find ourselves in,
And no one does 🙂
but we both understand that anytime we have sex, I could end up pregnant.
I think that’s the heart of the Church’s teaching. That’s being open to life: accepting what results from that marriage.
We also both understand that just because we’re getting married doesn’t mean we should expect it all the time.
I grew up thinking it was expected all the time 🙂 But as I got older and viewed the world around me, I realized many factors don’t make that possible. The ones who are getting it every day are very lucky and blessed and they should enjoy every minute of it while it lasts, because like you said, you don’t know what will happen to change all that. You might get a 48 hour flu that lasts a week 🙂
So, I think we are well prepared and understand as much as an engaged couple can about NFP. But then I come on here and I wonder whether we really know what we’re in for.
Some may argue but my perspective is: of course you don’t know what you’re in for. Marriage is a growing experience. Expect the unexpected and pick your battles.
If we do have to abstain for months or years at some point, is that going to tear our marriage apart? I tend to agree with the posters who say that if it does, it’s not because of NFP but because of some other problem, but I get nervous.
I don’t believe ABCs or NFP tear marriages apart by itself. I believe the couple will set the standard for the marriage. Most problems arise when both of the couple are not completely on board, for whatever reason. And the frustration on both sides doesn’t make it easy to deal with. I think that people who view marriage as a Sacrament or even a religious bonding (for non-Catholics) are more likely to stay together and work on making it work, regardless of what method they use. If one views marriage as disposable, then that’s how it will end up. Regardless of whether a couple is using NFP, or whether mom can’t have sex post-birth for a few weeks, if a man will cheat, he will cheat. And regardless of whether it’s NFP or whether her husband just had back surgery and can’t have sex for several weeks, if she’s going to cheat, she will. IMOHO, if the two are dedicated to the marriage, it doesn’t matter what they choose. Those who are using NFP are more likely to view marriage as a Sacrament due to the nature of the relationship between traditional Catholicism and NFP. But there are no studies correlating ABCs and the divorce rate that don’t count in other factors. So I don’t buy it. I think if people go into marriage thinking it’s as smooth as cherry pie, they will have problems. It’s a forever growing experience and it’s a series of compromises. It’s much harder to live married than to live single.
To the OP.
IMOHO, from what the OP says, his wife is clinically depressed and on tilt with anxiety and until that’s resolved, this will be his battle to man. You cannot rationalize with someone who is not in a state of mind to reason. She’s in flight mode right now. He’s in a difficult spot and I don’t have the answers to help him. He knows his wife. I know if someone pushes me when I’m stressed out, I push back and push back hard, but I am not his wife 🙂 I can’t imagine being in her position right now.
 
Marriages do not break down due to NFP. If the lack of sex is causing that serious of an issue in your marriage then you have other problems. Also, let’s be clear here. The OP wants to use NFP…his wife wants HIM to sin and use a condom. On top of their combined depression issues, do you really think adding mortal sin will help?
Here we go again - blame something else and not the lack of sexual intimacy. Wake up, people! Marriages may not break down because of NFP, but they do in fact break down because of a lack of sexual intimacy. Look at the posts of people here - are we all lying?
 
Here we go again - blame something else and not the lack of sexual intimacy. Wake up, people! Marriages may not break down because of NFP, but they do in fact break down because of a lack of sexual intimacy. Look at the posts of people here - are we all lying?
You are not lying but you are denying that there are other problems. Yes it is difficult to go w/out sex yes it is exponentially harder when you are married and spend your nights w/ your spouseto whom you are sexually attracted. But if your marriage breaks down because of this there must be other problems because sex is not or should not be the glue that is binding your marriage together.
 
Here we go again - blame something else and not the lack of sexual intimacy. Wake up, people! Marriages may not break down because of NFP, but they do in fact break down because of a lack of sexual intimacy. Look at the posts of people here - are we all lying?
People who don’t find abstaining a stumbling block are in no way going to understand your perspective. Unless one can relate to your point of view, it will be difficult for them to understand what you’re saying. Some people find abstaining a positive thing in their marriage, and some quite obviously do not. Of course the lack of intimacy will deterimental to some marriages. It’s much easier to deal with a blatant contraindication for sex (like a physical illness, like a high risk pregnancy, like post pregnancy abstinence). But it’s quite a different senario when there isn’t a physical impediment, and what’s keeping the couple from a need for physical contact is something else (like the fear of an unwanted/untimely pregnancy for various reasons).
 
And this is one of the ridiculous answers given. There must be a CCC playbook on how to give a comeback. Is this someohow supposed to change the reality of a couples’ lives? Who are you or anyone else or even the church to tell a couple that what they are experienceing is not real, or is lessened somehow because “the church says so”, or no one has died without having sex, or offer it up, or anything else?

There are huge, negative impacts on marriages where there is limited to no sexual intimacy. Just because the church pretends it isn’t supposed to be that way does not change reality in the least. Maybe no one has died from not having sex, but the emotional impact can be worse.
I am sorry you think this is ridiculous? It’s the truth.

Do not project your defensiveness onto what you think I said. I never said anyone’s struggle wasn’t real or was lessened by Church teaching. I just laid out the Church teaching on sexual intimacy in black and white.
 
I’m not blaming anyone. I am stating a fact that if pregnancy is going to result in death that is obviously the woman that is at risk. I suppose she could be the one wanting sex but it seems unlikely as self-preservation is something that is almost reflexive.

You seem angry. Who is the Church to tell us? The Vicar of Christ? The one who will hold the keys to the kingdom of Heaven until Christ returns? All of that sounds like someone I want to follow. If you do not that is obviously your choice, but please don’t encourage others to sin so that you don’t feel so alone. And if you don’t agree but do it anyway, well that is commendable but please try to work out your anger so that you don’t lead others to sin.
Where am I leading others to sin because I disagree with church teachings and state the fact it has had negative impacts on my marriage? Your statement is a perfect example of what someone mentioned earlier - shove into a corner those who disagree with and do in fact have problems with NFP and church teachings; sit still, be quiet NFP is rosy.

No, it is not. Stating the facts of what is happening in one’s marriage is not leading others to sin.
 
Where am I leading others to sin because I disagree with church teachings and state the fact it has had negative impacts on my marriage? Your statement is a perfect example of what someone mentioned earlier - shove into a corner those who disagree with and do in fact have problems with NFP and church teachings; sit still, be quiet NFP is rosy.

No, it is not. Stating the facts of what is happening in one’s marriage is not leading others to sin.
You were encouraging others to seek out alternate, immoral forms of sexual gratification. I’ll quote you in a minute.

You are creating scandal.
 
You are not lying but you are denying that there are other problems. Yes it is difficult to go w/out sex yes it is exponentially harder when you are married and spend your nights w/ your spouseto whom you are sexually attracted. But if your marriage breaks down because of this there must be other problems because sex is not or should not be the glue that is binding your marriage together.
In that, I will agree - there may be other problems, and there were/are; however, the point is that consistently in these boards it is stated that NFP surely cannot be the problem. Yes, it can be. And again, it isn’t the lack of sex; it is the lack of sexual intimacy with one’s God given spouse. Even people here who promote NFP so much seem to miss that.
 
This goes perfectly with mwncheesehead’s comment that “no one said living the faith is easy”.** This is the insanity of the dictates by the church in teachings on sex**. It isn’t NFP that is the problem; NFP works. It is that the church mandates that under all circumstances, at all times, no matter what, the man must climax via intercourse - semen has to land in one spot. And if not, it is “grave”, and “intrinsically evil”, and “disordered”.

Does anyone honestly, sincerely, deeply believe that God intends for couples to be distant and suffer and not be sexually intimate whatsoever, in any manner, for months on end or even years, because there may be times the semen lands somewhere else? I do not.

**The church tells us *what ***we are supposed to believe, but it does not change reality. Couples have no option to pray and decide for themselves that for the sake of a marriage and intimacy, **they may need to choose non-intercourse sex or some other means for sex. Is it right all the time? Maybe or maybe not. Should the church tell couples to suck it up, life’s a ***, that’s just the way it is, and what you’re going thru isn’t supposed to be? Absolutely not. Should couples be able to pray and decide what is best for them without being condemned? Absolutely yes.

Some couples are perfectly fine or able to cope with no sex or extremely limited sex; some are not and it has a major, negative impact on the marriage.

And for the record, even guys need intimacy; it isn’t just sex. As a couple, we disagree on, but we follow, church teachings and NFP, and it has not been positive.
Emphasis mine.
 
People who don’t find abstaining a stumbling block are in no way going to understand your perspective. Unless one can relate to your point of view, it will be difficult for them to understand what you’re saying. Some people find abstaining a positive thing in their marriage, and some quite obviously do not. Of course the lack of intimacy will deterimental to some marriages. It’s much easier to deal with a blatant contraindication for sex (like a physical illness, like a high risk pregnancy, like post pregnancy abstinence). But it’s quite a different senario when there isn’t a physical impediment, and what’s keeping the couple from a need for physical contact is something else (like the fear of an unwanted/untimely pregnancy for various reasons).
Absolutely.
 
In that, I will agree - there may be other problems, and there were/are; however, the point is that consistently in these boards it is stated that NFP surely cannot be the problem. Yes, it can be. And again, it isn’t the lack of sex; it is the lack of sexual intimacy with one’s God given spouse. Even people here who promote NFP so much seem to miss that.
No one has ever said that the Church requires couples to practice NFP. They are certainly free to have as much sex as often as they want, but they have to be prepared to accept the consequences of their sexual act.

If they think they can handle the consequences… fine. Have sex.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top