Yet Another "NFP Stuggles" Thread

  • Thread starter Thread starter Lookouts
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
L

Lookouts

Guest
Quick background: I’m 29, my wife is 27. Married three years. We used NFP to delay having a baby, and after a bit then we decided stop. We now have a nine month old boy, who:
  • Had reflux.
  • Then had reflux and colic.
  • Then just colic.
  • Then colic and teething.
  • Now just teething.
He requires attention nonstop. Loud baby, squeals often. Meanwhile, my wife has clinical depression. She is getting treated for it, and has for a few years. A couple months ago she relapsed. She thought about killing herself, and actually took a knife with her in a room. I have my own mental illness, currently starting to be treated. I work full-time.

A family member of hers offered to pay for child care, so that is helping. My wife is recovering. But make no mistake; this definitely qualifies for “grave reasons” to use NFP. We simply, for the health of her and our son (and lets face it, myself) can’t have another kid right now. Or maybe ever.

We haven’t had sex in nine months, and she is getting upset. She had her first period last month, so I tried being optimistic saying “we can start charting again”. She does not want to use female birth control, because it can act as an abortificant. The issue is that she sees no issue with condoms, and thinks that it’s no different than the barrier that NFP puts up. I explained the differences a few times, but she simply disagrees with me. She doesn’t want to chance with NFP, she’d rather NFP + condoms.

It’s impacting our marriage a lot right now. She’s said a few times “I don’t get why the Church punishes us for being Catholic”. She’s made a couple of comments about how “we won’t have sex until menopause”. We talked the other night about it, and I thought we made head way. We talked about using NFP and getting a fertility monitor which you can pee on a stick to scope out hormone levels. My logic; 30 bucks a month on sticks equals the same price of the pill or a box or three of condoms.

This didn’t stop her from making the menopause comment again two days later.

I’m hurt by her comment, and the situation is pretty -----y overall.
 
I’m so sorry you’re going through this. My husband thinks as your wife–that there is no difference in NFP and barrier/hormonal methods of birth control. He also threatens to just go get a vacetomy without my knowledge (which I’ve told him I would not approve of, and I’m not sure I could forgive that). What a hard situation! I don’t know what advice to offer other than the obvious: pray! I will pray for your family as well. Is she not Catholic?
 
Quick background: I’m 29, my wife is 27. Married three years. We used NFP to delay having a baby, and after a bit then we decided stop. We now have a nine month old boy, who:
  • Had reflux.
  • Then had reflux and colic.
  • Then just colic.
  • Then colic and teething.
  • Now just teething.
He requires attention nonstop. Loud baby, squeals often. Meanwhile, my wife has clinical depression. She is getting treated for it, and has for a few years. A couple months ago she relapsed. She thought about killing herself, and actually took a knife with her in a room. I have my own mental illness, currently starting to be treated. I work full-time.

A family member of hers offered to pay for child care, so that is helping. My wife is recovering. But make no mistake; this definitely qualifies for “grave reasons” to use NFP. We simply, for the health of her and our son (and lets face it, myself) can’t have another kid right now. Or maybe ever.

We haven’t had sex in nine months, and she is getting upset. She had her first period last month, so I tried being optimistic saying “we can start charting again”. She does not want to use female birth control, because it can act as an abortificant. The issue is that she sees no issue with condoms, and thinks that it’s no different than the barrier that NFP puts up. I explained the differences a few times, but she simply disagrees with me. She doesn’t want to chance with NFP, she’d rather NFP + condoms.

It’s impacting our marriage a lot right now. She’s said a few times “I don’t get why the Church punishes us for being Catholic”. She’s made a couple of comments about how “we won’t have sex until menopause”. We talked the other night about it, and I thought we made head way. We talked about using NFP and getting a fertility monitor which you can pee on a stick to scope out hormone levels. My logic; 30 bucks a month on sticks equals the same price of the pill or a box or three of condoms.

This didn’t stop her from making the menopause comment again two days later.

I’m hurt by her comment, and the situation is pretty -----y overall.
it will help you trust NFP if you go as a couple and meet with your NFP teacher if you don’t have one get one. The teacher will help you gain confidence and trust and look at the charts you do have and help with any problems. if you use condoms during the fertile times is more risky than avoiding during the fertile times, condoms aren’t that reliable. The monitor is a good idea. Nine months old hang in there, babies start sleeping better around that time. NFP can be a real cross to bare, and its hard to trust God with our fertility sometimes. Once you use and learn NFP well it gets so much easier, you need a few months or more of charting to help gain confidence in it. The more you use it the better you understand it. there are lots of methods of NFP I hope you find one that works for you. Just between us my husband has a mental illness and I have depression too both treated with meds. Most people would never guess we do, he has a great job, we live in a nice house, and look like any other normal family. We have our little secret but most people don’t need to know or will ever find out. it doesn’t mean your a bad parent. We have four kids and still trust NFP (God) with our fertility we use stm ccl. you may need to talk to a Catholic counselor your wife may have anxiety about sex = babies ( it doesn’t always have to = babies, you just need to understand how to use nfp) and she may need some time to learn(chart) until she trust NFP. I’ll pray for you.
 
There are priests that would approve condoms due to grave reasons.
Are they right or wrong?
 
There are priests that would approve condoms due to grave reasons.
Are they right or wrong?
They are wrong. That is contrary to the teaching of the Church. Their are only two morally acceptable options of avoiding or postponing pregnancy, and they can only be used with just/serious reason: periodic abstinence (NFP) and total abstinence.
 
OP one more thing I forgot don’t pressure your wife about sex don’t even bring it up if it causes her anxiety talk to a counselor first. I can totally understand her anxiety about it, she may be thinking she “can’t do this ever again” it needs to be worked out with a counselor. Pressuring her makes it worse. she needs to see babies do get grow into toddlers and life gets easier, and she may need to wait until that happens. She may resent you if you don’t respect her desire to not have a baby (right now). She may say never again but realize time heals things and it could me not right now. Just take it one day at time. God did give you the most precious gift a baby and God has trusted you as parents to raise him. When I tell myself that it always makes me feel better. Give your troubles to God and pray about it.
 
Quick background: I’m 29, my wife is 27. Married three years. We used NFP to delay having a baby, and after a bit then we decided stop. We now have a nine month old boy, who:
  • Had reflux.
  • Then had reflux and colic.
  • Then just colic.
  • Then colic and teething.
  • Now just teething.
He requires attention nonstop. Loud baby, squeals often. Meanwhile, my wife has clinical depression. She is getting treated for it, and has for a few years. A couple months ago she relapsed. She thought about killing herself, and actually took a knife with her in a room. I have my own mental illness, currently starting to be treated. I work full-time.

A family member of hers offered to pay for child care, so that is helping. My wife is recovering. But make no mistake; this definitely qualifies for “grave reasons” to use NFP. We simply, for the health of her and our son (and lets face it, myself) can’t have another kid right now. Or maybe ever.

We haven’t had sex in nine months, and she is getting upset. She had her first period last month, so I tried being optimistic saying “we can start charting again”. She does not want to use female birth control, because it can act as an abortificant. The issue is that she sees no issue with condoms, and thinks that it’s no different than the barrier that NFP puts up. I explained the differences a few times, but she simply disagrees with me. She doesn’t want to chance with NFP, she’d rather NFP + condoms.

It’s impacting our marriage a lot right now. She’s said a few times “I don’t get why the Church punishes us for being Catholic”. She’s made a couple of comments about how “we won’t have sex until menopause”. We talked the other night about it, and I thought we made head way. We talked about using NFP and getting a fertility monitor which you can pee on a stick to scope out hormone levels. My logic; 30 bucks a month on sticks equals the same price of the pill or a box or three of condoms.

This didn’t stop her from making the menopause comment again two days later.

I’m hurt by her comment, and the situation is pretty -----y overall.
Congratulations on your baby. My daughter is 9 months as well. I’m sorry the adjustment has not been going well.

A few questions: Why doesn’t she trust NFP when it seemingly worked at the beginning of your marriage? Why did you wait for the return of her cycle to have sex? The Marquette model is the way you want to go if you want to use a fertility monitor. nfp.marquette.edu/nfp_quick_inst_monitor.php
Marquette has their own online charting and message boards and what not, but there are other alternatives too:

myfertilitycharts.com/ has free online charting that interprets things for you.
There is also a downloadable version here: hormonalforecaster.com/

In regards to your disagreement about NFP, how open is she to praying with you? I often find that prayer is very unifying. I’ve seen it work in my parents and I’ve seen it work in my marriage. Where there is division, anger, resentment and fear, praying some prayer that takes a good period of time like the rosary or Divine Mercy chaplet allows the Holy Spirit to reorient you to be able to talk about these issues. It allows you to talk about why you’re afraid, what’s been communicated etc.
 
They are wrong. That is contrary to the teaching of the Church. Their are only two morally acceptable options of avoiding or postponing pregnancy, and they can only be used with just/serious reason: periodic abstinence (NFP) and total abstinence.
It seems OP’s wife mentioned the total abstinence and she sees that as a Church’s punishment.
At 27 the sex drive is high so I understand the struggle.
It’s very sad but there are many Catholics in the same situation.
 
I’m confused… if you’ve used NFP *successfully *to delay having your first child, then why is it a *sudden *issue?
Why have you avoided relations until her cycles returned if you’ve had success with NFP (and obviously know how to use it)?
What method of NFP did you use? Did you learn how to use it during the non-cycling postpartum months?
 
I’m confused… if you’ve used NFP *successfully *to delay having your first child, then why is it a *sudden *issue?
Why have you avoided relations until her cycles returned if you’ve had success with NFP (and obviously know how to use it)?
What method of NFP did you use? Did you learn how to use it during the non-cycling postpartum months?
If a baby is not an option for her right now then NFP is not good enough by itself. It makes sense.
 
I know EXACTLY how your wife feels. Honestly, the best thing you can do right now is not push the NFP issue…AT ALL. It will only drive her away more. Maybe just give her time…as long as she needs, then pick up NFP again when she is ready. Having a baby like that and trying to take care of him, is a HUGE drain. Give her some love and support. Most important: Sit and listen!..and don’t push the NFP issue. It may take several years, or it may never happen. No matter what statistics you give her, NFP teachers or classes you take her to, books you read, monitors you buy…it will only push her away more. Then, just pray…
 
It seems OP’s wife mentioned the total abstinence and she sees that as a Church’s punishment.
At 27 the sex drive is high so I understand the struggle.
It’s very sad but there are many Catholics in the same situation.
Whether or not someone has a high sex drive does not excuse immorality. I can’t imagine going before God on Judgement Day and saying, “Sorry I used condoms… I knew it was wrong but I had a really high sex drive.” 🤷
 
If a baby is not an option for her right now then NFP is not good enough by itself. It makes sense.
Morally, though, condoms are not the answer…nobody said that living the faith was easy. Condoms seem like the easy way out, again, they’re not the answer for us Catholics.
 
Whether or not someone has a high sex drive does not excuse immorality. I can’t imagine going before God on Judgement Day and saying, “Sorry I used condoms… I knew it was wrong but I had a really high sex drive.” 🤷
Good for you. I guess many will go there as you described.

Don’t underestimate sex drive. It can make people crazy.
 
For some of us who have serious health reasons to avoid permanently and NFP doesn’t work for, sex is a privilige that is reserved for those who NFP works for. The rest of us are just expected to be abstinent for the next 30 years and “offer it up.”🤷
 
For some of us who have serious health reasons to avoid permanently and NFP doesn’t work for, sex is a privilige that is reserved for those who NFP works for. The rest of us are just expected to be abstinent for the next 30 years and “offer it up.”🤷
Yep, good luck in sharing bed with your loved one without sex for next 30 years.
That really makes sense, doesn’t it?
 
For some of us who have serious health reasons to avoid permanently and NFP doesn’t work for, sex is a privilige that is reserved for those who NFP works for. The rest of us are just expected to be abstinent for the next 30 years and “offer it up.”🤷
No one has ever died from not having sex.

Your only moral options are periodic abstinence and total abstinence if you feel you have a just/serious reason to postpone or avoid pregnancy indefinitely.

But you already know this. How many times have we been around this block?
 
For some of us who have serious health reasons to avoid permanently and NFP doesn’t work for, sex is a privilige that is reserved for those who NFP works for. The rest of us are just expected to be abstinent for the next 30 years and “offer it up.”🤷
Yep, good luck in sharing bed with your loved one without sex for next 30 years.
That really makes sense, doesn’t it?
It isn’t an issue of whether or not something makes sense, and please don’t feel like your fellow Catholics don’t empathize with your situation. The fact is that artificial contraception (condoms, etc…) is an evil, gravely opposed to the nature of the marital act. We can empathize or sympathize all day long with the hardships that many face, but we cannot turn around and support the use of something that is gravely disordered to the marital act. God gave us 1 way to naturally avoid conception…it is called abstinance.
 
I don’t understand the illogical leap of " we have to abstain for NOW due to these reasons" to " we’ll have to abstain for 30 YEARS" Ummmm, no, there is a middle ground because circumstances change. Depression can be medically treated. Finances can be improved. Life CHANGES. A couple might have to abstain for a while for many reasons…maybe even to make sure they know NFP well enough to trust it. Maybe until cycles return postpartem so that charting is easier. Maybe until a medical condition is under control or even fixed.

To the OP, I’d suggest finding a faithful priest and you and your wife go and speak to him about what’s going on. NFP can be a struggle and that’s okay. If your wife is having depression issues, now might not be the best time for these discussions. Waiting might be the prudent thing for both of you. Contraception is not the answer to the underlying problems here. Communication and patience is.
 
It isn’t an issue of whether or not something makes sense, and please don’t feel like your fellow Catholics don’t empathize with your situation. The fact is that artificial contraception (condoms, etc…) is an evil, gravely opposed to the nature of the marital act. We can empathize or sympathize all day long with the hardships that many face, but we cannot turn around and support the use of something that is gravely disordered to the marital act. God gave us 1 way to naturally avoid conception…it is called abstinance.
A question to all married fellows here:
Were you told by a priest during your marriage preparation that if you have grave reasons not to have children and NFP is not going to work for you then the only option you have is abstinence?
Did you understand the consequence that maybe for 25/30 years you are not going to have sex?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top