It was explained to me that periodic abstinence is the method to avoid conception, not that “periodic” meant to discern monthly. It’s abstinence during a fertile time, it’s a period of infertility. So is that you’re only example of a supposed requirement of ‘monthly discernment’?
I was just thinking that people who are using NFP to avoid wouldn’t need to necessarily do a monthly-check to see if they can or cannot use NFP that month if they 1) have good enough reason to want to avoid pregnancy, such as finances, illness, or other issues (I mean most issues don’t disappear over a month’s time anyway) and also 2) the Church doesn’t require Catholics to have a certain number of kids, or continue having kids or even to actively try to have kids. The teaching is that they must be open to life, not to try to have more kids as soon as they’re able. Just curious about how this ‘monthly discernment’ came into the picture…