Yet Another "NFP Stuggles" Thread

  • Thread starter Thread starter Lookouts
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
A lot. There are many couples that NFP does not work for them.
NFP is periodic abstinence, that means that it shouldn’t be happening forever. Can you give a specific example of why a couple can decide w/ 20+ years of fertility left that their family is complete?
 
“periodic” abstinence is the terminology used in the Catechism. When better to discuss it than when you are noticing your fertility?
Yes, and all of the documents speak of delaying and spacing children - not “avoid them like the ungodly plague” :eek:
 
A lot. There are many couples that NFP does not work for them.
Okay, so NFP doesn’t work for them and I will give you the benefit of doubt that they have exhausted ALL the doctors, NFP instructors, and every other channel available to see WHY NFP doesn’t seem to work for them.

Still, why does that mean that they have to abstain for 20-30 years? Is their situation not EVER going to change? Are they NEVER going to find them in a position where they could extend the generosity to accept another child? EVER?

Now how often do you think it happens that 1. a couple struggles making NFP work. 2. they exhaust all methods of help and NFP still doesn’t work for them, and 3. their just/serious reasons for for needing to avoid a pregnancy NEVER changes?
 
And remember, NFP is supposed to be hard. It is supposed to make you sad. It is only used because something is wrong.

ETA - it is very much like the times when you are at Mass and you cannot receive the Eucharist, you have to abstain because you are in a state of mortal sin or you broke the fast, no one is “Yippee!!! I get to abstain this time”. We pray, offer up the pain and do our best that we do not have to abstain next time!
 
Yup. I could put two and two together.

Sex = babies (thanks, bio 101)
just/serious circumstances = no babies
no babies = no sex.

Pretty straight forward.

Now… how often do you think ACTUAL circumstances serious enough to have to completely avoid relations for 20-30 years? I would venture to guess it would be pretty rare.
Some people have health problems and would put their life and the baby’s life at a very high risk if a pregnancy were to happen. A lot of times, this same health problem will make charting fertile days vs infertile days virtually impossible.

…This is actually more common than you’d think. 😦
 
And remember, NFP is supposed to be hard. It is supposed to make you sad. It is only used because something is wrong.
Not necessarily. We need JUST reasons to abstain… not GRAVE.

With me for example, nothing is necessarily “wrong” in mine and my husband’s life. But we have just reason to avoid right now due to finances and the lack of health insurance. I wouldn’t consider that a grave reason, but I’d say it’s just.
 
Some people have health problems and would put their life and the baby’s life at a very high risk if a pregnancy were to happen. A lot of times, this same health problem will make charting fertile days vs infertile days virtually impossible.

…This is actually more common than you’d think. 😦
I think that if pregnancy will definitely lead to death then abstinence is the only moral choice. If it is a risk then you also have the option to trust God. I am not trying to be flippant, but if you are certain that pregnancy will lead to death then maybe sex should be lower on the priority list. If you are not certain…why not put it in God’s hands?
 
Not necessarily. We need JUST reasons to abstain… not GRAVE.

With me for example, nothing is necessarily “wrong” in mine and my husband’s life. But we have just reason to avoid right now due to finances and the lack of health insurance. I wouldn’t consider that a grave reason, but I’d say it’s just.
Correct. Just/serious reasons necessarily. I think ideally it should still feel like a hard ship, since the natural state of marriage should be not using NFP. In an ideal world.
 
Okay, so NFP doesn’t work for them and I will give you the benefit of doubt that they have exhausted ALL the doctors, NFP instructors, and every other channel available to see WHY NFP doesn’t seem to work for them.

Still, why does that mean that they have to abstain for 20-30 years? Is their situation not EVER going to change? Are they NEVER going to find them in a position where they could extend the generosity to accept another child? EVER?

Now how often do you think it happens that 1. a couple struggles making NFP work. 2. they exhaust all methods of help and NFP still doesn’t work for them, and 3. their just/serious reasons for for needing to avoid a pregnancy NEVER changes?
It happens a lot.
Think about all the couples in mid 30’s with 3+ kids that can not afford another baby and NFP does work for them.
There are plenty.
 
I think that if pregnancy will definitely lead to death then abstinence is the only moral choice. If it is a risk then you also have the option to trust God. I am not trying to be flippant, but if you are certain that pregnancy will lead to death then maybe sex should be lower on the priority list. If you are not certain…why not put it in God’s hands?
I guess it could work for some people to not have relations with their spouse. But it wouldn’t work for my husband and I. I’d rather take the 1% chance of a dangerous pregnancy occurring (given my birth control method failed) over not being intimate with my husband again. I actually think most people would feel the same way. But perhaps not all.
 
I think that if pregnancy will definitely lead to death then abstinence is the only moral choice. If it is a risk then you also have the option to trust God. I am not trying to be flippant, but if you are certain that pregnancy will lead to death then maybe sex should be lower on the priority list. If you are not certain…why not put it in God’s hands?
Right, this is the part I don’t get, too, Jea.

If pregnancy = death then isn’t the only OBVIOUS choice abstinence? Because ANY form of birth control can fail.
 
“periodic” abstinence is the terminology used in the Catechism. When better to discuss it than when you are noticing your fertility?
It was explained to me that periodic abstinence is the method to avoid conception, not that “periodic” meant to discern monthly. It’s abstinence during a fertile time, it’s a period of infertility. So is that you’re only example of a supposed requirement of ‘monthly discernment’?

I was just thinking that people who are using NFP to avoid wouldn’t need to necessarily do a monthly-check to see if they can or cannot use NFP that month if they 1) have good enough reason to want to avoid pregnancy, such as finances, illness, or other issues (I mean most issues don’t disappear over a month’s time anyway) and also 2) the Church doesn’t require Catholics to have a certain number of kids, or continue having kids or even to actively try to have kids. The teaching is that they must be open to life, not to try to have more kids as soon as they’re able. Just curious about how this ‘monthly discernment’ came into the picture…
 
It was explained to me that periodic abstinence is the method to avoid conception, not that “periodic” meant to discern monthly. It’s abstinence during a fertile time, it’s a period of infertility. So is that you’re only example of a supposed requirement of ‘monthly discernment’?

I was just thinking that people who are using NFP to avoid wouldn’t need to necessarily do a monthly-check to see if they can or cannot use NFP that month if they 1) have good enough reason to want to avoid pregnancy, such as finances, illness, or other issues (I mean most issues don’t disappear over a month’s time anyway) and also 2) the Church doesn’t require Catholics to have a certain number of kids, or continue having kids or even to actively try to have kids. The teaching is that they must be open to life, not to try to have more kids as soon as they’re able. Just curious about how this ‘monthly discernment’ came into the picture…
I don’t think you have to have a discussion monthly…just that you are fertile once a month so it seems like a good time to discuss it. I think that the more often you discuss it the better. In the interest of full disclosure we don’t use NFP, we have decided that there are very few reasons we would avoid and we haven’t reached them.
 
Right, this is the part I don’t get, too, Jea.

If pregnancy = death then isn’t the only OBVIOUS choice abstinence? Because ANY form of birth control can fail.
Haha. I’m a romantic I guess. Or maybe I’m just madly in love with my husband. 🙂

I’d rather take a 1% chance that my life will be in danger rather than not be intimate with my husband for the rest of my life.
 
I guess it could work for some people to not have relations with their spouse. But it wouldn’t work for my husband and I. I’d rather take the 1% chance of a dangerous pregnancy occurring (given my birth control method failed) over not being intimate with my husband again. I actually think most people would feel the same way. But perhaps not all.
So if you are in the 1% (which I disagree w/, most sources say that is only w/perfect use) you and your husband will think that all those months/years w/ all that sex was worth your death? Even if you knew you could prevent it w/ abstaining? I guess sex just isn’t that important to us then. :-/
 
Yes, and all of the documents speak of delaying and spacing children - not “avoid them like the ungodly plague” :eek:
Actually, HV says you can use NFP for avoiding indefinitely:
With regard to physical, economic, psychological and social conditions, responsible parenthood is exercised by those who prudently and generously decide to have more children, and by those who, for serious reasons and with due respect to moral precepts, decide not to have additional children for either a certain or an indefinite period of time.
There’s nothing that says anything about discerning monthly…
 
It was explained to me that periodic abstinence is the method to avoid conception, not that “periodic” meant to discern monthly. It’s abstinence during a fertile time, it’s a period of infertility. So is that you’re only example of a supposed requirement of ‘monthly discernment’?

I was just thinking that people who are using NFP to avoid wouldn’t need to necessarily do a monthly-check to see if they can or cannot use NFP that month if they 1) have good enough reason to want to avoid pregnancy, such as finances, illness, or other issues (I mean most issues don’t disappear over a month’s time anyway) and also 2) the Church doesn’t require Catholics to have a certain number of kids, or continue having kids or even to actively try to have kids. The teaching is that they must be open to life, not to try to have more kids as soon as they’re able. Just curious about how this ‘monthly discernment’ came into the picture…
I agree. I don’t see a reason to discern monthly, at least not in my case. If I know I still don’t have health insurance or money, then I don’t need to go into the same deep thoughts every single month regarding whether or not I should have a kid, haha. When things change, THEN I’ll think again.
 
I guess it could work for some people to not have relations with their spouse. But it wouldn’t work for my husband and I. I’d rather take the 1% chance of a dangerous pregnancy occurring (given my birth control method failed) over not being intimate with my husband again. I actually think most people would feel the same way. But perhaps not all.
As someone who was in that situation when we were early in our marriage (we had been married fewer than 5 years), my husband loved me too much to take that 1% chance of my death from pregnancy. We were not Catholic then, we did not use any form of ABC, so we abstained for a few years, then we went to conservative NFP.
 
Actually, HV says you can use NFP for avoiding indefinitely:

There’s nothing that says anything about discerning monthly…
I don’t think it has to be monthly. Just a fluid subject, open for discussion and further discernment. Circumstances change.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top