Yet Another "NFP Stuggles" Thread

  • Thread starter Thread starter Lookouts
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
A question to all married fellows here:
Were you told by a priest during your marriage preparation that if you have grave reasons not to have children and NFP is not going to work for you then the only option you have is abstinence?
Did you understand the consequence that maybe for 25/30 years you are not going to have sex?
If you didn’t realize that sex often equals babies and aren’t willing to figure out why NFP doesn’t work for you that still doesn’t negate responsibility for using immoral means to avoid pregnancy.

And let’s be real folks. Condoms and hormonal contraceptions fail. What will you do then? Will it be easier to accept? Will you realize this was God’s plan for you and your family?
 
A question to all married fellows here:
Were you told by a priest during your marriage preparation that if you have grave reasons not to have children and NFP is not going to work for you then the only option you have is abstinence?
Did you understand the consequence that maybe for 25/30 years you are not going to have sex?
I don’t think it was explicitly said that “If you have a grave reason to avoid pregnancy you won’t be having sex until menopause.” It was understood that you understood that sex = babies, the only moral options were NFP/complete abstinence with a just/serious reason to avoid, and that you were a grown up who would pursue further understanding and conformity to God’s will for your life through study and prayer.
 
For some of us who have serious health reasons to avoid permanently and NFP doesn’t work for, sex is a privilige that is reserved for those who NFP works for. The rest of us are just expected to be abstinent for the next 30 years and “offer it up.”🤷
Sad indeed. 😦
 
If you didn’t realize that sex often equals babies and aren’t willing to figure out why NFP doesn’t work for you that still doesn’t negate responsibility for using immoral means to avoid pregnancy.

And let’s be real folks. Condoms and hormonal contraceptions fail. What will you do then? Will it be easier to accept? Will you realize this was God’s plan for you and your family?
You did not answer the questions.
Thanks for schooling though. 🙂
 
A question to all married fellows here:
Were you told by a priest during your marriage preparation that if you have grave reasons not to have children and NFP is not going to work for you then the only option you have is abstinence?
Did you understand the consequence that maybe for 25/30 years you are not going to have sex?
Since I had basic biology in high school, I knew what caused babies and how my body worked. No priest had to explain that to me.
 
I don’t think it was explicitly said that “If you have a grave reason to avoid pregnancy you won’t be having sex until menopause.” It was understood that you understood that sex = babies, the only moral options were NFP/complete abstinence with a just/serious reason to avoid, and that you were a grown up who would pursue further understanding and conformity to God’s will for your life through study and prayer.
So you were not warned or you did not understand the consequence?
 
So you were not warned or you did not understand the consequence?
I was taught the Church’s teaching on marriage. It was understood that I would understand what that meant. No one had to spell it out for me. It was also understood that if there was anything they left unsaid, I was old enough to study, learn, and pray on my own to find out the full meaning of the Church’s teaching and how it applied to my family.
 
Since I had basic biology in high school, I knew what caused babies and how my body worked. No priest had to explain that to me.
Please, read the question again and if you are willing then share your experience.
It’s not about babies but HV and NFP.
 
Please, read the question again and if you are willing then share your experience.
It’s not about babies but HV and NFP.
As I said, I knew biology and was using NFP way before I ever thought of becoming Catholic. I also knew Catholic moral teaching on marriage before I considered conversion.
 
You did not answer the questions.
Thanks for schooling though. 🙂
We had one session w/ our priest. No we did not discuss this because we had read the marriage rite “will you lovingly accept children”. If you understand sex=babies then it makes the rest so much easier. I understand that their are times when some will not be able to accept children. Holy Mother Church in Her infinite wisdom and mercy has given us the gift of NFP. It definitely sounds like the OP and his wife have serious reasons to avoid. They should definitely see a Holy priest and figure out a conservative method to use. I encourage the OP to ask his wife what she will do if the condom fails, while she is against the use of BCP because it can be an abortifaciant, how will she handle a pregnancy that occurs w/ condom use. If that will cause the same depression it sounds like abstinence is the safest for them.
 
I was taught the Church’s teaching on marriage. It was understood that I would understand what that meant. No one had to spell it out for me. It was also understood that if there was anything they left unsaid, I was old enough to study, learn, and pray on my own to find out the full meaning of the Church’s teaching and how it applied to my family.
Thanks, fair enough.
The second question is if you understood that you could end up without sex for 25 years.
If you are willing to answer, please, be honest and to the point.
 
Thanks, fair enough.
The second question is if you understood that you could end up without sex for 25 years.
If you are willing to answer, please, be honest and to the point.
Of course, again, it is basic biology. I also knew that the vast majority of women who are in a loving marriage can practice NFP.

For some reason this forum seems to attract the miniscule percentage of the general public who do not have observable signs. That is baffling.
 
Thanks, fair enough.
The second question is if you understood that you could end up without sex for 25 years.
If you are willing to answer, please, be honest and to the point.
Yup. I could put two and two together.

Sex = babies (thanks, bio 101)
just/serious circumstances = no babies
no babies = no sex.

Pretty straight forward.

Now… how often do you think ACTUAL circumstances serious enough to have to completely avoid relations for 20-30 years? I would venture to guess it would be pretty rare.
 
Thanks, fair enough.
The second question is if you understood that you could end up without sex for 25 years.
If you are willing to answer, please, be honest and to the point.
here is a question for you. if your spouse had a accident and could never have sex again (25 years +) would you get a divorce because you can’t possibly live without sex?
 
Thanks, fair enough.
The second question is if you understood that you could end up without sex for 25 years.
If you are willing to answer, please, be honest and to the point.
I personally don’t understand this. How is that possible? Because NFP should be a monthly decision. Very few medical reasons are true that the woman will die w/ pregnancy and if it is truly that serious but a husband is not willing to abstain even though it might result in my DEATH, sex would be the furthest thing from my mind.
 
I was taught the Church’s teaching on marriage. It was understood that I would understand what that meant. No one had to spell it out for me. It was also understood that if there was anything they left unsaid, I was old enough to study, learn, and pray on my own to find out the full meaning of the Church’s teaching and how it applied to my family.
In all fairness, Janosik does have a point.

NFP promoters from the Church and in my marriage prep classes, sure do paint a very rosy picture of NFP. Truth is it turns into a huge disappointment for a lot of people, puts pressure on a lot of marriages, and leaves a lot of people unable to make love to their spouses (an extraordinarily sad thing). They don’t exactly prepare you for that, or even warn you…

I’ve had problems with NFP myself in my marriage and now I HATE nfp. I often wonder if things would be different and if I would be more accepting of nfp if I was given the raw truth about it from the get go.
 
I’m curious…where is it written by the Vatican that NFP must be discerned monthly? I may have missed it, but it just occurred to me that I just don’t remember seeing it anywhere other than on the forum…
 
Yup. I could put two and two together.

Sex = babies (thanks, bio 101)
just/serious circumstances = no babies
no babies = no sex.

Pretty straight forward.

Now… how often do you think ACTUAL circumstances serious enough to have to completely avoid relations for 20-30 years? I would venture to guess it would be pretty rare.
A lot. There are many couples that NFP does not work for them.
 
I’m curious…where is it written by the Vatican that NFP must be discerned monthly? I may have missed it, but it just occurred to me that I just don’t remember seeing it anywhere other than on the forum…
“periodic” abstinence is the terminology used in the Catechism. When better to discuss it than when you are noticing your fertility?
 
Thanks, fair enough.
The second question is if you understood that you could end up without sex for 25 years.
If you are willing to answer, please, be honest and to the point.
I will answer the question. NO, I did not. I had no idea NFP didn’t work for so many people. It was promoted to me as a wonderful, fail proof method (if you did it right) of postponing/avoiding children for just reasons. NFP promoters within the Church should be more honest to engaged couples about the method, IMHO.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top