I realize that there is tension between traditionalists and non-traditionalists–we’ve come to different conclusions about some important issues.
Still, with regard to some of the comments, the title of this thread is “You know you’re a Traditional Catholic when…” It is a take-off from a Foxworthy running joke: “You MIGHT be a redneck if…”
So, perhaps the thread should have used Foxworthy’s formulation for clarity, but it is clear enough to me that no absolutism was implied. The thread was NOT entitled, “You know that you are NOT a Ordinary Form (OF) Catholic if…”
It is certainly true that many OF Catholics do love tradition! It is also true that some traditionalists do not realize that…but most do.
Still, it ought not to bring protests when common traditional practices are used as humorous illustrations–even if there are some non-traditionalists who do such things as well. So, yes, some non-traditionalists ask priests over for supper, but it is more traditional Catholicism that causes the priest to feel a greater obligation to go. But again, this is not an universal and absolute claim.
In my diocese, you might be a traditionalists if you always go to mass Sunday afternoon (12:30 pm or 1:30 pm)–because that is the only time the Extraordinary Form (EF) is offered.
You might be a traditionalist if you keep changing parishes, because the Bishop is indifferent to any continuity of community–suddenly transferring priests capable of doing the ER without replacement with another.
You might be a traditionalist if you read in the Sunday bulletin that this or that will be offered after every mass, but it never is at your mass.
You might be a traditionalist if you secretly hope for a SSPX parish to be formed in your diocese, because that is the only way your Bishop will ever approve an EF parish–and then he will approve it instantly and without obstacles.
You might be a traditionalist if you are dumbstruck by the opposition to the minor new revisions to the OF: and wonder if they can even imagine the incredible change that Catholics were forced to go through in the 1960/1970’s.
You might be a traditionalist if you think that “post hoc ergo propter hoc” translates (using fluid ICEL principles) into “I refuse to learn from experience.”

The last refuge of the non-traditionalist intellectual hiding from reality.
