Your religion, your crutch...Part 2

  • Thread starter Thread starter Strength
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
In regard to choosing a particular religion, you must constantly search for truth and form and follow your conscience according to what you find. When you find what appears to be inconsistency, you must investigate it to see if it is real or merely your own misunderstanding.
 
You guys are way over my head but something in this whole discussion seems off to me.

The original post claimed that for a non-believer to act morally forces the believer to accept that morals are not related to religion.

Who said the non-believer was not “guided” unknowingly?

I don’t think either side can be proven.
 
40.png
Strength:
I’m not sure if how we come to morality dimishes the fact that we indeed do come to it…and it doesn’t necessarily have to be through a religion…right? ( I am evidence of this I contend) Didn’t jesus mention giving up our worldly possessions?..but yet - we still have selfishness… Even if religion does provide a moral absolute…is society as a whole even aware of it? Do we operate in this context? This is probably something worth discussing.

Regarding if there were proof of god…would I believe? Brother…if I could even understand a religion(s)…I may come to it…but this is a big limiter for me I guess. How would I choose? Why would I choose? The three major religions all say the same thing about eachother…and then themselves. Islam is the one true religion…Christianity is the one true religion etc…etc… How could I compel myself knowing full well that there is not a way to critically, and empirically come to a satisfactory conclusion (at least for my own intellect)…this is important stuff…Maybe when I was a teen I spent to many lazy afternoons reading Kant, and Nietzche…James…religious books of all shapes and sizes…Heck I own a copy of the Bhagadvad Ghita!..I recently came into possession of a huge piece of work that compares and contrasts major religions…postulates ancient religions that our modern ones may have evolved from…Zoroastrianism is quite amazing…Do you know there are ancient persian religious traditions that correspond very closely to accounts in the bible?..neat stuff…

I still postulate that a group of individuals could get together…and develop an absolute moral code…I believe this strongly in human intellect. I guess if I didn’t…maybe I would turn to god…maybe that is the answer?
There is a way to find which is the true religion. Search for the truth unceasingly. As you do you will find that each share some truths that man can come to know by reason alone. As you continue you will then begin to understand Revelation and its importance to coming to know the religion that has the fullness of truth.

Your other point - you do not live in a vacuum either. Therefore your morality has been shaped by others.

Jesus is the ideal, we are human and try to attain the ideal. Since we are human we fail. Should we stop trying to journey toward perfection? No, even though we fail we get up and try again while seeking forgiveness.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top