Your side on masturbation

  • Thread starter Thread starter xSteven
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I go through cycles. I am in counseling for this along with repressed religious issues stemming from a pentecostal upbringing. I abstained for 8 days 3 weeks ago, slipped to 5 times the next week, 3 times last week with the final time being a week ago today. So…I am now at 7 days of abstinence and trying to persist.

What boggles my mind is the difference of mortal/venial amongst the priesthood as it pertains to this act. I’ve heard both from priests before and it gets confusing. Peace.
 
Personal beliefs regarding issues of morality are not just based on what we “think” something is or should be but rather on what the Church teaches and why.

From the Catechism:

So it’s wrong, definately. But whether it’s a mortal sin is something you need to discuss with your priest in Confession.

Also, if you feel this is an addiction (as noted in your #4) , you need to get help to overcome it.
Actually a priest of 35 years gave me the scoop on this and for a great number of years it was not considered a sin for a woman…only for a man because of spilling seed. In fact the term “grave matter” was not interpreted the same way. I wish I could quote what he said because he really went through this for over an hour—needless to say, it’s certainly not “encouraged” but he told me to make an act of contrition and attend confession once a month and not to worry, God would not send me to hell for it. So…that’s the edict of a long-standing and greatly respected priest. I just wish I could have stated all that he said because he’s a Catholic history expert on law and the history of contraception/sex/masturbation and other family/sexual matters.
 
The appropriate person to give you direction (morally, spiritually) is a trustworthy spiritual director. Not internet strangers who don’t know you any more deeply than to see that you have a picture of JPII as your avatar, identify as a daily mass goer, and quote the wonderful poet St John of the Cross in your signature. As a tangent, St John of the Cross was widely considered to be an amazing spiritual director!

A good spiritual director will talk through your ongoing struggles, and is the appropriate person to discuss issues of mortal sin and whether or not to abstain from the Eucharist (when certain sins are yet to be confessed).

I’m sorry if you feel that some of the responses seem harsh. It probably comes down to the difference between discussing such matters in the abstract sense (eg that masturbation is an objective mortal sin) vs specific cases (each individual struggling with this). Sometimes these lines can seem a little blurred.
Thanks for that, you gave a compassionate response. I did go see a priest and he had a totally different take than I’ve been hearing, but like you said, a spiritual director can better assess your mental status, situation, and such. Thanks for your kindness.
 
I agree. Why would a loving God create people exactly the way he wanted them, and then spend the rest of life on earth punishing them for how he created them?? Doesn’t fit with my world view anymore.

Toddlers masturbate. It’s a normal, human thing. We were created as sexual beings. Should you become obsessed with it? No, you shouldn’t become obsessed with anything. Does it mean you don’t love God if you do it? I don’t even know where this idea came from, it’s ludicrous.
I agree.
 
I go through cycles. I am in counseling for this along with repressed religious issues stemming from a pentecostal upbringing. I abstained for 8 days 3 weeks ago, slipped to 5 times the next week, 3 times last week with the final time being a week ago today. So…I am now at 7 days of abstinence and trying to persist.

What boggles my mind is the difference of mortal/venial amongst the priesthood as it pertains to this act. I’ve heard both from priests before and it gets confusing. Peace.
3 Catholics 5 opinions
3 priests 7 opinions
 
You might want to read Fr. Groeschel’s book, “The Courage to be Chaste.”

It’s very good and it covers a lot of what you mention… wet dreams, lustful thoughts, and such. Fr. Groeschel makes a clear distinction between involuntary moments (such as during sleep) and auto eroticism (what we commonly refer to as masturbating).

It sounds like you are trying to justify masturbating because it is such a strong addiction. Yes, masturbation is a sin and a highly disordered sin at that. It’s a common problem, but that doesn’t make it any less grave.
I am tired of the post here. I am positive that 99% of the people on here are married and probably run and have sex after reading this. I find absolutely no help in hearing married people tell those of us who are single (and I’m newly single) what sinners we are. I’m glad my priest doesn’t confer. I never had this problem married so I’m going to keep following what my priest said and his history of this whole belief in the Church is fascinating and I’m feeling a LOT better.
 
To respond to the OP:

What I think is immaterial. I submit myself to the authority of the Church. If the Church says it’s harmful and even sinful and I abide by that it hurts NO ONE. So I will abide by it. As should you.

When/if the Church changes it’s position then… er… knock yourself out. Until then you’d do well to trust the authority that Christ has left in place to guide us.

PS: The idea that NOT masturbating causes MORE lustful thoughts is RIDICULOUS. I routinely committed this sin prior to converting to the Catholic Church. I can tell you that I had WAY more lustful thoughts back when I did it then now. In the two years since I quit I have lustful thoughts maybe ONCE a month and they are easily combated with prayer. 🤷
 
I am tired of the post here. I am positive that 99% of the people on here are married and probably run and have sex after reading this. I find absolutely no help in hearing married people tell those of us who are single (and I’m newly single) what sinners we are. I’m glad my priest doesn’t confer. I never had this problem married so I’m going to keep following what my priest said and his history of this whole belief in the Church is fascinating and I’m feeling a LOT better.
Amen! It’s easy for those who have OUTLETS. That being said I am at 8 days and counting abstinence. I hope God sends me a good Catholic wife someday. It’s good to know that not only men struggle with this. Peace.👍
 
I agree. Why would a loving God create people exactly the way he wanted them, and then spend the rest of life on earth punishing them for how he created them?? Doesn’t fit with my world view anymore.

Toddlers masturbate. It’s a normal, human thing. We were created as sexual beings. Should you become obsessed with it? No, you shouldn’t become obsessed with anything. Does it mean you don’t love God if you do it? I don’t even know where this idea came from, it’s ludicrous.
Toddlers soil their pants, spit up, put everything in their mouth and choke to death if not watched. Soon we all grow up.
 
What’s your side on it? I personally believe it is not a sin for many reasons.
  1. When we don’t masturbate, we get more lustful thoughts in our heads making us sin more, and think/do/say bad things.
  2. we have wet dreams so we are still spilling the “seed” and wet dreams is still masturbating in our sleep
  3. Some people don’t masturbate for pleasure all the time. It can be used to get rid of stress, and our lustful thoughts. I remember I just coulden’t focus on anything, all i could think of was lusful thoughts and I would tell myself “STOP! This is not what God wants!” I just couldent focus to pray to him, or get these thoughts out of my head. How else would I get them out?
  4. If you shoot someone, the gun isn’t the sinful part. So masturbation is the gun, and lust, addiction are the killing things. I just believe in that.
P.S. I am a Roman Catholic and I am sitll confused on wether masturbation is a sin or not. I do go to church every sunday and pray daily.

Thanks!🙂 Bless you all!
Steven,

You identified yourself as an 8th grader about to be confirmed. I suggest you speak to your priest at your Church about these issues and read the Catechism for teens cover to cover and in particular the areas you have questions about. Your concern for issues is a start in the right direction. Continue to ask and you will in time find answers.
 
If you were to masturbate without having lustful thoughts, you probably wouldn’t be excited.

Perhaps I’m wrong, but as far as im concerned you need to be turned on by something in order to masturbate correctly otherwise you’d be dry (if youre a girl) and limp (if you’re a guy).

Right?
🤷
 
Sorry for bringing this back up, but I’d like to just ask another question.
If Catholics and Christians both believe in Christ, why do Christians believe masturbation is normal, and Catholics thinks it’s bad? What happened to the concept of the Church is God’s word also?

Thank you~
 
If you were to masturbate without having lustful thoughts, you probably wouldn’t be excited.

Perhaps I’m wrong, but as far as im concerned you need to be turned on by something in order to masturbate correctly otherwise you’d be dry (if youre a girl) and limp (if you’re a guy).

Right?
🤷
Pumpkin,

Correct Adultery vs Incorrect Adultery
Correct Murder vs Incorrect Murder
Correct Masturbation vs Incorrect Masturbation

Does this make sense?
 
Sorry for bringing this back up, but I’d like to just ask another question.
If Catholics and Christians both believe in Christ, why do Christians believe masturbation is normal, and Catholics thinks it’s bad? What happened to the concept of the Church is God’s word also?

Thank you~
Steven,

Catholics are Christians

Protestants are Christians…

I started a thread about this very issue

**Re: There’s a place where I can go, in my room **

forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=741457

Baptist, Lutheran and Pentacostal have chimed in…Masturbation is sin…go check it out…👍
 
What’s your side on it? I personally believe it is not a sin for many reasons.
I don’t believe it is a sin. I know my opinion is in direct conflict with the Church, but that’s how it is for me. When I used to go to confession, this was about the only sin I had to confess. I now think it’s perfectly natural and not sinful. I know the Church says otherwise though.
 
Sorry for bringing this back up, but I’d like to just ask another question.
If Catholics and Christians both believe in Christ, why do Christians believe masturbation is normal, and Catholics thinks it’s bad? What happened to the concept of the Church is God’s word also?

Thank you~
As has been said, Catholics are Christians. Christian just means confessing Christ as savior.

Non-Catholics have a variety of opinions on it, and many of them have changed with time. What makes them Protestant is largely their refusal to acknowledge any kind of teaching authority. Nonetheless, nearly all Protestant denominations had basically the same moral theology as Catholics re: sex (with the exception of divorce) until about 80 years ago, and the sexual revolution sealed the total apostasy of many Protestant denominations.
 
Steven,

Catholics are Christians

Protestants are Christians…

I started a thread about this very issue

**Re: There’s a place where I can go, in my room **

forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=741457

Baptist, Lutheran and Pentacostal have chimed in…Masturbation is sin…go check it out…👍
I know that, but I still don’t get how like Protestants believe different, and Catholics believe different, yet we say the Church’s word is God’s word. I just don’t get it? (I’m making this up for for example) Protestants believe masturbation is okay, and yes they are apart of Christianity. Catholics believe masturbation is a sin. They are both apart of Christianity faith but believe 2 things and in the Bible it says the Church’s word is God’s word but it says 2 different things? I just don’t understand this.
 
What aren’t you understanding? Non-Catholics aren’t Catholics so of course they don’t believe everything Catholics believe.
 
What aren’t you understanding? Non-Catholics aren’t Catholics so of course they don’t believe everything Catholics believe.
Someone up there said Catholics, Protestants, etc are all part of the Christian faith. So if Jesus said the Church is his word, how would that work out if Protestants and Catholics believe differently? Do you understand what I’m trying to say? It’s hard to word.
 
If you were to masturbate without having lustful thoughts, you probably wouldn’t be excited.

Perhaps I’m wrong, but as far as im concerned you need to be turned on by something in order to masturbate correctly otherwise you’d be dry (if youre a girl) and limp (if you’re a guy).

Right?
🤷
Wrong. When I was around 9 I did it once (and I wasn’t “turned on”, or thinking about anything). I was really confused and only realized what I did when I was 13… 🤷
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top