YouTube and Atheist comments

  • Thread starter Thread starter Blade_and_Blood
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I troll and debate atheists all the time on you tube. Its not malicious trolling, as they are the ones misrepresenting our teachings and to be honest, as LostWanderer said, I’m frank, tact and sometimes downright unkind to the idiots who use such idiotic reasoning.
 
How do rabidly anti-theistic comments on youtube (or anywhere else for that matter) make me feel? Worried more than anything. Not so much for the content; I’ve rarely seen a raging comment on youtube present a decent argument. It’s more for the spirit that runs behind said comments. Internet anonymity is infamous for turning normal people into raging haters but if even a quarter of that rage is real in half the people who post it there’s going to be some trouble in the future.
 
It bothers me that they are committing sins and if died right now they would go to hell, it bothers me that they carry the burden of sin, it bothers me how much hate they have towards other, etc… The videos do not bother me, but what they’re doing to they’re souls and the world, and how they make others have the burden of sin and pushing them towards hell bothers me.
 
Atheism isn’t a religion, it’s just a belief; there is a fine line…
I beg to differ. Atheism IS a religion: it’s saying you don’t believe in something and you’re taking the belief that you’re right on faith. You have no idea… atheism is just as much a religion as anything else, and if you don’t believe me, we must know very different atheists.
 
I beg to differ. Atheism IS a religion: it’s saying you don’t believe in something and you’re taking the belief that you’re right on faith. You have no idea… atheism is just as much a religion as anything else, and if you don’t believe me, we must know very different atheists.
No Theism. Atheism.
Astampcollector. Non Stamp Collector.

Baldness. Abaldness?

Those jerks never invited me to their super top secret meetings. How will I know what to do without constant reinforcement of some sort on a regular basis?
 
Being a long time You tuber who discusses with Atheists quite often the main problem I see with these videos is that they like to set up a straw man of what Christianity is. A good portion of the remarks they make about Christianity are foreign to the traditional historic beliefs of Christianity.
 
I don’t really watch atheist videos… I watch Christian videos or talks by priests, EWTN, etc.

I have a YouTube channel and sometimes get comments from atheists, agnostics, or even Protestants who disagree with my videos. What I’d have to say is that some of them show misunderstanding of Catholicism and what the Church actually teaches. I don’t get annoyed, I just try to dialogue with them.

God bless
 
Being a long time You tuber who discusses with Atheists quite often the main problem I see with these videos is that they like to set up a straw man of what Christianity is. A good portion of the remarks they make about Christianity are foreign to the traditional historic beliefs of Christianity.
I agree…
 
Being a long time You tuber who discusses with Atheists quite often the main problem I see with these videos is that they like to set up a straw man of what Christianity is. A good portion of the remarks they make about Christianity are foreign to the traditional historic beliefs of Christianity.
It’d really help though if we had fewer self-proclaimed ‘Christians’ who actually justify these strawmen. Dealing with atheists is bad enough without having to equally confront the nutbar Bible thumpers who also frequent that site. It’s why I quit YouTube really. It’s become like 4chan except with videos. It’s rife with trolls, immaturity, and the sort of nonsense you can only expect from the internet’s most dumb.

I don’t know about you, but I’d rather just leave the anti-theistic haters and the wild fanatics be in the hopes that they’ll simply destroy each other.
 
Kind of like how these forums are riddled with homophobia comments…both sides aren’t too pretty with some of their choice of words

As far as atheistic comments on Christian videos; they don’t bother me, except when they start getting vulgar, disgusting, or hateful, then I flag 'em.
 
It’d really help though if we had fewer self-proclaimed ‘Christians’ who actually justify these strawmen. Dealing with atheists is bad enough without having to equally confront the nutbar Bible thumpers who also frequent that site. It’s why I quit YouTube really. It’s become like 4chan except with videos. It’s rife with trolls, immaturity, and the sort of nonsense you can only expect from the internet’s most dumb.

I don’t know about you, but I’d rather just leave the anti-theistic haters and the wild fanatics be in the hopes that they’ll simply destroy each other.
No, we can’t. Mary became the Mother of God for both sinners and the predestined. We mustn’t call them or denigrate them as being a worthless, hopeless cause. we must convince them why our religion is good and why you need to join it and we can do it with help from the Blessed Virgin while at the same time showing them why they are wrong.
 
It’s so funny, I peruse and comment on many atheist forums as well as these forums on this site. Both sides have theirs people who attack one another. The big difference I see is that on the atheist sites the people there are strictly attacking religion for the most part. While on this site not only are they attacking other faiths and religions, there is an immense amount of hatred for other human beings. For a christian website there is hate and intolerence bleeding out of every corner of this site. As a christian it is really sad to see, this is not what my Jesus intended
 
It’s so funny, I peruse and comment on many atheist forums as well as these forums on this site. Both sides have theirs people who attack one another. The big difference I see is that on the atheist sites the people there are strictly attacking religion for the most part. While on this site not only are they attacking other faiths and religions, there is an immense amount of hatred for other human beings. For a christian website there is hate and intolerence bleeding out of every corner of this site. As a christian it is really sad to see, this is not what my Jesus intended
That has got to be the most biased observation I’ve seen yet. Atheists attack religion is somehow more humane to you than how we attack other religion? That’s like saying a green apple is better than a red apple because of its color.

I’ve had as much experience as you. At the very least, this site has less profanity and crude jokes against religious figures.

You’re obviously too sympathetic towards the atheists than comfort would allow. Atheists know no difference between attacking religion and attacking religious believers. The reason? Obviously because common sense tells you that not a lot of people like having their religion attacked. Even if Mr. Nice Atheist would try to tell me that, that’s no excuse for the insults I’ve seen the YouTube Atheist Squad of Trolls flung at every form of religious belief they can identify.
 
No, we can’t. Mary became the Mother of God for both sinners and the predestined. We mustn’t call them or denigrate them as being a worthless, hopeless cause. we must convince them why our religion is good and why you need to join it and we can do it with help from the Blessed Virgin while at the same time showing them why they are wrong.
As far as any form or method of human convincing is concerned, the ARE a hopeless cause. You know what the Bible says about people with the sort of conviction these rabid atheists have? Here’s a hint, it went like “Cast not your pearls before swine.”

Then again, I’d bet there are more than one or two atheists who have the same view towards us. In the end, argumentation is pointless. You might as well just pray for a miracle.
 
That has got to be the most biased observation I’ve seen yet. Atheists attack religion is somehow more humane to you than how we attack other religion? That’s like saying a green apple is better than a red apple because of its color.

I’ve had as much experience as you. At the very least, this site has less profanity and crude jokes against religious figures.

You’re obviously too sympathetic towards the atheists than comfort would allow. Atheists know no difference between attacking religion and attacking religious believers. The reason? Obviously because common sense tells you that not a lot of people like having their religion attacked. Even if Mr. Nice Atheist would try to tell me that, that’s no excuse for the insults I’ve seen the YouTube Atheist Squad of Trolls flung at every form of religious belief they can identify.
i am not trying to make excuses for atheist. i know they attack religion and their followers with persistence, and I don’t agree with it. What i don’t like to see on here is the bigotry towards people outside of the religious discussion. I’ve read comments on here full of hatred for homosexuals, or comments proclaiming homeless people as pathetic and don’t deserve help, or accusing unmarried men with children as people who are just sex craved and deserve to be punished. There are countless others.

If i am sympathetic to atheists it is only in the area where I can understand why they are so viral towards us when they consistently see things like that said about fellow human beings. I just think we are better than that

Although that is just me, I don’t believe in denying anyone the same rights that i have no matter what my religion tells me to do
 
YOU WROTE: “I am not trying to make excuses for atheists. I know they attack religion and their followers with persistence, and I don’t agree with it. What I don’t like to see on here is the bigotry towards people outside of the religious discussion. I’ve read comments on here full of hatred for homosexuals, or comments proclaiming homeless people as pathetic and don’t deserve help, or accusing unmarried men with children as people who are just sex craved and deserve to be punished. There are countless others.”
  • I understand precisely where you’re coming from. These types of comments that you mention are very common. They show up here on Catholic Answers quite often. They do not represent official Church teaching in any way whatsoever. I believe they originate from people with their own ideas about Catholicism. From people who have not absorbed the Church’s position on peace, and who sometimes use their Catholicism to advance hurtful personal opinions. This is very sad.
I myself have never had any problems with the atheists on this site. I find them often to be sincere, and usually they are genuinely interested in discussion. The people I most often find myself arguing with (sad to say) are other Catholics. It has been my experience that a huge number of Catholics have never heard the Catholic Church’s official teachings on this or that subject, but they still post their own personal opinions as if THESE represent the truth of our religion, when in fact they often do not.

The Roman Catholic Church tries very, very hard to follow the philosophy of Aristotle. It always tries to put forward the most balanced teachings that it possibly can, so as not to be oppressive on people. Never too loose, or people will be confused about what the Church is saying. But never, ever too strict, or people will simply become depressed and leave. The Church recognizes that people don’t do well with extremes. Too much or too little of something can be very harmful for us. It is a sentiment I wish to see more of on Catholic Answers in general. But many people, unfortunately, do not appear to have absorbed the Church’s position on this matter, either.

The Catholic Answers Staff generally have a fairly well- balanced view of Church teaching. Go to their AAA (Ask an Apologist) forum and just read it. The forum covers many questions about official Church teaching, and is restricted to answers directly from the Staff themselves. They are usually very precise. This should clear up much confusion about questions of Church teaching and outlook. I have found it to be extremely reliable. It can be reached here:

forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=214374
forums.catholic-questions.org/search.php?searchid=9416071

And if you still have questions about what the Staff have written, you can certainly contact Catholic Answers directly.

FROM THE FORUM ADMINISTRATOR: “You can contact our staff apologists by phone by calling Catholic Answers at 619-387-7200 (Mon-Fri, 9 A.M. to 4 P.M. Pacific)”

forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=4

The thing to remember is that a lot of what appears on the ordinary Catholic Answers Forums is opinion. If something doesn’t sound quite right or moral, then it probably isn’t. You are right to have objections and doubts. Discovering the truth of things can take time. It is often easier for people just to state a hurtful, inaccurate personal opinion, rather than to do actual research to discover the truth of things. And such research, even with the help of the Internet, can often be very, very difficult.
  • Regards.
 
i am not trying to make excuses for atheist. i know they attack religion and their followers with persistence, and I don’t agree with it. What i don’t like to see on here is the bigotry towards people outside of the religious discussion. I’ve read comments on here full of hatred for homosexuals, or comments proclaiming homeless people as pathetic and don’t deserve help, or accusing unmarried men with children as people who are just sex craved and deserve to be punished. There are countless others.

If i am sympathetic to atheists it is only in the area where I can understand why they are so viral towards us when they consistently see things like that said about fellow human beings. I just think we are better than that

Although that is just me, I don’t believe in denying anyone the same rights that i have no matter what my religion tells me to do
I’m sorry to sound rude but you must note that some atheists and secularists themselves say the same things about homeless people. It isn’t something unique to Catholics because there isn’t a single saint in history who never gave alms to the poor. As for the unmarried men thing, I honestly NEVER saw a single person on this forum, catholic or not calling a non-married person deserving of punishment. When a Protestant woman who married her catholic husband outside both their churches and by the government, she complained that her rusty mother called her a ‘*****’ and a whore. Do you know how many catholics told her to go to hell? None. Simply none. She said she was surprised how kindly we received her and whatnot.

As for religion, I don’t think they fight so much as disagree. What, atheists can insult our religion with their pathetic insults yet we can’t give them or other religions reason why we disagree with their point of view? I never came across any Catholic who thinks because I’m a traditionalist Catholic then I am an anti-christ, and I’ve seen my fair share of polite atheists who were unbiased on these very forums, such as that when a Jewish member was accusing our Church for being nothing but an anti-semitic organization and he jumped in and gave documents showing the good the Church did for Jews. I’ve seen more ignorant, derogatory remarks from atheists who support the sour likes of Christopher Hitchens and Stephen Fry who all think they are smarter, wittier and more pleasant than their religious enemies.

Catholics are better than being jerks are they Mr. Pugnax? Being a jerk isn’t unique to Catholics now is it? And as for homosexuals, of course we disagree with their lifestyle which is fueled by lust no matter how they try to paint it. We don’t want them killed but how do you expect us to support a practice which to us is wrong and immoral?
 
YOU WROTE: “I’ve seen more ignorant, derogatory remarks from atheists who support the sour likes of Christopher Hitchens and Stephen Fry who all think they are smarter, wittier and more pleasant than their religious enemies.”
  • Honestly, I just don’t know. As a Catholic myself, I am frequently astonished at the vitriol and venom I see oozing from comments that Catholics (and others) often direct toward atheists. These comments can be quite disturbing in their viciousness. There was even a ban on atheism on Catholic Answers (I don’t know if it’s still in effect) because of the seeming inability of many Catholics here to respond to the comments of atheists without getting furious, insulting, and/or abusive in their responses. I personally do not find such behavior Christian in any way whatsoever.
For example, I have seen plenty of Catholics refer to atheists as “satanic,” as “the spawn of the anti-Christ,” as “evil,” as “demonic,” – often simply because an atheist has voiced a slight disagreement with what a Catholic has said. (I am most certainly not going to name names.) A quick search of Catholic Answers reveals to me quite a lot of apparent hatred focused toward atheists from religious people, seemingly just because they are “not like us.” I have also noticed that the Catholic Answers Staff try very hard to limit or even remove hateful comments like that. But plenty of them slip through anyway – nobody, I suppose, can catch them all.

When people say that Catholics are “not as insulting as atheists,” this just strikes me as bizarre. People are people. And I have noticed that people frequently tend to insult others who do not belong to their own particular “group.”

Even scientific studies have shown that individuals who identify with some group (like atheists, or religious folk) can often become very territorial to those in other groups – even when there is absolutely no reason to be. Such behavior may in fact be hardwired into our systems. It might be part of our basic human nature. And it would also seem to be the Christian message to deal with this nature for what it is, and to rise above it – which many Catholics, in my own personal view, have failed to do.

Instead of the “We-vs-They” mentality that frequently seems to exist, the Church recommends that we relate in friendship to everyone, regardless of religion, or lack thereof.

We are not called to convert people. If God wishes you to speak of religion, he will send someone your way. We are simply called to be as we are. And we are certainly not meant to insult those who think differently than us. Pope John Paul II stated in his encyclical Nostra Aetate:

"5. We cannot truly call on God, the Father of all, if we refuse to treat in a brotherly way any man, created as he is in the image of God. Man’s relation to God the Father and his relation to men his brothers are so linked together that Scripture says: “He who does not love does not know God” (1 John 4:8).”

(continued) “No foundation therefore remains for any theory or practice that leads to discrimination between man and man or people and people, so far as their human dignity and the rights flowing from it are concerned.”

(continued) “The Church reproves, as foreign to the mind of Christ, any discrimination against men or harassment of them because of their race, color, condition of life, or religion. On the contrary, following in the footsteps of the holy Apostles Peter and Paul, this sacred synod ardently implores the Christian faithful to “maintain good fellowship among the nations” (1 Peter 2:12), and, if possible, to live for their part in peace with all men,(14) so that they may truly be sons of the Father who is in heaven.(15)”

vatican.va/archive/hist_councils/ii_vatican_council/documents/vat-ii_decl_19651028_nostra-aetate_en.html
 
The urge to ridicule, mock and verbally abuse another or another party is something which should be completelty alien to a person of Judeo-Christian persuasion.

Pat Condell sounds biting at first but when I heard him say something (regarding history) which I knew quite clearly to be untrue, he lost all credibility and I just switched off. Actually that was a major moment for me as I wondered how could religion cause such anger in such men, and even more importantly, if religion was just insignificant drivel(which I kind of believed at that time), then why did they have this illogical, almost “demonic” obsession with it?
 
The urge to ridicule, mock and verbally abuse another or another party is something which should be completelty alien to a person of Judeo-Christian persuasion.
Perhaps, but only depending on how sincerely their ‘Judeo-Christian persuasion’ is. I’ve seen plenty of ridicule come from people who claim to be of such a persuasion.

I have to agree with Lost Wanderer. The vitriol that one finds on youtube, especially from anti-theists, is one reason why I almost never use it. Just to listen to music, but other than that, I don’t bother. The people themselves may not be hopeless causes, but they seem to bring only the worst in themselves to youtube, so as a medium of discussion, youtube is, I think, quite hopeless.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top