Zika virus and contraception

  • Thread starter Thread starter Ron_Conte
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
What do you mean by ‘women, who for very serious reasons wish to abstain, but are not allowed to’?
She is referring to what some other posters have claimed in this thread, that in certain cultures, women have no choice in the matter and are not permitted to refuse the advances of their husbands. i knew that this happens in some marriages, but I was not aware that it can be a widespread problem in some cultures. In the last six months, I have read testimonies that women in two separate cultures, where Catholicism is the predominant religion, are not permitted by their husbands, due to cultural expectations, to abstain from intercourse. This is why I questioned the deacon earlier.
 
Well we can’t really look at the issue and compare it to all the other church teaching in light of tob if we can’t actually look at it can we?
Is that your way of saying that you would strongly prefer I find that link? 😉

I will see what I can find. But the key words I provided also work in your search engine, too. 😛

I will post as soon as I find something.
 
She is referring to what some other posters have claimed in this thread, that in certain cultures, women have no choice in the matter and are not permitted to refuse the advances of their husbands. i knew that this happens in some marriages, but I was not aware that it can be a widespread problem in some cultures. In the last six months, I have read testimonies that women in two separate cultures, where Catholicism is the predominant religion, are not permitted by their husbands, due to cultural expectations, to abstain from intercourse. This is why I questioned the deacon earlier.
I have two cousins who had children long, long after it was dangerous for them to continue to do so. NFP didn’t work because they couldn’t get their husbands to abstain. No skin off of their nose if she gets pregnant. I have no doubt that it happens more often in traditional cultures.
 
The entire situation with this virus puts our day to day theoretical postings about the use of contraception into the very real world, where millions are affected, not just me, myself and I. What will happen to the poorer than poor families who are not educated enough to understand the ramifications of being pregnant and becoming infected with the virus in places such as Peru, Columbia, and the even poorer parts of Central America? The babies born with the birth defects that this virus causes will, in many cases, not have access to the best pre and post natal care that we have in Canada, Western Europe and the USA.
There are some situations where we have to use common sense and not continue to quote the CCC.:eek:
 
The entire situation with this virus puts our day to day theoretical postings about the use of contraception into the very real world, where millions are affected, not just me, myself and I. What will happen to the poorer than poor families who are not educated enough to understand the ramifications of being pregnant and becoming infected with the virus in places such as Peru, Columbia, and the even poorer parts of Central America? The babies born with the birth defects that this virus causes will, in many cases, not have access to the best pre and post natal care that we have in Canada, Western Europe and the USA.
There are some situations where we have to use common sense and not continue to quote the CCC.
Being poor does not make someone stoopid. That’s very insulting.

Also, we don’t throw out the rules when they become inconvenient. We can drop our cross and run away to the wide and easy road if we like, but that leads to Hell.
 
I have two cousins who had children long, long after it was dangerous for them to continue to do so. NFP didn’t work because they couldn’t get their husbands to abstain. No skin off of their nose if she gets pregnant. I have no doubt that it happens more often in traditional cultures.
That is where the Church needs to be working. Right there with the attitude that husbands have the right to use their wives. Not helping the wives sneakily contracept. But intervening in a culture that says it is okay to use wives instead of cherish them.
 
She is referring to what some other posters have claimed in this thread, that in certain cultures, women have no choice in the matter and are not permitted to refuse the advances of their husbands. i knew that this happens in some marriages, but I was not aware that it can be a widespread problem in some cultures. In the last six months, I have read testimonies that women in two separate cultures, where Catholicism is the predominant religion, are not permitted by their husbands, due to cultural expectations, to abstain from intercourse. This is why I questioned the deacon earlier.
But do you mean to say that the Church allows this practice as a valid expression of sacramental marriage within a culture? Or that it is a cultural aberration that is strongly opposed by the Church. I’ll go back to your earlier post to catch up on the gist.
 
The entire situation with this virus puts our day to day theoretical postings about the use of contraception into the very real world, where millions are affected, not just me, myself and I. What will happen to the poorer than poor families who are not educated enough to understand the ramifications of being pregnant and becoming infected with the virus in places such as Peru, Columbia, and the even poorer parts of Central America? The babies born with the birth defects that this virus causes will, in many cases, not have access to the best pre and post natal care that we have in Canada, Western Europe and the USA.
There are some situations where we have to use common sense and not continue to quote the CCC.:eek:
Right. Lots of opinions but doesn’t need to concern itself with the practicalities of people’s lives. Offering prayer is, well, frankly cheap. Caring for a disabled child is not.
 
But do you mean to say that the Church allows this practice as a valid expression of sacramental marriage within a culture? Or that it is a cultural aberration that is strongly opposed by the Church. I’ll go back to your earlier post to catch up on the gist.
That it is a cultural aberration, that runs counter to the Church’s teaching all the way back to the apostolic exhortation for husbands to love their wives and give up his life for her.

More to the point of the thread, I hope the clergy in the areas where the Zika virus is so widespread will address the need to practice self-control instead of contraception. Frankly, I would love to hear homilies and read pastoral letters here in America about practicing self-control instead of contraception. 😦

I think my posting history would show that I love it when the Church lovingly and boldly proclaims the truth and calls people to conversion, rather than make accommodation for people’s sins or try to find loopholes due to adverse circumstances. And not just the clergy, but all the faithful, too.
 
Ok. Then shall I provide a list of families facing bankruptcy due to their children’s medical bills that the church is now suddenly going to provide for? To whom should I direct the memo to. Perhaps not from this condition, but from many many others.
 
Being poor does not make someone stoopid. That’s very insulting.

Also, we don’t throw out the rules when they become inconvenient. We can drop our cross and run away to the wide and easy road if we like, but that leads to Hell.
As a person who taught special ed for 35 years, I can assure you that I was not calling poor people from 3rd world nations “stoopid”. If you never had the opportunity to go to school beyond the 3rd grade, your ability to process with appropriate comprehension, the scientific facts regarding this virus will be seriously jeopardized. Continuing to be in denial is cacatastrophic. Look at what is happening in Flint. :confused:
 
Right. Lots of opinions but doesn’t need to concern itself with the practicalities of people’s lives. Offering prayer is, well, frankly cheap. Caring for a disabled child is not.
I never understand why people say prayer is cheap. Is God omnipotent or not? Do we believe that God is the Author of Life or not? Do we believe He loves us or not?

And why do you paint a picture of either prayer or practicalities? What about the corporal works of mercy, that every parish in the entire world is right now carrying out in some form or fashion? What about the countless religious orders that are entirely devoted to the works of mercy as well as missions? The Catholic Church is not some ivory tower system of philosophy, but is always and everywhere engaged in fulfilling Our Lord’s commands to feed the hungry, clothe the naked, give drink to the thirsty.
 
Ok. Then shall I provide a list of families facing bankruptcy due to their children’s medical bills that the church is now suddenly going to provide for? To whom should I direct the memo to. Perhaps not from this condition, but from many many others.
Are these children born disabled directly as a result of the Church teaching against contraception or the Church teaching against abortion? That would be as colossal as Roe v Wade if it succeeded.
 
We can discuss this further when you finish Med school, training, board certifications and have some understanding of what you are talking about. Or actually have some experience.
 
Are these children born disabled directly as a result of the Church teaching against contraception or the Church teaching against abortion? That would be as colossal as Roe v Wade if it succeeded.
My point is that the church asks people to be “open to life” but then does not provide the practical support to then care for that life when it is more complicated than expected.

The list of children could be the patient list of any pediatric neurologist or geneticist.
 
And my next door neighbor’s cousins’ uncle twice removed is a rocket scientist. Doesn’t mean I know anything about NASA.

I still stand by my position that the church offers little practical assistance once the proverbial doo doo hits the fan for the typical family with a disabled child.

I realize this is a considerably broader topic than the Zika virus.

But in that vein, yes, the government of Brazil is quite correct in recommending pregnancy avoidance by whatever means that is until they can get the mosquito population under control and/or a better handle on management of spread.
 
Then you live in a much kinder world than I do, because in my experience this has not been true.
 
Yes, frankly, and that’s what i would recommend provided they didn’t want to take the risk.
 
And my next door neighbor’s cousins’ uncle twice removed is a rocket scientist. Doesn’t mean I know anything about NASA.

I still stand by my position that the church offers little practical assistance once the proverbial doo doo hits the fan for the typical family with a disabled child.

I realize this is a considerably broader topic than the Zika virus.

But in that vein, yes, the government of Brazil is quite correct in recommending pregnancy avoidance by whatever means that is until they can get the mosquito population under control and/or a better handle on management of spread.
PhiloMed,

You said “by whatever means”. Please clarify. Do you believe that should include recourse to abortion?

How does that square with the Hippocratic Oath? Or do doctors not take that oath anymore?

The part to first, do no harm?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top