Zika virus and contraception

  • Thread starter Thread starter Ron_Conte
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
My point is that the church asks people to be “open to life” but then does not provide the practical support to then care for that life when it is more complicated than expected.

The list of children could be the patient list of any pediatric neurologist or geneticist.
But Church teaching and pastoral care work are different things.

For example if there’s a class of children who for one reason or another have been poorly educated in Math. The solution is not to say the majority of these kids don’t know their 12 times tables so we’ll change it to that any answer can be right for them. There is a very good reason why mathematics has to accord with objective principles and that’s because it supports a lot of important structures of society. Start messing with the equations based on the practical needs of the less educated and it will eventually undermine everything that depends on maths for its soundness.
 
PhiloMed,

You said “by whatever means”. Please clarify. Do you believe that should include recourse to abortion?

How does that square with the Hippocratic Oath? Or do doctors not take that oath anymore?

The part to first, do no harm?
How would pregnancy avoidance be abortion? An abortion presupposes one has become pregnant.
 
Funny thing is I didn’t used to. I bought into it 100% including practicing it myself.

Life experience and CAF brought me to “the dark side” I suppose you would say. 😊
 
Yes, frankly, and that’s what i would recommend provided they didn’t want to take the risk.
PhiloMed,
So you love medicine, as per your username.

But you were created to know God, to love Him, to serve Him in the world and to be happy with Him forever in heaven. We know what God wants us to do through the Catholic Church. It is the Church who has the authority to teach us how to live, not governments or medical schools. Jesus tells us, in His own words and through the Catholic Church, that we should love God with all our heart and all our mind and all our soul and all our strength. That is the first and greatest commandment.

When the Church forbids married couples to use contraception, and She always has, She speaks with the authority of our Lord Jesus.

So, a question for you to ponder PhiloMed, who or what do you love more?

God or Medicine?

Which one has your loyalty?

Your profile says you are Catholic. But what do your words and actions say?
 
Funny thing is I didn’t used to. I bought into it 100% including practicing it myself.

Life experience and CAF brought me to “the dark side” I suppose you would say. 😊
This saddens me to hear. I know you think prayer is cheap but I will say a prayer for you just the same, PhiloMed.
 
Funny thing is I didn’t used to. I bought into it 100% including practicing it myself.

Life experience and CAF brought me to “the dark side” I suppose you would say. 😊
How did CAF bring you to ‘the dark side’?
 
How did CAF bring you to ‘the dark side’?
Because I see people giving life advice, based on church teaching, that absolutely contradicts any reality I know. It’s like offering advice but never actually having to deal with the problem face to face or in this case dr to patient.

I do appreciate prayers, though! Always do! I didn’t mean it was cheap in that it is worthless, just that it doesn’t pay the bill in front of you.
 
I understand the opposition of Catholics to artificial means of birth control, but would like to know if using a natural form of BC like NFP be allowed in a case like this? I ask this because many of the discussion is centered around artificial BC.
As I do not live in a country where a significant percentage of the christians are Catholic (or other groups that are against ABC), this has not factored into the discussion about the response to the virus. It would be interesting to hear from people who live in countries where catholicism is the main religion, how do the governments handle these concerns.
 
I understand the opposition of Catholics to artificial means of birth control, but would like to know if using a natural form of BC like NFP be allowed in a case like this? I ask this because many of the discussion is centered around artificial BC.
As I do not live in a country where a significant percentage of the christians are Catholic (or other groups that are against ABC), this has not factored into the discussion about the response to the virus. It would be interesting to hear from people who live in countries where catholicism is the main religion, how do the governments handle these concerns.
Certainly NFP could and should be used in such situations! 👍

ETA: The catechism says a government has the right to mandate NFP usage in these and other life threatening situations.
 
Because I see people giving life advice, based on church teaching, that absolutely contradicts any reality I know. It’s like offering advice but never actually having to deal with the problem face to face or in this case dr to patient.
I do not envy the priests in Brazil having to deal with the real pastoral issues within their parishes. The Church teaches. Yet the priests in the front line have to deal with the souls entrusted to them. I know one thing though. Using Church teaching like a bludgeon is not the way to deal with real people. Likewise, ignoring Church teaching out of utilitarianism is also unhealthy. In the end, there will have to be a greater teaching of NFP. I do not buy that Catholic men in South America are all a bunch of rapists with their wives.
 
I may be accused of heresy for this idea, but it is one I truly believe.

It is parents responsibility to care about the well-being of their children. If there is a high risk of a child being permanently damaged by the Zika virus, than they are under a duty to try and not procreate until this thing is reasonably under control. A duty of care so to speak.

And whether that end is accomplished by abstinence or contraceptive sex, I think either one is fine personally, as long as the end is achievd.blush: I am not speaking for the church at all, but I really can’t blame don’t think ill of couples who use contraceptive sex in this situation. I just don’t believe its wrong.

It’s really not my business to think about it anyway…😊
It follows then that you believe a means - potentially any means - can be justified if it brings about a sufficient good. This of course is diametrically opposed to catholic moral theology which holds that some acts are always and everywhere wrong, no matter the ends being pursued. There is no more fundamental tenet of Catholic moral teaching.
 
This is a major public health issue whose effects are devastating to infants. United Airlines is giving full refunds for those afraid of traveling to South America and the Caribbean which is a huge indicator concerning this killer virus. Women must decide themselves and with their partners what protection they will use, or if they will use protection at all. I would think that this situation would be hard even for traditionalists.🤷
The disease carriers are mosquitos, hence efforts are made to eradicate them to protect the large human population. Were the carriers a small tribe of “Indians”, some (yes, I’ve encountered them on CAF) would argue that that tribe should be eliminated to save the far larger population, and that such an act is moral because of the greater good compared to the smaller evil. An example of the ends justifying the means. Catholic moral theology opposes doing evil to promote good. Of course, in this context, one must accept contraception is evil, otherwise, the entire discussion is moot.
 
Is it gravely immoral for the emergency contraceptive pill to be taken after a rape if conception has not yet occurred?

Is it gravely immoral for victims of rape to attempt coitus interruptus?
One may always defend oneself from aggression. Push the attacker off is fine. Flush away sperm is fine. Destroy a child conceived is not fine. Contraception is not fine. These acts are all different - they are not of the same moral species.
 
Were the carriers a small tribe of “Indians”, some (yes, I’ve encountered them on CAF) would argue that that tribe should be eliminated to save the far larger population, and that such an act is moral because of the greater good compared to the smaller evil…
I am rather skeptical of this claim. I have never seen anything remotely posted so brutally utilitarian.
 
Just to be clear, the relationship between this virus and birth defects is new and not yet established.
cdc.gov/zika/disease-qa.html
There have been reports of a serious birth defect of the brain called microcephaly(http://www.cdc.gov/ncbddd/birthdefects/microcephaly.html) (a condition in which a baby’s head is smaller than expected when compared to babies of the same sex and age) and other poor pregnancy outcomes in babies of mothers who were infected with Zika virus while pregnant. Knowledge of the link between Zika and these outcomes is evolving, but until more is known, CDC recommends special precautions for the following groups:
I appreciate the need to err on the side of caution, but the overreaction by Brazil seems too much.
 
…There are some situations where we have to use common sense and not continue to quote the CCC.:eek:
What you mean is that “we” should either:
  1. reject the Catholic Church teaching that contraception is intrinsically evil; OR
  2. reject the idea that intrinsically evil acts exist at all (which amounts to accepting the idea that the ends can justify the means).
I believe you position is in fact (1), the least bad of these.
 
I am rather skeptical of this claim. I have never seen anything remotely posted so brutally utilitarian.
Seriously? You’ve never heard of Consequentialism and/ or Proportionalism (refer Veritatis Splendor). Those moral systems make it entirely acceptable to kill n innocent persons if that is required to save n+1 innocents. They reject entirely the notion of intrinsic evil. And we have had posters on CAF argue for that system. The poster Pallas Athene comes to mind.
 
Seriously? You’ve never heard of Consequentialism and/ or Proportionalism (refer Veritatis Splendor).
Yes. What I have not heard is anyone here who would think you could commit genocide for a greater good.
 
Yes. What I have not heard is anyone here who would think you could commit genocide for a greater good.
On this thread? No. On CAF - yes. If acts are judged purely by their (discernible) consequences, then it is not clear how one cannot agree that killing an innocent to save a greater number of innocents is warranted. The notion of intrinsic evils - the negative precepts of the God given law - are what rule out such acts.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top